[{"_1":2,"_16763":-5,"_16764":-5},"loaderData",{"_3":4,"_18":19},"root",{"_5":6,"_7":8,"_9":10,"_11":10,"_12":13,"_14":15,"_16":17},"isProd",true,"enableStats",false,"domain","gabo.es","siteHost","sentryTrace","33baf1fa13f64291a4f7db67ccb38726--0","sentryBaggage","sentry-environment=production,sentry-trace_id=33baf1fa13f64291a4f7db67ccb38726,sentry-sampled=false","remixVersion",2,"routes/$",{"_20":21,"_14448":14449},"json",{"_22":23,"_24":25,"_26":-5,"_27":-5,"_28":29,"_92":-5,"_93":6,"_39":94,"_103":104,"_105":106,"_14440":6,"_11":334,"_14441":334,"_14442":14443,"_14445":14446},"prefersLanguages",[],"viewTerm","comments","panelParam","openComment","document",{"_30":31,"_72":42,"_73":55,"_74":75,"_56":76,"_77":78,"_79":80,"_81":82,"_86":87,"_88":89,"_90":91},"content",[32],{"_33":34,"_35":36},"children",[],"block",{"_37":38,"_39":40,"_41":42,"_43":44,"_67":68,"_69":70,"_71":70},"type","Query","id","ebnwHRgd","revision","bafy2bzacedlhlpb6mbjnz752batie53mzzwcc4gq5w4z4e7st7psec2aa2dgi","attributes",{"_45":46,"_47":48,"_49":50,"_66":8},"style","Card","columnCount",3,"query",{"_51":52,"_60":61},"includes",[53],{"_54":55,"_56":57,"_58":59},"space","z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou","path","private-notes","mode","AllDescendants","sort",[62],{"_63":8,"_64":65},"reverse","term","UpdateTime","banner","annotations",[],"text","","link","version","account","authors",[55],"/private-notes","createTime","2024-12-16T09:46:55.189Z","updateTime","2026-01-06T21:41:02.679Z","metadata",{"_83":84,"_85":6},"name","Notes","showOutline","detachedBlocks",{},"genesis","bafy2bzacecy7ynnmzylwfemxm2rr35jcgavhimiob32uauwo5sz5zispskayy","visibility","PUBLIC","comment","isLatest",{"_56":95,"_72":42,"_96":8,"_97":55,"_39":98,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5},[57],"latest","uid","hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes","blockRef","blockRange","hostname","scheme","siteHomeIcon","ipfs://bafkreifg4zwc2bidz3zuddxbld6dzeq5xfmbfhrzgx4hpj5bkxqtw6mgku","dehydratedState",{"_107":108,"_109":110},"mutations",[],"queries",[111,154,387,802,2390,2403,3428,3439,3468,3497,7026,7180,7202,7339,7385,7429,7443,7457,7770,7838,7874,8091,8244,8399,8685,8907,8935,8955,9260,9318,9558,9572,9586,9614,9807,10038,10644,10665,10713,10764,10785,10926,10955,11031,11066,11202,11230,11300,11426,11515,11627,11716,11838,11932,11946,11960,12009,12030,12629,12804,12849,13118,13151,13209,13283,13304,13334,13362,13405,13420,13497,13806,14006,14019,14033,14426],{"_112":113,"_149":150,"_152":153},"state",{"_114":115,"_133":134,"_135":136,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},"data",{"_37":28,"_28":116,"_39":131},{"_30":117,"_72":42,"_73":55,"_74":128,"_56":76,"_77":78,"_79":80,"_81":129,"_86":130,"_88":89,"_90":91},[118],{"_33":119,"_35":120},[],{"_37":38,"_39":40,"_41":42,"_43":121,"_67":127,"_69":70,"_71":70},{"_45":46,"_47":48,"_49":122,"_66":8},{"_51":123,"_60":125},[124],{"_54":55,"_56":57,"_58":59},[126],{"_63":8,"_64":65},[],[55],{"_83":84,"_85":6},{},{"_39":98,"_97":55,"_56":132,"_72":42,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":8},[57],"dataUpdateCount",1,"dataUpdatedAt",1772124421670,"error","errorUpdateCount",0,"errorUpdatedAt","fetchFailureCount","fetchFailureReason","fetchMeta","isInvalidated","status","success","fetchStatus","idle","queryKey",[151,98,42],"ENTITY","queryHash","[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes\",\"bafy2bzacedlhlpb6mbjnz752batie53mzzwcc4gq5w4z4e7st7psec2aa2dgi\"]",{"_112":155,"_149":385,"_152":386},{"_114":156,"_133":134,"_135":384,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":157,"_39":381},{"_30":158,"_72":185,"_73":55,"_74":324,"_56":70,"_77":325,"_79":326,"_81":327,"_86":346,"_88":380,"_90":91},[159,205,305],{"_33":160,"_35":198},[161],{"_33":162,"_35":189},[163,173,181],{"_33":164,"_35":165},[],{"_37":166,"_39":167,"_41":168,"_43":169,"_67":171,"_69":70,"_71":172},"Embed","O7ToizTjcU","bafy2bzacedea7rgwjqgx3hck7oqacikboyfjvz6ly4ae4gsktdyk3ig4pjqam",{"_170":46},"view",[],"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/the-society-of-mind?v=bafy2bzacecx6wljek2flzkjnp2xrsb5nnh6es5jzd7eox7mu3df3zg32on67y",{"_33":174,"_35":175},[],{"_37":166,"_39":176,"_41":177,"_43":178,"_67":179,"_69":70,"_71":180},"vAhPOLxEOA","bafy2bzaceco6knhua4nz4rwwbxgit5rip7sqomk3ckl6xdz343f2fynazk5wc",{"_170":46},[],"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/education?v=bafy2bzacecano6z23vyfb5jwftryqekjegcjcqb7xvgpvdagguan3x5uwdo7g",{"_33":182,"_35":183},[],{"_37":166,"_39":184,"_41":185,"_43":186,"_67":187,"_69":70,"_71":188},"UCzcgEqNlX","bafy2bzacedsxhqs4eng26skwzlctyxqjn7b3hcyv7mvq4nrxdvwjttqyi2yky",{"_170":46},[],"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/distribute-objects-on-the-web?v=bafy2bzacebkuapdgegcl6fvwdo3s2yaf2kpwv3wfqpfxmv54l5vqy6gyakt7o&l",{"_37":190,"_39":191,"_41":192,"_43":193,"_67":196,"_69":197,"_71":70},"Heading","--IereXb","bafy2bzaceay7wokc6vu37fqhknt2r3uncbc2k4w3wmoeanpt2s433scrxve5u",{"_194":195},"childrenType","Group",[],"My Current Areas of Interest",{"_37":199,"_39":200,"_41":201,"_43":202,"_67":203,"_69":204,"_71":70},"Paragraph","ALa7tlkL","bafy2bzacebw7jscevpjrpepco7okujntk35b6ss5p4xr7kfe7tirubaovpmgc",{"_194":195},[],"I'm Gabo. I am building Seed Hypermedia. A tool for thought on the web. Hello people!",{"_33":206,"_35":299},[207,222,250,271],{"_33":208,"_35":217},[209],{"_33":210,"_35":211},[],{"_37":199,"_39":212,"_41":213,"_43":214,"_67":215,"_69":216,"_71":70},"qQ_RdNzu","bafy2bzacebkfktcndzfvcbmtchm3xg5exh744mzvwev7w5ftkcgcmt3slwdg2",{},[],"My journey started in finance—I studied it in college and landed a job at Morgan Stanley right after graduation. But wait! Before that, I worked for a small food company in Chicago, selling Jamón and Chorizo. That’s when I had my first real entrepreneurial spark—I knew I wanted to build something of my own.",{"_37":190,"_39":218,"_41":213,"_43":219,"_67":220,"_69":221,"_71":70},"Ockp45Gj",{"_194":195},[],"From finance to entrepreneurship",{"_33":223,"_35":245},[224],{"_33":225,"_35":226},[],{"_37":199,"_39":227,"_41":228,"_43":229,"_67":230,"_69":244,"_71":70},"3vvczJBp","bafy2bzacecjv5h7nygrwt3x2v36jfkbyqm5refnefcyayym4se7n3jmjc4gqy",{},[231],{"_37":232,"_233":234,"_238":239,"_43":243,"_71":70},"Bold","starts",[235,236,237],95,308,353,"ends",[240,241,242],111,328,361,{},"After some time at Morgan Stanley and Oquendo, a small M&A boutique, I found my first venture: Nexer Renovables, a solar energy company. It was a success by Spanish standards, and I loved the industry. However, it was too dependent on subsidies then, so I pivoted to a different sector with a similar impact—sustainable mobility. That’s when I launched Bluemove, one of Spain’s first car-sharing companies. In 2016, Europcar acquired Bluemove, and I helped shape the company's new mobility and technology division.",{"_37":190,"_39":246,"_41":213,"_43":247,"_67":248,"_69":249,"_71":70},"6gZzS3_L",{"_194":195},[],"Banking, Solar, and Carsharing.",{"_33":251,"_35":266},[252,259],{"_33":253,"_35":254},[],{"_37":199,"_39":255,"_41":228,"_43":256,"_67":257,"_69":258,"_71":70},"HhlPb4rv",{},[],"Bluemove required a fair amount of software and hardware. I was coming from spreadsheets and having to face HTML in Mailchimp->then CSS->Javascript->Terminal->Git->PHP->MYSQL->Python->Pandas->Numpy->ML->Bitcoin",{"_33":260,"_35":261},[],{"_37":199,"_39":262,"_41":228,"_43":263,"_67":264,"_69":265,"_71":70},"iKmPjkSQ",{},[],"Thanks to my technical friends who taught me, websites like Codecademy, Teamtreehouse, universities like MIT or Stanford through Coursera, and edX.",{"_37":190,"_39":267,"_41":213,"_43":268,"_67":269,"_69":270,"_71":70},"Lx69l5rk",{"_194":195},[],"Technology",{"_33":272,"_35":294},[273],{"_33":274,"_35":275},[],{"_37":199,"_39":276,"_41":228,"_43":277,"_67":278,"_69":293,"_71":70},"yyGQPtEk",{},[279,285],{"_37":232,"_233":280,"_238":282,"_43":284,"_71":70},[281],103,[283],132,{},{"_37":286,"_233":287,"_238":289,"_43":291,"_71":292},"Link",[288],159,[290],174,{},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/as-we-may-think?v=bafy2bzaceaqvup7xqozrjgf5aadd7ud7bey44u5zmekpj3w76qscejbnnc4gy","Now, I’m working on something more significant. I want to make a web where human consciousness exists, free from centralized servers. Everything started here: As We May Think",{"_37":190,"_39":295,"_41":213,"_43":296,"_67":297,"_69":298,"_71":70},"UztM6pdt",{"_194":195},[],"Interactive Web",{"_37":199,"_39":300,"_41":301,"_43":302,"_67":303,"_69":304,"_71":70},"qZvwGSFs","bafy2bzaceajktxpt7sq7ijul5xhdbcafilzizy77b2vjmuwjhq6hzqqcm5b2w",{"_194":195},[],"A Short Introduction to my worklife:",{"_33":306,"_35":319},[307],{"_33":308,"_35":309},[],{"_37":310,"_39":311,"_41":312,"_43":313,"_67":317,"_69":70,"_71":318},"Button","5uHKUquf","bafy2bzacedodgdg2jyw7vkrijwezejsh6pntqpceodgdupa7rlehzsxpo5kqc",{"_194":195,"_83":314,"_315":316},"Download Seed","alignment","center",[],"https://seed.hyper.media/hm/download",{"_37":199,"_39":320,"_41":228,"_43":321,"_67":322,"_69":323,"_71":70},"sHlli0B4",{"_194":195},[],"And this is the best implementation I have seen of those fundamental ideas:",[55],"1970-01-01T00:00:00Z","2026-02-23T15:38:18.646Z",{"_83":328,"_329":104,"_330":104,"_331":332,"_333":334,"_335":70,"_336":337,"_338":70,"_339":8,"_340":341,"_342":343},"Gabo H Beaumont","icon","thumbnail","cover","ipfs://bafybeiguwj7jll23xgh37usasgzapg7n5x2xfbzyat3jyrdthmwv2mufe4","siteUrl","https://gabo.es","layout","displayPublishTime","2025-01-21","seedExperimentalLogo","showActivity","contentWidth","L","theme",{"_344":345},"headerLayout","Center",{"_347":348},"navigation",{"_33":349,"_35":379},[350,356,362,367,373],{"_33":351,"_35":352},[],{"_37":286,"_39":353,"_71":354,"_69":355},"D4M0vdWGO_0DhNs_gD82Q","hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/hypertext?l","Hypertext",{"_33":357,"_35":358},[],{"_37":286,"_39":359,"_71":360,"_69":361},"JQKhsp-mGF6M8imtJjM5q","hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/liveable-cities?l","Liveable cities",{"_33":363,"_35":364},[],{"_37":286,"_39":365,"_71":366,"_69":84},"GvM_18W-DZLpMZnjJ35pl","hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes?l",{"_33":368,"_35":369},[],{"_37":286,"_39":370,"_71":371,"_69":372},"j6NO0hQ1Yx83E8d1UtRB8","hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/bitcoin?l"," My Road to Bitcoin",{"_33":374,"_35":375},[],{"_37":286,"_39":376,"_71":377,"_69":378},"5m6bIIjfg2qFKqAD27kzF","hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/reading-list?v=bafy2bzacectcrhr25vycemuvqi52wo36slyt2gdx6wwfbdr5rkhygmnzzgngg&l","Reading List",{"_37":195,"_39":347},"bafy2bzacebeulb5jemhe4qwd7evy5efew3n5a3nbxuud6o5shveyodalkaqgm",{"_39":382,"_97":55,"_56":383,"_72":-5,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou",[],1772124422190,[151,382,-5],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou\",null]",{"_112":388,"_149":798,"_152":801},{"_114":389,"_133":134,"_135":797,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},[390,429,457,481,506,530,558,579,601,629,653,677,698,721,749,769],{"_37":28,"_39":391,"_56":396,"_74":397,"_77":398,"_79":403,"_406":407,"_88":408,"_72":395,"_409":410,"_413":414,"_421":422,"_425":-5,"_81":426,"_90":91},{"_39":392,"_97":55,"_56":393,"_72":395,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/distribute-objects-on-the-web",[394],"distribute-objects-on-the-web","bafy2bzacebyb3xzm2qpakrj3mrxd6xdqfffmbzethy5imxgj5aqwgttdxqxhm",[394],[55],{"_399":400,"_401":402},"seconds","1770832201","nanos",811000000,{"_399":404,"_401":405},"1771861074",943000000,"sortTime","2026-02-11T17:50:01.811Z","bafy2bzacebkuapdgegcl6fvwdo3s2yaf2kpwv3wfqpfxmv54l5vqy6gyakt7o","breadcrumbs",[411],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},"isMissing","activitySummary",{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":419,"_420":6},"latestCommentTime","latestCommentId","commentCount","latestChangeTime",{"_399":404,"_401":405},"isUnread","generationInfo",{"_88":408,"_423":424},"generation","1770832201811","redirectInfo",{"_83":427,"_331":428},"Distribute Objects on the Web","ipfs://bafybeicfv5zmy3zwmyi2v4oew6kfv7axiwrnuhgde4fbtglocg54c4q6ae",{"_37":28,"_39":430,"_56":435,"_74":436,"_77":437,"_79":440,"_406":443,"_88":444,"_72":434,"_409":445,"_413":447,"_421":454,"_425":-5,"_81":456,"_90":91},{"_39":431,"_97":55,"_56":432,"_72":434,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/hypertext",[433],"hypertext","bafy2bzacec4jpz7ctdq2ppzuuayn5itui2fefijolvcz2f66za5qm3ctetxvk",[433],[55],{"_399":438,"_401":439},"1744442146",81000000,{"_399":441,"_401":442},"1771179428",711000000,"2025-04-12T07:15:46.081Z","bafy2bzaceb7etlxu6mcmft2377mgcebv5baawled4obbk6mu3xubsutnevfns",[446],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":448,"_416":451,"_417":452,"_418":453,"_420":6},{"_399":449,"_401":450},"1767743850",872000000,"zDnaeabGCpkitghcMccUCSTa37xikHSptr6LQJ2yEVxwnubRv/z6ErnhxBhRgfm4",11,{"_399":441,"_401":442},{"_88":444,"_423":455},"1744442146081",{"_83":355,"_339":6},{"_37":28,"_39":458,"_56":463,"_74":464,"_77":465,"_79":468,"_406":471,"_88":472,"_72":462,"_409":473,"_413":475,"_421":477,"_425":-5,"_81":479,"_90":91},{"_39":459,"_97":55,"_56":460,"_72":462,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/education",[461],"education","bafy2bzacearzvnunky7k6nvx36tiw2cfrkvnn5ybfqblqhuhqh27zwzanpvv6",[461],[55],{"_399":466,"_401":467},"1770832150",92000000,{"_399":469,"_401":470},"1771145566",638000000,"2026-02-11T17:49:10.092Z","bafy2bzacecano6z23vyfb5jwftryqekjegcjcqb7xvgpvdagguan3x5uwdo7g",[474],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":476,"_420":8},{"_399":469,"_401":470},{"_88":472,"_423":478},"1770832150092",{"_83":480},"Education",{"_37":28,"_39":482,"_56":487,"_74":488,"_77":489,"_79":492,"_406":493,"_88":486,"_72":486,"_409":494,"_413":496,"_421":502,"_425":-5,"_81":504,"_90":91},{"_39":483,"_97":55,"_56":484,"_72":486,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/the-society-of-mind",[485],"the-society-of-mind","bafy2bzacecx6wljek2flzkjnp2xrsb5nnh6es5jzd7eox7mu3df3zg32on67y",[485],[55],{"_399":490,"_401":491},"1770831826",690000000,{"_399":490,"_401":491},"2026-02-11T17:43:46.690Z",[495],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":497,"_416":500,"_417":134,"_418":501,"_420":6},{"_399":498,"_401":499},"1770887248",693000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6FQ8LvdpohEgt",{"_399":490,"_401":491},{"_88":486,"_423":503},"1770831826689",{"_83":505},"The Society of Mind",{"_37":28,"_39":507,"_56":512,"_74":513,"_77":514,"_79":517,"_406":520,"_88":521,"_72":511,"_409":522,"_413":524,"_421":526,"_425":-5,"_81":528,"_90":91},{"_39":508,"_97":55,"_56":509,"_72":511,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/seed-universidades",[510],"seed-universidades","bafy2bzacebcxmmvcjutyrygwzigwy34yhurfndannm3emv7r6hyviixmyckec",[510],[55],{"_399":515,"_401":516},"1765893650",436000000,{"_399":518,"_401":519},"1770284977",717000000,"2025-12-16T14:00:50.436Z","bafy2bzaced34ysw7swt3vd6gpbnvfeedwg6imv2u52s6bkcgwinr25jyuzonu",[523],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":525,"_420":8},{"_399":518,"_401":519},{"_88":521,"_423":527},"0",{"_83":529},"Una nueva infraestructura digital para la universidad del siglo XXI",{"_37":28,"_39":531,"_56":536,"_74":537,"_77":538,"_79":541,"_406":544,"_88":545,"_72":535,"_409":546,"_413":548,"_421":555,"_425":-5,"_81":557,"_90":91},{"_39":532,"_97":55,"_56":533,"_72":535,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/liveable-cities",[534],"liveable-cities","bafy2bzaceahtt2et52wjr5kmshxfsjh2u33mjohta6k5plvzprwpeok5hnjrq",[534],[55],{"_399":539,"_401":540},"1744442231",276000000,{"_399":542,"_401":543},"1770026262",207000000,"2025-04-12T07:17:11.276Z","bafy2bzaceapkr7r2erh2vovxilucxkuxmzottgcee4a4f3h2bcwjr2gq7ev7u",[547],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":549,"_416":552,"_417":553,"_418":554,"_420":6},{"_399":550,"_401":551},"1771847657",464000000,"zDnaef3gq3z4oPBQNfMErADkWHuMBHcpcaZmhPcUkBwYTTizV/z6FZhh2FWkawUk",18,{"_399":542,"_401":543},{"_88":545,"_423":556},"1744442231276",{"_83":361},{"_37":28,"_39":559,"_56":564,"_74":565,"_77":566,"_79":569,"_406":570,"_88":563,"_72":563,"_409":571,"_413":573,"_421":575,"_425":-5,"_81":577,"_90":91},{"_39":560,"_97":55,"_56":561,"_72":563,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/untitled-document",[562],"untitled-document","bafy2bzacedmg3sbipeu3wmh2bdt643j3lzur2vyhnvibsw5xvsoyksaxp3f6u",[562],[55],{"_399":567,"_401":568},"1769709551",150000000,{"_399":567,"_401":568},"2026-01-29T17:59:11.150Z",[572],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":574,"_420":8},{"_399":567,"_401":568},{"_88":563,"_423":576},"1769709551150",{"_83":578},"Vault or Secrets",{"_37":28,"_39":580,"_56":582,"_74":583,"_77":584,"_79":587,"_406":78,"_88":89,"_72":42,"_409":590,"_413":592,"_421":598,"_425":-5,"_81":600,"_90":91},{"_39":98,"_97":55,"_56":581,"_72":42,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57],[57],[55],{"_399":585,"_401":586},"1734342415",189000000,{"_399":588,"_401":589},"1767735662",679000000,[591],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":593,"_416":596,"_417":17,"_418":597,"_420":6},{"_399":594,"_401":595},"1771863136",926000000,"z6MkomKJd58PhVSoDZPi9RtUZ6rLrT2P8UN9ijLpb7Hj2tdn/z6FZreAskjherq",{"_399":588,"_401":589},{"_88":89,"_423":599},"1734342415189",{"_83":84,"_85":6},{"_37":28,"_39":602,"_56":607,"_74":608,"_77":609,"_79":612,"_406":615,"_88":616,"_72":606,"_409":617,"_413":619,"_421":626,"_425":-5,"_81":628,"_90":91},{"_39":603,"_97":55,"_56":604,"_72":606,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/reading-list",[605],"reading-list","bafy2bzacedrdnzjh2fz2pb7tfqapwwf4xoy5hj7hwb3pieuezfcv4nbmitw3w",[605],[55],{"_399":610,"_401":611},"1763983766",293000000,{"_399":613,"_401":614},"1765450011",339000000,"2025-11-24T11:29:26.293Z","bafy2bzacectcrhr25vycemuvqi52wo36slyt2gdx6wwfbdr5rkhygmnzzgngg",[618],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":620,"_416":623,"_417":624,"_418":625,"_420":6},{"_399":621,"_401":622},"1770838614",780000000,"zDnaefcevAYg159NYTnXCyiSBc4BvPGXnxBey4H4YRrcneurC/z6FPeDr2LbJYoY",6,{"_399":613,"_401":614},{"_88":616,"_423":627},"1763983766292",{"_83":378},{"_37":28,"_39":630,"_56":635,"_74":636,"_77":637,"_79":640,"_406":643,"_88":644,"_72":634,"_409":645,"_413":647,"_421":649,"_425":-5,"_81":651,"_90":91},{"_39":631,"_97":55,"_56":632,"_72":634,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/contact",[633],"contact","bafy2bzacecjtc32qsk6p7k3zmt22pcsgri5covh6gjladmeyxojwsszs2pe7k",[633],[55],{"_399":638,"_401":639},"1745826975",279000000,{"_399":641,"_401":642},"1764240605",716000000,"2025-04-28T07:56:15.279Z","bafy2bzacec5jbrbltpqeqvakdb5ukyt2xjs2od6griaxovarovydgxwkkd4ng",[646],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":648,"_420":6},{"_399":641,"_401":642},{"_88":644,"_423":650},"1745826975279",{"_83":652},"Contact",{"_37":28,"_39":654,"_56":659,"_74":660,"_77":661,"_79":664,"_406":667,"_88":668,"_72":658,"_409":669,"_413":671,"_421":673,"_425":-5,"_81":674,"_90":91},{"_39":655,"_97":55,"_56":656,"_72":658,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/para-mi-madre",[657],"para-mi-madre","bafy2bzaceai7adzc2q7py3odxr23gmqf7ko2epatwjwmzp4cwawx2pxdi2pds",[657],[55],{"_399":662,"_401":663},"1760630363",617000000,{"_399":665,"_401":666},"1760630417",686000000,"2025-10-16T15:59:23.617Z","bafy2bzacec2tqw7udkbrs3wnlzxzeghzvrh26uflgmtxdv3imgqj2w3dp62jg",[670],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":672,"_420":6},{"_399":665,"_401":666},{"_88":668,"_423":527},{"_83":675,"_340":676},"Para mi madre","S",{"_37":28,"_39":678,"_56":683,"_74":684,"_77":685,"_79":688,"_406":689,"_88":682,"_72":682,"_409":690,"_413":692,"_421":694,"_425":-5,"_81":696,"_90":91},{"_39":679,"_97":55,"_56":680,"_72":682,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/cosmos",[681],"cosmos","bafy2bzaceathisl7vgdcvhoqzyqj4optleokgljlkreemx5ytay6nwwfvgf74",[681],[55],{"_399":686,"_401":687},"1758897426",245000000,{"_399":686,"_401":687},"2025-09-26T14:37:06.245Z",[691],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":693,"_420":6},{"_399":686,"_401":687},{"_88":682,"_423":695},"1758897426245",{"_83":697},"Cosmos",{"_37":28,"_39":699,"_56":704,"_74":705,"_77":706,"_79":709,"_406":712,"_88":713,"_72":703,"_409":714,"_413":716,"_421":718,"_425":-5,"_81":719,"_90":91},{"_39":700,"_97":55,"_56":701,"_72":703,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/find-what-is-relevant",[702],"find-what-is-relevant","bafy2bzacecopvqngr3ougbuqzvgm6cjr676zvwtyanrfbwazkebiqd5wcp4cu",[702],[55],{"_399":707,"_401":708},"1756826541",288000000,{"_399":710,"_401":711},"1756984800",883000000,"2025-09-02T15:22:21.288Z","bafy2bzacecvwp33i3n7fpb4vgvm7dcyaovf2rxew7pwproddp4ue5nqzxo6i4",[715],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":717,"_420":6},{"_399":710,"_401":711},{"_88":713,"_423":527},{"_83":720},"Find what is relevant",{"_37":28,"_39":722,"_56":727,"_74":728,"_77":729,"_79":732,"_406":735,"_88":736,"_72":726,"_409":737,"_413":739,"_421":745,"_425":-5,"_81":747,"_90":91},{"_39":723,"_97":55,"_56":724,"_72":726,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/seed-hypermedia-construyendo-conocimiento-juntos",[725],"seed-hypermedia-construyendo-conocimiento-juntos","bafy2bzacecyg4i6aomerryvbhy3ung3pf726q3n47x3vap2n3srosjoepl6jm",[725],[55],{"_399":730,"_401":731},"1756721588",185000000,{"_399":733,"_401":734},"1756723714",210000000,"2025-09-01T10:13:08.185Z","bafy2bzacedt4jj6wg26nrrei6wzob4llcwym36iwmvp3mxmw67vwxqhslden4",[738],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":740,"_416":743,"_417":134,"_418":744,"_420":6},{"_399":741,"_401":742},"1765979336",516000000,"zDnaetWgjmGQR7RDQSHbbMFm7bTGwQDEyaXM1zHmuAqkU4Nw6/z6EZCPqfNmsJ7r",{"_399":733,"_401":734},{"_88":736,"_423":746},"1756721588184",{"_83":748},"Seed Hypermedia: Construyendo Conocimiento Juntos",{"_37":28,"_39":750,"_56":755,"_74":756,"_77":757,"_79":759,"_406":760,"_88":754,"_72":754,"_409":761,"_413":763,"_421":765,"_425":-5,"_81":767,"_90":91},{"_39":751,"_97":55,"_56":752,"_72":754,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/gif-test",[753],"gif-test","bafy2bzacebo6hemwz6grypjiunvkfogndbryqtrhqxiqn3my7oo5a6cnlndzc",[753],[55],{"_399":758,"_401":568},"1756202297",{"_399":758,"_401":568},"2025-08-26T09:58:17.150Z",[762],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":764,"_420":6},{"_399":758,"_401":568},{"_88":754,"_423":766},"1756202297147",{"_83":768},"Gif Test",{"_37":28,"_39":770,"_56":775,"_74":776,"_77":777,"_79":780,"_406":783,"_88":784,"_72":774,"_409":785,"_413":787,"_421":794,"_425":-5,"_81":796,"_90":91},{"_39":771,"_97":55,"_56":772,"_72":774,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/bitcoin",[773],"bitcoin","bafy2bzacebgvdhl752qdhdqpbh2nnv354xkbwceagteitqvlh2vssh6yqubxs",[773],[55],{"_399":778,"_401":779},"1744442261",941000000,{"_399":781,"_401":782},"1748296782",431000000,"2025-04-12T07:17:41.941Z","bafy2bzacedwamzp4pab4o2pzzak3ysgnstc3po66p47cgy32r3ed6avwxnov4",[786],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_415":788,"_416":791,"_417":792,"_418":793,"_420":6},{"_399":789,"_401":790},"1763389820",270000000,"zDnaezAgTJhrKJhHLvmmg943569b5bQv4hzLBnLyv2SS4aVhR/z6E7P2tmsL9a7P",5,{"_399":781,"_401":782},{"_88":784,"_423":795},"1744442261941",{"_83":372,"_331":70,"_340":676},1772124422022,[799,382,800],"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY","Children","[\"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou\",\"Children\"]",{"_112":803,"_149":2388,"_152":2389},{"_114":804,"_133":134,"_135":2387,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},[805,831,857,881,910,937,962,985,1014,1036,1058,1087,1111,1136,1159,1180,1205,1226,1248,1270,1295,1317,1342,1364,1386,1408,1429,1451,1473,1496,1524,1549,1575,1603,1625,1647,1673,1695,1717,1739,1761,1782,1811,1836,1866,1892,1914,1936,1965,1986,2013,2035,2060,2083,2109,2135,2160,2182,2206,2227,2249,2274,2299,2321,2343,2365],{"_37":28,"_39":806,"_56":811,"_74":812,"_77":813,"_79":816,"_406":817,"_88":810,"_72":810,"_409":818,"_413":821,"_421":827,"_425":-5,"_81":829,"_90":91},{"_39":807,"_97":55,"_56":808,"_72":810,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/workouts-and-kettleballs",[57,809],"workouts-and-kettleballs","bafy2bzaceaqibti63gujgqzk3rdsl5h3f4db54d23jwjk4qwpws5fl5w2aynw",[57,809],[55],{"_399":814,"_401":815},"1771517422",101000000,{"_399":814,"_401":815},"2026-02-19T16:10:22.101Z",[819,820],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":822,"_416":825,"_417":134,"_418":826,"_420":8},{"_399":823,"_401":824},"1771517470",885000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6FWQmFqpiPfHm",{"_399":814,"_401":815},{"_88":810,"_423":828},"1771517422098",{"_83":830},"Workouts and Kettleballs",{"_37":28,"_39":832,"_56":837,"_74":838,"_77":839,"_79":842,"_406":843,"_88":836,"_72":836,"_409":844,"_413":847,"_421":853,"_425":-5,"_81":855,"_90":91},{"_39":833,"_97":55,"_56":834,"_72":836,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/what-killed-rss",[57,835],"what-killed-rss","bafy2bzacea2pd5tg2vcx36seucgvygewkkbd6rqrvbpxrwhojdkei644zess4",[57,835],[55],{"_399":840,"_401":841},"1771145366",661000000,{"_399":840,"_401":841},"2026-02-15T08:49:26.661Z",[845,846],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":848,"_416":851,"_417":134,"_418":852,"_420":8},{"_399":849,"_401":850},"1771364561",250000000,"zDnaeyhj1iGJbMTZELU3ZXoCCrDn2LQsmp8SHmRKwQaAhS2cT/z6FUtLzGDJSB3c",{"_399":840,"_401":841},{"_88":836,"_423":854},"1771145366661",{"_83":856},"What killed RSS?",{"_37":28,"_39":858,"_56":863,"_74":864,"_77":865,"_79":868,"_406":869,"_88":862,"_72":862,"_409":870,"_413":873,"_421":875,"_425":-5,"_81":877,"_90":91},{"_39":859,"_97":55,"_56":860,"_72":862,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/the-early-history-of-smalltalk",[57,861],"the-early-history-of-smalltalk","bafy2bzacecjoy45pfstjoybf47gnkham5nxahhznif2nx2645gqpfhck4hp4s",[57,861],[55],{"_399":866,"_401":867},"1770722686",779000000,{"_399":866,"_401":867},"2026-02-10T11:24:46.779Z",[871,872],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":874,"_420":8},{"_399":866,"_401":867},{"_88":862,"_423":876},"1770722686776",{"_83":878,"_879":880},"The Early History Of Smalltalk","summary","Alan C. Kay\nApple Computer\nkay2@apple.com.Internet#",{"_37":28,"_39":882,"_56":887,"_74":888,"_77":889,"_79":892,"_406":895,"_88":896,"_72":886,"_409":897,"_413":900,"_421":906,"_425":-5,"_81":908,"_90":91},{"_39":883,"_97":55,"_56":884,"_72":886,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/document-crdt-overview-from-martin-kleppmann",[57,885],"document-crdt-overview-from-martin-kleppmann","bafy2bzacebhcl4vpfxeyx66nri4oqr26fn5sll6765jjimykc5bimmowkp4oq",[57,885],[55],{"_399":890,"_401":891},"1770656180",582000000,{"_399":893,"_401":894},"1770659688",259000000,"2026-02-09T16:56:20.582Z","bafy2bzaceanxupo2vpb5m3kidvwngcsmjioai2udbhpzdwntvmnpwr2dft426",[898,899],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":901,"_416":904,"_417":134,"_418":905,"_420":8},{"_399":902,"_401":903},"1770660150",360000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6FMs2XKNgcsos",{"_399":893,"_401":894},{"_88":896,"_423":907},"1770656180581",{"_83":909},"Document CRDT overview from Martin Kleppmann",{"_37":28,"_39":911,"_56":916,"_74":917,"_77":918,"_79":921,"_406":922,"_88":915,"_72":915,"_409":923,"_413":926,"_421":933,"_425":-5,"_81":935,"_90":91},{"_39":912,"_97":55,"_56":913,"_72":915,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/ideas-for-a-programming-framework-for-the-web",[57,914],"ideas-for-a-programming-framework-for-the-web","bafy2bzaceby6jiotug42gwaaubf7cah7wxk4wbyurkdkasbqmhgdljagedt6w",[57,914],[55],{"_399":919,"_401":920},"1770657488",142000000,{"_399":919,"_401":920},"2026-02-09T17:18:08.142Z",[924,925],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":927,"_416":930,"_417":931,"_418":932,"_420":8},{"_399":928,"_401":929},"1770711203",543000000,"zDnaeabGCpkitghcMccUCSTa37xikHSptr6LQJ2yEVxwnubRv/z6FNNYjtVDJbCv",7,{"_399":919,"_401":920},{"_88":915,"_423":934},"1770657488142",{"_83":936},"Ideas for a programming framework for the web",{"_37":28,"_39":938,"_56":943,"_74":944,"_77":945,"_79":948,"_406":951,"_88":952,"_72":942,"_409":953,"_413":956,"_421":958,"_425":-5,"_81":960,"_90":91},{"_39":939,"_97":55,"_56":940,"_72":942,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/francis-bacon-novum-organum",[57,941],"francis-bacon-novum-organum","bafy2bzaceaz2gyzvtbauji5vk572mkkebibu25orppsxw5jjxc4jiayfsnwn6",[57,941],[55],{"_399":946,"_401":947},"1770652685",687000000,{"_399":949,"_401":950},"1770655530",232000000,"2026-02-09T15:58:05.687Z","bafy2bzacecua32agmjsson56nzvrxznymoe7w34wfwhde72lergkmjh2kkbuc",[954,955],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":957,"_420":8},{"_399":949,"_401":950},{"_88":952,"_423":959},"1770652685687",{"_83":961},"Francis Bacon, Novum organum",{"_37":28,"_39":963,"_56":968,"_74":969,"_77":970,"_79":973,"_406":974,"_88":967,"_72":967,"_409":975,"_413":978,"_421":980,"_425":-5,"_81":982,"_90":91},{"_39":964,"_97":55,"_56":965,"_72":967,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/scientists-dont-give-you-science",[57,966],"scientists-dont-give-you-science","bafy2bzacednmb2dmdhqq2wfihebikuwmecxut6jdg56oyl67mcpl6i7ectoi2",[57,966],[55],{"_399":971,"_401":972},"1770653665",205000000,{"_399":971,"_401":972},"2026-02-09T16:14:25.205Z",[976,977],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":979,"_420":8},{"_399":971,"_401":972},{"_88":967,"_423":981},"1770653665205",{"_83":983,"_879":984},"Scientists don't give you Science","Quote from Alan Kay",{"_37":28,"_39":986,"_56":991,"_74":992,"_77":993,"_79":996,"_406":999,"_88":1000,"_72":990,"_409":1001,"_413":1004,"_421":1010,"_425":-5,"_81":1012,"_90":91},{"_39":987,"_97":55,"_56":988,"_72":990,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/alan-kay-on-simplicity",[57,989],"alan-kay-on-simplicity","bafy2bzaceb26442bzf6behywkepek5eyhcgrfxyup5apic2kbpqflpbnjbcqa",[57,989],[55],{"_399":994,"_401":995},"1770061928",136000000,{"_399":997,"_401":998},"1770067571",491000000,"2026-02-02T19:52:08.136Z","bafy2bzacedwx2yj2gy7svo3k5podih7rrtp5frdktzrtkgytgirqky52cr7p2",[1002,1003],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1005,"_416":1008,"_417":134,"_418":1009,"_420":8},{"_399":1006,"_401":1007},"1770067485",292000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6FFxKnAo69dhU",{"_399":997,"_401":998},{"_88":1000,"_423":1011},"1770061928136",{"_83":1013},"Alan Kay on Simplicity",{"_37":28,"_39":1015,"_56":1020,"_74":1021,"_77":1022,"_79":1025,"_406":1026,"_88":1019,"_72":1019,"_409":1027,"_413":1030,"_421":1032,"_425":-5,"_81":1034,"_90":91},{"_39":1016,"_97":55,"_56":1017,"_72":1019,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/humans-are-the-bottleneck",[57,1018],"humans-are-the-bottleneck","bafy2bzaceauvgzvbg7f43cpckqaaq23n5elsbsdwyzyfhwjkn7wid232vvklu",[57,1018],[55],{"_399":1023,"_401":1024},"1770026899",907000000,{"_399":1023,"_401":1024},"2026-02-02T10:08:19.907Z",[1028,1029],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1031,"_420":8},{"_399":1023,"_401":1024},{"_88":1019,"_423":1033},"1770026899907",{"_83":1035},"Humans are the bottleneck",{"_37":28,"_39":1037,"_56":1042,"_74":1043,"_77":1044,"_79":1047,"_406":1048,"_88":1041,"_72":1041,"_409":1049,"_413":1052,"_421":1054,"_425":-5,"_81":1056,"_90":91},{"_39":1038,"_97":55,"_56":1039,"_72":1041,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/education-and-ai",[57,1040],"education-and-ai","bafy2bzacecgzc3o2y7uj3o6ycpcxowqusp2yql46gwldayqoxh6ilwpmi7keu",[57,1040],[55],{"_399":1045,"_401":1046},"1769967558",653000000,{"_399":1045,"_401":1046},"2026-02-01T17:39:18.653Z",[1050,1051],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1053,"_420":8},{"_399":1045,"_401":1046},{"_88":1041,"_423":1055},"1769967558653",{"_83":1057},"Education and AI",{"_37":28,"_39":1059,"_56":1064,"_74":1065,"_77":1066,"_79":1069,"_406":1072,"_88":1073,"_72":1063,"_409":1074,"_413":1077,"_421":1083,"_425":-5,"_81":1085,"_90":91},{"_39":1060,"_97":55,"_56":1061,"_72":1063,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/thoughts-on-comment-sections",[57,1062],"thoughts-on-comment-sections","bafy2bzacea5yis3sofdk4tg65j3slub42yxud4mdne7ttai6qcvgmgvm7vsym",[57,1062],[55],{"_399":1067,"_401":1068},"1755194849",41000000,{"_399":1070,"_401":1071},"1769166706",538000000,"2025-08-14T18:07:29.041Z","bafy2bzacebe7zcqqzrmysad7rujxrttpnj2msz3wav2k7pwilejwxu5u77lwi",[1075,1076],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1078,"_416":1081,"_417":17,"_418":1082,"_420":6},{"_399":1079,"_401":1080},"1755253800",327000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6CiGTqhiDePDJ",{"_399":1070,"_401":1071},{"_88":1073,"_423":1084},"1755194849041",{"_83":1086},"Thoughts on comment sections",{"_37":28,"_39":1088,"_56":1093,"_74":1094,"_77":1095,"_79":1098,"_406":1100,"_88":1101,"_72":1092,"_409":1102,"_413":1105,"_421":1107,"_425":-5,"_81":1109,"_90":91},{"_39":1089,"_97":55,"_56":1090,"_72":1092,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/changes-to-augment",[57,1091],"changes-to-augment","bafy2bzaceb3grlezctgvirvp2towqbnbij6w4ryuqkljxyvumzn22rzxm2zau",[57,1091],[55],{"_399":1096,"_401":1097},"1767736103",866000000,{"_399":1099,"_401":568},"1769099237","2026-01-06T21:48:23.866Z","bafy2bzacedxeozqwljq2ewpkcnmnrtdhujzimmrvmkak7e243g2odo4zr6742",[1103,1104],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1106,"_420":8},{"_399":1099,"_401":568},{"_88":1101,"_423":1108},"1767736103866",{"_83":1110},"Changes to Augment",{"_37":28,"_39":1112,"_56":1117,"_74":1118,"_77":1119,"_79":1122,"_406":1125,"_88":1126,"_72":1116,"_409":1127,"_413":1130,"_421":1132,"_425":-5,"_81":1134,"_90":91},{"_39":1113,"_97":55,"_56":1114,"_72":1116,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/adfasdfasdf",[57,1115],"adfasdfasdf","bafy2bzacecloet77vhvk55cud6wb7ic4sacnhq77cdvhzqinf5tidz6euibow",[57,1115],[55],{"_399":1120,"_401":1121},"1768400268",888000000,{"_399":1123,"_401":1124},"1768400348",452000000,"2026-01-14T14:17:48.888Z","bafy2bzacebf2ytrmg44nckhqruzcdhd6y7ciuuersp3bzmkpquvseor3it3fe",[1128,1129],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1131,"_420":6},{"_399":1123,"_401":1124},{"_88":1126,"_423":1133},"1768400268888",{"_83":1135},"test",{"_37":28,"_39":1137,"_56":1142,"_74":1143,"_77":1144,"_79":1145,"_406":520,"_88":521,"_72":1141,"_409":1148,"_413":1151,"_421":1156,"_425":-5,"_81":1157,"_90":91},{"_39":1138,"_97":55,"_56":1139,"_72":1141,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/demo-seed-espanol",[57,1140],"demo-seed-espanol","bafy2bzaceca2yngzwddg5owvyxb52tmfjxzoytwdkxqpbdz22tzynvzv3p4vk",[57,1140],[55],{"_399":515,"_401":516},{"_399":1146,"_401":1147},"1766055250",792000000,[1149,1150],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1152,"_416":1154,"_417":134,"_418":1155,"_420":6},{"_399":1153,"_401":543},"1766054899","z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6EZx6467mNYPm",{"_399":1146,"_401":1147},{"_88":521,"_423":527},{"_83":1158},"Demostración de Seed",{"_37":28,"_39":1160,"_56":1165,"_74":1166,"_77":1167,"_79":1168,"_406":520,"_88":521,"_72":1164,"_409":1171,"_413":1174,"_421":1176,"_425":-5,"_81":1178,"_90":91},{"_39":1161,"_97":55,"_56":1162,"_72":1164,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/demo-seed",[57,1163],"demo-seed","bafy2bzacecny3hm7jpt4ics4pyzwrksd7wjf425qyhihek34xnlq2ahxadogm",[57,1163],[55],{"_399":515,"_401":516},{"_399":1169,"_401":1170},"1766053637",71000000,[1172,1173],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1175,"_420":8},{"_399":1169,"_401":1170},{"_88":521,"_423":1177},"1765893650435",{"_83":1179},"Demo Seed",{"_37":28,"_39":1181,"_56":1186,"_74":1187,"_77":1188,"_79":1191,"_406":1194,"_88":1195,"_72":1185,"_409":1196,"_413":1199,"_421":1201,"_425":-5,"_81":1203,"_90":91},{"_39":1182,"_97":55,"_56":1183,"_72":1185,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/personal-productivity",[57,1184],"personal-productivity","bafy2bzaceageqzrnyq4e2vwty6tbihwug5ics5pk2nd3rzvfp24lklr5jzpm2",[57,1184],[55],{"_399":1189,"_401":1190},"1765737718",212000000,{"_399":1192,"_401":1193},"1765747186",541000000,"2025-12-14T18:41:58.212Z","bafy2bzacedldyxfuouhrsevtoqtzmm3kqzl7saabn5hmxqtj4cliea4si23qg",[1197,1198],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1200,"_420":8},{"_399":1192,"_401":1193},{"_88":1195,"_423":1202},"1765737718212",{"_83":1204},"Personal Productivity",{"_37":28,"_39":1206,"_56":1211,"_74":1212,"_77":1213,"_79":1215,"_406":1216,"_88":1210,"_72":1210,"_409":1217,"_413":1220,"_421":1222,"_425":-5,"_81":1224,"_90":91},{"_39":1207,"_97":55,"_56":1208,"_72":1210,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/cognitive-light-cone",[57,1209],"cognitive-light-cone","bafy2bzacebikx7yj6hq2fntm3hqjlkbede67ms2kf7y3elxjqzwxbtevijd5y",[57,1209],[55],{"_399":1214,"_401":1193},"1765101287",{"_399":1214,"_401":1193},"2025-12-07T09:54:47.541Z",[1218,1219],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1221,"_420":8},{"_399":1214,"_401":1193},{"_88":1210,"_423":1223},"1765101287538",{"_83":1225},"Cognitive Light Cone",{"_37":28,"_39":1227,"_56":1232,"_74":1233,"_77":1234,"_79":1237,"_406":1238,"_88":1231,"_72":1231,"_409":1239,"_413":1242,"_421":1244,"_425":-5,"_81":1246,"_90":91},{"_39":1228,"_97":55,"_56":1229,"_72":1231,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/hyperlocal-journalism-and-seed-hypermedia-protocol",[57,1230],"hyperlocal-journalism-and-seed-hypermedia-protocol","bafy2bzacea3ii6ouwzcinjb4jyu65gejt2udur7czcgx4nwoy7k5utyhjj3xm",[57,1230],[55],{"_399":1235,"_401":1236},"1764931364",266000000,{"_399":1235,"_401":1236},"2025-12-05T10:42:44.266Z",[1240,1241],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1243,"_420":8},{"_399":1235,"_401":1236},{"_88":1231,"_423":1245},"1764931364266",{"_83":1247},"Hyperlocal Journalism and Seed Hypermedia Protocol",{"_37":28,"_39":1249,"_56":1254,"_74":1255,"_77":1256,"_79":1259,"_406":1260,"_88":1253,"_72":1253,"_409":1261,"_413":1264,"_421":1266,"_425":-5,"_81":1268,"_90":91},{"_39":1250,"_97":55,"_56":1251,"_72":1253,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/flood-or-gossip-comparing-decentralized-protocols",[57,1252],"flood-or-gossip-comparing-decentralized-protocols","bafy2bzacecfy64ukqspye4pq2hpffkulzxw7ep4onngl2q7potlj4dcwvzgra",[57,1252],[55],{"_399":1257,"_401":1258},"1764853603",905000000,{"_399":1257,"_401":1258},"2025-12-04T13:06:43.905Z",[1262,1263],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1265,"_420":8},{"_399":1257,"_401":1258},{"_88":1253,"_423":1267},"1764853603905",{"_83":1269},"Flood or Gossip: Comparing Decentralized Protocols",{"_37":28,"_39":1271,"_56":1276,"_74":1277,"_77":1279,"_79":1282,"_406":1285,"_88":1286,"_72":1275,"_409":1287,"_413":1290,"_421":1292,"_425":-5,"_81":1293,"_90":91},{"_39":1272,"_97":55,"_56":1273,"_72":1275,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/handling-errors-in-gos-range-functions-iterators",[57,1274],"handling-errors-in-gos-range-functions-iterators","bafy2bzacedl2xhupaazhaaa4fwknmlvzq3bzqxssm5mfbu3lm6fwumyb6wpuy",[57,1274],[55,1278],"z6MkgYR76i3w2Xc2fcvgFJWfYjsop6YwUonDhQx3AdLmQ4BQ",{"_399":1280,"_401":1281},"1764175415",938000000,{"_399":1283,"_401":1284},"1764176019",865000000,"2025-11-26T16:43:35.938Z","bafy2bzacediuvjuny2w5loofhsrxl6itp6nmzmteihukmyyddpha7o35nehre",[1288,1289],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1291,"_420":6},{"_399":1283,"_401":1284},{"_88":1286,"_423":527},{"_83":1294},"Handling Errors in Go's Range Functions (Iterators)",{"_37":28,"_39":1296,"_56":1301,"_74":1302,"_77":1303,"_79":1306,"_406":1307,"_88":1300,"_72":1300,"_409":1308,"_413":1311,"_421":1313,"_425":-5,"_81":1315,"_90":91},{"_39":1297,"_97":55,"_56":1298,"_72":1300,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/wikipedia-is-not-a-forum",[57,1299],"wikipedia-is-not-a-forum","bafy2bzaceb5kgbjr6yxyeivgc4wf5u3lffc2v7hlg3pxlsrg3sp2aeo2ed6ce",[57,1299],[55],{"_399":1304,"_401":1305},"1764174194",121000000,{"_399":1304,"_401":1305},"2025-11-26T16:23:14.121Z",[1309,1310],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1312,"_420":6},{"_399":1304,"_401":1305},{"_88":1300,"_423":1314},"1764174194121",{"_83":1316},"Wikipedia is not a Forum",{"_37":28,"_39":1318,"_56":1323,"_74":1324,"_77":1325,"_79":1328,"_406":1331,"_88":1332,"_72":1322,"_409":1333,"_413":1336,"_421":1338,"_425":-5,"_81":1340,"_90":91},{"_39":1319,"_97":55,"_56":1320,"_72":1322,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/robust-opennes",[57,1321],"robust-opennes","bafy2bzaceddjds4z7klrw7v2o5sy572ow5vegsur3jjoi5gfkyl6vjucpzliw",[57,1321],[55],{"_399":1326,"_401":1327},"1738669594",674000000,{"_399":1329,"_401":1330},"1763988914",225000000,"2025-02-04T11:46:34.674Z","bafy2bzaceaxdagmpzvhbf5zeae2otlehx5xnmjoy4iterrqlle2ku4q3adyga",[1334,1335],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1337,"_420":6},{"_399":1329,"_401":1330},{"_88":1332,"_423":1339},"1738669594674",{"_83":1341},"Robust Opennes",{"_37":28,"_39":1343,"_56":1348,"_74":1349,"_77":1350,"_79":1353,"_406":1354,"_88":1347,"_72":1347,"_409":1355,"_413":1358,"_421":1360,"_425":-5,"_81":1362,"_90":91},{"_39":1344,"_97":55,"_56":1345,"_72":1347,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/glucose-spikes",[57,1346],"glucose-spikes","bafy2bzaceal477qcnot3ikdodtguvfiqcw5x3faocdruc4knq43a45m4fnz3o",[57,1346],[55],{"_399":1351,"_401":1352},"1763482658",618000000,{"_399":1351,"_401":1352},"2025-11-18T16:17:38.618Z",[1356,1357],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1359,"_420":6},{"_399":1351,"_401":1352},{"_88":1347,"_423":1361},"1763482658618",{"_83":1363},"Glucose Spikes",{"_37":28,"_39":1365,"_56":1370,"_74":1371,"_77":1372,"_79":1375,"_406":1376,"_88":1369,"_72":1369,"_409":1377,"_413":1380,"_421":1382,"_425":-5,"_81":1384,"_90":91},{"_39":1366,"_97":55,"_56":1367,"_72":1369,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/testing-new-seed-app",[57,1368],"testing-new-seed-app","bafy2bzacedlbhmcmzoyss35yq5zu4npmopte24ezfbz2muyklrhdu2lynjzly",[57,1368],[55],{"_399":1373,"_401":1374},"1761212374",982000000,{"_399":1373,"_401":1374},"2025-10-23T09:39:34.982Z",[1378,1379],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1381,"_420":6},{"_399":1373,"_401":1374},{"_88":1369,"_423":1383},"1761212374982",{"_83":1385},"testing new seed app",{"_37":28,"_39":1387,"_56":1392,"_74":1393,"_77":1394,"_79":1397,"_406":1398,"_88":1391,"_72":1391,"_409":1399,"_413":1402,"_421":1404,"_425":-5,"_81":1406,"_90":91},{"_39":1388,"_97":55,"_56":1389,"_72":1391,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/peticion-olivia",[57,1390],"peticion-olivia","bafy2bzacebgnvvnvhk7edmirgq3dnvj4sgcddkc665wbrkahi2jwvladjtmia",[57,1390],[55],{"_399":1395,"_401":1396},"1760630621",973000000,{"_399":1395,"_401":1396},"2025-10-16T16:03:41.973Z",[1400,1401],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1403,"_420":6},{"_399":1395,"_401":1396},{"_88":1391,"_423":1405},"1760630621973",{"_83":1407},"Petición Olivia",{"_37":28,"_39":1409,"_56":1414,"_74":1415,"_77":1416,"_79":1419,"_406":1420,"_88":1413,"_72":1413,"_409":1421,"_413":1424,"_421":1426,"_425":-5,"_81":1427,"_90":91},{"_39":1410,"_97":55,"_56":1411,"_72":1413,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/fixed",[57,1412],"fixed","bafy2bzacecpos2zpz2nk7bdkhhiz5aa4lypvwk37si6muuudxpwgouh37nw5u",[57,1412],[55],{"_399":1417,"_401":1418},"1758908207",746000000,{"_399":1417,"_401":1418},"2025-09-26T17:36:47.746Z",[1422,1423],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1425,"_420":6},{"_399":1417,"_401":1418},{"_88":1413,"_423":527},{"_83":1428},"fixed!",{"_37":28,"_39":1430,"_56":1435,"_74":1436,"_77":1437,"_79":1440,"_406":1441,"_88":1434,"_72":1434,"_409":1442,"_413":1445,"_421":1447,"_425":-5,"_81":1449,"_90":91},{"_39":1431,"_97":55,"_56":1432,"_72":1434,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/methodology",[57,1433],"methodology","bafy2bzaceayxvmdfu477a4bsyyawhiwwn6vlqeet54wzhbgsuxlrzm4dcgvaa",[57,1433],[55],{"_399":1438,"_401":1439},"1756551546",272000000,{"_399":1438,"_401":1439},"2025-08-30T10:59:06.272Z",[1443,1444],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1446,"_420":6},{"_399":1438,"_401":1439},{"_88":1434,"_423":1448},"1756551546272",{"_83":1450},"Methodology",{"_37":28,"_39":1452,"_56":1457,"_74":1458,"_77":1459,"_79":1462,"_406":1463,"_88":1456,"_72":1456,"_409":1464,"_413":1467,"_421":1469,"_425":-5,"_81":1471,"_90":91},{"_39":1453,"_97":55,"_56":1454,"_72":1456,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/methodologies",[57,1455],"methodologies","bafy2bzacech4ifkbgqkjko3odxbvt5rryn6r5fqyxq2cexrk6c56g445nci2e",[57,1455],[55],{"_399":1460,"_401":1461},"1756458122",85000000,{"_399":1460,"_401":1461},"2025-08-29T09:02:02.085Z",[1465,1466],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1468,"_420":6},{"_399":1460,"_401":1461},{"_88":1456,"_423":1470},"1756458122084",{"_83":1472},"Methodologies",{"_37":28,"_39":1474,"_56":1479,"_74":1480,"_77":1481,"_79":1484,"_406":1485,"_88":1478,"_72":1478,"_409":1486,"_413":1489,"_421":1491,"_425":-5,"_81":1493,"_90":91},{"_39":1475,"_97":55,"_56":1476,"_72":1478,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/hayek",[57,1477],"hayek","bafy2bzaceareylhplnlnywhzd3xgo36uyfuqb7jx4oa5ki4vxtsj7r5jowfou",[57,1477],[55],{"_399":1482,"_401":1483},"1754319027",330000000,{"_399":1482,"_401":1483},"2025-08-04T14:50:27.330Z",[1487,1488],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1490,"_420":6},{"_399":1482,"_401":1483},{"_88":1478,"_423":1492},"1754319027330",{"_83":1494,"_331":1495},"Hayek","ipfs://bafkreifjclpssmjkfoyu5kcdvqu5ynjfuqb2e4xlucrnjwxn5rrnkvdb3u",{"_37":28,"_39":1497,"_56":1502,"_74":1503,"_77":1505,"_79":1506,"_406":1509,"_88":1510,"_72":1501,"_409":1511,"_413":1514,"_421":1520,"_425":-5,"_81":1522,"_90":91},{"_39":1498,"_97":55,"_56":1499,"_72":1501,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/luis-",[57,1500],"luis-","bafy2bzacecfdecmkukzru4exkfpolhkk4w4socrfuefi6qaangmwqaceo6d5i",[57,1500],[55,1504],"z6Mko238YMK8YUQDcHtC2zJPwxMJ8NDTiEMsCz3NYiYmbR9t",{"_399":527,"_401":139},{"_399":1507,"_401":1508},"1750087569",296000000,"1970-01-01T00:00:00.000Z","bafy2bzacedzeylnhrjyh7u6q3oj2cre5ur3by4w3qaxvszr4msnf6piermx76",[1512,1513],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1515,"_416":1518,"_417":792,"_418":1519,"_420":6},{"_399":1516,"_401":1517},"1753263293",120000000,"zDnaeuKgfvxgKkmnhDvUPNTgZ2wGmYtJbKcEqPhAwe6mp35KK/z6CNRUQFAU19Zn",{"_399":1507,"_401":1508},{"_88":1510,"_423":1521},"1750087509916",{"_83":1523},"Luis ",{"_37":28,"_39":1525,"_56":1530,"_74":1531,"_77":1532,"_79":1535,"_406":1538,"_88":1539,"_72":1529,"_409":1540,"_413":1543,"_421":1545,"_425":-5,"_81":1547,"_90":91},{"_39":1526,"_97":55,"_56":1527,"_72":1529,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/gabo-is-amazing",[57,1528],"gabo-is-amazing","bafy2bzacebam7b5s6zmdyhcfnefqrlhunaqsdbkkaqxfrb475hdlcosyny274",[57,1528],[55],{"_399":1533,"_401":1534},"1747984789",899000000,{"_399":1536,"_401":1537},"1750085330",177000000,"2025-05-23T07:19:49.899Z","bafy2bzacecvwfzfn2srfkvcxjjwkkd27b25hkgchmc7k6zez77mjv7drp2xds",[1541,1542],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1544,"_420":6},{"_399":1536,"_401":1537},{"_88":1539,"_423":1546},"1747984789898",{"_83":1548},"Gabo is amazing!",{"_37":28,"_39":1550,"_56":1555,"_74":1556,"_77":1557,"_79":1560,"_406":1561,"_88":1554,"_72":1554,"_409":1562,"_413":1565,"_421":1571,"_425":-5,"_81":1573,"_90":91},{"_39":1551,"_97":55,"_56":1552,"_72":1554,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/de-donde-sale-el-nombre-de-los-cantizales",[57,1553],"de-donde-sale-el-nombre-de-los-cantizales","bafy2bzacecjiu3jurwrzly73ujjkql7oijlwey7mwc5uplrylluwrjsuee77e",[57,1553],[55],{"_399":1558,"_401":1559},"1747670984",284000000,{"_399":1558,"_401":1559},"2025-05-19T16:09:44.284Z",[1563,1564],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1566,"_416":1569,"_417":134,"_418":1570,"_420":6},{"_399":1567,"_401":1568},"1749506167",319000000,"zDnaeXWXuy4pXkctJDhPze8HXMe1k6RGg7CAgQCZrzgTj737w/z6BixxH6vzB3c6",{"_399":1558,"_401":1559},{"_88":1554,"_423":1572},"1747670984284",{"_83":1574},"De dónde sale el nombre de \"Los Cantizales\"?",{"_37":28,"_39":1576,"_56":1581,"_74":1582,"_77":1583,"_79":1586,"_406":1588,"_88":1589,"_72":1580,"_409":1590,"_413":1593,"_421":1599,"_425":-5,"_81":1601,"_90":91},{"_39":1577,"_97":55,"_56":1578,"_72":1580,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/are-market-economies-incompatible-with-prosperity-equality-and-broad-based-decision-making-in-the-long-run",[57,1579],"are-market-economies-incompatible-with-prosperity-equality-and-broad-based-decision-making-in-the-long-run","bafy2bzaceaaynr53unb44jq6gi3fuv2ul4w3i45fadc4jrs6pipc3eps6htbg",[57,1579],[55],{"_399":1584,"_401":1585},"1747417454",30000000,{"_399":1587,"_401":867},"1747417791","2025-05-16T17:44:14.030Z","bafy2bzacedr334xud27c7ukbqwryz53qh3gt7z7q5trojxamkbbrekbmyggm2",[1591,1592],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1594,"_416":1597,"_417":17,"_418":1598,"_420":6},{"_399":1595,"_401":1596},"1747419182",302000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6BNABBANVNFhK",{"_399":1587,"_401":867},{"_88":1589,"_423":1600},"1747417454029",{"_83":1602},"Are Market Economies Incompatible with Prosperity, Equality, and Broad-Based Decision-Making in the Long Run?",{"_37":28,"_39":1604,"_56":1609,"_74":1610,"_77":1611,"_79":1614,"_406":1615,"_88":1608,"_72":1608,"_409":1616,"_413":1619,"_421":1621,"_425":-5,"_81":1623,"_90":91},{"_39":1605,"_97":55,"_56":1606,"_72":1608,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/exponential-period",[57,1607],"exponential-period","bafy2bzacebikvdlvyde2ygpa4s4dp5mjvw6tq2f7b6ayrh2ghjxsgojri3lws",[57,1607],[55],{"_399":1612,"_401":1613},"1746391801",286000000,{"_399":1612,"_401":1613},"2025-05-04T20:50:01.286Z",[1617,1618],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1620,"_420":6},{"_399":1612,"_401":1613},{"_88":1608,"_423":1622},"1746391801286",{"_83":1624},"Exponential Period",{"_37":28,"_39":1626,"_56":1631,"_74":1632,"_77":1633,"_79":1636,"_406":1637,"_88":1630,"_72":1630,"_409":1638,"_413":1641,"_421":1643,"_425":-5,"_81":1645,"_90":91},{"_39":1627,"_97":55,"_56":1628,"_72":1630,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/citizendium",[57,1629],"citizendium","bafy2bzacec3qcafvnrchm2bvj62qevflqhmgxibpywlwdeeudivko44hycqiu",[57,1629],[55],{"_399":1634,"_401":1635},"1746391364",34000000,{"_399":1634,"_401":1635},"2025-05-04T20:42:44.034Z",[1639,1640],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1642,"_420":8},{"_399":1634,"_401":1635},{"_88":1630,"_423":1644},"1746391364034",{"_83":1646},"Citizendium",{"_37":28,"_39":1648,"_56":1653,"_74":1654,"_77":1655,"_79":1658,"_406":1659,"_88":1652,"_72":1652,"_409":1660,"_413":1663,"_421":1669,"_425":-5,"_81":1671,"_90":91},{"_39":1649,"_97":55,"_56":1650,"_72":1652,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/media",[57,1651],"media","bafy2bzacebcmghf5p5pbudcnvmzws4aizivmttk5kvwdbn52zzhyq7wrrigto",[57,1651],[55],{"_399":1656,"_401":1657},"1746391081",282000000,{"_399":1656,"_401":1657},"2025-05-04T20:38:01.282Z",[1661,1662],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1664,"_416":1667,"_417":134,"_418":1668,"_420":6},{"_399":1665,"_401":1666},"1746637554",940000000,"zDnaeuKgfvxgKkmnhDvUPNTgZ2wGmYtJbKcEqPhAwe6mp35KK/z6BEND2rn1BsRV",{"_399":1656,"_401":1657},{"_88":1652,"_423":1670},"1746391081282",{"_83":1672},"Media",{"_37":28,"_39":1674,"_56":1679,"_74":1680,"_77":1681,"_79":1684,"_406":1685,"_88":1678,"_72":1678,"_409":1686,"_413":1689,"_421":1691,"_425":-5,"_81":1693,"_90":91},{"_39":1675,"_97":55,"_56":1676,"_72":1678,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/introduccion-a-mintter-hypermedia-bienvenidos-a-la-web-p2p",[57,1677],"introduccion-a-mintter-hypermedia-bienvenidos-a-la-web-p2p","bafy2bzacecx32jo5eb7cryzto4ap3arb76mtzrarton2lh3mypp7da5zu4pvy",[57,1677],[55],{"_399":1682,"_401":1683},"1746390793",884000000,{"_399":1682,"_401":1683},"2025-05-04T20:33:13.884Z",[1687,1688],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1690,"_420":8},{"_399":1682,"_401":1683},{"_88":1678,"_423":1692},"1746390793884",{"_83":1694},"Introducción a Mintter Hypermedia. Bienvenidos a la Web p2p",{"_37":28,"_39":1696,"_56":1701,"_74":1702,"_77":1703,"_79":1706,"_406":1707,"_88":1700,"_72":1700,"_409":1708,"_413":1711,"_421":1713,"_425":-5,"_81":1715,"_90":91},{"_39":1697,"_97":55,"_56":1698,"_72":1700,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/krishnamurti-the-book-of-life",[57,1699],"krishnamurti-the-book-of-life","bafy2bzaceckttgxza2rvnsbv7hhwzkuvuql2s6awjqeocyqu5x7t4o7xlph42",[57,1699],[55],{"_399":1704,"_401":1705},"1746390725",56000000,{"_399":1704,"_401":1705},"2025-05-04T20:32:05.056Z",[1709,1710],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1712,"_420":6},{"_399":1704,"_401":1705},{"_88":1700,"_423":1714},"1746390725056",{"_83":1716},"Krishnamurti The Book Of Life",{"_37":28,"_39":1718,"_56":1723,"_74":1724,"_77":1725,"_79":1728,"_406":1729,"_88":1722,"_72":1722,"_409":1730,"_413":1733,"_421":1735,"_425":-5,"_81":1737,"_90":91},{"_39":1719,"_97":55,"_56":1720,"_72":1722,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/la-vida-es-sueno-1635",[57,1721],"la-vida-es-sueno-1635","bafy2bzacebzkuq4eph6kmmllkn3f3asr2j36bzg5r3ua6u6ysk56e73dbck7k",[57,1721],[55],{"_399":1726,"_401":1727},"1746390538",211000000,{"_399":1726,"_401":1727},"2025-05-04T20:28:58.211Z",[1731,1732],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1734,"_420":8},{"_399":1726,"_401":1727},{"_88":1722,"_423":1736},"1746390538211",{"_83":1738},"La vida es sueño (1635)",{"_37":28,"_39":1740,"_56":1745,"_74":1746,"_77":1747,"_79":1750,"_406":1751,"_88":1744,"_72":1744,"_409":1752,"_413":1755,"_421":1757,"_425":-5,"_81":1759,"_90":91},{"_39":1741,"_97":55,"_56":1742,"_72":1744,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/philosophical-transactions-of-the-royal-society-of-london",[57,1743],"philosophical-transactions-of-the-royal-society-of-london","bafy2bzaceaaz6g7honcfmsczssg6palsn5psyv24ymphuowkflsg2gwduwpug",[57,1743],[55],{"_399":1748,"_401":1749},"1746169016",425000000,{"_399":1748,"_401":1749},"2025-05-02T06:56:56.425Z",[1753,1754],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1756,"_420":6},{"_399":1748,"_401":1749},{"_88":1744,"_423":1758},"1746169016425",{"_83":1760},"Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London",{"_37":28,"_39":1762,"_56":1767,"_74":1768,"_77":1769,"_79":1771,"_406":1772,"_88":1766,"_72":1766,"_409":1773,"_413":1776,"_421":1778,"_425":-5,"_81":1780,"_90":91},{"_39":1763,"_97":55,"_56":1764,"_72":1766,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/can-we-trust-information-without-editorial-review",[57,1765],"can-we-trust-information-without-editorial-review","bafy2bzacebjlowawqkd4nvqs232ompyacozgpa77glt7rb4om5td3duhmlwtu",[57,1765],[55],{"_399":1770,"_401":995},"1746114917",{"_399":1770,"_401":995},"2025-05-01T15:55:17.136Z",[1774,1775],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1777,"_420":8},{"_399":1770,"_401":995},{"_88":1766,"_423":1779},"1746114917136",{"_83":1781},"Can We Trust Information Without Editorial Review?",{"_37":28,"_39":1783,"_56":1788,"_74":1789,"_77":1790,"_79":1793,"_406":1796,"_88":1797,"_72":1787,"_409":1798,"_413":1801,"_421":1807,"_425":-5,"_81":1809,"_90":91},{"_39":1784,"_97":55,"_56":1785,"_72":1787,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/podemos-confiar-en-la-informacion-sin-revision-editorial",[57,1786],"podemos-confiar-en-la-informacion-sin-revision-editorial","bafy2bzacebogtnsh4sznxhi5o2yijamz2ngy2lgh5wuuqvnvusek7w25motcg",[57,1786],[55],{"_399":1791,"_401":1792},"1746088975",155000000,{"_399":1794,"_401":1795},"1746113511",141000000,"2025-05-01T08:42:55.155Z","bafy2bzacebdvne3lihujwiutzgwko2ffdzzzpp5avlj35cn5amyqlzwmmjyr2",[1799,1800],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1802,"_416":1805,"_417":17,"_418":1806,"_420":6},{"_399":1803,"_401":1804},"1746089748",833000000,"z6MktSTkA9HTh57iqc3CCrsLohAtCmBg2mVe73eE8BVzqoP5/z6B8uSmHnLSLut",{"_399":1794,"_401":1795},{"_88":1797,"_423":1808},"1746088975154",{"_83":1810},"¿Podemos confiar en la información sin revisión editorial?",{"_37":28,"_39":1812,"_56":1817,"_74":1818,"_77":1819,"_79":1822,"_406":1825,"_88":1826,"_72":1816,"_409":1827,"_413":1830,"_421":1832,"_425":-5,"_81":1834,"_90":91},{"_39":1813,"_97":55,"_56":1814,"_72":1816,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/when-exactly-did-hal-start-running-bitcoin",[57,1815],"when-exactly-did-hal-start-running-bitcoin","bafy2bzaceahv4bmmc4cmcm5uzvulbxf66f2lblff3sktl6envvwwhd27t3ej6",[57,1815],[55],{"_399":1820,"_401":1821},"1746090352",544000000,{"_399":1823,"_401":1824},"1746094654",849000000,"2025-05-01T09:05:52.544Z","bafy2bzaceb6acs6jeq3k2d6wl6rqkfdqrj6c4bqs2tmei5rpmen7i6pcl2pyy",[1828,1829],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1831,"_420":6},{"_399":1823,"_401":1824},{"_88":1826,"_423":1833},"1746090352544",{"_83":1835},"When Exactly Did Hal Start Running Bitcoin?",{"_37":28,"_39":1837,"_56":1842,"_74":1843,"_77":1844,"_79":1847,"_406":1850,"_88":1851,"_72":1841,"_409":1852,"_413":1855,"_421":1861,"_425":-5,"_81":1863,"_90":91},{"_39":1838,"_97":55,"_56":1839,"_72":1841,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/y-si-tina-paterson-tuviera-su-propio-archivo-digital",[57,1840],"y-si-tina-paterson-tuviera-su-propio-archivo-digital","bafy2bzaceahij6hayckj6tukfsicknc4mu44r32z5ts55bl6whn3n45bhmk7k",[57,1840],[55],{"_399":1845,"_401":1846},"1746094398",37000000,{"_399":1848,"_401":1849},"1746094415",373000000,"2025-05-01T10:13:18.037Z","bafy2bzaceae3do7itdeupu3shycb2bhrvkl3yojgiiqfcccn2celf4np4o4gu",[1853,1854],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1856,"_416":1859,"_417":134,"_418":1860,"_420":6},{"_399":1857,"_401":1858},"1746097505",918000000,"z6MktSTkA9HTh57iqc3CCrsLohAtCmBg2mVe73eE8BVzqoP5/z6B8yvvMoouUpt",{"_399":1848,"_401":1849},{"_88":1851,"_423":1862},"1746094398036",{"_83":1864,"_331":1865},"¿Y si Tina Paterson tuviera su propio archivo digital?","ipfs://bafkreiaylalnvpwsvooeq7ellzydajrrrprokzaqko4m7mlnzop33ee7j4",{"_37":28,"_39":1867,"_56":1872,"_74":1873,"_77":1874,"_79":1877,"_406":1878,"_88":1871,"_72":1871,"_409":1879,"_413":1882,"_421":1888,"_425":-5,"_81":1890,"_90":91},{"_39":1868,"_97":55,"_56":1869,"_72":1871,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/la-energia-renovable-nunca-llego-realmente-",[57,1870],"la-energia-renovable-nunca-llego-realmente-","bafy2bzaceab4lrg5svq3ifqhn32fcrcrchu3nrwmhv2ff3sxx6jgfdxvfzivc",[57,1870],[55],{"_399":1875,"_401":1876},"1746091613",489000000,{"_399":1875,"_401":1876},"2025-05-01T09:26:53.489Z",[1880,1881],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1883,"_416":1886,"_417":134,"_418":1887,"_420":6},{"_399":1884,"_401":1885},"1746103789",702000000,"z6Mkvz9TgGtv9zsGsdrksfNk1ajbFancgHREJEz3Y2HsAVdk/z6B93ZfZsHUdip",{"_399":1875,"_401":1876},{"_88":1871,"_423":1889},"1746091613489",{"_83":1891},"¿La energía renovable nunca llegó realmente? ",{"_37":28,"_39":1893,"_56":1898,"_74":1899,"_77":1900,"_79":1903,"_406":1904,"_88":1897,"_72":1897,"_409":1905,"_413":1908,"_421":1910,"_425":-5,"_81":1912,"_90":91},{"_39":1894,"_97":55,"_56":1895,"_72":1897,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/se-puede-resolver-el-problema-de-la-inercia-solo-con-renovables",[57,1896],"se-puede-resolver-el-problema-de-la-inercia-solo-con-renovables","bafy2bzacecnctjo6zohg2gn7b4rbaf3hbxqohtb4hquiosfohtcyzu7ge3q6c",[57,1896],[55],{"_399":1901,"_401":1902},"1746036947",122000000,{"_399":1901,"_401":1902},"2025-04-30T18:15:47.122Z",[1906,1907],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1909,"_420":8},{"_399":1901,"_401":1902},{"_88":1897,"_423":1911},"1746036947122",{"_83":1913},"Se puede resolver el problema de la inercia solo con renovables?",{"_37":28,"_39":1915,"_56":1920,"_74":1921,"_77":1922,"_79":1925,"_406":1926,"_88":1919,"_72":1919,"_409":1927,"_413":1930,"_421":1932,"_425":-5,"_81":1934,"_90":91},{"_39":1916,"_97":55,"_56":1917,"_72":1919,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/espana-necesita-energia-nuclear",[57,1918],"espana-necesita-energia-nuclear","bafy2bzacedp37s3s2ljl6c4hvxj3t56hyqufreoonac2u3wxp2edkh4scb45s",[57,1918],[55],{"_399":1923,"_401":1924},"1746036801",370000000,{"_399":1923,"_401":1924},"2025-04-30T18:13:21.370Z",[1928,1929],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1931,"_420":8},{"_399":1923,"_401":1924},{"_88":1919,"_423":1933},"1746036801370",{"_83":1935},"España necesita Energía Nuclear?",{"_37":28,"_39":1937,"_56":1942,"_74":1943,"_77":1944,"_79":1947,"_406":1950,"_88":1951,"_72":1941,"_409":1952,"_413":1955,"_421":1961,"_425":-5,"_81":1963,"_90":91},{"_39":1938,"_97":55,"_56":1939,"_72":1941,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/what-is-the-best-video-hosting-service",[57,1940],"what-is-the-best-video-hosting-service","bafy2bzacecq7x6hy3ilmvnrkawi5rqrclwuciyq73wcwhw2i3yebqnngoce74",[57,1940],[55],{"_399":1945,"_401":1946},"1745829132",749000000,{"_399":1948,"_401":1949},"1745830332",976000000,"2025-04-28T08:32:12.749Z","bafy2bzaceaeje4pfc54zd4bumba7i5lqh5jh3zrbkzgnm5rtt5hxaxuvmsgri",[1953,1954],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":1956,"_416":1959,"_417":624,"_418":1960,"_420":6},{"_399":1957,"_401":1958},"1745833038",407000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6B6M1EaWuN38r",{"_399":1948,"_401":1949},{"_88":1951,"_423":1962},"1745829132748",{"_83":1964},"What is the best video hosting service?",{"_37":28,"_39":1966,"_56":1971,"_74":1972,"_77":1973,"_79":1975,"_406":1976,"_88":1970,"_72":1970,"_409":1977,"_413":1980,"_421":1982,"_425":-5,"_81":1984,"_90":91},{"_39":1967,"_97":55,"_56":1968,"_72":1970,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/competicion-de-tenis-en-canal",[57,1969],"competicion-de-tenis-en-canal","bafy2bzaceakrbu4foooftr5fluzqqhrncqisp6l4y6nilxmn4iypltm4bfj7o",[57,1969],[55],{"_399":1974,"_401":790},"1745405510",{"_399":1974,"_401":790},"2025-04-23T10:51:50.270Z",[1978,1979],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":1981,"_420":8},{"_399":1974,"_401":790},{"_88":1970,"_423":1983},"1745405510270",{"_83":1985},"Competición de tenis en Canal",{"_37":28,"_39":1987,"_56":1992,"_74":1993,"_77":1995,"_79":1998,"_406":2001,"_88":2002,"_72":1991,"_409":2003,"_413":2006,"_421":2008,"_425":-5,"_81":2010,"_90":91},{"_39":1988,"_97":55,"_56":1989,"_72":1991,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/nunchuk-tu-primera-wallet-bitcoin-de-testnet",[57,1990],"nunchuk-tu-primera-wallet-bitcoin-de-testnet","bafy2bzacedsscdkre244u3xhpps45yyanvkjmmjpuwv6gvx5p2sr5t5ktlwhg",[57,1990],[55,1994],"z6MkpHiG87oJnyMajxKyJcEwNRTbrHWjKSnmVxuuxq7bP3nb",{"_399":1996,"_401":1997},"1744656306",847000000,{"_399":1999,"_401":2000},"1745398255",52000000,"2025-04-14T18:45:06.847Z","bafy2bzacedqvlr6ljzx74fq23qczwbm27y6t23ejy7wsvojqj5bl4kwy7jfde",[2004,2005],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2007,"_420":6},{"_399":1999,"_401":2000},{"_88":2002,"_423":2009},"1745398228749",{"_83":2011,"_331":2012},"Nunchuk: Tu primera wallet bitcoin de testnet","ipfs://bafybeifuhtwiaa3er4du4pcx6hro5grdqktg4iggmj24dcu3bfodpvgnku",{"_37":28,"_39":2014,"_56":2019,"_74":2020,"_77":2021,"_79":2024,"_406":2025,"_88":2018,"_72":2018,"_409":2026,"_413":2029,"_421":2031,"_425":-5,"_81":2033,"_90":91},{"_39":2015,"_97":55,"_56":2016,"_72":2018,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/how-to-learn-anything",[57,2017],"how-to-learn-anything","bafy2bzacec7675em6o5cipug27oaxwbzcotadhwcsn66jreiidqi6av7mfqqc",[57,2017],[55],{"_399":2022,"_401":2023},"1745229417",195000000,{"_399":2022,"_401":2023},"2025-04-21T09:56:57.195Z",[2027,2028],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2030,"_420":6},{"_399":2022,"_401":2023},{"_88":2018,"_423":2032},"1745229417195",{"_83":2034},"HOW TO LEARN ANYTHING",{"_37":28,"_39":2036,"_56":2041,"_74":2042,"_77":2043,"_79":2046,"_406":2049,"_88":2050,"_72":2040,"_409":2051,"_413":2054,"_421":2056,"_425":-5,"_81":2058,"_90":91},{"_39":2037,"_97":55,"_56":2038,"_72":2040,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/newspaper-is-a-great-business",[57,2039],"newspaper-is-a-great-business","bafy2bzaceb7zbnoftclkntwhthifbxmsdnw22na3nvgsqjx6ralh2vhcungcs",[57,2039],[55],{"_399":2044,"_401":2045},"1744448029",845000000,{"_399":2047,"_401":2048},"1744449318",882000000,"2025-04-12T08:53:49.845Z","bafy2bzacedwiufnnxqc3cvs2tyj6fdxlr5gtbpf5uziwncfg3a3g2q37upf34",[2052,2053],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2055,"_420":6},{"_399":2047,"_401":2048},{"_88":2050,"_423":2057},"1744448029845",{"_83":2059},"Newspaper is a great Business",{"_37":28,"_39":2061,"_56":2066,"_74":2067,"_77":2068,"_79":2071,"_406":2072,"_88":2065,"_72":2065,"_409":2073,"_413":2076,"_421":2078,"_425":-5,"_81":2080,"_90":91},{"_39":2062,"_97":55,"_56":2063,"_72":2065,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/about-mintter",[57,2064],"about-mintter","bafy2bzacecyauo2rgpz6iibecbqo5bzsxp3r5pxwiqwb43jkjdynnkg2qvn22",[57,2064],[55],{"_399":2069,"_401":2070},"1744438418",622000000,{"_399":2069,"_401":2070},"2025-04-12T06:13:38.622Z",[2074,2075],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2077,"_420":6},{"_399":2069,"_401":2070},{"_88":2065,"_423":2079},"1744438418622",{"_83":2081,"_336":2082,"_340":676},"About Mintter","2020-03-02",{"_37":28,"_39":2084,"_56":2089,"_74":2090,"_77":2092,"_79":2095,"_406":2098,"_88":2099,"_72":2088,"_409":2100,"_413":2103,"_421":2105,"_425":-5,"_81":2107,"_90":91},{"_39":2085,"_97":55,"_56":2086,"_72":2088,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/an-archival-system-for-the-web",[57,2087],"an-archival-system-for-the-web","bafy2bzacebl4uhek6tbjcemk2l74mrs5yugbadkuxibmnwrptsyecjxetb6o4",[57,2087],[55,2091],"z6MkeeXibqWALS7hJ8ZQYLSuY62xo1LKYhm7d5i9soF2edx4",{"_399":2093,"_401":2094},"1744197295",524000000,{"_399":2096,"_401":2097},"1744197472",14000000,"2025-04-09T11:14:55.524Z","bafy2bzaceaetev2qebehqlvgvvbx3kyqnpfjp4vvsdmdtolnjme4ueydp6vqq",[2101,2102],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2104,"_420":6},{"_399":2096,"_401":2097},{"_88":2099,"_423":2106},"1744206855589",{"_83":2108},"An archival system for the web",{"_37":28,"_39":2110,"_56":2115,"_74":2116,"_77":2118,"_79":2121,"_406":2124,"_88":2125,"_72":2114,"_409":2126,"_413":2129,"_421":2131,"_425":-5,"_81":2133,"_90":91},{"_39":2111,"_97":55,"_56":2112,"_72":2114,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/what-are-siloed-information-systems",[57,2113],"what-are-siloed-information-systems","bafy2bzaceatvxjv4ptzpfppqgyvo6rrzsmwginsiirgqcmmlmzmvz5jivpak6",[57,2113],[55,2117,2091],"z6Mkm8Uq6nbJDcA5ZyQCAhocWcL6KFfJkC7fFe465ZsMa6tw",{"_399":2119,"_401":2120},"1737656817",614000000,{"_399":2122,"_401":2123},"1743697190",812000000,"2025-01-23T18:26:57.614Z","bafy2bzacecvgih6m4zrffohio2zdz2ndsfpygbin6djegdlhi527w4vapa4j6",[2127,2128],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2130,"_420":6},{"_399":2122,"_401":2123},{"_88":2125,"_423":2132},"1743697136046",{"_83":2134},"What are Siloed Information Systems?",{"_37":28,"_39":2136,"_56":2141,"_74":2142,"_77":2144,"_79":2145,"_406":1509,"_88":2148,"_72":2140,"_409":2149,"_413":2152,"_421":2154,"_425":-5,"_81":2156,"_90":91},{"_39":2137,"_97":55,"_56":2138,"_72":2140,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/blog-templet",[57,2139],"blog-templet","bafy2bzacebwz7pvcwgagm6xtljnwy37dv3urbkhcaugpoomtmvkj4e4s4hf42",[57,2139],[55,2143],"z6MkrvMBtbQHQX1YyYE9k5oNcTURbV9fPr4UPencXcLG1Y4X",{"_399":527,"_401":139},{"_399":2146,"_401":2147},"1743688713",453000000,"bafy2bzacebydyoxjsb3yt5gc2zoc6okjk5jv2mvdg533vy3t6dviyxguvii6q",[2150,2151],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2153,"_420":8},{"_399":2146,"_401":2147},{"_88":2148,"_423":2155},"1743688704538",{"_83":2157,"_329":2158,"_338":2159,"_339":8},"Blog Templet","ipfs://bafkreibvpapgultftgrwyfftkjp6te5osir27ovpzv3nofl36sddsbnoeu","ipfs://bafkreigajxupfkuq24va4ri6fkgv2kpz4zsrjclqrziyoufz4jbieffx74",{"_37":28,"_39":2161,"_56":2166,"_74":2167,"_77":2168,"_79":2171,"_406":2172,"_88":2165,"_72":2165,"_409":2173,"_413":2176,"_421":2178,"_425":-5,"_81":2180,"_90":91},{"_39":2162,"_97":55,"_56":2163,"_72":2165,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/republished-a-lunaticoin-post",[57,2164],"republished-a-lunaticoin-post","bafy2bzacedxano3hetuxijr4a47r5ki6wpplklorfnfn4fho7sjho2zmcxozw",[57,2164],[55],{"_399":2169,"_401":2170},"1742638848",132000000,{"_399":2169,"_401":2170},"2025-03-22T10:20:48.132Z",[2174,2175],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2177,"_420":8},{"_399":2169,"_401":2170},{"_88":2165,"_423":2179},"1742638848132",{"_83":2181},"Republished a Lunaticoin Post",{"_37":28,"_39":2183,"_56":2187,"_74":2188,"_77":2189,"_79":2192,"_406":2195,"_88":2196,"_72":2186,"_409":2197,"_413":2200,"_421":2202,"_425":-5,"_81":2204,"_90":91},{"_39":2184,"_97":55,"_56":2185,"_72":2186,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/test",[57,1135],"bafy2bzacedoxitriwtlnmet7cddafy6xfimd2ey5mfdgzxpanxtzgwonymwc6",[57,1135],[55],{"_399":2190,"_401":2191},"1739966681",939000000,{"_399":2193,"_401":2194},"1741607164",340000000,"2025-02-19T12:04:41.939Z","bafy2bzacebmhemmu43gogj3hgr5k3bo4uetg357xuk5wegqyxdgkuzacrlf3y",[2198,2199],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2201,"_420":6},{"_399":2193,"_401":2194},{"_88":2196,"_423":2203},"1739966681939",{"_83":2205},"Object Capabilities",{"_37":28,"_39":2207,"_56":2212,"_74":2213,"_77":2214,"_79":2216,"_406":2217,"_88":2211,"_72":2211,"_409":2218,"_413":2221,"_421":2223,"_425":-5,"_81":2225,"_90":91},{"_39":2208,"_97":55,"_56":2209,"_72":2211,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/b2b-sales",[57,2210],"b2b-sales","bafy2bzacebedntzqjtsk2uet3unna4eioy33hmyl7sru6qlattvvu3vxdb4uo",[57,2210],[55],{"_399":2215,"_401":1804},"1740574759",{"_399":2215,"_401":1804},"2025-02-26T12:59:19.833Z",[2219,2220],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2222,"_420":6},{"_399":2215,"_401":1804},{"_88":2211,"_423":2224},"1740574759833",{"_83":2226},"B2B Sales",{"_37":28,"_39":2228,"_56":2233,"_74":2234,"_77":2235,"_79":2238,"_406":2239,"_88":2232,"_72":2232,"_409":2240,"_413":2243,"_421":2245,"_425":-5,"_81":2247,"_90":91},{"_39":2229,"_97":55,"_56":2230,"_72":2232,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/openness",[57,2231],"openness","bafy2bzaceduowa5qkfppyncerepllqfqhmuqcalwred5mq7nbpaiqtfdfs4ji",[57,2231],[55],{"_399":2236,"_401":2237},"1740569787",908000000,{"_399":2236,"_401":2237},"2025-02-26T11:36:27.908Z",[2241,2242],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2244,"_420":8},{"_399":2236,"_401":2237},{"_88":2232,"_423":2246},"1740569787908",{"_83":2248},"Openness",{"_37":28,"_39":2250,"_56":2255,"_74":2256,"_77":2257,"_79":2260,"_406":2263,"_88":2264,"_72":2254,"_409":2265,"_413":2268,"_421":2270,"_425":-5,"_81":2272,"_90":91},{"_39":2251,"_97":55,"_56":2252,"_72":2254,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/ads",[57,2253],"ads","bafy2bzaceaws73bj5sq4n6f7f2lcnbo3gsgzfygl24d2pldmrbvesp7qqel3a",[57,2253],[55],{"_399":2258,"_401":2259},"1732809576",243000000,{"_399":2261,"_401":2262},"1740565387",636000000,"2024-11-28T15:59:36.243Z","bafy2bzacebuu2bthzpflcuq7k2fivz5fkiz46tdrwscvt52sfq3dfh2y3eimm",[2266,2267],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2269,"_420":6},{"_399":2261,"_401":2262},{"_88":2264,"_423":2271},"1743612341011",{"_83":2273},"Ads",{"_37":28,"_39":2275,"_56":2280,"_74":2281,"_77":2282,"_79":2285,"_406":2288,"_88":2289,"_72":2279,"_409":2290,"_413":2293,"_421":2295,"_425":-5,"_81":2297,"_90":91},{"_39":2276,"_97":55,"_56":2277,"_72":2279,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/keywords",[57,2278],"keywords","bafy2bzaceauwvbxmi4taz7oz4mlml3khvml4xbar6euj36podll5ou6hutxji",[57,2278],[55],{"_399":2283,"_401":2284},"1733822157",133000000,{"_399":2286,"_401":2287},"1740565366",389000000,"2024-12-10T09:15:57.133Z","bafy2bzacebmjuozpxuj7gz5xopm7bcqql3wrsuvtxwex3myzvynb4vrsa7r3q",[2291,2292],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2294,"_420":6},{"_399":2286,"_401":2287},{"_88":2289,"_423":2296},"1744441942397",{"_83":2298},"Keywords",{"_37":28,"_39":2300,"_56":2305,"_74":2306,"_77":2307,"_79":2310,"_406":2311,"_88":2304,"_72":2304,"_409":2312,"_413":2315,"_421":2317,"_425":-5,"_81":2319,"_90":91},{"_39":2301,"_97":55,"_56":2302,"_72":2304,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/desinformacion",[57,2303],"desinformacion","bafy2bzacedb6ktx3h34m4oz5o5mhmjlsg3vmkzetvj3oi4kshkhiqcyzcml4i",[57,2303],[55],{"_399":2308,"_401":2309},"1740216357",834000000,{"_399":2308,"_401":2309},"2025-02-22T09:25:57.834Z",[2313,2314],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2316,"_420":6},{"_399":2308,"_401":2309},{"_88":2304,"_423":2318},"1743696870006",{"_83":2320},"Desinformación",{"_37":28,"_39":2322,"_56":2327,"_74":2328,"_77":2329,"_79":2332,"_406":2333,"_88":2326,"_72":2326,"_409":2334,"_413":2337,"_421":2339,"_425":-5,"_81":2341,"_90":91},{"_39":2323,"_97":55,"_56":2324,"_72":2326,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/fund-raising",[57,2325],"fund-raising","bafy2bzacebxkfjbxbhcygqbysjv2k2eqlpg5gf7tuv5m6oyratki7qzfoy4o4",[57,2325],[55],{"_399":2330,"_401":2331},"1739086886",460000000,{"_399":2330,"_401":2331},"2025-02-09T07:41:26.460Z",[2335,2336],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2338,"_420":8},{"_399":2330,"_401":2331},{"_88":2326,"_423":2340},"1739086886460",{"_83":2342},"Fund Raising",{"_37":28,"_39":2344,"_56":2349,"_74":2350,"_77":2351,"_79":2354,"_406":2355,"_88":2348,"_72":2348,"_409":2356,"_413":2359,"_421":2361,"_425":-5,"_81":2363,"_90":91},{"_39":2345,"_97":55,"_56":2346,"_72":2348,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/document-1",[57,2347],"document-1","bafy2bzacedkn3mzizqno7ikx6gh5accy4q33jyuqbj6pincsu5lpmmunpxnkg",[57,2347],[55],{"_399":2352,"_401":2353},"1738769136",162000000,{"_399":2352,"_401":2353},"2025-02-05T15:25:36.162Z",[2357,2358],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2360,"_420":6},{"_399":2352,"_401":2353},{"_88":2348,"_423":2362},"1738769136162",{"_83":2364},"Document 1",{"_37":28,"_39":2366,"_56":2371,"_74":2372,"_77":2373,"_79":2376,"_406":2377,"_88":2370,"_72":2370,"_409":2378,"_413":2381,"_421":2383,"_425":-5,"_81":2385,"_90":91},{"_39":2367,"_97":55,"_56":2368,"_72":2370,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/references",[57,2369],"references","bafy2bzacecoj3a3s4hrzxdysiislhlywrhcf2kp4bav7pkuvxzzxygaxwn3sk",[57,2369],[55],{"_399":2374,"_401":2375},"1737040138",619000000,{"_399":2374,"_401":2375},"2025-01-16T15:08:58.619Z",[2379,2380],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2382,"_420":6},{"_399":2374,"_401":2375},{"_88":2370,"_423":2384},"1744441927881",{"_83":2386},"References",1772124421934,[799,98,800],"[\"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes\",\"Children\"]",{"_112":2391,"_149":2400,"_152":2402},{"_114":2392,"_133":134,"_135":2399,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_2393":17,"_25":48,"_2394":2395,"_33":2396,"_2397":2398},"citations","changes",12,66,"blocks",{},1772124422156,[2401,98],"DOCUMENT_INTERACTION_SUMMARY","[\"DOCUMENT_INTERACTION_SUMMARY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes\"]",{"_112":2404,"_149":3426,"_152":3427},{"_114":2405,"_133":134,"_135":3425,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},[2406,2421,2436,2450,2465,2480,2494,2508,2523,2537,2551,2566,2580,2594,2609,2623,2637,2665,2679,2693,2707,2721,2735,2749,2763,2777,2791,2805,2819,2833,2847,2862,2876,2891,2906,2920,2934,2949,2963,2977,2991,3005,3019,3034,3048,3063,3078,3092,3106,3121,3135,3149,3163,3177,3191,3205,3219,3233,3247,3261,3275,3289,3303,3317,3331,3355,3369,3383,3411],{"_37":28,"_39":2407,"_56":2409,"_74":2410,"_77":2411,"_79":2412,"_406":817,"_88":810,"_72":810,"_409":2413,"_413":2416,"_421":2419,"_425":-5,"_81":2420,"_90":91},{"_39":807,"_97":55,"_56":2408,"_72":810,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,809],[57,809],[55],{"_399":814,"_401":815},{"_399":814,"_401":815},[2414,2415],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2417,"_416":825,"_417":134,"_418":2418,"_420":8},{"_399":823,"_401":824},{"_399":814,"_401":815},{"_88":810,"_423":828},{"_83":830},{"_37":28,"_39":2422,"_56":2424,"_74":2425,"_77":2426,"_79":2427,"_406":843,"_88":836,"_72":836,"_409":2428,"_413":2431,"_421":2434,"_425":-5,"_81":2435,"_90":91},{"_39":833,"_97":55,"_56":2423,"_72":836,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,835],[57,835],[55],{"_399":840,"_401":841},{"_399":840,"_401":841},[2429,2430],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2432,"_416":851,"_417":134,"_418":2433,"_420":8},{"_399":849,"_401":850},{"_399":840,"_401":841},{"_88":836,"_423":854},{"_83":856},{"_37":28,"_39":2437,"_56":2439,"_74":2440,"_77":2441,"_79":2442,"_406":869,"_88":862,"_72":862,"_409":2443,"_413":2446,"_421":2448,"_425":-5,"_81":2449,"_90":91},{"_39":859,"_97":55,"_56":2438,"_72":862,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,861],[57,861],[55],{"_399":866,"_401":867},{"_399":866,"_401":867},[2444,2445],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2447,"_420":8},{"_399":866,"_401":867},{"_88":862,"_423":876},{"_83":878,"_879":880},{"_37":28,"_39":2451,"_56":2453,"_74":2454,"_77":2455,"_79":2456,"_406":895,"_88":896,"_72":886,"_409":2457,"_413":2460,"_421":2463,"_425":-5,"_81":2464,"_90":91},{"_39":883,"_97":55,"_56":2452,"_72":886,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,885],[57,885],[55],{"_399":890,"_401":891},{"_399":893,"_401":894},[2458,2459],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2461,"_416":904,"_417":134,"_418":2462,"_420":8},{"_399":902,"_401":903},{"_399":893,"_401":894},{"_88":896,"_423":907},{"_83":909},{"_37":28,"_39":2466,"_56":2468,"_74":2469,"_77":2470,"_79":2471,"_406":922,"_88":915,"_72":915,"_409":2472,"_413":2475,"_421":2478,"_425":-5,"_81":2479,"_90":91},{"_39":912,"_97":55,"_56":2467,"_72":915,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,914],[57,914],[55],{"_399":919,"_401":920},{"_399":919,"_401":920},[2473,2474],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2476,"_416":930,"_417":931,"_418":2477,"_420":8},{"_399":928,"_401":929},{"_399":919,"_401":920},{"_88":915,"_423":934},{"_83":936},{"_37":28,"_39":2481,"_56":2483,"_74":2484,"_77":2485,"_79":2486,"_406":951,"_88":952,"_72":942,"_409":2487,"_413":2490,"_421":2492,"_425":-5,"_81":2493,"_90":91},{"_39":939,"_97":55,"_56":2482,"_72":942,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,941],[57,941],[55],{"_399":946,"_401":947},{"_399":949,"_401":950},[2488,2489],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2491,"_420":8},{"_399":949,"_401":950},{"_88":952,"_423":959},{"_83":961},{"_37":28,"_39":2495,"_56":2497,"_74":2498,"_77":2499,"_79":2500,"_406":974,"_88":967,"_72":967,"_409":2501,"_413":2504,"_421":2506,"_425":-5,"_81":2507,"_90":91},{"_39":964,"_97":55,"_56":2496,"_72":967,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,966],[57,966],[55],{"_399":971,"_401":972},{"_399":971,"_401":972},[2502,2503],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2505,"_420":8},{"_399":971,"_401":972},{"_88":967,"_423":981},{"_83":983,"_879":984},{"_37":28,"_39":2509,"_56":2511,"_74":2512,"_77":2513,"_79":2514,"_406":999,"_88":1000,"_72":990,"_409":2515,"_413":2518,"_421":2521,"_425":-5,"_81":2522,"_90":91},{"_39":987,"_97":55,"_56":2510,"_72":990,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,989],[57,989],[55],{"_399":994,"_401":995},{"_399":997,"_401":998},[2516,2517],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2519,"_416":1008,"_417":134,"_418":2520,"_420":8},{"_399":1006,"_401":1007},{"_399":997,"_401":998},{"_88":1000,"_423":1011},{"_83":1013},{"_37":28,"_39":2524,"_56":2526,"_74":2527,"_77":2528,"_79":2529,"_406":1026,"_88":1019,"_72":1019,"_409":2530,"_413":2533,"_421":2535,"_425":-5,"_81":2536,"_90":91},{"_39":1016,"_97":55,"_56":2525,"_72":1019,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1018],[57,1018],[55],{"_399":1023,"_401":1024},{"_399":1023,"_401":1024},[2531,2532],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2534,"_420":8},{"_399":1023,"_401":1024},{"_88":1019,"_423":1033},{"_83":1035},{"_37":28,"_39":2538,"_56":2540,"_74":2541,"_77":2542,"_79":2543,"_406":1048,"_88":1041,"_72":1041,"_409":2544,"_413":2547,"_421":2549,"_425":-5,"_81":2550,"_90":91},{"_39":1038,"_97":55,"_56":2539,"_72":1041,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1040],[57,1040],[55],{"_399":1045,"_401":1046},{"_399":1045,"_401":1046},[2545,2546],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2548,"_420":8},{"_399":1045,"_401":1046},{"_88":1041,"_423":1055},{"_83":1057},{"_37":28,"_39":2552,"_56":2554,"_74":2555,"_77":2556,"_79":2557,"_406":1072,"_88":1073,"_72":1063,"_409":2558,"_413":2561,"_421":2564,"_425":-5,"_81":2565,"_90":91},{"_39":1060,"_97":55,"_56":2553,"_72":1063,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1062],[57,1062],[55],{"_399":1067,"_401":1068},{"_399":1070,"_401":1071},[2559,2560],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2562,"_416":1081,"_417":17,"_418":2563,"_420":6},{"_399":1079,"_401":1080},{"_399":1070,"_401":1071},{"_88":1073,"_423":1084},{"_83":1086},{"_37":28,"_39":2567,"_56":2569,"_74":2570,"_77":2571,"_79":2572,"_406":1100,"_88":1101,"_72":1092,"_409":2573,"_413":2576,"_421":2578,"_425":-5,"_81":2579,"_90":91},{"_39":1089,"_97":55,"_56":2568,"_72":1092,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1091],[57,1091],[55],{"_399":1096,"_401":1097},{"_399":1099,"_401":568},[2574,2575],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2577,"_420":8},{"_399":1099,"_401":568},{"_88":1101,"_423":1108},{"_83":1110},{"_37":28,"_39":2581,"_56":2583,"_74":2584,"_77":2585,"_79":2586,"_406":1125,"_88":1126,"_72":1116,"_409":2587,"_413":2590,"_421":2592,"_425":-5,"_81":2593,"_90":91},{"_39":1113,"_97":55,"_56":2582,"_72":1116,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1115],[57,1115],[55],{"_399":1120,"_401":1121},{"_399":1123,"_401":1124},[2588,2589],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2591,"_420":6},{"_399":1123,"_401":1124},{"_88":1126,"_423":1133},{"_83":1135},{"_37":28,"_39":2595,"_56":2597,"_74":2598,"_77":2599,"_79":2600,"_406":520,"_88":521,"_72":1141,"_409":2601,"_413":2604,"_421":2607,"_425":-5,"_81":2608,"_90":91},{"_39":1138,"_97":55,"_56":2596,"_72":1141,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1140],[57,1140],[55],{"_399":515,"_401":516},{"_399":1146,"_401":1147},[2602,2603],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2605,"_416":1154,"_417":134,"_418":2606,"_420":6},{"_399":1153,"_401":543},{"_399":1146,"_401":1147},{"_88":521,"_423":527},{"_83":1158},{"_37":28,"_39":2610,"_56":2612,"_74":2613,"_77":2614,"_79":2615,"_406":520,"_88":521,"_72":1164,"_409":2616,"_413":2619,"_421":2621,"_425":-5,"_81":2622,"_90":91},{"_39":1161,"_97":55,"_56":2611,"_72":1164,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1163],[57,1163],[55],{"_399":515,"_401":516},{"_399":1169,"_401":1170},[2617,2618],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2620,"_420":8},{"_399":1169,"_401":1170},{"_88":521,"_423":1177},{"_83":1179},{"_37":28,"_39":2624,"_56":2626,"_74":2627,"_77":2628,"_79":2629,"_406":1194,"_88":1195,"_72":1185,"_409":2630,"_413":2633,"_421":2635,"_425":-5,"_81":2636,"_90":91},{"_39":1182,"_97":55,"_56":2625,"_72":1185,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1184],[57,1184],[55],{"_399":1189,"_401":1190},{"_399":1192,"_401":1193},[2631,2632],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2634,"_420":8},{"_399":1192,"_401":1193},{"_88":1195,"_423":1202},{"_83":1204},{"_37":28,"_39":2638,"_56":2643,"_74":2644,"_77":2645,"_79":2648,"_406":2651,"_88":2652,"_72":2642,"_409":2653,"_413":2658,"_421":2660,"_425":-5,"_81":2662,"_90":91},{"_39":2639,"_97":55,"_56":2640,"_72":2642,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/personal-productivity/productivity-text-file",[57,1184,2641],"productivity-text-file","bafy2bzacedgeqfvbo76tgcxo3ak52fkbnivuoqfmhqpue7ipevgwj2p6likxg",[57,1184,2641],[55],{"_399":2646,"_401":2647},"1765737836",608000000,{"_399":2649,"_401":2650},"1765737888",778000000,"2025-12-14T18:43:56.608Z","bafy2bzacedk7hufm7uzbhqgslsgxbboh436vooejjgd7wlygfemdyuxn5we5y",[2654,2655,2656],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_83":1204,"_56":2657,"_412":8},"/private-notes/personal-productivity",{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2659,"_420":8},{"_399":2649,"_401":2650},{"_88":2652,"_423":2661},"1765737836608",{"_83":2663,"_879":2664},"Over 14 years of todos recorded in text","My productivity app is a never-ending .txt file",{"_37":28,"_39":2666,"_56":2668,"_74":2669,"_77":2670,"_79":2671,"_406":1216,"_88":1210,"_72":1210,"_409":2672,"_413":2675,"_421":2677,"_425":-5,"_81":2678,"_90":91},{"_39":1207,"_97":55,"_56":2667,"_72":1210,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1209],[57,1209],[55],{"_399":1214,"_401":1193},{"_399":1214,"_401":1193},[2673,2674],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2676,"_420":8},{"_399":1214,"_401":1193},{"_88":1210,"_423":1223},{"_83":1225},{"_37":28,"_39":2680,"_56":2682,"_74":2683,"_77":2684,"_79":2685,"_406":1238,"_88":1231,"_72":1231,"_409":2686,"_413":2689,"_421":2691,"_425":-5,"_81":2692,"_90":91},{"_39":1228,"_97":55,"_56":2681,"_72":1231,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1230],[57,1230],[55],{"_399":1235,"_401":1236},{"_399":1235,"_401":1236},[2687,2688],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2690,"_420":8},{"_399":1235,"_401":1236},{"_88":1231,"_423":1245},{"_83":1247},{"_37":28,"_39":2694,"_56":2696,"_74":2697,"_77":2698,"_79":2699,"_406":1260,"_88":1253,"_72":1253,"_409":2700,"_413":2703,"_421":2705,"_425":-5,"_81":2706,"_90":91},{"_39":1250,"_97":55,"_56":2695,"_72":1253,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1252],[57,1252],[55],{"_399":1257,"_401":1258},{"_399":1257,"_401":1258},[2701,2702],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2704,"_420":8},{"_399":1257,"_401":1258},{"_88":1253,"_423":1267},{"_83":1269},{"_37":28,"_39":2708,"_56":2710,"_74":2711,"_77":2712,"_79":2713,"_406":1285,"_88":1286,"_72":1275,"_409":2714,"_413":2717,"_421":2719,"_425":-5,"_81":2720,"_90":91},{"_39":1272,"_97":55,"_56":2709,"_72":1275,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1274],[57,1274],[55,1278],{"_399":1280,"_401":1281},{"_399":1283,"_401":1284},[2715,2716],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2718,"_420":6},{"_399":1283,"_401":1284},{"_88":1286,"_423":527},{"_83":1294},{"_37":28,"_39":2722,"_56":2724,"_74":2725,"_77":2726,"_79":2727,"_406":1307,"_88":1300,"_72":1300,"_409":2728,"_413":2731,"_421":2733,"_425":-5,"_81":2734,"_90":91},{"_39":1297,"_97":55,"_56":2723,"_72":1300,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1299],[57,1299],[55],{"_399":1304,"_401":1305},{"_399":1304,"_401":1305},[2729,2730],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2732,"_420":6},{"_399":1304,"_401":1305},{"_88":1300,"_423":1314},{"_83":1316},{"_37":28,"_39":2736,"_56":2738,"_74":2739,"_77":2740,"_79":2741,"_406":1331,"_88":1332,"_72":1322,"_409":2742,"_413":2745,"_421":2747,"_425":-5,"_81":2748,"_90":91},{"_39":1319,"_97":55,"_56":2737,"_72":1322,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1321],[57,1321],[55],{"_399":1326,"_401":1327},{"_399":1329,"_401":1330},[2743,2744],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2746,"_420":6},{"_399":1329,"_401":1330},{"_88":1332,"_423":1339},{"_83":1341},{"_37":28,"_39":2750,"_56":2752,"_74":2753,"_77":2754,"_79":2755,"_406":1354,"_88":1347,"_72":1347,"_409":2756,"_413":2759,"_421":2761,"_425":-5,"_81":2762,"_90":91},{"_39":1344,"_97":55,"_56":2751,"_72":1347,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1346],[57,1346],[55],{"_399":1351,"_401":1352},{"_399":1351,"_401":1352},[2757,2758],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2760,"_420":6},{"_399":1351,"_401":1352},{"_88":1347,"_423":1361},{"_83":1363},{"_37":28,"_39":2764,"_56":2766,"_74":2767,"_77":2768,"_79":2769,"_406":1376,"_88":1369,"_72":1369,"_409":2770,"_413":2773,"_421":2775,"_425":-5,"_81":2776,"_90":91},{"_39":1366,"_97":55,"_56":2765,"_72":1369,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1368],[57,1368],[55],{"_399":1373,"_401":1374},{"_399":1373,"_401":1374},[2771,2772],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2774,"_420":6},{"_399":1373,"_401":1374},{"_88":1369,"_423":1383},{"_83":1385},{"_37":28,"_39":2778,"_56":2780,"_74":2781,"_77":2782,"_79":2783,"_406":1398,"_88":1391,"_72":1391,"_409":2784,"_413":2787,"_421":2789,"_425":-5,"_81":2790,"_90":91},{"_39":1388,"_97":55,"_56":2779,"_72":1391,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1390],[57,1390],[55],{"_399":1395,"_401":1396},{"_399":1395,"_401":1396},[2785,2786],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2788,"_420":6},{"_399":1395,"_401":1396},{"_88":1391,"_423":1405},{"_83":1407},{"_37":28,"_39":2792,"_56":2794,"_74":2795,"_77":2796,"_79":2797,"_406":1420,"_88":1413,"_72":1413,"_409":2798,"_413":2801,"_421":2803,"_425":-5,"_81":2804,"_90":91},{"_39":1410,"_97":55,"_56":2793,"_72":1413,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1412],[57,1412],[55],{"_399":1417,"_401":1418},{"_399":1417,"_401":1418},[2799,2800],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2802,"_420":6},{"_399":1417,"_401":1418},{"_88":1413,"_423":527},{"_83":1428},{"_37":28,"_39":2806,"_56":2808,"_74":2809,"_77":2810,"_79":2811,"_406":1441,"_88":1434,"_72":1434,"_409":2812,"_413":2815,"_421":2817,"_425":-5,"_81":2818,"_90":91},{"_39":1431,"_97":55,"_56":2807,"_72":1434,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1433],[57,1433],[55],{"_399":1438,"_401":1439},{"_399":1438,"_401":1439},[2813,2814],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2816,"_420":6},{"_399":1438,"_401":1439},{"_88":1434,"_423":1448},{"_83":1450},{"_37":28,"_39":2820,"_56":2822,"_74":2823,"_77":2824,"_79":2825,"_406":1463,"_88":1456,"_72":1456,"_409":2826,"_413":2829,"_421":2831,"_425":-5,"_81":2832,"_90":91},{"_39":1453,"_97":55,"_56":2821,"_72":1456,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1455],[57,1455],[55],{"_399":1460,"_401":1461},{"_399":1460,"_401":1461},[2827,2828],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2830,"_420":6},{"_399":1460,"_401":1461},{"_88":1456,"_423":1470},{"_83":1472},{"_37":28,"_39":2834,"_56":2836,"_74":2837,"_77":2838,"_79":2839,"_406":1485,"_88":1478,"_72":1478,"_409":2840,"_413":2843,"_421":2845,"_425":-5,"_81":2846,"_90":91},{"_39":1475,"_97":55,"_56":2835,"_72":1478,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1477],[57,1477],[55],{"_399":1482,"_401":1483},{"_399":1482,"_401":1483},[2841,2842],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2844,"_420":6},{"_399":1482,"_401":1483},{"_88":1478,"_423":1492},{"_83":1494,"_331":1495},{"_37":28,"_39":2848,"_56":2850,"_74":2851,"_77":2852,"_79":2853,"_406":1509,"_88":1510,"_72":1501,"_409":2854,"_413":2857,"_421":2860,"_425":-5,"_81":2861,"_90":91},{"_39":1498,"_97":55,"_56":2849,"_72":1501,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1500],[57,1500],[55,1504],{"_399":527,"_401":139},{"_399":1507,"_401":1508},[2855,2856],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2858,"_416":1518,"_417":792,"_418":2859,"_420":6},{"_399":1516,"_401":1517},{"_399":1507,"_401":1508},{"_88":1510,"_423":1521},{"_83":1523},{"_37":28,"_39":2863,"_56":2865,"_74":2866,"_77":2867,"_79":2868,"_406":1538,"_88":1539,"_72":1529,"_409":2869,"_413":2872,"_421":2874,"_425":-5,"_81":2875,"_90":91},{"_39":1526,"_97":55,"_56":2864,"_72":1529,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1528],[57,1528],[55],{"_399":1533,"_401":1534},{"_399":1536,"_401":1537},[2870,2871],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2873,"_420":6},{"_399":1536,"_401":1537},{"_88":1539,"_423":1546},{"_83":1548},{"_37":28,"_39":2877,"_56":2879,"_74":2880,"_77":2881,"_79":2882,"_406":1561,"_88":1554,"_72":1554,"_409":2883,"_413":2886,"_421":2889,"_425":-5,"_81":2890,"_90":91},{"_39":1551,"_97":55,"_56":2878,"_72":1554,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1553],[57,1553],[55],{"_399":1558,"_401":1559},{"_399":1558,"_401":1559},[2884,2885],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2887,"_416":1569,"_417":134,"_418":2888,"_420":6},{"_399":1567,"_401":1568},{"_399":1558,"_401":1559},{"_88":1554,"_423":1572},{"_83":1574},{"_37":28,"_39":2892,"_56":2894,"_74":2895,"_77":2896,"_79":2897,"_406":1588,"_88":1589,"_72":1580,"_409":2898,"_413":2901,"_421":2904,"_425":-5,"_81":2905,"_90":91},{"_39":1577,"_97":55,"_56":2893,"_72":1580,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1579],[57,1579],[55],{"_399":1584,"_401":1585},{"_399":1587,"_401":867},[2899,2900],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2902,"_416":1597,"_417":17,"_418":2903,"_420":6},{"_399":1595,"_401":1596},{"_399":1587,"_401":867},{"_88":1589,"_423":1600},{"_83":1602},{"_37":28,"_39":2907,"_56":2909,"_74":2910,"_77":2911,"_79":2912,"_406":1615,"_88":1608,"_72":1608,"_409":2913,"_413":2916,"_421":2918,"_425":-5,"_81":2919,"_90":91},{"_39":1605,"_97":55,"_56":2908,"_72":1608,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1607],[57,1607],[55],{"_399":1612,"_401":1613},{"_399":1612,"_401":1613},[2914,2915],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2917,"_420":6},{"_399":1612,"_401":1613},{"_88":1608,"_423":1622},{"_83":1624},{"_37":28,"_39":2921,"_56":2923,"_74":2924,"_77":2925,"_79":2926,"_406":1637,"_88":1630,"_72":1630,"_409":2927,"_413":2930,"_421":2932,"_425":-5,"_81":2933,"_90":91},{"_39":1627,"_97":55,"_56":2922,"_72":1630,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1629],[57,1629],[55],{"_399":1634,"_401":1635},{"_399":1634,"_401":1635},[2928,2929],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2931,"_420":8},{"_399":1634,"_401":1635},{"_88":1630,"_423":1644},{"_83":1646},{"_37":28,"_39":2935,"_56":2937,"_74":2938,"_77":2939,"_79":2940,"_406":1659,"_88":1652,"_72":1652,"_409":2941,"_413":2944,"_421":2947,"_425":-5,"_81":2948,"_90":91},{"_39":1649,"_97":55,"_56":2936,"_72":1652,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1651],[57,1651],[55],{"_399":1656,"_401":1657},{"_399":1656,"_401":1657},[2942,2943],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":2945,"_416":1667,"_417":134,"_418":2946,"_420":6},{"_399":1665,"_401":1666},{"_399":1656,"_401":1657},{"_88":1652,"_423":1670},{"_83":1672},{"_37":28,"_39":2950,"_56":2952,"_74":2953,"_77":2954,"_79":2955,"_406":1685,"_88":1678,"_72":1678,"_409":2956,"_413":2959,"_421":2961,"_425":-5,"_81":2962,"_90":91},{"_39":1675,"_97":55,"_56":2951,"_72":1678,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1677],[57,1677],[55],{"_399":1682,"_401":1683},{"_399":1682,"_401":1683},[2957,2958],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2960,"_420":8},{"_399":1682,"_401":1683},{"_88":1678,"_423":1692},{"_83":1694},{"_37":28,"_39":2964,"_56":2966,"_74":2967,"_77":2968,"_79":2969,"_406":1707,"_88":1700,"_72":1700,"_409":2970,"_413":2973,"_421":2975,"_425":-5,"_81":2976,"_90":91},{"_39":1697,"_97":55,"_56":2965,"_72":1700,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1699],[57,1699],[55],{"_399":1704,"_401":1705},{"_399":1704,"_401":1705},[2971,2972],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2974,"_420":6},{"_399":1704,"_401":1705},{"_88":1700,"_423":1714},{"_83":1716},{"_37":28,"_39":2978,"_56":2980,"_74":2981,"_77":2982,"_79":2983,"_406":1729,"_88":1722,"_72":1722,"_409":2984,"_413":2987,"_421":2989,"_425":-5,"_81":2990,"_90":91},{"_39":1719,"_97":55,"_56":2979,"_72":1722,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1721],[57,1721],[55],{"_399":1726,"_401":1727},{"_399":1726,"_401":1727},[2985,2986],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":2988,"_420":8},{"_399":1726,"_401":1727},{"_88":1722,"_423":1736},{"_83":1738},{"_37":28,"_39":2992,"_56":2994,"_74":2995,"_77":2996,"_79":2997,"_406":1751,"_88":1744,"_72":1744,"_409":2998,"_413":3001,"_421":3003,"_425":-5,"_81":3004,"_90":91},{"_39":1741,"_97":55,"_56":2993,"_72":1744,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1743],[57,1743],[55],{"_399":1748,"_401":1749},{"_399":1748,"_401":1749},[2999,3000],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3002,"_420":6},{"_399":1748,"_401":1749},{"_88":1744,"_423":1758},{"_83":1760},{"_37":28,"_39":3006,"_56":3008,"_74":3009,"_77":3010,"_79":3011,"_406":1772,"_88":1766,"_72":1766,"_409":3012,"_413":3015,"_421":3017,"_425":-5,"_81":3018,"_90":91},{"_39":1763,"_97":55,"_56":3007,"_72":1766,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1765],[57,1765],[55],{"_399":1770,"_401":995},{"_399":1770,"_401":995},[3013,3014],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3016,"_420":8},{"_399":1770,"_401":995},{"_88":1766,"_423":1779},{"_83":1781},{"_37":28,"_39":3020,"_56":3022,"_74":3023,"_77":3024,"_79":3025,"_406":1796,"_88":1797,"_72":1787,"_409":3026,"_413":3029,"_421":3032,"_425":-5,"_81":3033,"_90":91},{"_39":1784,"_97":55,"_56":3021,"_72":1787,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1786],[57,1786],[55],{"_399":1791,"_401":1792},{"_399":1794,"_401":1795},[3027,3028],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":3030,"_416":1805,"_417":17,"_418":3031,"_420":6},{"_399":1803,"_401":1804},{"_399":1794,"_401":1795},{"_88":1797,"_423":1808},{"_83":1810},{"_37":28,"_39":3035,"_56":3037,"_74":3038,"_77":3039,"_79":3040,"_406":1825,"_88":1826,"_72":1816,"_409":3041,"_413":3044,"_421":3046,"_425":-5,"_81":3047,"_90":91},{"_39":1813,"_97":55,"_56":3036,"_72":1816,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1815],[57,1815],[55],{"_399":1820,"_401":1821},{"_399":1823,"_401":1824},[3042,3043],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3045,"_420":6},{"_399":1823,"_401":1824},{"_88":1826,"_423":1833},{"_83":1835},{"_37":28,"_39":3049,"_56":3051,"_74":3052,"_77":3053,"_79":3054,"_406":1850,"_88":1851,"_72":1841,"_409":3055,"_413":3058,"_421":3061,"_425":-5,"_81":3062,"_90":91},{"_39":1838,"_97":55,"_56":3050,"_72":1841,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1840],[57,1840],[55],{"_399":1845,"_401":1846},{"_399":1848,"_401":1849},[3056,3057],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":3059,"_416":1859,"_417":134,"_418":3060,"_420":6},{"_399":1857,"_401":1858},{"_399":1848,"_401":1849},{"_88":1851,"_423":1862},{"_83":1864,"_331":1865},{"_37":28,"_39":3064,"_56":3066,"_74":3067,"_77":3068,"_79":3069,"_406":1878,"_88":1871,"_72":1871,"_409":3070,"_413":3073,"_421":3076,"_425":-5,"_81":3077,"_90":91},{"_39":1868,"_97":55,"_56":3065,"_72":1871,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1870],[57,1870],[55],{"_399":1875,"_401":1876},{"_399":1875,"_401":1876},[3071,3072],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":3074,"_416":1886,"_417":134,"_418":3075,"_420":6},{"_399":1884,"_401":1885},{"_399":1875,"_401":1876},{"_88":1871,"_423":1889},{"_83":1891},{"_37":28,"_39":3079,"_56":3081,"_74":3082,"_77":3083,"_79":3084,"_406":1904,"_88":1897,"_72":1897,"_409":3085,"_413":3088,"_421":3090,"_425":-5,"_81":3091,"_90":91},{"_39":1894,"_97":55,"_56":3080,"_72":1897,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1896],[57,1896],[55],{"_399":1901,"_401":1902},{"_399":1901,"_401":1902},[3086,3087],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3089,"_420":8},{"_399":1901,"_401":1902},{"_88":1897,"_423":1911},{"_83":1913},{"_37":28,"_39":3093,"_56":3095,"_74":3096,"_77":3097,"_79":3098,"_406":1926,"_88":1919,"_72":1919,"_409":3099,"_413":3102,"_421":3104,"_425":-5,"_81":3105,"_90":91},{"_39":1916,"_97":55,"_56":3094,"_72":1919,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1918],[57,1918],[55],{"_399":1923,"_401":1924},{"_399":1923,"_401":1924},[3100,3101],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3103,"_420":8},{"_399":1923,"_401":1924},{"_88":1919,"_423":1933},{"_83":1935},{"_37":28,"_39":3107,"_56":3109,"_74":3110,"_77":3111,"_79":3112,"_406":1950,"_88":1951,"_72":1941,"_409":3113,"_413":3116,"_421":3119,"_425":-5,"_81":3120,"_90":91},{"_39":1938,"_97":55,"_56":3108,"_72":1941,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1940],[57,1940],[55],{"_399":1945,"_401":1946},{"_399":1948,"_401":1949},[3114,3115],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":3117,"_416":1959,"_417":624,"_418":3118,"_420":6},{"_399":1957,"_401":1958},{"_399":1948,"_401":1949},{"_88":1951,"_423":1962},{"_83":1964},{"_37":28,"_39":3122,"_56":3124,"_74":3125,"_77":3126,"_79":3127,"_406":1976,"_88":1970,"_72":1970,"_409":3128,"_413":3131,"_421":3133,"_425":-5,"_81":3134,"_90":91},{"_39":1967,"_97":55,"_56":3123,"_72":1970,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1969],[57,1969],[55],{"_399":1974,"_401":790},{"_399":1974,"_401":790},[3129,3130],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3132,"_420":8},{"_399":1974,"_401":790},{"_88":1970,"_423":1983},{"_83":1985},{"_37":28,"_39":3136,"_56":3138,"_74":3139,"_77":3140,"_79":3141,"_406":2001,"_88":2002,"_72":1991,"_409":3142,"_413":3145,"_421":3147,"_425":-5,"_81":3148,"_90":91},{"_39":1988,"_97":55,"_56":3137,"_72":1991,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1990],[57,1990],[55,1994],{"_399":1996,"_401":1997},{"_399":1999,"_401":2000},[3143,3144],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3146,"_420":6},{"_399":1999,"_401":2000},{"_88":2002,"_423":2009},{"_83":2011,"_331":2012},{"_37":28,"_39":3150,"_56":3152,"_74":3153,"_77":3154,"_79":3155,"_406":2025,"_88":2018,"_72":2018,"_409":3156,"_413":3159,"_421":3161,"_425":-5,"_81":3162,"_90":91},{"_39":2015,"_97":55,"_56":3151,"_72":2018,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2017],[57,2017],[55],{"_399":2022,"_401":2023},{"_399":2022,"_401":2023},[3157,3158],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3160,"_420":6},{"_399":2022,"_401":2023},{"_88":2018,"_423":2032},{"_83":2034},{"_37":28,"_39":3164,"_56":3166,"_74":3167,"_77":3168,"_79":3169,"_406":2049,"_88":2050,"_72":2040,"_409":3170,"_413":3173,"_421":3175,"_425":-5,"_81":3176,"_90":91},{"_39":2037,"_97":55,"_56":3165,"_72":2040,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2039],[57,2039],[55],{"_399":2044,"_401":2045},{"_399":2047,"_401":2048},[3171,3172],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3174,"_420":6},{"_399":2047,"_401":2048},{"_88":2050,"_423":2057},{"_83":2059},{"_37":28,"_39":3178,"_56":3180,"_74":3181,"_77":3182,"_79":3183,"_406":2072,"_88":2065,"_72":2065,"_409":3184,"_413":3187,"_421":3189,"_425":-5,"_81":3190,"_90":91},{"_39":2062,"_97":55,"_56":3179,"_72":2065,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2064],[57,2064],[55],{"_399":2069,"_401":2070},{"_399":2069,"_401":2070},[3185,3186],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3188,"_420":6},{"_399":2069,"_401":2070},{"_88":2065,"_423":2079},{"_83":2081,"_336":2082,"_340":676},{"_37":28,"_39":3192,"_56":3194,"_74":3195,"_77":3196,"_79":3197,"_406":2098,"_88":2099,"_72":2088,"_409":3198,"_413":3201,"_421":3203,"_425":-5,"_81":3204,"_90":91},{"_39":2085,"_97":55,"_56":3193,"_72":2088,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2087],[57,2087],[55,2091],{"_399":2093,"_401":2094},{"_399":2096,"_401":2097},[3199,3200],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3202,"_420":6},{"_399":2096,"_401":2097},{"_88":2099,"_423":2106},{"_83":2108},{"_37":28,"_39":3206,"_56":3208,"_74":3209,"_77":3210,"_79":3211,"_406":2124,"_88":2125,"_72":2114,"_409":3212,"_413":3215,"_421":3217,"_425":-5,"_81":3218,"_90":91},{"_39":2111,"_97":55,"_56":3207,"_72":2114,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2113],[57,2113],[55,2117,2091],{"_399":2119,"_401":2120},{"_399":2122,"_401":2123},[3213,3214],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3216,"_420":6},{"_399":2122,"_401":2123},{"_88":2125,"_423":2132},{"_83":2134},{"_37":28,"_39":3220,"_56":3222,"_74":3223,"_77":3224,"_79":3225,"_406":1509,"_88":2148,"_72":2140,"_409":3226,"_413":3229,"_421":3231,"_425":-5,"_81":3232,"_90":91},{"_39":2137,"_97":55,"_56":3221,"_72":2140,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2139],[57,2139],[55,2143],{"_399":527,"_401":139},{"_399":2146,"_401":2147},[3227,3228],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3230,"_420":8},{"_399":2146,"_401":2147},{"_88":2148,"_423":2155},{"_83":2157,"_329":2158,"_338":2159,"_339":8},{"_37":28,"_39":3234,"_56":3236,"_74":3237,"_77":3238,"_79":3239,"_406":2172,"_88":2165,"_72":2165,"_409":3240,"_413":3243,"_421":3245,"_425":-5,"_81":3246,"_90":91},{"_39":2162,"_97":55,"_56":3235,"_72":2165,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2164],[57,2164],[55],{"_399":2169,"_401":2170},{"_399":2169,"_401":2170},[3241,3242],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3244,"_420":8},{"_399":2169,"_401":2170},{"_88":2165,"_423":2179},{"_83":2181},{"_37":28,"_39":3248,"_56":3250,"_74":3251,"_77":3252,"_79":3253,"_406":2195,"_88":2196,"_72":2186,"_409":3254,"_413":3257,"_421":3259,"_425":-5,"_81":3260,"_90":91},{"_39":2184,"_97":55,"_56":3249,"_72":2186,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1135],[57,1135],[55],{"_399":2190,"_401":2191},{"_399":2193,"_401":2194},[3255,3256],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3258,"_420":6},{"_399":2193,"_401":2194},{"_88":2196,"_423":2203},{"_83":2205},{"_37":28,"_39":3262,"_56":3264,"_74":3265,"_77":3266,"_79":3267,"_406":2217,"_88":2211,"_72":2211,"_409":3268,"_413":3271,"_421":3273,"_425":-5,"_81":3274,"_90":91},{"_39":2208,"_97":55,"_56":3263,"_72":2211,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2210],[57,2210],[55],{"_399":2215,"_401":1804},{"_399":2215,"_401":1804},[3269,3270],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3272,"_420":6},{"_399":2215,"_401":1804},{"_88":2211,"_423":2224},{"_83":2226},{"_37":28,"_39":3276,"_56":3278,"_74":3279,"_77":3280,"_79":3281,"_406":2239,"_88":2232,"_72":2232,"_409":3282,"_413":3285,"_421":3287,"_425":-5,"_81":3288,"_90":91},{"_39":2229,"_97":55,"_56":3277,"_72":2232,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2231],[57,2231],[55],{"_399":2236,"_401":2237},{"_399":2236,"_401":2237},[3283,3284],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3286,"_420":8},{"_399":2236,"_401":2237},{"_88":2232,"_423":2246},{"_83":2248},{"_37":28,"_39":3290,"_56":3292,"_74":3293,"_77":3294,"_79":3295,"_406":2263,"_88":2264,"_72":2254,"_409":3296,"_413":3299,"_421":3301,"_425":-5,"_81":3302,"_90":91},{"_39":2251,"_97":55,"_56":3291,"_72":2254,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2253],[57,2253],[55],{"_399":2258,"_401":2259},{"_399":2261,"_401":2262},[3297,3298],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3300,"_420":6},{"_399":2261,"_401":2262},{"_88":2264,"_423":2271},{"_83":2273},{"_37":28,"_39":3304,"_56":3306,"_74":3307,"_77":3308,"_79":3309,"_406":2288,"_88":2289,"_72":2279,"_409":3310,"_413":3313,"_421":3315,"_425":-5,"_81":3316,"_90":91},{"_39":2276,"_97":55,"_56":3305,"_72":2279,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2278],[57,2278],[55],{"_399":2283,"_401":2284},{"_399":2286,"_401":2287},[3311,3312],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3314,"_420":6},{"_399":2286,"_401":2287},{"_88":2289,"_423":2296},{"_83":2298},{"_37":28,"_39":3318,"_56":3320,"_74":3321,"_77":3322,"_79":3323,"_406":2311,"_88":2304,"_72":2304,"_409":3324,"_413":3327,"_421":3329,"_425":-5,"_81":3330,"_90":91},{"_39":2301,"_97":55,"_56":3319,"_72":2304,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2303],[57,2303],[55],{"_399":2308,"_401":2309},{"_399":2308,"_401":2309},[3325,3326],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3328,"_420":6},{"_399":2308,"_401":2309},{"_88":2304,"_423":2318},{"_83":2320},{"_37":28,"_39":3332,"_56":3337,"_74":3338,"_77":3339,"_79":3342,"_406":3343,"_88":3336,"_72":3336,"_409":3344,"_413":3349,"_421":3351,"_425":-5,"_81":3353,"_90":91},{"_39":3333,"_97":55,"_56":3334,"_72":3336,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/fund-raising/travis-kalanick",[57,2325,3335],"travis-kalanick","bafy2bzaceaytcpmfcwqgqlhpb72igiakeptlwouhx4uzstyrozw4dh4a2dcgm",[57,2325,3335],[55],{"_399":3340,"_401":3341},"1739086975",861000000,{"_399":3340,"_401":3341},"2025-02-09T07:42:55.861Z",[3345,3346,3347],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_83":2342,"_56":3348,"_412":8},"/private-notes/fund-raising",{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3350,"_420":8},{"_399":3340,"_401":3341},{"_88":3336,"_423":3352},"1739086975861",{"_83":3354},"Travis Kalanick",{"_37":28,"_39":3356,"_56":3358,"_74":3359,"_77":3360,"_79":3361,"_406":2333,"_88":2326,"_72":2326,"_409":3362,"_413":3365,"_421":3367,"_425":-5,"_81":3368,"_90":91},{"_39":2323,"_97":55,"_56":3357,"_72":2326,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2325],[57,2325],[55],{"_399":2330,"_401":2331},{"_399":2330,"_401":2331},[3363,3364],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3366,"_420":8},{"_399":2330,"_401":2331},{"_88":2326,"_423":2340},{"_83":2342},{"_37":28,"_39":3370,"_56":3372,"_74":3373,"_77":3374,"_79":3375,"_406":2355,"_88":2348,"_72":2348,"_409":3376,"_413":3379,"_421":3381,"_425":-5,"_81":3382,"_90":91},{"_39":2345,"_97":55,"_56":3371,"_72":2348,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2347],[57,2347],[55],{"_399":2352,"_401":2353},{"_399":2352,"_401":2353},[3377,3378],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3380,"_420":6},{"_399":2352,"_401":2353},{"_88":2348,"_423":2362},{"_83":2364},{"_37":28,"_39":3384,"_56":3389,"_74":3390,"_77":3391,"_79":3394,"_406":3395,"_88":3388,"_72":3388,"_409":3396,"_413":3401,"_421":3407,"_425":-5,"_81":3409,"_90":91},{"_39":3385,"_97":55,"_56":3386,"_72":3388,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/robust-opennes/gnunet-key-learnings",[57,1321,3387],"gnunet-key-learnings","bafy2bzacecsleaek5piqvges5rge25nloegde43elg57e5tbf6om6qoemjrhu",[57,1321,3387],[55],{"_399":3392,"_401":3393},"1738669610",901000000,{"_399":3392,"_401":3393},"2025-02-04T11:46:50.901Z",[3397,3398,3399],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_83":1341,"_56":3400,"_412":8},"/private-notes/robust-opennes",{"_415":3402,"_416":3405,"_417":134,"_418":3406,"_420":6},{"_399":3403,"_401":3404},"1765196389",441000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6ERPfSFrcH1ZA",{"_399":3392,"_401":3393},{"_88":3388,"_423":3408},"1738669610901",{"_83":3410},"GNUnet key learnings",{"_37":28,"_39":3412,"_56":3414,"_74":3415,"_77":3416,"_79":3417,"_406":2377,"_88":2370,"_72":2370,"_409":3418,"_413":3421,"_421":3423,"_425":-5,"_81":3424,"_90":91},{"_39":2367,"_97":55,"_56":3413,"_72":2370,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2369],[57,2369],[55],{"_399":2374,"_401":2375},{"_399":2374,"_401":2375},[3419,3420],{"_83":328,"_56":70,"_412":8},{"_83":84,"_56":76,"_412":8},{"_415":-5,"_416":70,"_417":139,"_418":3422,"_420":6},{"_399":2374,"_401":2375},{"_88":2370,"_423":2384},{"_83":2386},1772124422498,[799,98,59],"[\"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes\",\"AllDescendants\"]",{"_112":3429,"_149":3436,"_152":3438},{"_114":3430,"_133":134,"_135":3435,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":73,"_39":3431,"_81":3433},{"_72":185,"_97":55,"_39":382,"_56":3432,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5},[],{"_83":328,"_329":104,"_330":104,"_331":332,"_333":334,"_335":70,"_336":337,"_338":70,"_339":8,"_340":341,"_342":3434,"_879":-5},{"_344":345},1772124422389,[3437,55],"ACCOUNT","[\"ACCOUNT\",\"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou\"]",{"_112":3440,"_149":3466,"_152":3467},{"_114":3441,"_133":134,"_135":3465,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":3442,"_39":3463},{"_30":3443,"_72":810,"_73":55,"_74":3459,"_56":3460,"_77":817,"_79":817,"_81":3461,"_86":3462,"_88":810,"_90":91},[3444,3452],{"_33":3445,"_35":3446},[],{"_37":3447,"_39":3448,"_41":810,"_43":3449,"_67":3450,"_69":70,"_71":3451},"Video","6sSaRio8",{"_194":195},[],"https://www.youtube.com/embed/Z3OpxT65fKw",{"_33":3453,"_35":3454},[],{"_37":3447,"_39":3455,"_41":810,"_43":3456,"_67":3457,"_69":70,"_71":3458},"1jxleQrn",{"_194":195},[],"https://www.youtube.com/embed/cKx8xE8jJZs",[55],"/private-notes/workouts-and-kettleballs",{"_83":830},{},{"_39":807,"_97":55,"_56":3464,"_72":810,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,809],1772124423060,[151,807,810],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/workouts-and-kettleballs\",\"bafy2bzaceaqibti63gujgqzk3rdsl5h3f4db54d23jwjk4qwpws5fl5w2aynw\"]",{"_112":3469,"_149":3495,"_152":3496},{"_114":3470,"_133":134,"_135":3494,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":3471,"_39":3492},{"_30":3472,"_72":836,"_73":55,"_74":3488,"_56":3489,"_77":843,"_79":843,"_81":3490,"_86":3491,"_88":836,"_90":91},[3473,3480],{"_33":3474,"_35":3475},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3476,"_41":836,"_43":3477,"_67":3478,"_69":3479,"_71":70},"iXk0RyaG",{},[],"Social Newsfeed killed RSS. The social layer on what to read is better than feeling like you’re falling behind and not having good signal-to-noise filters. And publishers couldn’t monetize RSS via either ads or subscriptions.",{"_33":3481,"_35":3482},[],{"_37":3483,"_39":3484,"_41":836,"_43":3485,"_67":3486,"_69":70,"_71":3487},"WebEmbed","iTkorGN8",{},[],"https://x.com/rabble/status/1180500679145582593",[55],"/private-notes/what-killed-rss",{"_83":856},{},{"_39":833,"_97":55,"_56":3493,"_72":836,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,835],1772124423048,[151,833,836],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/what-killed-rss\",\"bafy2bzacea2pd5tg2vcx36seucgvygewkkbd6rqrvbpxrwhojdkei644zess4\"]",{"_112":3498,"_149":7024,"_152":7025},{"_114":3499,"_133":134,"_135":7023,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":3500,"_39":7021},{"_30":3501,"_72":862,"_73":55,"_74":7017,"_56":7018,"_77":869,"_79":869,"_81":7019,"_86":7020,"_88":862,"_90":91},[3502,3512,3519,3526,3534,3542,3550,3558,3566,3573,3580,3588,3596,3604,3611,3619,3627,3634,3641,3649,3656,3664,3672,3680,3687,3695,3703,3711,3718,3726,3734,3742,3749,3756,3763,3782,3788,3807,3814,3821,3834,3841,4219,4226,4233,4240,4247,4254,4267,4280,4287,4304,4311,4323,4330,4337,4344,4351,4358,4365,4372,4379,4386,4393,4399,4406,4413,4420,4426,4433,4440,4447,4454,4460,4467,4482,4489,4496,4503,4510,4516,4531,4538,4545,4552,4558,4565,4572,4588,4595,4602,4632,4638,4653,4662,4674,4680,4703,4710,4717,4723,4730,4736,4749,4766,4773,4788,4800,4817,4824,4831,4853,4860,4867,4873,4880,4887,4894,4907,4914,4921,4928,4935,4948,4954,4967,4974,4981,4987,4994,5007,5023,5030,5041,5048,5070,5077,5084,5091,5098,5105,5117,5130,5137,5144,5150,5157,5164,5170,5177,5184,5196,5202,5209,5216,5223,5230,5244,5257,5264,5275,5293,5300,5312,5319,5325,5332,5339,5415,5428,5443,5463,5474,5489,5496,5502,5514,5520,5533,5540,5552,5559,5570,5582,5589,5596,5603,5609,5616,5623,5630,5637,5644,5650,5664,5671,5682,5695,5701,5707,5714,5726,5733,5740,5747,5753,5760,5772,5779,5786,5793,5800,5815,5822,5829,5843,5850,5857,5864,5871,5877,5883,5890,5903,5910,5917,5924,5931,5944,5950,5956,5963,5981,5988,6004,6010,6016,6023,6042,6049,6056,6068,6075,6087,6098,6110,6117,6128,6148,6155,6162,6179,6201,6213,6219,6232,6238,6245,6258,6265,6272,6279,6290,6304,6311,6318,6329,6350,6356,6377,6451,6483,6490,6496,6503,6510,6523,6529,6535,6551,6562,6568,6574,6580,6587,6594,6600,6613,6619,6625,6638,6645,6652,6658,6664,6671,6678,6689,6703,6718,6724,6731,6743,6755,6761,6768,6775,6788,6795,6801,6808,6820,6840,6862,6875,6895,6913,6926,6939,6958,6965,6972,6984,6990,7004,7011],{"_33":3503,"_35":3504},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3506,"_41":862,"_43":3507,"_67":3510,"_69":880,"_71":3511},"Image","snpAi3FN",{"_194":195,"_3508":3509},"width",649.5263870094723,[],"ipfs://bafkreifr6kzu6p6wpjwioocujno3g276c6ivenh4jsqltfo3lykxizgbxi",{"_33":3513,"_35":3514},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3515,"_41":862,"_43":3516,"_67":3517,"_69":70,"_71":3518},"Ywe6U_ho",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreigy7pq2driohvr5ocr2rgfk2g4q6gfp7dqwetoj663buuw6kzktru",{"_33":3520,"_35":3521},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3522,"_41":862,"_43":3523,"_67":3524,"_69":70,"_71":3525},"ryvaW_hX",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreih2yxvshf5wlcouhcxvvoka5qatsex4vjqwpclv47uwbhvvos6bee",{"_33":3527,"_35":3528},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3529,"_41":862,"_43":3530,"_67":3532,"_69":70,"_71":3533},"zvmHV_lm",{"_194":195,"_3508":3531},433.2129963898917,[],"ipfs://bafkreie76rybat4knlngkxp7lotxfliyl7zp3gb2xjjv3f7hyqycjd5yr4",{"_33":3535,"_35":3536},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3537,"_41":862,"_43":3538,"_67":3540,"_69":70,"_71":3541},"C0qb_Iwn",{"_194":195,"_3508":3539},539.3258426966293,[],"ipfs://bafkreiedonuvswl3d4c6u6xxdw3tcagcpfq7gkdoehftf2z2p6iuzrir5u",{"_33":3543,"_35":3544},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3545,"_41":862,"_43":3546,"_67":3548,"_69":70,"_71":3549},"lhnldVxh",{"_194":195,"_3508":3547},592.5925925925926,[],"ipfs://bafkreib42p2n6eczrozj4s52odcj5cjykei56k7ap2kskudiaqlerkrwxa",{"_33":3551,"_35":3552},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3553,"_41":862,"_43":3554,"_67":3556,"_69":70,"_71":3557},"MRfyIpVR",{"_194":195,"_3508":3555},441.9889502762431,[],"ipfs://bafybeiengqyzqomphws2txxiyz6ofgdsksckww77jsdicnkpggn65l4ppy",{"_33":3559,"_35":3560},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3561,"_41":862,"_43":3562,"_67":3564,"_69":70,"_71":3565},"mrpbVk4-",{"_194":195,"_3508":3563},666.6666666666667,[],"ipfs://bafkreidtq4wytv34c32cfadi7fmo3me2qcaht7cy2dombt6k7sgscmwe2a",{"_33":3567,"_35":3568},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3569,"_41":862,"_43":3570,"_67":3571,"_69":70,"_71":3572},"1ijRqqhL",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreifddu5h5odr7lqjqc4vxsdwnl4nqavrhppg45vkdo3nqqwdxaqbde",{"_33":3574,"_35":3575},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3576,"_41":862,"_43":3577,"_67":3578,"_69":70,"_71":3579},"J9mICSzk",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreicmgj2bb4r3lwgqgnue62bsv7wdvlraiogbux5rqjyk6c72n74dfu",{"_33":3581,"_35":3582},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3583,"_41":862,"_43":3584,"_67":3586,"_69":70,"_71":3587},"lHYML9Ia",{"_194":195,"_3508":3585},641.7112299465241,[],"ipfs://bafkreih4bcz5dikykhytai5hgjgdtqkqzkw6aw2jg73popwc5dqi6dznzu",{"_33":3589,"_35":3590},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3591,"_41":862,"_43":3592,"_67":3594,"_69":70,"_71":3595},"ehh6Gzeb",{"_194":195,"_3508":3593},630.7490144546649,[],"ipfs://bafkreicaohyqcdiaq7llkaqjlimrdr5aqk5axnwcjqszxg2e2sf25d5zfu",{"_33":3597,"_35":3598},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3599,"_41":862,"_43":3600,"_67":3602,"_69":70,"_71":3603},"LW5NJjLP",{"_194":195,"_3508":3601},262,[],"ipfs://bafkreig2ymod76o4f2pqjvxdbbxl7ddopz3f6vm5l7c3hmipuwq2xus25y",{"_33":3605,"_35":3606},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3607,"_41":862,"_43":3608,"_67":3609,"_69":70,"_71":3610},"nxX3SMWi",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreieb4ol36zjuqgudbf3kmgvpih3xwt7vnbpaa5iibfweky2ji7yodi",{"_33":3612,"_35":3613},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3614,"_41":862,"_43":3615,"_67":3617,"_69":70,"_71":3618},"P5rx56ZR",{"_194":195,"_3508":3616},617.7606177606177,[],"ipfs://bafkreidc4y7oom6z36eiqswyduseycadvzic4vrbxistgny5r7dyumqsxm",{"_33":3620,"_35":3621},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3622,"_41":862,"_43":3623,"_67":3625,"_69":70,"_71":3626},"oGexH1YC",{"_194":195,"_3508":3624},229.5,[],"ipfs://bafkreiemubiqqdrw274qydzx64bejhwrl623tjlyy5vb75e3zrrsrb6vs4",{"_33":3628,"_35":3629},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3630,"_41":862,"_43":3631,"_67":3632,"_69":70,"_71":3633},"G6EGar05",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreifbcnukdnwkexfhzjfcwhxc42gggmxtuot2ltspwgkluxiz5alg5m",{"_33":3635,"_35":3636},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3637,"_41":862,"_43":3638,"_67":3639,"_69":70,"_71":3640},"jlFmdx76",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreif5m4yeavatvaqtd6zh5nd6iemktrbsp6nhy3c7v7hedgnoa2tvsq",{"_33":3642,"_35":3643},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3644,"_41":862,"_43":3645,"_67":3647,"_69":70,"_71":3648},"MP_lk0DL",{"_194":195,"_3508":3646},159.5,[],"ipfs://bafkreigbiuc6g6hbediep5raaosm63zrj4vzv2t26ncjav766ecrbvsbiy",{"_33":3650,"_35":3651},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3652,"_41":862,"_43":3653,"_67":3654,"_69":70,"_71":3655},"wWEnouwK",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreigv4exmvh6yknwnxvvlaynnyhhr6kdbcjj4vobiyeirpzljdait5m",{"_33":3657,"_35":3658},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3659,"_41":862,"_43":3660,"_67":3662,"_69":70,"_71":3663},"QkPmXS3x",{"_194":195,"_3508":3661},176,[],"ipfs://bafkreicjhdvgrfv6mwwe7l3hvnq23enj53mhcev3nvy77qgh37jxwa5npy",{"_33":3665,"_35":3666},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3667,"_41":862,"_43":3668,"_67":3670,"_69":70,"_71":3671},"o2AicyB2",{"_194":195,"_3508":3669},288.5,[],"ipfs://bafkreigrlhmsn5x2zgfegmuhnjtmfalztikmamveay7zpkclrgneb4jwle",{"_33":3673,"_35":3674},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3675,"_41":862,"_43":3676,"_67":3678,"_69":70,"_71":3679},"n8mpSqh9",{"_194":195,"_3508":3677},183.5,[],"ipfs://bafkreigt23gmpcbrerdwz4tbjkmxomgbfiwgrzvuxsg2vsafw4lvkxhluy",{"_33":3681,"_35":3682},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3683,"_41":862,"_43":3684,"_67":3685,"_69":70,"_71":3686},"nn3epQyF",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreia55ry7evs3xods6dvhzirojnen3xbjz5fwpzxp7dqzkdwcplj6e4",{"_33":3688,"_35":3689},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3690,"_41":862,"_43":3691,"_67":3693,"_69":70,"_71":3694},"k2cuftFy",{"_194":195,"_3508":3692},637.4501992031873,[],"ipfs://bafkreihuzrcjhyvcc62teuqkkzwnluylrdh3his7twyfge5yewmazduf4y",{"_33":3696,"_35":3697},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3698,"_41":862,"_43":3699,"_67":3701,"_69":70,"_71":3702},"Gu6P9tbZ",{"_194":195,"_3508":3700},235,[],"ipfs://bafkreibgv76kxxqb55ud64j3lckfkbb4jrn7t6vp2vbmmesqy35kg3hdey",{"_33":3704,"_35":3705},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3706,"_41":862,"_43":3707,"_67":3709,"_69":70,"_71":3710},"QoWx_n1h",{"_194":195,"_3508":3708},440.3669724770642,[],"ipfs://bafkreidv3t2bgml3lo2t5dgqnuqistawwaerhqtlspzd2dpfzorltx2s2e",{"_33":3712,"_35":3713},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3714,"_41":862,"_43":3715,"_67":3716,"_69":70,"_71":3717},"Y63WTHiU",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreihaukd2zcnf5a7jhv54e2zolxse7f427fjbcy2ihvp6ydkvoco46e",{"_33":3719,"_35":3720},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3721,"_41":862,"_43":3722,"_67":3724,"_69":70,"_71":3725},"KKMu6Tso",{"_194":195,"_3508":3723},162,[],"ipfs://bafkreiekup6xcdcqyg3shubb5n2f7vhrgmxc3azg424cxk4djp2xqly6ji",{"_33":3727,"_35":3728},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3729,"_41":862,"_43":3730,"_67":3732,"_69":70,"_71":3733},"gOwythtq",{"_194":195,"_3508":3731},411.31105398457584,[],"ipfs://bafkreidrj73utiqxglyymq3gm2trkrnxkukgbrcvbpypohrdcxejbmz7ey",{"_33":3735,"_35":3736},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3737,"_41":862,"_43":3738,"_67":3740,"_69":70,"_71":3741},"w8LeTwU3",{"_194":195,"_3508":3739},449.43820224719104,[],"ipfs://bafkreicdkoa5jngutvxrzoq3bpls35pzslhilyb6prqtbcmqb7ysabc3be",{"_33":3743,"_35":3744},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3745,"_41":862,"_43":3746,"_67":3747,"_69":70,"_71":3748},"jzE2d9AP",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreie4pibpjirljbsc75qnhgxawekdcsy4r3bu6dzt4s33h4nwechchu",{"_33":3750,"_35":3751},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3752,"_41":862,"_43":3753,"_67":3754,"_69":70,"_71":3755},"bWgVhjto",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreifm7jw3a2enklr3c7gc3c5jcsedcfzboccnsk3amcrojf7wldxiwa",{"_33":3757,"_35":3758},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":3759,"_41":862,"_43":3760,"_67":3761,"_69":70,"_71":3762},"E8Oa7Pyy",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreihq4kujx6rk652slpwose6ghszncxjvumfhxfdn6gumiygwnrzbdq",{"_33":3764,"_35":3765},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3766,"_41":862,"_43":3767,"_67":3768,"_69":3781,"_71":70},"wO5G-e_w",{},[3769,3774],{"_37":286,"_233":3770,"_238":3771,"_43":3772,"_71":3773},[139],[2395],{},"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/worrydream/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/master/SmalltalkHistoryHOPL-scanned-2015-07-16.pdf",{"_37":286,"_233":3775,"_238":3777,"_43":3779,"_71":3780},[3776],15,[3778],31,{},"https://github.com/worrydream/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk","original pdf / make corrections",{"_33":3783,"_35":3784},[],{"_37":190,"_39":3785,"_41":862,"_43":3786,"_67":3787,"_69":878,"_71":70},"OHujuc3O",{},[],{"_33":3789,"_35":3790},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3791,"_41":862,"_43":3792,"_67":3793,"_69":880,"_71":70},"RmHmpx_j",{},[3794,3800],{"_37":3795,"_233":3796,"_238":3797,"_43":3799,"_71":70},"Italic",[139],[3798],51,{},{"_37":286,"_233":3801,"_238":3803,"_43":3805,"_71":3806},[3802],27,[3804],41,{},"mailto:kay2@apple.com",{"_33":3808,"_35":3809},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3810,"_41":862,"_43":3811,"_67":3812,"_69":3813,"_71":70},"Lrc4qZDW",{},[],"Permission to copy without fee all or part of this material is granted provided that the copies are not made or distributed for direct commercial advantage, the ACM copyright notice and the title of the publication and its date appear, and notice is given that copying is by permission of the Association for Computing Machinery. To copy otherwise, or to republish, requires a fee and/or specific permission.\nHOPL-II/4/93/MA, USA © 1993 ACM 0-89791-571-2/93/0004/0069...$1.50",{"_33":3815,"_35":3816},[],{"_37":190,"_39":3817,"_41":862,"_43":3818,"_67":3819,"_69":3820,"_71":70},"b7I4h__D",{},[],"Abstract",{"_33":3822,"_35":3823},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3824,"_41":862,"_43":3825,"_67":3826,"_69":3833,"_71":70},"ILifWg0G",{},[3827],{"_37":3795,"_233":3828,"_238":3830,"_43":3832,"_71":70},[3829],808,[3831],814,{},"Most ideas come from previous ideas. The sixties, particularly in the ARPA community, gave rise to a host of notions about \"human-computer symbiosis\" through interactive time-shared computers, graphics screens and pointing devices. Advanced computer languages were invented to simulate complex systems such as oil refineries and semi-intelligent behavior. The soon-to-follow paradigm shift of modern personal computing, overlapping window interfaces, and object-oriented design came from seeing the work of the sixties as something more than a \"better old thing.\" That is, more than a better way: to do mainframe computing; for end-users to invoke functionality; to make data structures more abstract. Instead the promise of exponential growth in computing/$/volume demanded that the sixties be regarded as \"almost a new thing\" and to find out what the actual \"new things\" might be. For example, one would compute with a handheld \"Dynabook\" in a way that would not be possible on a shared mainframe; millions of potential users meant that the user interface would have to become a learning environment along the lines of Montessori and Bruner; and needs for large scope, reduction in complexity, and end-user literacy would require that data and control structures be done away with in favor of a more biological scheme of protected universal cells interacting only through messages that could mimic any desired behavior.",{"_33":3835,"_35":3836},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3837,"_41":862,"_43":3838,"_67":3839,"_69":3840,"_71":70},"epatU-KH",{},[],"Early Smalltalk was the first complete realization of these new points of view as parented by its many predecessors in hardware, language and user interface design. It became the exemplar of the new computing, in part, because we were actually trying for a qualitative shift in belief structures—a new Kuhnian paradigm in the same spirit as the invention of the printing press—and thus took highly extreme positions which almost forced these new styles to be invented.",{"_33":3842,"_35":4214},[3843,3857,3886,3914,3977,4039,4102,4135,4148,4161,4175,4189,4202],{"_33":3844,"_35":3845},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3846,"_41":862,"_43":3847,"_67":3848,"_69":3856,"_71":70},"uhblAPGo",{},[3849],{"_37":286,"_233":3850,"_238":3852,"_43":3854,"_71":3855},[3851],13,[3853],14,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p2","Introduction 2",{"_33":3858,"_35":3873},[3859,3866],{"_33":3860,"_35":3861},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3862,"_41":862,"_43":3863,"_67":3864,"_69":3865,"_71":70},"EAl0HADJ",{},[],"B220 File System",{"_33":3867,"_35":3868},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3869,"_41":862,"_43":3870,"_67":3871,"_69":3872,"_71":70},"AMZvOeYK",{},[],"SketchPad & Simula",{"_37":199,"_39":3874,"_41":862,"_43":3875,"_67":3877,"_69":3885,"_71":70},"xv69dJB1",{"_194":3876},"Unordered",[3878],{"_37":286,"_233":3879,"_238":3881,"_43":3883,"_71":3884},[3880],62,[3882],63,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p4","I. 1960-66—Early OOP and other formative ideas of the sixties 4",{"_33":3887,"_35":3902},[3888,3895],{"_33":3889,"_35":3890},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3891,"_41":862,"_43":3892,"_67":3893,"_69":3894,"_71":70},"4v9NgUxp",{},[],"Doug Englebart and NLS",{"_33":3896,"_35":3897},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3898,"_41":862,"_43":3899,"_67":3900,"_69":3901,"_71":70},"Mdmkr1rU",{},[],"Plasma Panel, GRAIL, LOGO, Dynabook",{"_37":199,"_39":3903,"_41":862,"_43":3904,"_67":3905,"_69":3913,"_71":70},"FlbDhAj1",{"_194":3876},[3906],{"_37":286,"_233":3907,"_238":3909,"_43":3911,"_71":3912},[3908],60,[3910],61,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p6","II 1967-69—The FLEX Machine, an OOP-based personal computer 6",{"_33":3915,"_35":3965},[3916,3923,3930,3937,3944,3951,3958],{"_33":3917,"_35":3918},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3919,"_41":862,"_43":3920,"_67":3921,"_69":3922,"_71":70},"3spiLRh8",{},[],"KiddiKomp",{"_33":3924,"_35":3925},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3926,"_41":862,"_43":3927,"_67":3928,"_69":3929,"_71":70},"ByKdbphg",{},[],"miniCOM",{"_33":3931,"_35":3932},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3933,"_41":862,"_43":3934,"_67":3935,"_69":3936,"_71":70},"xa1UtW2N",{},[],"Smalltalk-71",{"_33":3938,"_35":3939},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3940,"_41":862,"_43":3941,"_67":3942,"_69":3943,"_71":70},"BeATlXUF",{},[],"Overlapping Windows",{"_33":3945,"_35":3946},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3947,"_41":862,"_43":3948,"_67":3949,"_69":3950,"_71":70},"Df3MxWZQ",{},[],"Font Editing, Painting, Animation, Music",{"_33":3952,"_35":3953},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3954,"_41":862,"_43":3955,"_67":3956,"_69":3957,"_71":70},"vddldCiN",{},[],"Byte Codes",{"_33":3959,"_35":3960},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3961,"_41":862,"_43":3962,"_67":3963,"_69":3964,"_71":70},"gpCzWS3I",{},[],"Iconic Programming",{"_37":199,"_39":3966,"_41":862,"_43":3967,"_67":3968,"_69":3976,"_71":70},"9HBpFEIv",{"_194":3876},[3969],{"_37":286,"_233":3970,"_238":3972,"_43":3974,"_71":3975},[3971],24,[3973],26,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p12","III. 1970-72—Xerox PARC 12",{"_33":3978,"_35":4027},[3979,3986,3993,4000,4007,4014],{"_33":3980,"_35":3981},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3982,"_41":862,"_43":3983,"_67":3984,"_69":3985,"_71":70},"ZIQcMt-h",{},[],"The two bets: birth of Smalltalk and Interim Dynabook",{"_33":3987,"_35":3988},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3989,"_41":862,"_43":3990,"_67":3991,"_69":3992,"_71":70},"BqZMVrVI",{},[],"Smalltalk-72 Principles",{"_33":3994,"_35":3995},[],{"_37":199,"_39":3996,"_41":862,"_43":3997,"_67":3998,"_69":3999,"_71":70},"qjeWUPKD",{},[],"The Smalltalk User Interface",{"_33":4001,"_35":4002},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4003,"_41":862,"_43":4004,"_67":4005,"_69":4006,"_71":70},"jInjMSw4",{},[],"Development of the Smalltalk Applications & System",{"_33":4008,"_35":4009},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4010,"_41":862,"_43":4011,"_67":4012,"_69":4013,"_71":70},"zvhDCzjw",{},[],"Evolution of Smalltalk: ST-74, ooze storage management",{"_33":4015,"_35":4016},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4017,"_41":862,"_43":4018,"_67":4019,"_69":4026,"_71":70},"nHPd_kBV",{},[4020],{"_37":286,"_233":4021,"_238":4022,"_43":4024,"_71":4025},[139],[4023],22,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#smalltalkAndChildren","Smalltalk and Children",{"_37":199,"_39":4028,"_41":862,"_43":4029,"_67":4030,"_69":4038,"_71":70},"UpylJZLo",{"_194":3876},[4031],{"_37":286,"_233":4032,"_238":4034,"_43":4036,"_71":4037},[4033],55,[4035],57,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p17","IV. 1972-76—Xerox PARC: The first real Smalltalk (-72) 17",{"_33":4040,"_35":4090},[4041,4048,4055,4062,4069,4076,4083],{"_33":4042,"_35":4043},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4044,"_41":862,"_43":4045,"_67":4046,"_69":4047,"_71":70},"iB9y-9EE",{},[],"\"Let's burn our disk packs\"",{"_33":4049,"_35":4050},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4051,"_41":862,"_43":4052,"_67":4053,"_69":4054,"_71":70},"2p23Xp-5",{},[],"The Notetaker",{"_33":4056,"_35":4057},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4058,"_41":862,"_43":4059,"_67":4060,"_69":4061,"_71":70},"telxBEkK",{},[],"Smalltalk-76",{"_33":4063,"_35":4064},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4065,"_41":862,"_43":4066,"_67":4067,"_69":4068,"_71":70},"2I-1XaHs",{},[],"Inheritance",{"_33":4070,"_35":4071},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4072,"_41":862,"_43":4073,"_67":4074,"_69":4075,"_71":70},"AqexYuUA",{},[],"More Troubles With Xerox",{"_33":4077,"_35":4078},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4079,"_41":862,"_43":4080,"_67":4081,"_69":4082,"_71":70},"P7zBo-Zz",{},[],"ThingLab",{"_33":4084,"_35":4085},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4086,"_41":862,"_43":4087,"_67":4088,"_69":4089,"_71":70},"VtDaIHqJ",{},[],"Apple Demo",{"_37":199,"_39":4091,"_41":862,"_43":4092,"_67":4093,"_69":4101,"_71":70},"v8IfIg1C",{"_194":3876},[4094],{"_37":286,"_233":4095,"_238":4097,"_43":4099,"_71":4100},[4096],44,[4098],46,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p29","V. 1976-80—The first modern Smalltalk (-76) 29",{"_33":4103,"_35":4124},[4104,4111],{"_33":4105,"_35":4106},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4107,"_41":862,"_43":4108,"_67":4109,"_69":4110,"_71":70},"OyvG8bgH",{},[],"Transformations",{"_33":4112,"_35":4113},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4114,"_41":862,"_43":4115,"_67":4116,"_69":4123,"_71":70},"0AChrHvy",{},[4117],{"_37":286,"_233":4118,"_238":4119,"_43":4121,"_71":4122},[139],[4120],4,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#coda","Coda",{"_37":199,"_39":4125,"_41":862,"_43":4126,"_67":4127,"_69":4134,"_71":70},"KXfLeiKG",{"_194":3876},[4128],{"_37":286,"_233":4129,"_238":4130,"_43":4132,"_71":4133},[3798],[4131],53,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p38","VI. 1980-83—The release version of Smalltalk (-80) 38",{"_33":4136,"_35":4137},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4138,"_41":862,"_43":4139,"_67":4140,"_69":4147,"_71":70},"U8xuyn7d",{},[4141],{"_37":286,"_233":4142,"_238":4144,"_43":4145,"_71":4146},[4143],25,[3802],{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p41","References Cited in Text 41",{"_33":4149,"_35":4150},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4151,"_41":862,"_43":4152,"_67":4153,"_69":4160,"_71":70},"7R_aEH4f",{},[4154],{"_37":286,"_233":4155,"_238":4156,"_43":4158,"_71":4159},[3802],[4157],29,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p45","Appendix I: KiddiKomp Memo 45",{"_33":4162,"_35":4163},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4164,"_41":862,"_43":4165,"_67":4166,"_69":4174,"_71":70},"0JQJLp0M",{},[4167],{"_37":286,"_233":4168,"_238":4170,"_43":4172,"_71":4173},[4169],45,[4171],47,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p47","Appendix II: Smalltalk-72 Interpreter Design 47",{"_33":4176,"_35":4177},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4178,"_41":862,"_43":4179,"_67":4180,"_69":4188,"_71":70},"bdWOmn4N",{},[4181],{"_37":286,"_233":4182,"_238":4184,"_43":4186,"_71":4187},[4183],30,[4185],32,{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p50","Appendix III: Acknowledgments 50",{"_33":4190,"_35":4191},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4192,"_41":862,"_43":4193,"_67":4194,"_69":4201,"_71":70},"yj_v1X_R",{},[4195],{"_37":286,"_233":4196,"_238":4198,"_43":4199,"_71":4200},[4197],39,[3804],{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p53","Appendix IV: Event Driven Loop Example 53",{"_33":4203,"_35":4204},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4205,"_41":862,"_43":4206,"_67":4207,"_69":4213,"_71":70},"D-YrHGqx",{},[4208],{"_37":286,"_233":4209,"_238":4210,"_43":4211,"_71":4212},[4169],[4171],{},"https://worrydream.com/EarlyHistoryOfSmalltalk/#p54","Appendix V: Smalltalk-76 Internal Structures 54",{"_37":190,"_39":4215,"_41":862,"_43":4216,"_67":4217,"_69":4218,"_71":70},"caU84OSH",{"_194":3876},[],"Table of Contents",{"_33":4220,"_35":4221},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4222,"_41":862,"_43":4223,"_67":4224,"_69":4225,"_71":70},"gsfIbGF4",{},[],"—To Dan Ingalls, Adele Goldberg and the rest of Xerox PARC LRG gang",{"_33":4227,"_35":4228},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4229,"_41":862,"_43":4230,"_67":4231,"_69":4232,"_71":70},"kO13hD9o",{},[],"—To Dave Evens, Bob Barton, Marvin Minsky, and Seymour Papert",{"_33":4234,"_35":4235},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4236,"_41":862,"_43":4237,"_67":4238,"_69":4239,"_71":70},"HBqxCXKS",{},[],"—To SKETCHPAD, JOSS, LISP, and SIMULA, the 4 great programming conceptions of the sixties",{"_33":4241,"_35":4242},[],{"_37":190,"_39":4243,"_41":862,"_43":4244,"_67":4245,"_69":4246,"_71":70},"NueBegjO",{},[],"Introduction",{"_33":4248,"_35":4249},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4250,"_41":862,"_43":4251,"_67":4252,"_69":4253,"_71":70},"3hC3NUZ5",{},[],"I'm writing this introduction in an airplane at 35,000 feet. On my lap is a five pound notebook computer—1992's \"Interim Dynabook\"—by the end of the year it sold for under $700. It has a flat, crisp, high-resolution bitmap screen, overlapping windows, icons, a pointing device, considerable storage and computing capacity, and its best software is object-oriented. It has advanced networking built-in and there are already options for wireless networking. Smalltalk runs on this system, and is one of the main systems I use for my current work with children. In some ways this is more than a Dynabook (quantitatively), and some ways not quite there yet (qualitatively). All in all, pretty much what was in mind during the late sixties.",{"_33":4255,"_35":4256},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4257,"_41":862,"_43":4258,"_67":4259,"_69":4266,"_71":70},"yDnf4r3q",{},[4260],{"_37":3795,"_233":4261,"_238":4263,"_43":4265,"_71":70},[4262],90,[4264],109,{},"Smalltalk was part of this larger pursuit of ARPA, and later of Xerox PARC, that I called personal computing. There were so many people involved in each stage from the research communities that the accurate allocation of credit for ideas is intractably difficult. Instead, as Bob Barton liked to quote Goethe, we should \"share in the excitement of discovery without vain attempts to claim priority.\"",{"_33":4268,"_35":4269},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4270,"_41":862,"_43":4271,"_67":4272,"_69":4279,"_71":70},"55XMzA7w",{},[4273],{"_37":3795,"_233":4274,"_238":4276,"_43":4278,"_71":70},[4275],168,[4277],177,{},"I will try to show where most of the influences came from and how they were transformed in the magnetic field formed by the new personal computing metaphor. It was the attitudes as well as the great ideas of the pioneers that helped Smalltalk get invented. Many of the people I admired most at this time—such as Ivan Sutherland, Marvin Minsky, Seymour Papert, Gordon Moore, Bob Barton, Dave Evans, Butler Lampson, Jerome Bruner, and others—seemed to have a splendid sense that their creations, though wonderful by relative standards, were not near to the absolute thresholds that had to be crossed. Small minds try to form religions, the great ones just want better routes up the mountain. Where Newton said he saw further by standing on the shoulders of giants, computer scientists all too often stand on each other's toes. Myopia is still a problem where there are giants' shoulders to stand on—\"outsight\" is better than insight—but it can be minimized by using glasses whose lenses are highly sensitive to esthetics and criticism.",{"_33":4281,"_35":4282},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4283,"_41":862,"_43":4284,"_67":4285,"_69":4286,"_71":70},"m1RWZp-C",{},[],"Programming languages can be categorized in a number of ways: imperative, applicative, logic-based, problem-oriented, etc. But they all seem to be either an \"agglutination of features\" or a \"crystallization of style.\" COBOL, PL/1, Ada, etc., belong to the first kind; LISP, APL— and Smalltalk—are the second kind. It is probably not an accident that the agglutinative languages all seem to have been instigated by committees, and the crystallization languages by a single person.",{"_33":4288,"_35":4289},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4290,"_41":862,"_43":4291,"_67":4292,"_69":4303,"_71":70},"BBppHvFr",{},[4293],{"_37":3795,"_233":4294,"_238":4298,"_43":4302,"_71":70},[4295,4296,4297],539,556,677,[4299,4300,4301],544,570,686,{},"Smalltalk's design—and existence—is due to the insight that everything we can describe can be represented by the recursive composition of a single kind of behavioral building block that hides its combination of state and process inside itself and can be dealt with only through the exchange of messages. Philosophically, Smalltalk's objects have much in common with the monads of Leibniz and the notions of 20th century physics and biology. Its way of making objects is quite Platonic in that some of them act as idealizations of concepts—Ideas—from which manifestations can be created. That the Ideas are themselves manifestations (of the Idea-Idea) and that the Idea-Idea is a-kind-of Manifestation-Idea—which is a-kind-of itself, so that the system is completely self-describing— would have been appreciated by Plato as an extremely practical joke [Plato].",{"_33":4305,"_35":4306},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4307,"_41":862,"_43":4308,"_67":4309,"_69":4310,"_71":70},"_O7LSGER",{},[],"In computer terms, Smalltalk is a recursion on the notion of computer itself. Instead of dividing \"computer stuff\" into things each less strong than the whole—like data structures, procedures, and functions which are the usual paraphernalia of programming languages—each Smalltalk object is a recursion on the entire possibilities of the computer. Thus its semantics are a bit like having thousands and thousands of computers all hooked together by a very fast network. Questions of concrete representation can thus be postponed almost indefinitely because we are mainly concerned that the computers behave appropriately, and are interested in particular strategies only if the results are off or come back too slowly.",{"_33":4312,"_35":4313},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4314,"_41":862,"_43":4315,"_67":4316,"_69":4322,"_71":70},"ln7vsHB1",{},[4317],{"_37":3795,"_233":4318,"_238":4319,"_43":4321,"_71":70},[281],[4320],118,{},"Though it has noble ancestors indeed, Smalltalk's contribution is a new design paradigm—which I called object-oriented—for attacking large problems of the professional programmer, and making small ones possible for the novice user. Object-oriented design is a successful attempt to qualitatively improve the efficiency of modeling the ever more complex dynamic systems and user relationships made possible by the silicon explosion.",{"_33":4324,"_35":4325},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4326,"_41":862,"_43":4327,"_67":4328,"_69":4329,"_71":70},"jKFyspzh",{},[],"\"We would know what they thought\nwhen they did it.\"\n—Richard Hamming",{"_33":4331,"_35":4332},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4333,"_41":862,"_43":4334,"_67":4335,"_69":4336,"_71":70},"KVWIE6xc",{},[],"\"Memory and imagination are but two\nwords for the same thing.\"\n—Thomas Hobbes",{"_33":4338,"_35":4339},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4340,"_41":862,"_43":4341,"_67":4342,"_69":4343,"_71":70},"an3vYV0g",{},[],"In this history I will try to be true to Hamming's request as moderated by Hobbes' observation. I have had difficulty in previous attempts to write about Smalltalk because my emotional involvement has always been centered on personal computing as an amplifier for human reach—rather than programming system design—and we haven't got there yet. Though I was the instigator and original designer of Smalltalk, it has always belonged more to the people who make it work and got it out the door, especially Dan Ingalls and Adele Goldberg. Each of the LRGers contributed in deep and remarkable ways to the project, and I wish there was enough space to do them all justice. But I think all of us would agree that for most of the development of Smalltalk, Dan was the central figure. Programming is at heart a practical art in which real things are built, and a real implementation thus has to exist. In fact many if not most languages are in use today not because they have any real merits but because of their existence on one or more machines, their ability to be bootstrapped, etc. But Dan was far more than a great implementer, he also became more and more of the designer, not just of the language but also of the user interface as Smalltalk moved into the practical world.",{"_33":4345,"_35":4346},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4347,"_41":862,"_43":4348,"_67":4349,"_69":4350,"_71":70},"p7ioIIGT",{},[],"Here, I will try to center focus on the events leading up to Smalltalk-72 and its transition to its modern form as Smalltalk-76. Most of the ideas occurred here, and many of the earliest stages of OOP are poorly documented in references almost impossible to find.",{"_33":4352,"_35":4353},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4354,"_41":862,"_43":4355,"_67":4356,"_69":4357,"_71":70},"l46bfJYq",{},[],"This history is too long, but I was amazed at how many people and systems that had an influence appear only as shadows or not at all. I am sorry not to be able to say more about Bob Balzer, Bob Barton, Danny Bobrow, Steve Carr, Wes Clark, Barbara Deutsch, Peter Deutsch, Bill Duvall, Bob Flegal, Laura Gould, Bruce Horn, Butler Lampson, Dave Liddle, William Newman, Bill Paxton, Trygve Reenskaug, Dave Robson, Doug Ross, Paul Rovner, Bob Sproull, Dan Swinehart, Bert Sutherland, Bob Taylor, Warren Teitelman, Bonnie Tennenbaum, Chuck Thacker, and John Warnock. Worse, I have omitted to mention many systems whose design I detested, but that generated considerable useful ideas and attitudes in reaction. In other words \"histories\" should not be believed very seriously but considered as \"FEEBLE GESTURES OFF\" done long after the actors have departed the stage.",{"_33":4359,"_35":4360},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4361,"_41":862,"_43":4362,"_67":4363,"_69":4364,"_71":70},"uleAq_QF",{},[],"Thanks to the numerous reviewers for enduring the many drafts they had to comment on. Special thanks to Mike Mahoney for helping so gently that I heeded his suggestions and so well that they greatly improved this essay—and to Jean Sammet, an old old friend, who quite literally frightened me into finishing it—I did not want to find out what would happen if I were late. Sherri McLoughlin and Kim Rose were of great help in getting all the materials together.",{"_33":4366,"_35":4367},[],{"_37":190,"_39":4368,"_41":862,"_43":4369,"_67":4370,"_69":4371,"_71":70},"jXcr2jPT",{},[],"I. 1960-66—Early OOP and other formative ideas of the sixties",{"_33":4373,"_35":4374},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4375,"_41":862,"_43":4376,"_67":4377,"_69":4378,"_71":70},"rocfEf6k",{},[],"Though OOP came from many motivations, two were central. The large scale one was to find a better module scheme for complex systems involving hiding of details, and the small scale one was to find a more flexible version of assignment, and then to try to eliminate it altogether. As with most new ideas, it originally happened in isolated fits and starts.",{"_33":4380,"_35":4381},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4382,"_41":862,"_43":4383,"_67":4384,"_69":4385,"_71":70},"ypzUvzlC",{},[],"New ideas go through stages of acceptance, both from within and without. From within, the sequence moves from \"barely seeing\" a pattern several times, then noting it but not perceiving its \"cosmic\" significance, then using it operationally in several areas, then comes a \"grand rotation\" in which the pattern becomes the center of a new way of thinking, and finally, it turns into the same kind of inflexible religion that it originally broke away from. From without, as Schopenhauer noted, the new idea is first denounced as the work of the insane, in a few years it is considered obvious and mundane, and finally the original denouncers will claim to have invented it.",{"_33":4387,"_35":4388},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4389,"_41":862,"_43":4390,"_67":4391,"_69":4392,"_71":70},"fAfRpa17",{},[],"True to the stages, I \"barely saw\" the idea several times ca. 1961 while a programmer in the Air",{"_33":4394,"_35":4395},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4396,"_41":862,"_43":4397,"_67":4398,"_69":70,"_71":3549},"R9LCWRpp",{"_194":195,"_3508":3547},[],{"_33":4400,"_35":4401},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4402,"_41":862,"_43":4403,"_67":4404,"_69":4405,"_71":70},"KvcteeG4",{},[],"Force. The first was on the Burroughs 220 in the form of a style for transporting files from one Air Training Command installation to another. There were no standard operating systems or file formats back then, so some (to this day unknown) designer decided to finesse the problem by taking each file and dividing it into three parts. The third part was all of the actual data records of arbitrary size and format. The second part contained the B220 procedures that knew how to get at records and fields to copy and update the third part. And the first part was an array of relative pointers into entry points of the procedures in the second part (the initial pointers were in a standard order representing standard meanings). Needless to say, this was a great idea, and was used in many subsequent systems until the enforced use of COBOL drove it out of existence.",{"_33":4407,"_35":4408},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4409,"_41":862,"_43":4410,"_67":4411,"_69":4412,"_71":70},"DoxrgZE9",{},[],"The second barely-seeing of the idea came just a little later when ATC decided to replace the 220 with a B5000. I didn't have the perspective to really appreciate it at the time, but I did take note of its segmented storage system, its efficiency of HLL compilation and byte-coded execution, its automatic mechanisms for subroutine calling and multiprocess switching, its pure code for sharing, its protection mechanisms, etc. And, I saw that the access to its Program Reference Table corresponded to the 220 file system scheme of providing a procedural interface to a module. However, my big hit from this machine at this time was not the OOP idea, but some insights into HLL translation and evaluation. [Barton, 1961] [Burroughs, 1961]",{"_33":4414,"_35":4415},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4416,"_41":862,"_43":4417,"_67":4418,"_69":4419,"_71":70},"E_poDqaQ",{},[],"After the Air Force, I worked my way through the rest of college by programming mostly retrieval",{"_33":4421,"_35":4422},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4423,"_41":862,"_43":4424,"_67":4425,"_69":70,"_71":3541},"KsO4CPem",{"_194":195,"_3508":3539},[],{"_33":4427,"_35":4428},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4429,"_41":862,"_43":4430,"_67":4431,"_69":4432,"_71":70},"ee4NCr2J",{},[],"systems for large collections of weather data for the National Center for Atmospheric Research. I got interested in simulation in general—particularly of one machine by another—but aside from doing a one-dimensional version of a bit-field block transfer (bitblt) on a CDC 6600 to simulate word sizes of various machines, most of my attention was distracted by school, or I should say the theatre at school. While in Chippewa Falls helping to debug the 6600, I read an article by Gordon Moore which predicted that integrated silicon on chips was going to exponentially improve in density and cost over many years [Moore 65]. At the time in 1965, standing next to the room-sized freon-cooled 10 MIP 6600, his astounding predictions had little projection into my horizons.",{"_33":4434,"_35":4435},[],{"_37":190,"_39":4436,"_41":862,"_43":4437,"_67":4438,"_69":4439,"_71":70},"tgN0yhKa",{},[],"Sketchpad and Simula",{"_33":4441,"_35":4442},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4443,"_41":862,"_43":4444,"_67":4445,"_69":4446,"_71":70},"4TWkSUgO",{},[],"Through a series of flukes, I wound up in graduate school at the University of Utah in the Fall of 1966, \"knowing nothing.\" That is to say, I had never heard of ARPA or its projects, or that Utah's main goal in this community was to solve the \"hidden line\" problem in 3D graphics, until I actually walked into Dave Evans' office looking for a job and a desk. On Dave's desk was a foot-high stack of brown covered documents, one of which he handed to me: \"Take this and read it.\"",{"_33":4448,"_35":4449},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4450,"_41":862,"_43":4451,"_67":4452,"_69":4453,"_71":70},"Tx-kV8Y0",{},[],"Every newcomer got one. The title was \"Sketchpad: A man-machine graphical communication system\" [Sutherland, 1963]. What it could do was quite remarkable, and completely foreign to any use of a computer I had ever encountered. The three big ideas that were easiest to grapple with were: it was the invention of modern interactive computer graphics; things were described by making a \"master drawing\" that could produce \"instance drawings\"; control and dynamics were supplied by \"constraints,\" also in graphical form, that could be applied to the masters to shape an inter-related parts. Its data structures were hard to understand—the only vaguely familiar construct was the embedding of pointers to procedures and using a process called reverse indexing to jump through them to routines, like the 220 file system [Ross, 1961]. It was the first to have clipping and zooming windows—one \"sketched\" on a virtual sheet about 1/3 mile square!",{"_33":4455,"_35":4456},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4457,"_41":862,"_43":4458,"_67":4459,"_69":70,"_71":3533},"Co7Oe5_u",{"_194":195,"_3508":3531},[],{"_33":4461,"_35":4462},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4463,"_41":862,"_43":4464,"_67":4465,"_69":4466,"_71":70},"j0vnbvuL",{},[],"Head whirling, I found my desk. On it was a pile of tapes and listings, and a note: \"This is the Algol for the 1108. It doesn't work. Please make it work.\" The latest graduate student gets the latest dirty task.",{"_33":4468,"_35":4469},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4470,"_41":862,"_43":4471,"_67":4472,"_69":4481,"_71":70},"ecPyBKnN",{},[4473],{"_37":3795,"_233":4474,"_238":4477,"_43":4480,"_71":70},[4475,4476],275,288,[4478,4479],283,295,{},"The documentation was incomprehensible. Supposedly, this was the Case-Western Reserve 1107 Algol—but it had been doctored to make a language called Simula; the documentation read like Norwegian transliterated into English, which in fact it was. There were uses of words like activity and process that didn't seem to coincide with normal English usage.",{"_33":4483,"_35":4484},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4485,"_41":862,"_43":4486,"_67":4487,"_69":4488,"_71":70},"AH6laYKS",{},[],"Finally, another graduate student and I unrolled the program listing 80 feet down the hall and crawled over it yelling discoveries to each other. The weirdest part was the storage allocator, which did not obey a stack discipline as was usual for Algol. A few days later, that provided the clue. What Simula was allocating were structures very much like the instances of Sketchpad. There were descriptions that acted like masters and they could create instances, each of which was an independent entity. What Sketchpad called masters and instances, Simula called activities and processes. Moreover, Simula was a procedural language for controlling Sketchpad-like objects, thus having considerably more flexibility than constraints (though at some cost in elegance) [Nygaard, 1966, Nygaard, 1983].",{"_33":4490,"_35":4491},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4492,"_41":862,"_43":4493,"_67":4494,"_69":4495,"_71":70},"ODFD4TbX",{},[],"This was the big hit, and I've not been the same since. I think the reason the hit had such impact was that I had seen the idea enough times in enough different forms that the final recognition was in such general terms to have the quality of an epiphany. My math major had centered on abstract algebras with their few operations generally applying to many structures. My biology major had focused on both cell metabolism and larger scale morphogenesis with its notions of simple mechanisms controlling complex processes and one kind of building block able to differentiate into all needed building blocks. The 220 file system, the B5000, Sketchpad, and finally Simula, all used the same idea for different purposes. Bob Barton, the main designer of the B5000 and a professor at Utah had said in one of his talks a few days earlier: \"The basic principle of recursive design is to make the parts have the same power as the whole.\" For the first time I thought of the whole as the entire computer and wondered why anyone would want to divide it up into weaker things called data structures and procedures. Why not divide it up into little computers, as time sharing was starting to? But not in dozens. Why not thousands of them, each simulating a useful structure?",{"_33":4497,"_35":4498},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4499,"_41":862,"_43":4500,"_67":4501,"_69":4502,"_71":70},"ef2ud2oF",{},[],"I recalled the monads of Leibniz, the \"dividing nature at its joints\" discourse of Plato, and other attempts to parse complexity. Of course, philosophy is about opinion and engineering is about deeds, with science the happy medium somewhere in between. It is not too much of an exaggeration to say that most of my ideas from then on took their roots from Simula—but not as an attempt to improve it. It was the promise of an entirely new way to structure computations that took my fancy. As it turned out, it would take quite a few years to understand how to use the insights and to devise efficient mechanisms to execute them.",{"_33":4504,"_35":4505},[],{"_37":190,"_39":4506,"_41":862,"_43":4507,"_67":4508,"_69":4509,"_71":70},"aolRVAXA",{},[],"II. 1967-69—The FLEX Machine, a first attempt at an OOP-based personal computer",{"_33":4511,"_35":4512},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4513,"_41":862,"_43":4514,"_67":4515,"_69":70,"_71":3518},"7XK9MyDq",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":4517,"_35":4518},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4519,"_41":862,"_43":4520,"_67":4521,"_69":4530,"_71":70},"r_Rghw6P",{},[4522],{"_37":3795,"_233":4523,"_238":4526,"_43":4529,"_71":70},[4524,4525],916,929,[4527,4528],924,936,{},"Dave Evans was not a great believer in graduate school as an institution. As with many of the ARPA \"contractors\" he wanted his students to be doing \"real things\"; they should move through graduate school as quickly as possible; and their theses should advance the state of the art. Dave would often get consulting jobs for his students, and in early 1967, he introduced me to Ed Cheadle, a friendly hardware genius at a local aerospace company who was working on a \"little machine.\" It was not the first personal computer—that was the LINC of Wes Clark—but Ed wanted it for noncomputer professionals, in particular, he wanted to program it in a higher level language, like BASIC. I said; \"What about JOSS? It's nicer.\" He said: \"Sure, whatever you think,\" and that was the start of a very pleasant collaboration we called the FLEX machine. As we got deeper into the design, we realized that we wanted to dynamically simulate and extend, neither of which JOSS (or any existing language that I knew of) was particularly good at. The machine was too small for Simula, so that was out. The beauty of JOSS was the extreme attention of its design to the end-user—in this respect, it has not been surpassed [Joss 1964, Joss 1978]. JOSS was too slow for serious computing (but cf. Lampson 65), did not have real procedures, variable scope, and so forth. A language that looked a little like JOSS but had considerably more potential power was Wirth's EULER [Wirth 1966]. This was a generalization of Algol along lines first set forth by van Wijngaarden [van Wijngaarden 1963] in which types were discarded, different features consolidated, procedures were made into first class objects, and so forth. Actually kind of LISPlike, but without the deeper insights of LISP.",{"_33":4532,"_35":4533},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4534,"_41":862,"_43":4535,"_67":4536,"_69":4537,"_71":70},"7WXDizu9",{},[],"But EULER was enough of \"an almost new thing\" to suggest that the same techniques be applied to simplify Simula. The EULER compiler was a part of its formal definition and made a simple conversion into B5000-like byte-codes. This was appealing because it suggested that Ed's little machine could run byte-codes emulated in the longish slow microcode that was then possible. The EULER compiler however, was tortuously rendered in an \"extended precedence\" grammar that actually required concessions in the language syntax (e.g. \",\" could only be used in one role because the precedence scheme had no state space). I initially adopted a bottom-up Floyd-Evans parser (adapted from Jerry Feldman's original compiler-compiler [Feldman 1977]) and later went to various top-down schemes, several of them related to Shorre's META II [Shorre 1963] that eventually put the translater in the name space of the language.",{"_33":4539,"_35":4540},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4541,"_41":862,"_43":4542,"_67":4543,"_69":4544,"_71":70},"B9DqkcHj",{},[],"The semantics of what was now called the FLEX language needed to be influenced more by Simula than by Algol or EULER. But it was not completely clear how. Nor was it clear how the users should interact with the system. Ed had a display (for graphing, etc.) even on his first machine, and the LINC had a \"glass teletype,\" but a Sketchpad-like system seemed far beyond the scope that we could accomplish with the maximum of 16k 16-bit words that our cost budget allowed.",{"_33":4546,"_35":4547},[],{"_37":190,"_39":4548,"_41":862,"_43":4549,"_67":4550,"_69":4551,"_71":70},"jLdCwj7k",{},[],"Doug Engelbart and NLS",{"_33":4553,"_35":4554},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4555,"_41":862,"_43":4556,"_67":4557,"_69":70,"_71":3525},"g3Ti1fRY",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":4559,"_35":4560},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4561,"_41":862,"_43":4562,"_67":4563,"_69":4564,"_71":70},"G8jP0Xmk",{},[],"This was in early 1967, and while we were pondering the FLEX machine, Utah was visited by Doug Engelbart. A prophet of Biblical dimensions, he was very much one of the fathers of what on the FLEX machine I had started to call \"personal computing.\" He actually traveled with his own 16mm projector with a remote control for starting and stopping it to show what was going on (people were not used to seeing and following cursors back then). His notion on the ARPA dream was that the destiny of oNLine Systems (NLS) was the \"augmentation of human intellect\" via an interactive vehicle navigating through \"thought vectors in concept space.\" What his system could do then—even by today's standards—was incredible. Not just hypertext, but graphics, multiple panes, efficient navigation and command input, interactive collaborative work, etc. An entire conceptual world and world view [Engelbart 68]. The impact of this vision was to produce in the minds of those who were \"eager to be augmented\" a compelling metaphor of what interactive computing should be like, and I immediately adopted many of the ideas for the FLEX machine.",{"_33":4566,"_35":4567},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4568,"_41":862,"_43":4569,"_67":4570,"_69":4571,"_71":70},"i9dWn6UX",{},[],"In the midst of the ARPA context of human-computer symbiosis and in the presence of Ed's \"little machine\", Gordon Moore's \"Law\" again came to mind, this time with great impact. For the first time I made the leap of putting the room-sized interactive TX-2 or even a 10 MIP 6600 on a desk. I was almost frightened by the implications; computing as we knew it couldn't survive—the actual meaning of the word changed—it must have been the same kind of disorientation people had after reading Copernicus and first looked up from a different Earth to a different Heaven.",{"_33":4573,"_35":4574},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4575,"_41":862,"_43":4576,"_67":4577,"_69":4587,"_71":70},"EpkFXWo6",{},[4578],{"_37":3795,"_233":4579,"_238":4583,"_43":4586,"_71":70},[4580,4581,4582],34,257,527,[4171,4584,4585],265,538,{},"Instead of at most a few thousand institutional mainframes in the world—even today in 1992 it is estimated that there are only 4000 IBM mainframes in the entire world—and at most a few thousand users trained for each application, there would be millions of personal machines and users, mostly outside of direct institutional control. Where would the applications and training come from? Why should we expect an applications programmer to anticipate the specific needs of a particular one of the millions of potential users? An extensional system seemed to be called for in which the end-users would do most of the tailoring (and even some of the direct construction) of their tools. ARPA had already figured this out in the context of their early successes in time-sharing. Their larger metaphor of human-computer symbiosis helped the community avoid making a religion of their subgoals and kept them focused on the abstract holy grail of \"augmentation.\"",{"_33":4589,"_35":4590},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4591,"_41":862,"_43":4592,"_67":4593,"_69":4594,"_71":70},"lf5-o2vR",{},[],"One of the interesting features of NLS was that its user interface was parametric and could be supplied by the end user in the form of a \"grammar of interaction\" given in their compiler-compiler TreeMeta. This was similar to William Newman's early \"Reaction Handler\" [Newman 66] work in specifying interfaces by having the end-user or developer construct through tablet and stylus an iconic regular expression grammar with action procedures at the states (NLS allowed embeddings via its context free rules). This was attractive in many ways, particularly William's scheme, but to me there was a monstrous bug in this approach. Namely, these grammars forced the user to be in a system state which required getting out of before any new kind of interaction could be done. In hierarchical menus or \"screens\" one would have to backtrack to a master state in order to go somewhere else. What seemed to be required were states in which there was a transition arrow to every other state—not a fruitful concept in formal grammar theory. In other words, a much \"flatter\" interface seemed called for—but could such a thing be made interesting and rich enough to be useful?",{"_33":4596,"_35":4597},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4598,"_41":862,"_43":4599,"_67":4600,"_69":4601,"_71":70},"Q00d2I6R",{},[],"Again, the scope of the FLEX machine was too small for a miniNLS, and we were forced to find alternate designs that would incorporate some of the power of the new ideas, and in some cases to improve them. I decided that Sketchpad's notion of a general window that viewed a larger virtual world was a better idea than restricted horizontal panes and with Ed came up with a clipping algorithm very similar to that under development at the same time by Sutherland and his students at Harvard for the 3D \"virtual reality\" helmet project [Sutherland 1968].",{"_33":4603,"_35":4604},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4605,"_41":862,"_43":4606,"_67":4607,"_69":4631,"_71":70},"mrD7XyRz",{},[4608,4624],{"_37":3795,"_233":4609,"_238":4616,"_43":4623,"_71":70},[4610,4611,4612,4613,4614,4615],576,591,717,844,930,1332,[4617,4618,4619,4620,4621,4622],586,592,722,845,945,1397,{},{"_37":4625,"_233":4626,"_238":4628,"_43":4630,"_71":70},"Underline",[4627],952,[4629],955,{},"Object references were handled on the FLEX machine as a generalization of B5000 descriptors. Instead of a few formats for referencing numbers, arrays, and procedures, a FLEX descriptor contained two pointers: the first to the \"master\" of the object, and the second to the object instances (later we realized that we should put the master pointer in the instance to save space). A different method was taken for handling generalized assignment. The B5000 used l-values and r-values [Strachey*] which worked for some cases but couldn't handle more complex objects. For example: a[55] := 0, if a was a sparse array whose default element was 0 would still generate an element in the array because := is an \"operator\" and a[55] is dereferenced into an l-value before anyone gets to see that the r-value is the default element, regardless of whether a is an array or a procedure fronting for an array. What is needed is something like: a(55, ':=', 0), which can look at all relevant operands before any store is made. In other words, := is not an operator, but a kind of index that can select a behavior from a complex object. It took me a remarkably long time to see this, partly I think because one has to invert the traditional notion of operators and functions, etc., to see that objects need to privately own all of their behaviors: that objects are a kind of mapping whose values are its behaviors. A book on logic by Carnap [Ca *] helped by showing that \"intensional\" definitions covered the same territory as the more traditional extensional technique and were often more intuitive and convenient.",{"_33":4633,"_35":4634},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4635,"_41":862,"_43":4636,"_67":4637,"_69":70,"_71":3511},"NgvdJe4O",{"_194":195,"_3508":3509},[],{"_33":4639,"_35":4640},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4641,"_41":862,"_43":4642,"_67":4643,"_69":4652,"_71":70},"w1jm4BvD",{},[4644],{"_37":232,"_233":4645,"_238":4648,"_43":4651,"_71":70},[4646,4647],415,468,[4649,4650],420,473,{},"As in Simula, a coroutining control structure [Conway, 1963] was used as a way to suspend and resume objects. Persistent objects like files and documents were treated as suspended processes and were organized according to their Algol-like static variable scopes. These were shown on the screen and could be opened by pointing at them. Coroutining was also used as a control structure for looping. A single operator while was used to test the generators which returned false when unable to furnish a new value. Booleans were used to link multiple generators. So a \"for-type\" loop would be written as:",{"_33":4654,"_35":4655},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":4657,"_41":862,"_43":4658,"_67":4660,"_69":4661,"_71":70},"Code","xQlBvRnT",{"_4659":70},"language",[],"while i <= 1 to 30 by 2 ^ j <= 2 to k by 3 do j<-j * i;",{"_33":4663,"_35":4664},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4665,"_41":862,"_43":4666,"_67":4667,"_69":4673,"_71":70},"NzgJHUQx",{},[4668],{"_37":232,"_233":4669,"_238":4671,"_43":4672,"_71":70},[4670],10,[3802],{},"where the ... to ... by ... was a kind of coroutine object. Many of these ideas were reimplemented in a stronger style in Smalltalk later on.",{"_33":4675,"_35":4676},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4677,"_41":862,"_43":4678,"_67":4679,"_69":70,"_71":3755},"9OeKJHWi",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":4681,"_35":4682},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4683,"_41":862,"_43":4684,"_67":4685,"_69":4702,"_71":70},"OjSEx1aM",{},[4686,4696],{"_37":232,"_233":4687,"_238":4691,"_43":4695,"_71":70},[4688,4689,4690],97,300,647,[4692,4693,4694],101,304,651,{},{"_37":3795,"_233":4697,"_238":4699,"_43":4701,"_71":70},[4698],622,[4700],629,{},"Another control structure of interest in FLEX was a kind of event-driven \"soft interrupt\" called when. Its boolean expression was compiled into a \"tournament sort\" tree that cached all possible intermediate results. The relevant variables were threaded through all of the sorting trees in all of the whens so that any change only had to compute through the necessary parts of the booleans. The efficiency was very high and was similar to the techniques now used for spreadsheets. This was an embarrassment of riches with difficulties often encountered in event-driven systems. Namely, it was a complex task to control the context of just when the whens should be sensitive. Part of the boolean expression had to be used to check the contexts, where I felt that somehow the structure of the program should be able to set and unset the event drivers. This turned out to beyond the scope of the FLEX system and needed to wait for a better architecture.",{"_33":4704,"_35":4705},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4706,"_41":862,"_43":4707,"_67":4708,"_69":4709,"_71":70},"PhQizaId",{},[],"Still, quite a few of the original FLEX ideas in their proto-object form did turn out to be small enough to be feasible on the machine. I was writing the first compiler when something unusual happened: the Utah graduate students got invited to the ARPA contractors meeting held that year at Alta, Utah. Towards the end of the three days, Bob Taylor, who had succeeded Ivan Sutherland as head of ARPA-IPTO, asked the graduate students (sitting in a ring around the outside of the 20 or so contractors) if they had any comments. John Warnock raised his hand and pointed out that since the ARPA grad students would all soon be colleagues (and since we did all the real work anyway), ARPA should have a contractors-type meeting each year for the grad students. Taylor thought this was a great idea and set it up for the next summer.",{"_33":4711,"_35":4712},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4713,"_41":862,"_43":4714,"_67":4715,"_69":4716,"_71":70},"3gMvpNAg",{},[],"Another ski-lodge meeting happened in Park City later that spring. The general topic was education and it was the first time I heard Marvin Minsky speak. He put forth a terrific diatribe against traditional education methods, and from him I heard the ideas of Piaget and Papert for the first time. Marvin's talk was about how we think about complex situations and why schools are really bad places to learn these skills. He didn't have to make any claims about computers+kids to make his point. It was clear that education and learning had to be rethought in the light of 20th century cognitive psychology and how good thinkers really think. Computing enters as a new representation system with new and useful metaphors for dealing with complexity, especially of systems [Minsky 70].",{"_33":4718,"_35":4719},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4720,"_41":862,"_43":4721,"_67":4722,"_69":70,"_71":3694},"PEI7JFXZ",{"_194":195,"_3508":3692},[],{"_33":4724,"_35":4725},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4726,"_41":862,"_43":4727,"_67":4728,"_69":4729,"_71":70},"n6cLyxcf",{},[],"For the summer 1968 ARPA grad students meeting at Allerton House in Illinois, I boiled all the mechanisms in the FLEX machine down into one 2'x3' chart. This included all the \"object structures\", the compiler, the byte-code interpreter, i/o handlers, and a simple display editor for text and graphics. The grad students were a distinguished group that did indeed become colleagues in subsequent years. My FLEX machine talk was a success, but the big whammy for me came during a tour to U of Illinois where I saw a 1\" square lump of glass and neon gas in which individual spots would light up on command—it was the first flat-panel display. I spent the rest of the conference calculating just when the silicon of the FLEX machine could be put on the back of the display. According to Gordon Moore's \"Law\", the answer seemed to be sometime in the late seventies or early eighties. A long time off—it seemed too long to worry much about it then.",{"_33":4731,"_35":4732},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4733,"_41":862,"_43":4734,"_67":4735,"_69":70,"_71":3702},"b6qEo0lP",{"_194":195,"_3508":3700},[],{"_33":4737,"_35":4738},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4739,"_41":862,"_43":4740,"_67":4741,"_69":4748,"_71":70},"DHX7z6Hu",{},[4742],{"_37":4625,"_233":4743,"_238":4745,"_43":4747,"_71":70},[4744],678,[4746],681,{},"But later that year at RAND I saw a truly beautiful system. This was GRAIL, the graphical followon to JOSS. The first tablet (the famous RAND tablet) was invented by Tom Ellis [Davis 1964] in order to capture human gestures, and Gabe Groner wrote a program to efficiently recognize and respond to them [Groner 1966]. Though everything was fastened with bubble gum and the system crashed often, I have never forgotten my first interactions with this system. It was direct manipulation, it was analogical, it was modeless, it was beautiful. I realized that the FLEX interface was all wrong, but how could something like GRAIL be stuffed into such a tiny machine since it required all of a stand-alone 360/44 to run in?",{"_33":4750,"_35":4751},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4752,"_41":862,"_43":4753,"_67":4754,"_69":4765,"_71":70},"59x9YN62",{},[4755],{"_37":3795,"_233":4756,"_238":4760,"_43":4764,"_71":70},[4757,4758,4759],399,446,567,[4761,4762,4763],405,454,574,{},"A month later, I finally visited Seymour Papert, Wally Feurzig, Cynthia Solomon and some of the other original researchers who had built LOGO and were using it with children in the Lexington schools. Here were children doing real programming with a specially designed language and environment. As with Simula leading to OOP, this encounter finally hit me with what the destiny of personal computing really was going to be. Not a personal dynamic vehicle, as in Engelbart's metaphor opposed to the IBM \"railroads\", but something much more profound: a personal dynamic medium. With a vehicle one could wait until high school and give \"drivers ed\", but if it was a medium, it had to extend into the world of childhood.",{"_33":4767,"_35":4768},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4769,"_41":862,"_43":4770,"_67":4771,"_69":4772,"_71":70},"nNJCdcKu",{},[],"Now the collision of the FLEX machine, the flat-screen display, GRAIL, Barton's \"communications\" talk, McLuhan, and Papert's work with children all came together to form an image of what a personal computer really should be. I remembered Aldus Manutius who 40 years after the printing press put the book into its modern dimensions by making it fit into saddlebags. It had to be no larger than a notebook, and needed an interface as friendly as JOSS', GRAIL's, and LOGO's, but with the reach of Simula and FLEX. A clear romantic vision has a marvelous ability to focus thought and will. Now it was easy to know what to do next. I built a cardboard model of it to see what it would look and feel like, and poured in lead pellets to see how light it would have to be (less than two pounds). I put a keyboard on it as well as a stylus because, even if hand printing and writing were recognized perfectly (and there was no reason to expect that it would be), there still needed to be a balance between the low speed tactile degrees of freedom offered by the stylus and the more limited but faster keyboard. Since ARPA was starting to experiment with packet radio, I expected that the Dynabook when it arrived a decade or so hence, would have a wireless networking system.",{"_33":4774,"_35":4782},[4775],{"_33":4776,"_35":4777},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4778,"_41":862,"_43":4779,"_67":4780,"_69":4781,"_71":70},"2rgMSgIQ",{},[],"It has been such a long time since I have seen so many familiar faces shouting among so many familiar ideas. Discovery of something new in programming languages, like any discovery, has somewhat the same sequence of emotions as falling in love. A sharp elation followed by euphoria, a feeling of uniqueness, and ultimately the wandering eye (the urge to generalize) [ACM 69].",{"_37":199,"_39":4783,"_41":862,"_43":4784,"_67":4786,"_69":4787,"_71":70},"IDf_V_WI",{"_194":4785},"Blockquote",[],"Early next year (1969) there was a conference on Extensible Languages in which almost every famous name in the field attended. The debate was great and weighty—it was a religious war of unimplemented poorly thought out ideas. As Alan Perlis, one of the great men in Computer Science, put it with characteristic wit:",{"_33":4789,"_35":4790},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4791,"_41":862,"_43":4792,"_67":4793,"_69":4799,"_71":70},"w_93wyQJ",{},[4794],{"_37":4625,"_233":4795,"_238":4796,"_43":4798,"_71":70},[3778],[4797],35,{},"But it was all talk—no one had done anything yet. In the midst of all this, Ned Irons got up and presented IMP, a system that had already been working for several years that was more elegant than most of the nonworking proposals. The basic idea of IMP was that you could use any phrase in the grammar as a procedure heading and write a semantic definition in terms of the language as extended so far [Irons 1970].",{"_33":4801,"_35":4802},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4803,"_41":862,"_43":4804,"_67":4805,"_69":4816,"_71":70},"mv1b2U3w",{},[4806],{"_37":3795,"_233":4807,"_238":4811,"_43":4815,"_71":70},[4808,4809,4810],273,1026,1042,[4812,4813,4814],278,1032,1050,{},"I had already made the first version of the FLEX machine syntax driven, but where the meaning of a phrase was defined in the more usual way as the kind of code that was emitted. This separated the compiler-extensor part of the system from the end-user. In Irons' approach, every procedure in the system defined its own syntax in a natural and useful manner. I incorporated these ideas into the second versions of the FLEX machine and started to experiment with the idea of a direct interpreter rather than a syntax directed compiler. Somewhere in all of this, I realized that the bridge to an object-based system could be in terms of each object as a syntax directed interpreter of messages sent to it. In one fell swoop this would unify object-oriented semantics with the ideal of a completely extensible language. The mental image was one of separate computers sending requests to other computers that had to be accepted and understood by the receivers before anything could happen. In today's terms every object would be a server offering services whose deployment and discretion depended entirely on the server's notion of relationship with the servee. As Liebniz said: \"To get everything out of nothing, you only need to find one principle.\" This was not well thought out enough to do the FLEX machine any good, but formed a good point of departure for my thesis [Kay 69], which as Ivan Sutherland liked to say was \"anything you can get three people to sign.\"",{"_33":4818,"_35":4819},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4820,"_41":862,"_43":4821,"_67":4822,"_69":4823,"_71":70},"ORmsJAfn",{},[],"After three people signed it (Ivan was one of them), I went to the Stanford AI project and spent much more time thinking about notebook KiddyKomputers than AI. But there were two AI designs that were very intriguing. The first was Carl Hewitt's PLANNER, a programmable logic system that formed the deductive basis of Winograd's SHRDLU [Sussman 69, Hewitt 69] I designed several languages based on a combination of the pattern matching schemes of FLEX and PLANNER [Kay 70]. The second design was Pat Winston's concept formation system, a scheme for building semantic networks and comparing them to form analogies and learning processes [Winston 70]. It was kind of \"object-oriented\". One of its many good ideas was that the arcs of each net which served as attributes in AOV triples should themselves be modeled as nets. Thus, for example a first order arc called LEFT-OF could be asked a higher order question such as \"What is your converse?\" and its net could answer: RIGHT-OF. This point of view later formed the basis for Minsky's frame systems [Minsky 75]. A few years later I wished I had paid more attention to this idea.",{"_33":4825,"_35":4826},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4827,"_41":862,"_43":4828,"_67":4829,"_69":4830,"_71":70},"ipnSymbb",{},[],"That fall, I heard a wonderful talk by Butler Lampson about CAL-TSS, a capability-based operating system that seemed very \"object-oriented\" [Lampson 69]. Unforgeable pointers (ala B5000) were extended by bit-masks that restricted access to the object's internal operations. This confirmed my \"objects as server\" metaphor. There was also a very nice approach to exception handling which reminded me of the way failure was often handled in pattern matching systems. The only problem— which the CAL designers did not see as a problem at all—was that only certain (usually large and slow) things were \"objects\". Fast things and small things, etc., weren't. This needed to be fixed.",{"_33":4832,"_35":4833},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4834,"_41":862,"_43":4835,"_67":4836,"_69":4852,"_71":70},"1uqc6r7i",{},[4837],{"_37":3795,"_233":4838,"_238":4845,"_43":4851,"_71":70},[4839,4840,4841,4842,4843,4844],56,116,130,243,252,314,[4846,4847,4848,4849,4581,4850],73,124,134,247,318,{},"The biggest hit for me while at SAIL in late '69 was to really understand LISP. Of course, every student knew about car, cdr, and cons, but Utah was impoverished in that no one there used LISP and hence, no one had penetrated the mysteries of eval and apply. I could hardly believe how beautiful and wonderful the idea of LISP was [McCarthy 1960]. I say it this way because LISP had not only been around enough to get some honest barnacles, but worse, there were deep flaws in its logical foundations. By this, I mean that the pure language was supposed to be based on functions, but its most important components—such as lambda expressions, quotes, and conds—were not functions at all, and instead were called special forms. Landin and others had been able to get quotes and conds in terms of lambda by tricks that were variously clever and useful, but the flaw remained in the jewel. In the practical language things were better. There were not just EXPRs (which evaluated their arguments), but FEXPRs (which did not). My next question was, why on earth call it a functional language? Why not just base everything on FEXPRs and force evaluation on the receiving side when needed? I could never get a good answer, but the question was very helpful when it came time to invent Smalltalk, because this started a line of thought that said \"take the hardest and most profound thing you need to do, make it great, and then build every easier thing out of it\". That was the promise of LISP and the lure of lambda—needed was a better \"hardest and most profound\" thing. Objects should be it.",{"_33":4854,"_35":4855},[],{"_37":190,"_39":4856,"_41":862,"_43":4857,"_67":4858,"_69":4859,"_71":70},"Cmxt7zPd",{},[],"III. 1970-72—Xerox PARC: The KiddiKomp, miniCOM, and Smalltalk-71",{"_33":4861,"_35":4862},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4863,"_41":862,"_43":4864,"_67":4865,"_69":4866,"_71":70},"6WOU0jyZ",{},[],"In July 1970, Xerox, at the urging of its chief scientist Jack Goldman, decided to set up a long range research center in Palo Alto, California. In September, George Pake, the former chancellor at Washington University where Wes Clark's ARPA project was sited, hired Bob Taylor (who had left the ARPA office and was taking a sabbatical year at Utah) to start a \"Computer Science Laboratory.\" Bob visited Palo Alto and we stayed up all night talking about it. The Mansfield Amendment was threatening to blindly muzzle the most enlightened ARPA funding in favor of directly military research, and this new opportunity looked like a promising alternative. But work for a company? He wanted me to consult and I asked for a direction. He said: follow your instincts. I immediately started working up a new version of the KiddiKomp that could be made in enough quantity to do experiments leading to the user interface design for the eventual notebook. Bob Barton liked to say that \"good ideas don't often scale.\" He was certainly right when applied to the FLEX machine. The B5000 just didn't directly scale down into a tiny machine. Only the byte-codes did, and even these needed modification. I decided to take another look at Wes Clark's LINC, and was ready to appreciate it much more this time [Clark 1965].",{"_33":4868,"_35":4869},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4870,"_41":862,"_43":4871,"_67":4872,"_69":70,"_71":3640},"aS1AL__R",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":4874,"_35":4875},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4876,"_41":862,"_43":4877,"_67":4878,"_69":4879,"_71":70},"scPQuRG9",{},[],"I still liked pattern-directed approaches and OOP so I came up with a language design called \"Simulation LOGO\" or SLOGO for short (I had a feeling the first versions might run nice and slow). This was to be built into a SONY \"tummy trinitron\" and would use a coarse bit-map display and the FLEX machine rubber tablet as a pointing device.",{"_33":4881,"_35":4882},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4883,"_41":862,"_43":4884,"_67":4885,"_69":4886,"_71":70},"jIyxknBt",{},[],"Another beautiful system that I had come across was Peter Deutsch's PDP-1 LISP (implemented when he was only 15) [Deutsch 1966]. It used only 2K (18-bit words) of code and could run quite well in a 4K machine (it was its own operating system and interface). It seemed that even more could be done if the system were byte-coded, run by an architecture that was hospitable to dynamic systems, and stuck into the ever larger ROMs that were becoming available. One of the basic insights I had gotten from Seymour was that you didn't have to do a lot to make a computer an \"object for thought\" for children, but what you did had to be done well and be able to apply deeply.",{"_33":4888,"_35":4889},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4890,"_41":862,"_43":4891,"_67":4892,"_69":4893,"_71":70},"A-hnS_W8",{},[],"Right after New Years 1971, Bob Taylor scored an enormous coup by attracting most of the struggling Berkeley Computer Corp to PARC. This group included Butler Lampson, Chuck Thacker, Peter Deutsch, Jim Mitchell, Dick Shoup, Willie Sue Haugeland, and Ed Fiala. Jim Mitchell urged the group to hire Ed McCreight from CM and he arrived soon after. Gary Starkweather was there already, having been thrown out of the Xerox Rochester Labs for wanting to build a laser printer (which was against the local religion). Not long after, many of Doug Englebart's people joined up—part of the reason was that they want to reimplement NLS as a distributed network system, and Doug wanted to stay with time-sharing. The group included Bill English (the co-inventor of the mouse), Jeff Rulifson, and Bill Paxton.",{"_33":4895,"_35":4896},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4897,"_41":862,"_43":4898,"_67":4899,"_69":4906,"_71":70},"jCzOH5Zt",{},[4900],{"_37":3795,"_233":4901,"_238":4903,"_43":4905,"_71":70},[4902],488,[4904],493,{},"Almost immediately we got into trouble with Xerox when the group decided that the new lab needed a PDP-10 for continuity with the ARPA community. Xerox (which had bought SDS essentially sight unseen a few years before) was horrified at the idea of their main competitor's computer being used in the lab. They balked. The newly formed PARC group had a meeting in which it was decided that it would take about three years to do a good operating system for the XDS SIGMA-7 but that we could build \"our own PDP-10\" in a year. My reaction was \"Holy cow!\" In fact, they pulled it it off with considerable panache. MAXC was actually a microcoded emulation of the PDP-10 that used for the first time the new integrated chip memories (1K bits!) instead of core memory. Having practical in house experience with both of these new technologies was critical for the more radical systems to come.",{"_33":4908,"_35":4909},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4910,"_41":862,"_43":4911,"_67":4912,"_69":4913,"_71":70},"pXOnge5j",{},[],"One little incident of LISP beauty happened when Allen Newell visited PARC with his theory of hierarchical thinking and was challenged to prove it. He was given a programming problem to solve while the protocol was collected. The problem was: given a list of items, produce a list consisting of all of the odd indexed items followed by all of the even indexed items. Newell's internal programming language resembled IPL-V in which pointers are manipulated explicitly, and he got into quite a struggle to do the program. In 2 seconds I wrote down:",{"_33":4915,"_35":4916},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":4917,"_41":862,"_43":4918,"_67":4919,"_69":4920,"_71":70},"RQGBF0qS",{"_4659":70},[],"oddsEvens(x) = append(odds(x), evens(x))",{"_33":4922,"_35":4923},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4924,"_41":862,"_43":4925,"_67":4926,"_69":4927,"_71":70},"MWtId1mx",{},[],"the statement of the problem in Landin's LISP syntax—and also the first part of the solution. Then a few seconds later:",{"_33":4929,"_35":4930},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":4931,"_41":862,"_43":4932,"_67":4933,"_69":4934,"_71":70},"GguRxjxY",{"_4659":70},[],"where odds(x) = if null(x) ∨ null(tl(x)) then x\n else hd(x) & odds(ttl(x))\n evens(x) = if null(x) ∨ null(tl(x)) then nil\n else odds(tl(x))",{"_33":4936,"_35":4937},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4938,"_41":862,"_43":4939,"_67":4940,"_69":4947,"_71":70},"ZWZ8p6DY",{},[4941],{"_37":4625,"_233":4942,"_238":4944,"_43":4946,"_71":70},[4943],601,[4945],604,{},"This characteristic of writing down many solutions in declarative form and have them also be the programs is part of the appeal and beauty of this kind of language. Watching a famous guy much smarter than I struggle for more than 30 minutes to not quite solve the problem his way (there was a bug) made quite an impression. It brought home to me once again that \"point of view is worth 80 IQ points.\" I wasn't smarter but I had a much better internal thinking tool to amplify my abilities. This incident and others like it made paramount that any tool for children should have great thinking patterns and deep beauty \"built-in.\"",{"_33":4949,"_35":4950},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4951,"_41":862,"_43":4952,"_67":4953,"_69":70,"_71":3655},"LfDgADzb",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":4955,"_35":4956},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4957,"_41":862,"_43":4958,"_67":4959,"_69":4966,"_71":70},"tUuR28KH",{},[4960],{"_37":3795,"_233":4961,"_238":4963,"_43":4965,"_71":70},[4962],349,[4964],400,{},"Right around this time we were involved in another conflict with Xerox management, in particular with Don Pendery the head \"planner\". He really didn't understand what we were talking about and instead was interested in \"trends\" and \"what was the future going to be like\" and how could Xerox \"defend against it.\" I got so upset I said to him, \"Look. The best way to predict the future is to invent it. Don't worry about what all those other people might do, this is the century in which almost any clear vision can be made!\" He remained unconvinced, and that led to the famous \"Pendery Papers for PARC Planning Purposes,\" a collection of essays on various aspects of the future. Mine proposed a version of the notebook as a \"Display Transducer\", and Jim Mitchell's was entitled \"NLS on a Minicomputer.\"",{"_33":4968,"_35":4969},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4970,"_41":862,"_43":4971,"_67":4972,"_69":4973,"_71":70},"LXOeS6Zg",{},[],"Bill English took me under his wing and helped me start my group as I had always been a lone wolf and had no idea how to do it. One of his suggestions was that I should make a budget. I'm afraid that I really did ask Bill, \"What's a budget?\" I remembered at Utah, in pre-Mansfield Amendment days, Dave Evans saying to me as he went off on a trip to ARPA, \"We're almost out of money. Got to go get some more.\" That seemed about right to me. They give you some money. You spend it to find out what to do next. You run out. They give you some more. And so on. PARC never quite made it to that idyllic standard, but for the first half decade it came close. I needed a group because I had finally realized that I did not have all of the temperaments required to completely finish an idea. I called it the Learning Research Group (LRG) to be as vague as possible about our charter. I only hired people that got stars in their eyes when they heard about the notebook computer idea. I didn't like meetings: didn't believe brainstorming could substitute for cool sustained thought. When anyone asked me what to do, and I didn't have a strong idea, I would point at the notebook model and say, \"Advance that.\" LRG members developed a very close relationship with each other—as Dan Ingalls was to say later: \"... the rest has enfolded through the love and energy of the whole Learning Research Group.\" A lot of daytime was spent outside of PARC, playing tennis, bikeriding, drinking beer, eating Chinese food, and constantly talking about the Dynabook and its potential to amplify human reach and bring new ways of thinking to a faltering civilization that desperately needed it (that kind of goal was common in California in the aftermath of the sixties).",{"_33":4975,"_35":4976},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4977,"_41":862,"_43":4978,"_67":4979,"_69":4980,"_71":70},"9W2cw7-K",{},[],"In the summer of '71 I refined the KiddiKomp idea into a tighter design called miniCOM. It used a bit-slice approach like the NOVA 1200, had a bit-map display, a pointing device, a choice of \"secondary\" (really tertiary) storages, and a language I now called \"Smalltalk\"—as in \"programming should be a matter of ...\" and \"children should program in ...\". The name was also a reaction against the \"IndoEuropean god theory\" where systems were named Zeus, Odin, and Thor, and hardly did anything. I figured that \"Smalltalk\" was so innocuous a label that if it ever did anything nice people would be pleasantly surprised.",{"_33":4982,"_35":4983},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":4984,"_41":862,"_43":4985,"_67":4986,"_69":70,"_71":3610},"wAGQqC8i",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":4988,"_35":4989},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":4990,"_41":862,"_43":4991,"_67":4992,"_69":4993,"_71":70},"nDzhysjD",{"_4659":70},[],"Smalltalk-71 Programs\n\nto T 'and' :y do 'y'\nto F 'and' :y do F\n\nto 'factorial' 0 is 1\nto 'factorial' :n do 'n*factorial n-1'\n\nto 'fact' :n do 'to 'fact' n do factorial n. ^ fact n'\n\nto :e 'is-member-of' [] do F\nto :e 'is-member-of' :group\n do'if e = firstof group then T\n\t\t else e is-member-of rest of group'\n\nto 'cons' :x :y is self\nto 'hd' ('cons' :a :b) do 'a'\nto 'hd' ('cons' :a :b) '<-' :c do 'a <- c'\nto 'tl' ('cons' :a :b) do 'b'\nto 'tl' ('cons' :a :b) '<-' :c do 'b <- c'\n\nto :robot 'pickup' :block\n do 'robot clear-top-of block.\n\t\t robot hand move-to block.\n\t\t robot hand lift block 50.\n\t\t to 'height-of' block do 50'\n",{"_33":4995,"_35":4996},[],{"_37":199,"_39":4997,"_41":862,"_43":4998,"_67":4999,"_69":5006,"_71":70},"mCSng0Ll",{},[5000],{"_37":3795,"_233":5001,"_238":5003,"_43":5005,"_71":70},[5002],583,[5004],587,{},"This Smalltalk language (today labeled -71) was very influenced by FLEX, PLANNER, LOGO, META II, and my own derivatives from them. It was a kind of parser with object-attachment that executed tokens directly. (I think the awkward quoting conventions come from META). I was less interested in programs as algebraic patterns than I was in a clear scheme that could handle a variety of styles of programming. The patterned front-end allowed simple extension, patterns as \"data\" to be retrieved, a simple way to attach behaviors to objects, and a rudimentary but clear expression of its eval in terms that I thought children could understand after a few years experience with simpler programming. Program storage was sorted into a discrimination net and evaluation was straightforward pattern-matching.",{"_33":5008,"_35":5009},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5010,"_41":862,"_43":5011,"_67":5012,"_69":5022,"_71":70},"FxAtDSpn",{},[5013],{"_37":3795,"_233":5014,"_238":5018,"_43":5021,"_71":70},[5015,5016,5017],266,585,597,[4808,5019,5020],589,613,{},"As I mentioned previously, it was annoying that the surface beauty of LISP was marred by some of its key parts having to be introduced as \"special forms\" rather than as its supposed universal building block of functions. The actual beauty of LISP came more from the promise of its metastructures than its actual model. I spent a fair amount of time thinking about how objects could be characterized as universal computers without having to have any exceptions in the central metaphor. What seemed to be needed was complete control over what was passed in a message send; in particular when and in what environment did expressions get evaluated?",{"_33":5024,"_35":5025},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5026,"_41":862,"_43":5027,"_67":5028,"_69":5029,"_71":70},"2Eq7DNHp",{},[],"An elegant approach was suggested in a CMU thesis of Dave Fisher [Fisher 70] on the synthesis of control structures. ALGOL60 required a separate link for dynamic subroutine linking and for access to static global state. Fisher showed how a generalization of these links could be used to simulate a wide variety of control environments. One of the ways to solve the \"funarg problem\" of LISP is to associate the proper global state link with expressions and functions that are to be evaluated later so that the free variables referenced are the ones that were actually implied by the static form of the language. The notion of \"lazy evaluation\" is anticipated here as well.",{"_33":5031,"_35":5032},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5033,"_41":862,"_43":5034,"_67":5035,"_69":5040,"_71":70},"dEJQf255",{},[5036],{"_37":3795,"_233":5037,"_238":5038,"_43":5039,"_71":70},[4197],[4839],{},"Nowadays this approach would be called reflective design. Putting it together with the FLEX models suggested that all that should be required for \"doing LISP right\" or \"doing OOP right\" would be to handle the mechanics of invocations between modules without having to worry about the details of the modules themselves. The difference between LISP and OOP (or any other system) would then be what the modules could contain. A universal module (object) reference —ala B5000 and LISP—and a message holding structure—which could be virtual if the senders and receivers were sympatico— that could be used by all would do the job.",{"_33":5042,"_35":5043},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5044,"_41":862,"_43":5045,"_67":5046,"_69":5047,"_71":70},"yuzqtUtB",{},[],"If all of the fields of a messenger structure were enumerated according to this view, we would have:",{"_33":5049,"_35":5050},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5051,"_41":862,"_43":5052,"_67":5053,"_69":5069,"_71":70},"Z7oCIBqY",{},[5054],{"_37":3795,"_233":5055,"_238":5061,"_43":5068,"_71":70},[931,4131,5056,5057,5058,5059,5060],87,126,149,178,221,[4098,5062,5063,5064,5065,5066,5067],78,114,142,172,202,245,{},"GLOBAL:the environment of the parameter valuesSENDER:the sender of the messageRECEIVER:the receiver of the messageREPLY-STYLE:wait, fork, ...?STATUS:progress of the messageREPLY:eventual result (if any)OPERATION SELECTOR:relative to the receiver# OF PARAMETERS:P1:...:Pn:",{"_33":5071,"_35":5072},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5073,"_41":862,"_43":5074,"_67":5075,"_69":5076,"_71":70},"Y89Zxdhv",{},[],"This is a generalization of a stack frame, such as used by the B5000, and very similar to what a good intermodule scheme would require in an operating system such as CAL-TSS—a lot of state for every transaction, but useful to think about.",{"_33":5078,"_35":5079},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5080,"_41":862,"_43":5081,"_67":5082,"_69":5083,"_71":70},"peWwp6Vj",{},[],"Much of the pondering during this state of grace (before any workable implementation) had to do with trying to understand what \"beautiful\" might mean with reference to object-oriented design. A subjective definition of a beautiful thing is fairly easy but is not of much help: we think a thing beautiful because it evokes certain emotions. The cliche has it lie \"in the eye of the beholder\" so that it is difficult to think of beauty as other than a relation between subject and object in which the predispositions of the subject are all important.",{"_33":5085,"_35":5086},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5087,"_41":862,"_43":5088,"_67":5089,"_69":5090,"_71":70},"kT5STegr",{},[],"If there are such a thing as universally appealing forms then we can perhaps look to our shared biological heritage for the predispositions. But, for an object like LISP, it is almost certain that most of the basis of our judgment is learned and has much to do with other related areas that we think are beautiful, such as much of mathematics.",{"_33":5092,"_35":5093},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5094,"_41":862,"_43":5095,"_67":5096,"_69":5097,"_71":70},"X3FS3FFV",{},[],"One part of the perceived beauty of mathematics has to do with a wondrous synergy between parsimony, generality, enlightenment, and finesse. For example, the Pythagorean Theorem is expressible in a single line, is true for all of the infinite number of right triangles, is incredibly useful in understanding many other relationships, and can be shown by a few simple but profound steps.",{"_33":5099,"_35":5100},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5101,"_41":862,"_43":5102,"_67":5103,"_69":5104,"_71":70},"fu3PXO0X",{},[],"When we turn to the various languages for specifying computations we find many to be general and a few to be parsimonious. For example, we can define universal machine languages in just a few instructions that can specify anything that can be computed. But most of these we would not call beautiful, in part because the amount and kind of code that has to be written to do anything interesting is so contrived and turgid. A simple and small system that can do interesting things also needs a \"high slope\"—that is a good match between the degree of interestingness and the level of complexity needed to express it.",{"_33":5106,"_35":5107},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5108,"_41":862,"_43":5109,"_67":5110,"_69":5116,"_71":70},"x4WiqpIN",{},[5111],{"_37":4625,"_233":5112,"_238":5113,"_43":5115,"_71":70},[4812],[5114],282,{},"A fertilized egg that can transform itself into the myriad of specializations needed to make a complex organism has parsimony, generality, enlightenment, and finesse—in short, beauty, and a beauty much more in line with my own esthetics. I mean by this that Nature is wonderful both at elegance and practicality—the cell membrane is partly there to allow useful evolutionary kludges to do their necessary work and still be able act as component by presenting a uniform interface to the world.",{"_33":5118,"_35":5119},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5120,"_41":862,"_43":5121,"_67":5122,"_69":5129,"_71":70},"UpEC7QO4",{},[5123],{"_37":4625,"_233":5124,"_238":5126,"_43":5128,"_71":70},[5125],552,[5127],555,{},"One of my continual worries at this time was about the size of the bit-map display. Even if a mixed mode was used (between fine-grained generated characters and coarse-grained general bit-map for graphics) it would be hard to get enough information on the screen. It occurred to me (in a shower, my favorite place to think) that FLEXtype windows on a bit-map display could be made to appear as overlapping documents on a desktop. When an overlapped one was refreshed it would appear to come to the top of the stack. At the time, this did not appear as the wonderful solution to the problem but it did have the effect of magnifying the effective area of the display enormously, so I decided to go with it.",{"_33":5131,"_35":5132},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5133,"_41":862,"_43":5134,"_67":5135,"_69":5136,"_71":70},"iTYlUcIn",{},[],"To investigate the use of video as a display medium, Bill English and Butler Lampson specified an experimental character generator (built by Roger Bates) for the POLOS (PARC OnLine Office System) terminals. Gary Starkweather had just gotten the first laser printer to work and we ran a coax over to his lab to feed him some text to print. The \"SLOT machine\" (Scanning Laser Output Terminal) was incredible. The only Xerox copier Gary could get to work on went at 1 page a second and could not be slowed down. So Gary just made the laser run at that rate with a resolution of 500 pixels to the inch!",{"_33":5138,"_35":5139},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5140,"_41":862,"_43":5141,"_67":5142,"_69":5143,"_71":70},"ApIgh8Rv",{},[],"The character generator's font memory turned out to be large enough to simulate a bit-map display if one displayed a fixed \"strike\" and wrote into the font memory. Ben Laws built a beautiful font editor and he and I spent several months learning about the peculiarities of the human visual system (it is decidedly non-linear). I was very interested in high-quality text and graphical presentations because I thought it would be easier to get the Dynabook into schools as a \"trojan horse\" by simply replacing school books rather than to try to explain to teachers and school boards what was really great about personal computing.",{"_33":5145,"_35":5146},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5147,"_41":862,"_43":5148,"_67":5149,"_69":70,"_71":3579},"fHTRoOLR",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":5151,"_35":5152},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5153,"_41":862,"_43":5154,"_67":5155,"_69":5156,"_71":70},"15Mwm8Qb",{},[],"Things were generally going well all over the lab until May of 72 when I tried to get resources to build a few miniCOMs. A relatively new executive (\"X\") did not want to give them to me. I wrote a memo explaining why the system was a good idea (see Appendix II), and then had a meeting to discuss it. \"X\" shot it down completely saying among other things that we had used too many green stamps getting Xerox to fund the time-shared MAXC and this use of resources for personal machines would confuse them. I was shocked. I crawled away back to the experimental character generator and made a plan to get 4 more made and hooked to NOVAs for the initial kid experiments.",{"_33":5158,"_35":5159},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5160,"_41":862,"_43":5161,"_67":5162,"_69":5163,"_71":70},"t1mxtSr3",{},[],"I got Steve Purcell, a summer student from Stanford, to build my design for bit-map painting so the kids could sketch as well as display computer graphics. John Shoch built a line drawing and gesture recognition system (based on Ledeen's [Newman and Sproull 72]) that was integrated with the painting. Bill Duvall of POLOS built a miniNLS that was quite remarkable in its speed and power. The first overlapping windows started to appear. Bob Shur (with Steve Purcell's help) built a 2½D animation system. Along with Ben Laws' font editor, we could give quite a smashing demo of what we intended to build for real over the next few years. I remember giving one of these to a Xerox executive, including doing a portrait of him in the new painting system, and wound it up with a flourish declaring: \"And what's really great about this is that it only has a 20% chance of success. We're taking risk just like you asked us to!\" He looked me straight in the eye and said, \"Boy, that's great, but just make sure it works.\" This was a typical executive notion about risk. He wanted us to be in the \"20%\" one hundred percent of the time.",{"_33":5165,"_35":5166},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5167,"_41":862,"_43":5168,"_67":5169,"_69":70,"_71":3572},"js3gee33",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":5171,"_35":5172},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5173,"_41":862,"_43":5174,"_67":5175,"_69":5176,"_71":70},"HvVLQDfJ",{},[],"That summer while licking my wounds and getting the demo simulations built and going, Butler Lampson, Peter Deutsch, and I worked out a general scheme for emulated HLL machine languages. I liked the B5000 scheme, but Butler did not want to have to decode bytes, and pointed out that since an 8-bit byte had 256 total possibilities, what we should do is map different meanings onto different parts of the \"instruction space.\" This would give us a \"poor man's Huffman code\" that would be both flexible and simple. All subsequent emulators at PARC used this general scheme.",{"_33":5178,"_35":5179},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5180,"_41":862,"_43":5181,"_67":5182,"_69":5183,"_71":70},"cMja6Htb",{},[],"I also took another pass at the language for the kids. Jeff Rulifson was a big fan of Piaget (and semiotics) and we had many discussions about the \"stages\" and what iconic thinking might be about. After reading Piaget and especially Jerome Bruner, I was worried that the directly symbolic approach taken by FLEX, LOGO (and the current Smalltalk) would be difficult for the kids to process since evidence existed that the symbolic stage (or mentality) was just starting to switch on. In fact, all of the educators that I admired (including Montessori, Holt, and Suzuki) all seemed to call for a more figurative, more iconic approach. Rudolph Arnheim [Arnheim 69] had written a classic book about visual thinking, and so had the eminent art critic Gombrich [Gombrich **]. It really seemed that something better needed to be done here. GRAIL wasn't it, because its use of imagery was to portray and edit flowcharts, which seemed like a great step backwards. But Rovner's AMBIT-G held considerably more promise [Rovner 68]. It was kind of a visual SNOBOL [Farber 63] and the pattern matching ideas looked like they would work for the more PLANNERlike scheme I was using.",{"_33":5185,"_35":5186},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5187,"_41":862,"_43":5188,"_67":5189,"_69":5195,"_71":70},"Aw7J8ZCL",{},[5190],{"_37":3795,"_233":5191,"_238":5192,"_43":5194,"_71":70},[4812],[5193],281,{},"Bill English was still encouraging me to do more reasonable appearing things to get higher credibility, like making budgets, writing plans and milestone notes, so I wrote a plan that proposed over the next few years that we would build a real system on the character generators cum NOVAs that would involve OOP, windows, painting, music, animation, and \"iconic programming.\" The latter was deemed to be hard and would be handled by the usual method for hard problems, namely, give them to grad students.",{"_33":5197,"_35":5198},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5199,"_41":862,"_43":5200,"_67":5201,"_69":70,"_71":3686},"yWCP_VSt",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":5203,"_35":5204},[],{"_37":190,"_39":5205,"_41":862,"_43":5206,"_67":5207,"_69":5208,"_71":70},"kAgeLk34",{},[],"IV. 1972-76—The first real Smalltalk (-72), its birth, applications, and improvements",{"_33":5210,"_35":5211},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5212,"_41":862,"_43":5213,"_67":5214,"_69":5215,"_71":70},"3oMqJEjI",{},[],"In Sept, within a few weeks of each other, two bets happened that changed most of my plans. First, Butler and Chuck came over and asked: \"Do you have any money?\" I said, \"Yes, about $230K for NOVAs and CGs. Why?\" They said, \"How would you like us to build your little machine for you?\" I said, \"I'd like it fine. What is it?\" Butler said: \"I want a '$500 PDP-10', Chuck wants a '10 times faster NOVA', and you want a 'kiddicomp'. What do you need on it?\" I told them most of the results we had gotten from the fonts, painting, resolution, animation, and music studies. I asked where this had come from all of a sudden and Butler told me that they wanted to do it anyway, that Executive \"X\" was away for a few months on a \"task force\" so maybe they could \"Sneak it in\", and that Chuck had a bet with Bill Vitic that he could do a whole machine in just 3 months. \"Oh,\" I said.",{"_33":5217,"_35":5218},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5219,"_41":862,"_43":5220,"_67":5221,"_69":5222,"_71":70},"WPzIOyVs",{},[],"The second bet had even more surprising results. I had expected that the new Smalltalk would be an iconic language and would take at least two years to invent, but fate intervened. One day, in a typical PARC hallway bullsession, Ted Kaehler, Dan Ingalls, and I were standing around talking about programming languages. The subject of power came up and the two of them wondered how large a language one would have to make to get great power. With as much panache as I could muster, I asserted that you could define the \"most powerful language in the world\" in \"a page of code.\" They said, \"Put up or shut up.\"",{"_33":5224,"_35":5225},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5226,"_41":862,"_43":5227,"_67":5228,"_69":5229,"_71":70},"YacvYndI",{},[],"Ted went back to CMU but Dan was still around egging me on. For the next two weeks I got to PARC every morning at four o'clock and worked on the problem until eight, when Dan, joined by Henry Fuchs, John Shoch, and Steve Purcell showed up to kibbitz the morning's work.",{"_33":5231,"_35":5232},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5233,"_41":862,"_43":5234,"_67":5235,"_69":5243,"_71":70},"sFg9rsBf",{},[5236],{"_37":3795,"_233":5237,"_238":5240,"_43":5242,"_71":70},[5238,5239],279,331,[4478,5241],335,{},"I had originally made the boast because McCarthy's self-describing LISP interpreter was written in itself. It was about \"a page\", and as far as power goes, LISP was the whole nine-yards for functional languages. I was quite sure I could do the same for object-oriented languages plus be able to do a reasonable syntax for the code a la some of the FLEX machine techniques.",{"_33":5245,"_35":5246},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5247,"_41":862,"_43":5248,"_67":5249,"_69":5256,"_71":70},"kyqeyAjq",{},[5250],{"_37":3795,"_233":5251,"_238":5252,"_43":5255,"_71":70},[4618,4943],[5253,5254],596,608,{},"It turned out to be more difficult than I had first thought for three reasons. First, I wanted the program to be more like McCarthy's second non-recursive interpreter—the one implemented as a loop that tried to resemble the original 709 implementation of Steve Russell as much as possible. It was more \"real\". Second, the intertwining of the \"parsing\" with message receipt—the evaluation of parameters which was handled separately in LISP—required that my object-oriented interpreter re-enter itself \"sooner\" (in fact, much sooner) than LISP required. And, finally, I was still not clear how send and receive should work with each other.",{"_33":5258,"_35":5259},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5260,"_41":862,"_43":5261,"_67":5262,"_69":5263,"_71":70},"k66dCW6A",{},[],"The first few versions had flaws that were soundly criticized by the group. But by morning 8 or so, a version appeared that seemed to work (see Appendix III for a sketch of how the interpreter was designed). The major differences from the official Smalltalk-72 of a little bit later were that in the first version symbols were byte-coded and the receiving of return-values from a send was symmetric—i.e. receipt could be like parameter binding—this was particular useful for the return of multiple values. For various reasons, this was abandoned in favor of a more expression-oriented functional return style.",{"_33":5265,"_35":5266},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5267,"_41":862,"_43":5268,"_67":5269,"_69":5274,"_71":70},"bFfv8_4h",{},[5270],{"_37":4625,"_233":5271,"_238":5272,"_43":5273,"_71":70},[241],[5241],{},"Of course, I had gone to considerable pains to avoid doing any \"real work\" for the bet, but I felt I had proved my point. This had been an interesting holiday from our official \"iconic programming\" pursuits, and I thought that would be the end of it. Much to my surprise, only a few days later, Dan Ingalls showed me the scheme working on the NOVA. He had coded it up (in BASIC!), added a lot of details, such as a token scanner, a list maker, etc., and there it was—running. As he liked to say: \"You just do it and it's done.\"",{"_33":5276,"_35":5277},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5278,"_41":862,"_43":5279,"_67":5280,"_69":5292,"_71":70},"4Yc5SXzZ",{},[5281,5286],{"_37":3795,"_233":5282,"_238":5283,"_43":5285,"_71":70},[3851],[5284],16,{},{"_37":4625,"_233":5287,"_238":5289,"_43":5291,"_71":70},[5288],17,[5290],37,{},"It evaluated 3+4 v e r y s l o w l y (it was \"glacial\", as Butler liked to say) but the answer always came out 7. Well, there was nothing to do but keep going. Dan loved to bootstrap on a system that \"always ran,\" and over the next ten years he made at least 80 major releases of various flavors of Smalltalk.",{"_33":5294,"_35":5295},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5296,"_41":862,"_43":5297,"_67":5298,"_69":5299,"_71":70},"dXZt94iY",{},[],"In November, I presented these ideas and a demonstration of the interpretation scheme to the MIT AI lab. This eventually led to Carl Hewitt's more formal \"Actor\" approach [Hewitt 73]. In the first Actor paper the resemblance to Smalltalk is at its closest. The paths later diverged, partly because we were much more interested in making things than theorizing, and partly because we had something no one else had: Chuck Thacker's Interim Dynabook (later known as the \"ALTO\").",{"_33":5301,"_35":5302},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5303,"_41":862,"_43":5304,"_67":5305,"_69":5311,"_71":70},"f8nHtQpg",{},[5306],{"_37":3795,"_233":5307,"_238":5308,"_43":5310,"_71":70},[5239],[5309],344,{},"Just before Chuck started work on the machine I gave a paper to the National Council of Teachers of English [Kay 72c] on the Dynabook and its potential as a learning and thinking amplifier—the paper was an extensive rotogravure of \"20 things to do with a Dynabook\" [Kay 72c]. By the time I got back from Minnesota, Stewart Brand's Rolling Stone article about PARC [Brand 1972] and the surrounding hacker community had hit the stands. To our enormous surprise it caused a major furor at Xerox headquarters in Stamford, Connecticut. Though it was a wonderful article that really caught the spirit of the whole culture, Xerox went berserk, forced us to wear badges (over the years many were printed on t-shirts), and severely restricted the kinds of publications that could be made. This was particularly disastrous for LRG, since we were the \"lunatic fringe\" (so-called by the other computer scientists), were planning to go out to the schools, and needed to share our ideas (and programs) with our colleagues such as Seymour Papert and Don Norman.",{"_33":5313,"_35":5314},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5315,"_41":862,"_43":5316,"_67":5317,"_69":5318,"_71":70},"cCmAi7o2",{},[],"Executive \"X\" apparently heard some harsh words at Stamford about us, because when he returned around Christmas and found out about the interim Dynabook, he got even more angry and tried to kill it. Butler wound up writing a masterful defense of the machine to hold him off, and he went back to his \"task force.\"",{"_33":5320,"_35":5321},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5322,"_41":862,"_43":5323,"_67":5324,"_69":70,"_71":3741},"vGtBRMBM",{"_194":195,"_3508":3739},[],{"_33":5326,"_35":5327},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5328,"_41":862,"_43":5329,"_67":5330,"_69":5331,"_71":70},"rV-dxiXQ",{},[],"Chuck had started his \"bet\" on November 22, 1972. He and two technicians did all of the machine except for the disk interface which was done by Ed McCreight. It had a ~500,000 pixel (606x808) bitmap display, its microcode instruction rate was about 6 MIPS, it had a grand total of 128k, and the entire machine (exclusive of the memory) was rendered in 160 MSI chips distributed on two cards. It was beautiful [Thacker 1972, 1986]. One of the wonderful features of the machine was \"zero-over-head\" tasking. It had 16 program counters, one for each task. Condition flags were tied to interesting events (such as \"horizontal retrace pulse\", and \"disk sector pulse\", etc.). Lookaside logic scanned the flags while the current instruction was executing and picked the highest priority program counter to fetch from next. The machine never had to wait, and the result was that most hardware functions (particularly those that involved i/o (like feeding the display and handling the disk) could be replaced by microcode. Even the refresh of the MOS dynamic RAM was done by a task. In other words, this was a coroutine architecture. Chuck claimed that he got the idea from a lecture I had given on coroutines a few months before, but I remembered that Wes Clark's TX-2 (the Sketchpad machine) had used the idea first, and I probably mentioned that in the talk.",{"_33":5333,"_35":5334},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5335,"_41":862,"_43":5336,"_67":5337,"_69":5338,"_71":70},"cwowb-nX",{},[],"In early April, just a little over three months from the start, the first Interim Dynabook, known as 'Bilbo,' greeted the world and we had the first bit-map picture on the screen within minutes: the Muppets' Cookie Monster that I had sketched on our painting system.",{"_33":5340,"_35":5402},[5341,5348,5359,5371,5384,5395],{"_33":5342,"_35":5343},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5344,"_41":862,"_43":5345,"_67":5346,"_69":5347,"_71":70},"5AIibaUq",{},[],"Everything is an object",{"_33":5349,"_35":5350},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5351,"_41":862,"_43":5352,"_67":5353,"_69":5358,"_71":70},"QykUhXpb",{},[5354],{"_37":3795,"_233":5355,"_238":5356,"_43":5357,"_71":70},[4169],[4131],{},"Objects communicate by sending and receiving messages (in terms of objects)",{"_33":5360,"_35":5361},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5362,"_41":862,"_43":5363,"_67":5364,"_69":5370,"_71":70},"YQqqeiME",{},[5365],{"_37":3795,"_233":5366,"_238":5368,"_43":5369,"_71":70},[5367],19,[4157],{},"Objects have their own memory (in terms of objects)",{"_33":5372,"_35":5373},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5374,"_41":862,"_43":5375,"_67":5376,"_69":5383,"_71":70},"lGs2lSW4",{},[5377],{"_37":3795,"_233":5378,"_238":5380,"_43":5382,"_71":70},[5379],33,[5381],38,{},"Every object is an instance of a class (which must be an object)",{"_33":5385,"_35":5386},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5387,"_41":862,"_43":5388,"_67":5389,"_69":5394,"_71":70},"bH5cWbXb",{},[5390],{"_37":3795,"_233":5391,"_238":5392,"_43":5393,"_71":70},[3802],[4797],{},"The class holds the shared behavior for its instances (in the form of objects in a program list)",{"_33":5396,"_35":5397},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5398,"_41":862,"_43":5399,"_67":5400,"_69":5401,"_71":70},"cQcj_XUF",{},[],"To eval a program list, control is passed to the first object and the remainder is treated as its message",{"_37":199,"_39":5403,"_41":862,"_43":5404,"_67":5406,"_69":5414,"_71":70},"QjItcppp",{"_194":5405},"Ordered",[5407],{"_37":4625,"_233":5408,"_238":5411,"_43":5413,"_71":70},[5409,5410],523,547,[4582,5412],558,{},"Soon Dan had bootstrapped Smalltalk across, and for many months it was the sole software system to run on the Interim Dynabook. Appendix I has an \"acknowledgements\" document I wrote from this time that is interesting in its allocation of credits and the various priorities associated with them. My $230K was enough to get 15 of the original projected 30 machines (over the years some 2000 Interim Dynabooks were actually built). True to Schopenhauer's observation, Executive \"X\" now decided that the Interim Dynabook was a good idea and he wanted all but two for his lab (I was in the other lab). I had to go to considerable lengths to get our machines back, but finally succeeded.",{"_33":5416,"_35":5417},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5418,"_41":862,"_43":5419,"_67":5420,"_69":5427,"_71":70},"T0iO_d8Y",{},[5421],{"_37":4656,"_233":5422,"_238":5424,"_43":5426,"_71":70},[5423],654,[5425],662,{},"By this time most of Smalltalk's schemes had been sorted out into six main ideas that were in accord with the initial premises in designing the interpreter. The first three principles are what objects \"are about\"—how they are seen and used from \"the outside.\" These did not require any modification over the years. The last three—objects from the inside—were tinkered with in every version of Smalltalk (and in subsequent OOP designs). In this scheme (1 & 4) imply that classes are objects and that they must be instances of themself. (6) implies a LISPlike universal syntax, but with the receiving object as the first item followed by the message. Thus ci <- de (with subscripting rendered as \"○\" and multiplication as \"*\") means:",{"_33":5429,"_35":5430},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5431,"_41":862,"_43":5432,"_67":5433,"_69":5442,"_71":70},"q8EF7VYV",{},[5434,5438],{"_37":4625,"_233":5435,"_238":5436,"_43":5437,"_71":70},[139],[5288],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":5439,"_238":5440,"_43":5441,"_71":70},[5288],[4183],{},"receiver| messagec| ○ i <- d*e",{"_33":5444,"_35":5445},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5446,"_41":862,"_43":5447,"_67":5448,"_69":5462,"_71":70},"ZPqaI8KO",{},[5449,5453],{"_37":4625,"_233":5450,"_238":5451,"_43":5452,"_71":70},[4096],[4171],{},{"_37":4656,"_233":5454,"_238":5457,"_43":5461,"_71":70},[3798,5455,5456,4964],384,390,[3910,5458,5459,5460],388,394,411,{},"The c is bound to the receiving object, and all of ○ i <- d*e is the message to it. The message is made up of literal token \"○\", an expression to be evaluated in the sender's context (in this case i), another literal token <-, followed by an expression to be evaluated in the sender's context (d*e). Since \"LISP\" pairs are made from 2 element objects they can be indexed more simply: c hd, c tl, and c hd <- foo, etc.",{"_33":5464,"_35":5465},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5466,"_41":862,"_43":5467,"_67":5468,"_69":5473,"_71":70},"gLVGEYvG",{},[5469],{"_37":3795,"_233":5470,"_238":5471,"_43":5472,"_71":70},[3973,4580],[4157,5290],{},"\"Simple\" expressions like a+b and 3+4 seemed more troublesome at first. Did it really make sense to think of them as:",{"_33":5475,"_35":5476},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5477,"_41":862,"_43":5478,"_67":5479,"_69":5488,"_71":70},"NBOUUD-R",{},[5480,5484],{"_37":4625,"_233":5481,"_238":5482,"_43":5483,"_71":70},[139],[5288],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":5485,"_238":5486,"_43":5487,"_71":70},[5288],[4157],{},"receiver| messagea| + b3| + 4",{"_33":5490,"_35":5491},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5492,"_41":862,"_43":5493,"_67":5494,"_69":5495,"_71":70},"RZwTAH2f",{},[],"It seemed silly if only integers were considered, but there are many other metaphoric readings of \"+\", such as:",{"_33":5497,"_35":5498},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5499,"_41":862,"_43":5500,"_67":5501,"_69":70,"_71":3633},"eeFcmCAM",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":5503,"_35":5504},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5505,"_41":862,"_43":5506,"_67":5507,"_69":5513,"_71":70},"-jzWWkAm",{},[5508],{"_37":3795,"_233":5509,"_238":5510,"_43":5512,"_71":70},[3778],[5511],48,{},"This led to a style of finding generic behaviors for message symbols. \"Polymorphism\" is the official term (I believe derived from Strachey), but it is not really apt as its original meaning applied only to functions that could take more than one type of argument. An example class of objects in Smalltalk-72, such as a model of CONS pairs, would look like:",{"_33":5515,"_35":5516},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5517,"_41":862,"_43":5518,"_67":5519,"_69":70,"_71":3748},"1bEkW2bD",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":5521,"_35":5522},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5523,"_41":862,"_43":5524,"_67":5525,"_69":5532,"_71":70},"mQuRpGhD",{},[5526],{"_37":4625,"_233":5527,"_238":5529,"_43":5531,"_71":70},[5528],110,[5530],113,{},"Since control is passed to the class before any of the rest of the message is considered—the class can decide not to receive at its discretion—complete protection is retained. Smalltalk-72 objects are \"shiny\" and impervious to attack. Part of the environment is the binding of the SENDER in the \"messenger object\" (a generalized activation record) which allows the receiver to determine differential privileges (see Appendix II for more details). This looked ahead to the eventual use of Smalltalk as a network OS (See [Goldstein & Bobrow 1980]), and I don't recall it being used very much in Smalltalk-72.",{"_33":5534,"_35":5535},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5536,"_41":862,"_43":5537,"_67":5538,"_69":5539,"_71":70},"zBQ54RLx",{},[],"One of the styles retained from Smalltalk-71 was the comingling of function and class ideas. In other works, Smalltalk-72 classes looked like and could be used as functions, but it was easy to produce an instance (a kind of closure) by using the object ISNEW. Thus factorial could be written \"extensionally\" as:",{"_33":5541,"_35":5542},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5543,"_41":862,"_43":5544,"_67":5545,"_69":5551,"_71":70},"7G2UmlRf",{},[5546],{"_37":3795,"_233":5547,"_238":5548,"_43":5550,"_71":70},[139],[5549],43,{},"to fact n (^if :n=0 then 1 else n*fact n-1)",{"_33":5553,"_35":5554},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5555,"_41":862,"_43":5556,"_67":5557,"_69":5558,"_71":70},"qXifT5qH",{},[],"or \"intensionally,\" as part of class integer:",{"_33":5560,"_35":5561},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5562,"_41":862,"_43":5563,"_67":5564,"_69":5569,"_71":70},"ithetzxK",{},[5565],{"_37":3795,"_233":5566,"_238":5567,"_43":5568,"_71":70},[139],[3778],{},"(... ○! » (^:n=1) » (1) (n-1)!)",{"_33":5571,"_35":5572},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5573,"_41":862,"_43":5574,"_67":5575,"_69":5581,"_71":70},"sN3_ZbW4",{},[5576],{"_37":3795,"_233":5577,"_238":5579,"_43":5580,"_71":70},[5578],84,[4688],{},"Of course, the whole idea of Smalltalk (and OOP in general) is to define everything intensionally. And this was the direction of movement as we learned how to program in the new style. I never liked this syntax (too many parentheses and nestings) and wanted something flatter and more grammar-like as in Smalltalk-71. To the right is an example syntax from the notes of a talk I gave around then. We will see something more like this a few years later in Dan's design for Smalltalk-76. I think something similar happened with LISP—that the \"reality\" of the straightforward and practical syntax you could program in prevailed against the flights of fancy that never quite got built.",{"_33":5583,"_35":5584},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5585,"_41":862,"_43":5586,"_67":5587,"_69":5588,"_71":70},"ayqFcBbL",{},[],"Proposed Smalltalk-72 Syntax",{"_33":5590,"_35":5591},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":5592,"_41":862,"_43":5593,"_67":5594,"_69":5595,"_71":70},"gEgZLCVr",{"_4659":70},[],"Pair :h :t\n hd <- :h\n hd » h\n tl <- :t\n tl » t\n isPair » true\n print » '( print. SELF mprint.\n mprint » h print. if t isNil then ') print\n else if t isPair then t mprint\n else '● print. t print. ') print\n length » 1 + if t isList then t length else 0\n",{"_33":5597,"_35":5598},[],{"_37":190,"_39":5599,"_41":862,"_43":5600,"_67":5601,"_69":5602,"_71":70},"OFAwUk4M",{},[],"Development of the Smalltalk-72 System and Applications",{"_33":5604,"_35":5605},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5606,"_41":862,"_43":5607,"_67":5608,"_69":70,"_71":3626},"yLm5EyQh",{"_194":195,"_3508":3624},[],{"_33":5610,"_35":5611},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5612,"_41":862,"_43":5613,"_67":5614,"_69":5615,"_71":70},"gk3jnuCb",{},[],"The advent of a real Smalltalk on a real machine started off an explosion of parallel paths that are too difficult to intertwine in strict historical order. Let me first present the general development of the Smalltalk-72 system up to the transition to Smalltalk-76, and then follow that with the several years of work with children that were the primary motivation for the project. The Smalltalk-72 interpreter on the Interim Dynabook was not exactly zippy (\"majestic\" was Butler's pronouncement), but was easy to change and quite fast enough for many real-time interactive systems to be built in it.",{"_33":5617,"_35":5618},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5619,"_41":862,"_43":5620,"_67":5621,"_69":5622,"_71":70},"r-WjUs6j",{},[],"Overlapping windows were the first project tackled (with Diana Merry) after writing the code to read the keyboard and create a string of text. Diana built an early version of a bit field block transfer (bitblt) for displaying variable pitch fonts and generally writing on the display. The first window versions were done as real 2½D draggable objects that were just a little too slow to be useful. We decided to wait until Steve Purcell got his animation system going to do it right, and opted for the style that is still in use today, which is more like \"2¼D\". Windows were perhaps the most redesigned and reimplemented class in Smalltalk because we didn't quite have enough compute power to just do the continual viewing to \"world coordinates\" and refreshing that my former Utah colleagues were starting to experiment with on the flight simulator projects at Evans & Sutherland. This is a simple, powerful model but it is difficult to do in real-time even in 2½D. The first practical windows in Smalltalk used the GRAIL conventions of sensitive corners for moving, resizing, cloning, and closing. Window scheduling used a simple \"loopless\" control scheme that threaded all of the windows together.",{"_33":5624,"_35":5625},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5626,"_41":862,"_43":5627,"_67":5628,"_69":5629,"_71":70},"EuFkCiRG",{},[],"One of the next classes to be implemented on the Interim Dynabook (after the basics of numbers, strings, etc.) was an object-oriented version of the LOGO turtle implemented by Ted. This could make many turtle instances that were used both for drawing and as a kind of value for graphics transformations. Dan created a class of \"commander\" turtles that could control a troop of turtles. Soon the turtles were made so they could be clipped by the windows.",{"_33":5631,"_35":5632},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5633,"_41":862,"_43":5634,"_67":5635,"_69":5636,"_71":70},"NV8ljXX_",{},[],"John Shoch built a mouse-driven structured editor for Smalltalk code.",{"_33":5638,"_35":5639},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5640,"_41":862,"_43":5641,"_67":5642,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"k8nopLnu",{},[],"\n",{"_33":5645,"_35":5646},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5647,"_41":862,"_43":5648,"_67":5649,"_69":70,"_71":3663},"2Q9o1rRU",{"_194":195,"_3508":3661},[],{"_33":5651,"_35":5652},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5653,"_41":862,"_43":5654,"_67":5655,"_69":5663,"_71":70},"JXswaj1l",{},[5656],{"_37":3795,"_233":5657,"_238":5660,"_43":5662,"_71":70},[5658,5659],263,514,[5661,5409],272,{},"Larry Tesler (then working for POLOS) did not like the modiness and general approach of NLS, and he wanted both to show the former NLSers an alternative and to conduct some user studies (almost unheard of in those days) about editing. This led to his programming miniMOUSE in Smalltalk, the first real WYSIWYG galley editor at PARC. It was modeless (almost) and fun to use, not just for us but for the many people he tested it on (I ran the camera for the movies we took and remember their delight and enjoyment). miniMOUSE quickly became an alternate editor for Smalltalk code and some of the best demos we ever gave used it.",{"_33":5665,"_35":5666},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5667,"_41":862,"_43":5668,"_67":5669,"_69":5670,"_71":70},"bMvQ6UCc",{},[],"One of the \"small program\" projects I tried on an adult class in the Spring of '74 was a one-page paragraph editor. It turned out to be too complicated, but the example I did to show them was completely modeless (it was in the air) and became the basis for much of the Smalltalk text work over the next few years. Most of the improvements were made by Dan and Diana Merry. Of course, objects mean multi-media documents, you almost get them for free. Early on we realized that in such a document, each component object should handle its own editing chores. Steve Weyer built some of the earliest multi-media documents, whose range was greatly and variously expanded over the years by Bob Flegal, Diana Merry, Larry Tesler, Tim Mott, and Trygve Reenskaug.",{"_33":5672,"_35":5673},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5674,"_41":862,"_43":5675,"_67":5676,"_69":5681,"_71":70},"KFagw-qN",{},[5677],{"_37":3795,"_233":5678,"_238":5679,"_43":5680,"_71":70},[3973],[4185],{},"Steve Weyer and I devised Findit, a \"retrieval by example\" interface that used the analogy of classes to their instances to form retrieval requests. This was used for many years by the PARC library to control circulation.",{"_33":5683,"_35":5684},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5685,"_41":862,"_43":5686,"_67":5687,"_69":5694,"_71":70},"ilJ4DU-9",{},[5688],{"_37":4625,"_233":5689,"_238":5691,"_43":5693,"_71":70},[5690],892,[5692],896,{},"The sampling synthesis music I had developed on the NOVA could generate 3 high-quality real-time voices. Bob Shur and Chuck Thacker transferred the scheme to the Interim Dynabook and achieved 12 voices in real-time. The 256 bit generalized input that we had specified for low speed devices (used for the mouse and keyboard) made it easy to connect 154 more to wire up two organ keyboards and a pedal. Effects such as portamento and decay were programmed. Ted Kaehler wrote TWANG, a music capture and editing system, using a tablature notation that we devised to make music clear to children [Kay 1977a]. One of the things that was hard to do with sampling was the voltage controlled oscillator (VCO) effects that were popular on the \"Well Tempered Synthesizer.\" A summer later, Steve Saunders, another of our bright summer students, was challenged to find a way to accomplish John Chowning's very non-real-time FM synthesis in real-time on the ID. He had to find a completely different way to think of it than \"FM\", and succeeded brilliantly with 8 real-time voices that were integrated into TWANG [Saunders *].",{"_33":5696,"_35":5697},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5698,"_41":862,"_43":5699,"_67":5700,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"G07WUZ0k",{},[],{"_33":5702,"_35":5703},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5704,"_41":862,"_43":5705,"_67":5706,"_69":70,"_71":3679},"8bXN6yrX",{"_194":195,"_3508":3677},[],{"_33":5708,"_35":5709},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5710,"_41":862,"_43":5711,"_67":5712,"_69":5713,"_71":70},"PDYfQ382",{},[],"Chris Jeffers (who was a musician and educator, not a computer scientist) knocked us out with OPUS, the first real-time score capturing system. Unlike most systems today it did not require metronomic playing but instead took a first pass looking for strong and weak beats (the phrasing) to establish a local model of the likely tempo fluctuations and then used curve fitting and extrapolation to make judgments about just where in the measure, and for what time value, a given note had been struck.",{"_33":5715,"_35":5716},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5717,"_41":862,"_43":5718,"_67":5719,"_69":5725,"_71":70},"5tyjKc41",{},[5720],{"_37":3795,"_233":5721,"_238":5722,"_43":5724,"_71":70},[235],[5723],98,{},"The animations on the NOVA ran 3-5 objects at about 2-3 frames per second. Fast enough for the phi phenomenon to work (if double buffering was used), but we wanted \"Disney rates\" of 10-15 frames a second for 10 or more large objects and many more smaller ones. This task was put into the ingenious hands of Steve Purcell. By the fall of '73 he could demo 80 ping-pong balls and 10 flying horses running at 10 frames per second in 2½D. His next task was to make the demo into a general systems facility from which we could construct animation systems. His CHAOS system started working in May '74, just in time for summer visitors Ron Baecker, Tom Horseeley, and professional animator Eric Martin to visit and build SHAZAM a marvelously capable and simple animation system based on Ron's GENESYS thesis project on the TX-2 in the late sixties [Baecker 69].",{"_33":5727,"_35":5728},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5729,"_41":862,"_43":5730,"_67":5731,"_69":5732,"_71":70},"6R-LpYAT",{},[],"The main thesis project during this time was Dave Smith's PYGMALION [Smith 75], an essay into iconic programming (no, we hadn't quite forgotten). One programmed by showing the system how changes should be made, much as one would illustrate on a blackboard with another programmer. This program became the starting place from which many subsequent \"programming by example\" systems took off.",{"_33":5734,"_35":5735},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5736,"_41":862,"_43":5737,"_67":5738,"_69":5739,"_71":70},"-i56yD5b",{},[],"I should say something about the size of these programs. PYGMALION was the largest program ever written in Smalltalk-72. It was about 20 pages of code—all that would fit in the interim dynabook ALTO—and is given in full in Smith's thesis. All of the other applications were smaller. For example, the SHAZAM animation system was written and revised several times in the summer of 1974, and finally wound up as a 5-6 page application which included its icon-controlled multiwindowed user interface.",{"_33":5741,"_35":5742},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5743,"_41":862,"_43":5744,"_67":5745,"_69":5746,"_71":70},"nUWCMiKS",{},[],"Given its roots in simulation languages, it was easy to write in a few pages, Simpula, a simple version of the SIMULA sequencing set approach to scheduling. By this time we had decided that coroutines could be rendered more cleanly by scheduling individual methods as separate simulation phases. The generic SIMULA example was a job shop. This could be generalized into many useful forms such as a hospital with departments of resources serving patients (see to the right). The children did not care for hospitals but saw that they could model amusement parks, like Disneyland, their schools, the stores they and their parents shopped in, and so forth. Later this model formed the basis of the Smalltalk Sim-kit, a high-level end-user programming environment (described ahead).",{"_33":5748,"_35":5749},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5750,"_41":862,"_43":5751,"_67":5752,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"sH987ACs",{},[],{"_33":5754,"_35":5755},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":5756,"_41":862,"_43":5757,"_67":5758,"_69":5759,"_71":70},"0_kcdi4J",{"_4659":70},[],"(until Return or Delete do\n ('character <- display <- keyboard.\n character = ret » (Return)\n character = del » (Delete)\n )\nthen case\n Return: ('deal with this normal exit')\n Delete: ('handle the abnormal exit'))\n",{"_33":5761,"_35":5762},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5763,"_41":862,"_43":5764,"_67":5765,"_69":5771,"_71":70},"9ayTPUFT",{},[5766],{"_37":3795,"_233":5767,"_238":5769,"_43":5770,"_71":70},[5768],311,[241],{},"Many nice \"computer sciency\" constructs were easy to make in Smalltalk-72. For example, one of the controversies of the day was whether to have gotos or not (we didn't), and if not, how could certain very useful control structures—such as multiple exits from a loop—be specified? Chuck Zahn at SLAC proposed an event-driven case structure in which a set of events could be defined so that when an event is encountered, the loop will be exited and the event will select a statement in a case block [Zahn 1974, Knuth 1974]. Suppose we want to write a simple loop that reads characters from the keyboard and outputs them to a display. We want it to exit normally when the key is struck and with an error if the key is hit. Appendix IV shows how John Shoch defined this control structure.",{"_33":5773,"_35":5774},[],{"_37":190,"_39":5775,"_41":862,"_43":5776,"_67":5777,"_69":5778,"_71":70},"auMjDAkv",{},[],"The Evolution of Smalltalk-72",{"_33":5780,"_35":5781},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5782,"_41":862,"_43":5783,"_67":5784,"_69":5785,"_71":70},"xEH9I7uy",{},[],"Smalltalk-74 (sometimes known as FastTalk) was a version of Smalltalk-72 incorporating major improvements which included providing a real \"messenger\" object, message dictionaries for classes (a step towards real class objects), Diana Merry's bitblt (the now famous 2D graphics operator for bitmap graphics) redesigned by Dan and implemented in microcode, and a better, more general window interface. Dave Robson while a student at UC Irvine had heard of our project and made a pretty good stab at implementing an OOPL. We invited him for a summer and never let him go back—he was a great help in formulating an official semantics for Smalltalk.",{"_33":5787,"_35":5788},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5789,"_41":862,"_43":5790,"_67":5791,"_69":5792,"_71":70},"LeOBm80o",{},[],"The crowning addition was the OOZE (Object Oriented Zoned Environment) virtual memory system that served Smalltalk-74, and more importantly, Smalltalk-76 [Ing 78, Kae *]. The ALTO was not very large (128-256K), especially with its page-sized display (64k), and even with small programs, we soon ran out of storage. The 2.4 megabyte model 30 disk drive was faster and larger than a floppy and slower and smaller than today's hard drives. It was quite similar to the HP direct contact disk of the FLEX machine on which I had tried a fine-grain version of the B5000 segment swapper. It had not worked as well as I wanted, despite a few good ideas as to how to choose objects when purging. When the gang wanted to adopt this basic scheme, I said: \"But I never got it to work well.\" I remember Ted Kaehler saying, \"Don't worry, we'll make it work!\"",{"_33":5794,"_35":5795},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5796,"_41":862,"_43":5797,"_67":5798,"_69":5799,"_71":70},"ZohdisUq",{},[],"The basic idea in all of these systems is to be able to gather the most comprehensive possible working set of objects. This is most easily accomplished by swapping individual objects. Now the problem becomes the overhead of purging non-working set objects to make room for the ones that are needed. (Paging sometimes works better for this part because you can get more than one object (OOZE) in each disk touch.) Two ideas help a lot. First, Butler's insight in the GENIE OS that it was worthwhile to expend a small percentage of time purging dirty objects to make core as clean as possible [Lampson 1966]. Thus crashes tend not to hurt as much and there is always clean storage to fetch pages or objects from the disk into. The other is one from the FLEX system in which I set up a stochastic decision mechanism (based on the class of an object) that determined during a purge whether or not to throw an object out. This had two benefits: important objects tended not to go out, and a mistake would just bring it back in again with the distribution insuring a low probability that the object would be purged again soon.",{"_33":5801,"_35":5802},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5803,"_41":862,"_43":5804,"_67":5805,"_69":5814,"_71":70},"p9Tk59JR",{},[5806],{"_37":3795,"_233":5807,"_238":5810,"_43":5813,"_71":70},[5808,5127,5809],207,564,[5811,5812,4300],219,559,{},"The other problem that had to be taken care of was object-pointer integrity (and this is where I had failed in the FLEX machine to come up with a good enough solution). What was needed really was a complete transaction, a brand new technique (thought up by Butler?) that ensured recovery regardless of when the system crashed. This was called \"cosmic ray protection\" as the early ALTOS had a way of just crashing once or twice a day for no discernible good reason. This, by the way did not particularly bother anyone as it was fairly easy to come up with undo and replay mechanisms to get around the cosmic rays. For pointer-based systems that had automatic storage management, this was a bit more tricky.",{"_33":5816,"_35":5817},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5818,"_41":862,"_43":5819,"_67":5820,"_69":5821,"_71":70},"iWV3BFvp",{},[],"Ted and Dan decided to control storage using a Resident Object Table that was the only place machine addresses for objects would be found. Other useful information was stashed there as well to help LRU aging. Purging was done in background by picking a class, positioning the disk to its instances (all of a particular class were stored together), then running through the ROT to find the dirty ones in storage and stream them out. This was pretty efficient and, true to Butler's insight, furnished a good sized pool of clean storage that could be overwritten. The key to the design though (and the implementation of the transaction mechanism) was the checkpointing scheme they came up with. This insured that there was a recoverable image no more than a few seconds old, regardless of when a crash might occur. OOZE swapped objects in just 80kb of working storage and could handle about 65K objects (up to several megabytes worth, more than enough for the entire system, its interface, and its applications).",{"_33":5823,"_35":5824},[],{"_37":190,"_39":5825,"_41":862,"_43":5826,"_67":5827,"_69":5828,"_71":70},"fqcLCith",{},[],"\"Object-oriented\" Style",{"_33":5830,"_35":5831},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5832,"_41":862,"_43":5833,"_67":5834,"_69":5842,"_71":70},"UcIiY9n9",{},[5835],{"_37":3795,"_233":5836,"_238":5839,"_43":5841,"_71":70},[5837,5838],1021,1179,[4809,5840],1257,{},"This is probably a good place to comment on the difference between what we thought of as OOP-style and the superficial encapsulation called \"abstract data types\" that was just starting to be investigated in academic circles. Our early \"LISP-pair\" definition is an example of an abstract data type because it preserves the \"field access\" and \"field rebinding\" that is the hallmark of a data structure. Considerable work in the 60s was concerned with generalizing such structures [DSP *]. The \"official\" computer science world started to regard Simula as a possible vehicle for defining abstract data types (even by one of its inventors [Dahl 1970]), and it formed much of the later backbone of ADA. This led to the ubiquitous stack data-type example in hundreds of papers. To put it mildly, we were quite amazed at this, since to us, what Simula had whispered was something much stronger than simply reimplementing a weak and ad hoc idea. What I got from Simula was that you could now replace bindings and assignment with goals. The last thing you wanted any programmer to do is mess with internal state even if presented figuratively. Instead, the objects should be presented as sites of higher level behaviors more appropriate for use as dynamic components.",{"_33":5844,"_35":5845},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5846,"_41":862,"_43":5847,"_67":5848,"_69":5849,"_71":70},"52kOyPa_",{},[],"Even the way we taught children (cf. ahead) reflected this way of looking at objects. Not too surprisingly this approach has considerable bearing on the ease of programming, the size of the code needed, the integrity of the design, etc. It is unfortunate that much of what is called \"object-oriented programming\" today is simply old style programming with fancier constructs. Many programs are loaded with \"assignment-style\" operations now done by more expensive attached procedures.",{"_33":5851,"_35":5852},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5853,"_41":862,"_43":5854,"_67":5855,"_69":5856,"_71":70},"T-7wzXUD",{},[],"Where does the special efficiency of object-oriented design come from? This is a good question given that it can be viewed as a slightly different way to apply procedures to data-structures. Part of the effect comes from a much clearer way to represent a complex system. Here, the constraints are as useful as the generalities. Four techniques used together—persistent state, polymorphism, instantiation, and methods-as-goals for the object—account for much of the power. None of these require an \"object-oriented language\" to be employed—ALGOL 68 can almost be turned to this style—an OOPL merely focuses the designer's mind in a particular fruitful direction. However, doing encapsulation right is a commitment not just to abstraction of state, but to eliminate state oriented metaphors from programming.",{"_33":5858,"_35":5859},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5860,"_41":862,"_43":5861,"_67":5862,"_69":5863,"_71":70},"pTCNhYtA",{},[],"Perhaps the most important principle—again derived from operating system architectures—is that when you give someone a structure, rarely do you want them to have unlimited privileges with it. Just doing type-matching isn't even close to what's needed. Nor is it terribly useful to have some objects protected and others not. Make them all first class citizens and protect all.",{"_33":5865,"_35":5866},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5867,"_41":862,"_43":5868,"_67":5869,"_69":5870,"_71":70},"CnQ41sJA",{},[],"I believe that the much smaller size of a good OOP system comes not just by being gently forced to come up with a more thought out design. I think it also has to do with the \"bang per line of code\" you can get with OOP. The object carries with it a lot of significance and intention, its methods suggest the strongest kinds of goals it can carry out, its superclasses can add up to much more code-functionality being invoked than most procedures-on-data-structures. Assignment statements—even abstract ones—express very low-level goals, and more of them will be needed to get anything done. Generally, we don't want the programmer to be messing around with state, whether simulated or not. The ability to instantiate an object has a considerable effect on code size as well. Another way to think of all this is: though the late-binding of automatic storage allocations doesn't do anything a programmer can't do, its presence leads both to simpler and more powerful code. OOP is a late binding strategy for many things and all of them together hold off fragility and size explosion much longer than the older methodologies. In other words, human programmers aren't Turing machines—and the less their programming systems require Turing machine techniques the better.",{"_33":5872,"_35":5873},[],{"_37":190,"_39":5874,"_41":862,"_43":5875,"_67":5876,"_69":4026,"_71":70},"P5HtZlSZ",{},[],{"_33":5878,"_35":5879},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5880,"_41":862,"_43":5881,"_67":5882,"_69":70,"_71":3671},"3d1pjT0Y",{"_194":195,"_3508":3669},[],{"_33":5884,"_35":5885},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5886,"_41":862,"_43":5887,"_67":5888,"_69":5889,"_71":70},"YeODXiK3",{},[],"Now that I have summarized the \"adult\" activities (we were actually only semiadults) in Smalltalk up to 1976, let me return to the summer of '73, when we were ready to start experiments with children. None of us knew anything about working with children, but we knew that Adele Goldberg and Steve Weyer who were then with Pat Suppes at Stanford had done quite a bit and we were able to entice them to join us.",{"_33":5891,"_35":5892},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5893,"_41":862,"_43":5894,"_67":5895,"_69":5902,"_71":70},"oGLprZX4",{},[5896],{"_37":3795,"_233":5897,"_238":5899,"_43":5901,"_71":70},[5898],537,[5900],542,{},"Since we had no idea how to teach object-oriented programming to children (or anyone else), the first experiments Adele did mimicked LOGO turtle graphics, and she got what appeared to be very similar results. That is to say, the children could get the turtle to draw pictures on the screen, but there seemed to be little happening beyond surface effects. At that time I felt that since the content of personal computing was interactive tools, that the content of this new kind of authoring literacy should be the creation of interactive tools by the children. Procedural turtle graphics just wasn't it.",{"_33":5904,"_35":5905},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5906,"_41":862,"_43":5907,"_67":5908,"_69":5909,"_71":70},"lSKF5dSa",{},[],"Then Adele came up with a brilliant approach to teaching Smalltalk as an object-oriented language: the \"Joe Book.\" I believe this was partly influenced by Minsky's idea that you should teach a programming language holistically from working examples of serious programs.",{"_33":5911,"_35":5912},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5913,"_41":862,"_43":5914,"_67":5915,"_69":5916,"_71":70},"RKWWo85H",{},[],"Several instances of the class box are created and sent messages, culminating with a simple multiprocess animation. After getting kids to guess what a box might be like—they could come surprisingly close—they would be shown:",{"_33":5918,"_35":5919},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":5920,"_41":862,"_43":5921,"_67":5922,"_69":5923,"_71":70},"P94OV6uQ",{"_4659":70},[],"to box | x y size tilt\n(○draw » (@place x y turn tilt. square size.\n○undraw » (@ white. SELF draw. @black)\n○turn » (SELF undraw. 'tilt <- tilt + :. SELF draw)\n○grow » (SELF undraw. 'size <- size + :. SELF draw)\nISNEW » (SELF undraw. 'size <- size + :. SELF draw)",{"_33":5925,"_35":5926},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5927,"_41":862,"_43":5928,"_67":5929,"_69":5930,"_71":70},"jpLU-joj",{},[],"What was so wonderful about this idea were the myriad of children's projects that could spring off the humble boxes. And some of the earliest were tools! This was when we got really excited. For example, Marian Goldeen's (12 yrs old) painting system was a full-fledged tool. A few years later, so was Susan Hamet's (12 yrs old) OOP illustration system (with a design that was like the MacDraw to come). Two more were Bruce Horn's (15 yrs old) music score capture system and Steve Putz's (15 yrs old) circuit design system. Looking back, this could be called another example in computer science of the \"early success syndrome.\" The successes were real, but they weren't as general as we thought. They wouldn't extend into the future as strongly as we hoped. The children were chosen from the Palo Alto schools (hardly an average background) and we tended to be much more excited about the successes than the difficulties. In part, what we were seeing was the \"hacker phenomenon,\" that, for any given pursuit, a particular 5% of the population will jump into it naturally, while the 80% or so who can learn it in time do not find it at all natural.",{"_33":5932,"_35":5933},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5934,"_41":862,"_43":5935,"_67":5936,"_69":5943,"_71":70},"8WaaE3BI",{},[5937],{"_37":3795,"_233":5938,"_238":5940,"_43":5942,"_71":70},[5939],294,[5941],301,{},"We had a dim sense of this, but we kept on having relative successes. We could definitely see that learning the mechanics of the system was not a major problem. The children could get most of it themselves by swarming over the ALTOS with Adele's JOE book. The problem seemed more to be that of design.",{"_33":5945,"_35":5946},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5947,"_41":862,"_43":5948,"_67":5949,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"wtDQO4tr",{},[],{"_33":5951,"_35":5952},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":5953,"_41":862,"_43":5954,"_67":5955,"_69":70,"_71":3648},"kmw6ho65",{"_194":195,"_3508":3646},[],{"_33":5957,"_35":5958},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5959,"_41":862,"_43":5960,"_67":5961,"_69":5962,"_71":70},"Ed869Oum",{},[],"It started to hit home in the Spring of '74 after I taught Smalltalk to 20 PARC nonprogrammer adults. They were able to get through the initial material faster than the children, but just as it looked like an overwhelming success was at hand, they started to crash on problems that didn't look to me to be much harder than the ones they had just been doing well on. One of them was a project thought up by one of the adults, which was to make a little database system that could act like a card file or rolodex. They couldn't even come close to programming it. I was very surprised because I \"knew\" that such a project was well below the mythical \"two pages\" for end-users we were working within. That night I wrote it out, and the next day I showed all of them how to do it. Still, none of them were able to do it by themselves. Later, I sat in the room pondering the board from my talk. Finally, I counted the number of nonobvious ideas in this little program. They came to 17. And some of them were like the concept of the arch in building design: very hard to discover, if you don't already know them.",{"_33":5964,"_35":5965},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5966,"_41":862,"_43":5967,"_67":5968,"_69":5980,"_71":70},"Hg5Zmf5B",{},[5969],{"_37":3795,"_233":5970,"_238":5974,"_43":5979,"_71":70},[5530,5971,5972,5973],137,428,727,[5975,5976,5977,5978],123,143,434,743,{},"The connection to literacy was painfully clear. It isn't enough to just learn to read and write. There is also a literature that renders ideas. Language is used to read and write about them, but at some point the organization of ideas starts to dominate mere language abilities. And it helps greatly to have some powerful ideas under one's belt to better acquire more powerful ideas [Papert 70s]. So, we decided we should teach design. And Adele came up with another brilliant stroke to deal with this. She decided that what was needed was an intermediary between the vague ideas about the problem and the very detailed writing and debugging that had to be done to get it to run in Smalltalk. She called the intermediary forms design templates.",{"_33":5982,"_35":5983},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5984,"_41":862,"_43":5985,"_67":5986,"_69":5987,"_71":70},"EwaRlhpK",{},[],"Using these the children could look at a situation they wanted to simulate, and decompose it into classes and messages without having to worry just how a method would work. The method planning could then be done informally in English, and these notes would later serve as commentaries and guides to the writing of the actual code. This was a terrific idea, and it worked very well.",{"_33":5989,"_35":5990},[],{"_37":199,"_39":5991,"_41":862,"_43":5992,"_67":5993,"_69":6003,"_71":70},"D39p97AV",{},[5994],{"_37":4625,"_233":5995,"_238":5999,"_43":6002,"_71":70},[5996,5997,5998],131,329,377,[4848,6000,6001],333,379,{},"But not enough to satisfy us. As Adele liked to point out, it is hard to claim success if only some of the children are successful—and if a maximum effort of both children and teachers was required to get the successes to happen. Real pedagogy has to work in much less idealistic settings and be considerably more robust. Still, some successes are qualitatively different from no successes. We wanted more, and started to push on the inheritance idea as a way to let novices build on frameworks that could only be designed by experts. We had good reason to believe that this could work because we had been impressed by Lisa van Stone's ability to make significant changes to SHAZAM (the five or six page Smalltalk animation tool done by relatively expert adults). Unfortunately, inheritance—though an incredibly powerful technique—has turned out to be very difficult for novices (and even professionals) to deal with.",{"_33":6005,"_35":6006},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6007,"_41":862,"_43":6008,"_67":6009,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"Thv2YLDT",{},[],{"_33":6011,"_35":6012},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6013,"_41":862,"_43":6014,"_67":6015,"_69":70,"_71":3725},"exdjYgQ2",{"_194":195,"_3508":3723},[],{"_33":6017,"_35":6018},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6019,"_41":862,"_43":6020,"_67":6021,"_69":6022,"_71":70},"uHpAnm8w",{},[],"At this point, let me do a look back from the vantage point of today. I'm now pretty much convinced that our design template approach was a good one after all. We just didn't apply it longitudinally enough. I mean by this that there is now a large accumulation of results from many attempts to teach novices programming [Soloway 1989]. They all have similar stories that seem to have little to do with the various features of the programming languages used, and everything to do with the difficulties novices have thinking the special way that good programmers think. Even with a much better interface than we had then (and have today), it is likely that this really is actually more like writing than we wanted it to be. Namely, for the \"80%\", it really has to be learned gradually over a period of years in order to build up the structures that need to be there for design and solution look-ahead.41",{"_33":6024,"_35":6025},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6026,"_41":862,"_43":6027,"_67":6028,"_69":6041,"_71":70},"TjpP25mH",{},[6029,6033],{"_37":4625,"_233":6030,"_238":6031,"_43":6032,"_71":70},[3908],[3880],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":6034,"_238":6036,"_43":6040,"_71":70},[3601,6035,4962],317,[6037,6038,6039],267,321,355,{},"The problem is not to get the kids to do stuff—they love to do, even when they are not sure exactly what they are doing. This correlates well with studies of early learning of language, when much rehearsal is done regardless of whether content is involved. Just doing seems to help. What is difficult is to determine what ideas to put forth and how deeply they should penetrate at a given child's developmental level. This confusion still persists for reading and writing of natural language—and for mathematics—despite centuries of experience. And it is the main hurdle for teaching children programming. When, in what order and depth, and how should the powerful ideas be taught?",{"_33":6043,"_35":6044},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6045,"_41":862,"_43":6046,"_67":6047,"_69":6048,"_71":70},"OycwDSJP",{},[],"Should we even try to teach programming? I have met hundreds of programmers in the last 30 years and can see no discernible influence of programming on their general ability to think well or to take an enlightened stance on human knowledge. If anything, the opposite is true. Expert knowledge often remains rooted in the environments in which it was first learned—and most metaphorical extensions result in misleading analogies. A remarkable number of artists, scientists, philosophers are quite dull outside of their specialty (and one suspects within it as well). The first siren's song we need to be wary of is the one that promises a connection between an interesting pursuit and interesting thoughts. The music is not in the piano, and it is possible to graduate Juilliard without finding or feeling it.",{"_33":6050,"_35":6051},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6052,"_41":862,"_43":6053,"_67":6054,"_69":6055,"_71":70},"RjBgyptc",{},[],"I have also met a few people for whom computing provides an important new metaphor for thinking about human knowledge and reach. But something else was needed besides computing for enlightenment to happen.",{"_33":6057,"_35":6058},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6059,"_41":862,"_43":6060,"_67":6061,"_69":6067,"_71":70},"cBq6OqTf",{},[6062],{"_37":3795,"_233":6063,"_238":6065,"_43":6066,"_71":70},[6064],214,[4843],{},"Tools provide a path, a context, and almost an excuse for developing enlightenment, but no tool ever contained it or can dispense it. Cesare Pavese observed: to know the world we must construct it. In other words, we make not just to have, but to know. But the having can happen without most of the knowing taking place.",{"_33":6069,"_35":6070},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6071,"_41":862,"_43":6072,"_67":6073,"_69":6074,"_71":70},"noI4zeDj",{},[],"Another way to look at this is that knowledge is in its least interesting state when it is first being learned. The representations—whether markings, allusions, or physical controls—get in the way (almost take over as goals) and must be laboriously and painfully interpreted. From here there are several useful paths, two of which are important and intertwined.",{"_33":6076,"_35":6077},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6078,"_41":862,"_43":6079,"_67":6080,"_69":6086,"_71":70},"_QrsheZH",{},[6081],{"_37":3795,"_233":6082,"_238":6083,"_43":6085,"_71":70},[3851],[6084],20,{},"The first is fluency, which in part is the process of building mental structures that disappear the interpretation of the representations. The letters and words of a sentence are experienced as meaning rather than markings, the tennis racquet or keyboard becomes an extension of one's body, and so forth. If carried further one eventually becomes a kind of expert—but without deep knowledge in other areas, attempts to generalize are usually too crisp and ill formed.",{"_33":6088,"_35":6089},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6090,"_41":862,"_43":6091,"_67":6092,"_69":6097,"_71":70},"ewI9Ut2W",{},[6093],{"_37":3795,"_233":6094,"_238":6095,"_43":6096,"_71":70},[4131],[3910],{},"The second path is towards taking the knowledge as a metaphor than can illuminate other areas. But without fluency it is more likely that prior knowledge will hold sway and the metaphors from this side will be fuzzy and misleading.",{"_33":6099,"_35":6100},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6101,"_41":862,"_43":6102,"_67":6103,"_69":6109,"_71":70},"SsBsvYPw",{},[6104],{"_37":4625,"_233":6105,"_238":6107,"_43":6108,"_71":70},[6106],108,[240],{},"The \"trick,\" and I think that this is what liberal arts education is supposed to be about, is to get fluent and deep while building relationships with other fluent deep knowledge. Our society has lowered its aims so far that it is happy with \"increases in scores\" without daring to inquire whether any important threshold has been crossed. Being able to read a warning on a pill bottle or write about a summer vacation is not literacy and our society should not treat it so. Literacy, for example, is being able to fluently read and follow the 50 page argument in Paine's Common Sense and being able (and happy) to fluently write a critique or defense of it. Another kind of 20th century literacy is being able to hear about a new fatal contagious incurable disease and instantly know that a disastrous exponential relationship holds and early action is of the highest priority. Another kind of literacy would take citizens to their personal computers where they can fluently and without pain build a systems simulation of the disease to use as a comparison against further information.",{"_33":6111,"_35":6112},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6113,"_41":862,"_43":6114,"_67":6115,"_69":6116,"_71":70},"lgLS3Bmm",{},[],"At the liberal arts level we would expect that connections between each of the fluencies would form truly powerful metaphors for considering ideas in the light of others.",{"_33":6118,"_35":6119},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6120,"_41":862,"_43":6121,"_67":6122,"_69":6127,"_71":70},"MRvzhwmG",{},[6123],{"_37":4625,"_233":6124,"_238":6125,"_43":6126,"_71":70},[4812],[4476],{},"The reason, therefore, that many of us want children to understand computing deeply and fluently is that like literature, mathematics, science, music, and art, it carries special ways of thinking about situations that in contrast with other knowledge and other ways of thinking critically boost our ability to understand our world.",{"_33":6129,"_35":6130},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6131,"_41":862,"_43":6132,"_67":6133,"_69":6147,"_71":70},"BxkPJosr",{},[6134,6139],{"_37":3795,"_233":6135,"_238":6137,"_43":6138,"_71":70},[6136],231,[4849],{},{"_37":4625,"_233":6140,"_238":6143,"_43":6146,"_71":70},[6141,6142],794,890,[6144,6145],797,893,{},"We did not know then, and I'm sorry to say from 15 years later, that these critical questions still do not yet have really useful answers. But there are some indications. Even very young children can understand and use interactive transformational tools. The first ones are their hands! They can readily extend these experiences to computer objects and making changes to them. They can often imagine what a proposed change will do and not be surprised at the result. Two and three year olds can use the Smalltalk-style interface and manipulate object-oriented graphics. Third graders can (in a few days) learn more than 50 features—most of these are transformational tools—of a new system including its user interface. They can answer any question whose answer requires the application of just one of these tools. But it is extremely difficult for them to answer any question that requires two or more transformations. Yet they have no problem applying sequences of transformations, exploring \"forward.\" It is for conceiving and achieving even modest goals requiring several changes that they almost completely lack navigation abilities.",{"_33":6149,"_35":6150},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6151,"_41":862,"_43":6152,"_67":6153,"_69":6154,"_71":70},"Ru69QElR",{},[],"It seems that what needs to be learned and taught is now to package up transformations in twos and threes in a manner similar to learning a strategic game like checkers. The vague sense of a \"threesome\" pointing towards one's goal can be a set up for the more detailed work that is needed to accomplish it. This art is possible for a large percentage of the population, but for most, it will need to be learned gradually over several years.",{"_33":6156,"_35":6157},[],{"_37":190,"_39":6158,"_41":862,"_43":6159,"_67":6160,"_69":6161,"_71":70},"IUuiZ4Ku",{},[],"V. 1976-80—The first modern Smalltalk (-76), its birth, applications, and improvements",{"_33":6163,"_35":6164},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6165,"_41":862,"_43":6166,"_67":6167,"_69":6178,"_71":70},"QwD21rch",{},[6168],{"_37":3795,"_233":6169,"_238":6173,"_43":6177,"_71":70},[6170,6171,6172],431,594,1396,[6174,6175,6176],436,600,1405,{},"By the end of 1975 I felt that we were losing our balance—that the \"Dynabook for children\" idea was slowly dimming out—or perhaps starting to be overwhelmed by professional needs. In January 1976, I took the whole group to Pajaro Dunes for a three day offsite to bring up the issues and try to reset the compass. It was called \"Let's Burn Our Disk Packs.\" There were no shouting matches, the group liked (I would go so far to say: loved) each other too much for that. But we were troubled. I used the old aphorism that \"no biological organism can live in its own waste products\" to plead for a really fresh start: a hw-sw system very different from the ALTO and Smalltalk. One thing we all did agree on was that the current Smalltalk's power did not match our various levels of aspiration. I thought we needed something different, as I did not see how OOP by itself was going to solve our end-user problems. Others, particularly some of the grad students, really wanted a better Smalltalk that was faster and could be used for bigger problems. I think Dan felt that a better Smalltalk could be the vehicle for the different system I wanted, but could not describe clearly. The meeting was not a disaster, and we went back to PARC still friends and colleagues, but the absolute cohesiveness of the first four years never rejelled. I started designing a new small machine and language I called the NoteTaker and Dan started to design Smalltalk-76.",{"_33":6180,"_35":6181},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6182,"_41":862,"_43":6183,"_67":6184,"_69":6200,"_71":70},"GqDs2wxH",{},[6185,6195],{"_37":4625,"_233":6186,"_238":6190,"_43":6194,"_71":70},[6187,6188,6189],242,459,563,[6191,6192,6193],248,463,578,{},{"_37":3795,"_233":6196,"_238":6197,"_43":6199,"_71":70},[5455],[6198],389,{},"The reason I wanted to \"burn the disk packs\" is that I had a very McLuhanish feeling about media and environments: that once we've shaped tools, in his words, they turn around and \"reshape us.\" Of course this is a great idea if the tools are really good and aimed squarely at the issues in question. But the other edge of the sword cuts as deep—that inadequate tools and environments still reshape our thinking in spite of their problems, in part, because we want paradigms to guide our goals. Strong paradigms like LISP and Smalltalk are so compelling that they eat their young: when you look at an application in either of these two systems, they resemble the systems themselves, not a new idea. When I looked at Smalltalk in 1975, I was looking at something great, but I did not see an enduser language, I did not see a solution to the original goal of a \"reading\" and \"writing\" computer medium for children. I wanted to stop, dynamite everything and start from scratch again.",{"_33":6202,"_35":6203},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6204,"_41":862,"_43":6205,"_67":6206,"_69":6212,"_71":70},"hMNhWc_k",{},[6207],{"_37":3795,"_233":6208,"_238":6210,"_43":6211,"_71":70},[4120,6209],429,[3851,6170],{},"The NoteTaker was to be a \"laptop\" that could be built in a few years using the (almost) available 16K RAMS (a vast improvement over the 1K RAMS that the ALTO employed). A laptop couldn't use a mouse (which I hated anyway) and a tablet seemed awkward (not a lot of room and the stylus could flop out of reach when let go), so I came up with an embedded pointing device I called a \"tabmouse.\" It was a relative pointer and had an up sensor so it could be stroked like a mouse and would also stay where you left it, but it felt like a stylus and used a pantograph mechanism that eliminated the annoying hysteresis bias in the x and y directions that made it hard to use a mouse as a pen. I planned to use a multiprocessor architecture of slow but highly integrated chips as originally specified for the Dynabook and wanted a new bytecoded interpreter for a friendlier and simpler system than Smalltalk-72.",{"_33":6214,"_35":6215},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6216,"_41":862,"_43":6217,"_67":6218,"_69":70,"_71":3762},"GoqTdZ7y",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":6220,"_35":6221},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6222,"_41":862,"_43":6223,"_67":6224,"_69":6231,"_71":70},"M8poZIJw",{},[6225],{"_37":4625,"_233":6226,"_238":6228,"_43":6230,"_71":70},[6227],867,[6229],870,{},"Meanwhile Dan was proceeding with his total revamp of Smalltalk and along somewhat similar lines [In 78]. The first major thing that needed to be done was to get rid of the function/class dualism in favor of a completely intensional definition with every piece of code as an intrinsic method. We had wanted that from the beginning, (and most of the code was already written that way). There were a variety of strong desires for a real inheritance mechanism from Adele and me, from Larry Tesler, who was working on desktop publishing, and from the grad students. Dan had to find a better way than Simula's very rigid compile-time conception. It was time to make good on the idea that \"everything was an object,\" which included all the internal \"systems\" objects like \"activation records,\" etc. We were all agreed that the flexible syntax of the earlier Smalltalks was too flexible, and this level of extensibility was not desirable. All of the extensions we liked used various keyword schemes, so Dan came up with a combination keyword/operator syntax that was very flexible, but allowed the language to be read unambiguously by both humans and the machine. This allowed a FLEX machine-like byte-code compiler and efficient interpreter to be defined that ran up to 180 times as fast as the previous direct interpreter. The OOZE VM system could be modified to handle the new objects and its capacity was well matched to the ALTO's RAM and disk.",{"_33":6233,"_35":6234},[],{"_37":190,"_39":6235,"_41":862,"_43":6236,"_67":6237,"_69":4068,"_71":70},"Y97SumcR",{},[],{"_33":6239,"_35":6240},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6241,"_41":862,"_43":6242,"_67":6243,"_69":6244,"_71":70},"ZpXRMAEt",{},[],"A word about inheritance. Simula-I had neither classes as objects nor inheritance. Simula-67 added the latter as a generalization to the ALGOL-60 structure. This was a great idea. But it did have some drawbacks: minor ones like name clashes in multiple threaded lists (no one uses threaded lists anymore), and major ones like rigidity in the extended type structures, need to qualify types, only a single path of inheritance, and difficulty in adapting to an interactive development system with incremental compiling and other needs for instant changes. Then there were a host of problems that were really outside the scope of Simula's goals: having to do with various kinds of modeling and inferencing that were of interest in the world of artificial intelligence. For example, not all useful questions could be answered by following a static chain. Some of them required a kind of \"inheritance\" or \"inferencing\" through dynamically bound \"parts\" (i.e. instance variables). Multiple inheritance also looked important but the corresponding possible clashes between methods of the same name in different superclasses looked difficult to handle, and so forth.",{"_33":6246,"_35":6247},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6248,"_41":862,"_43":6249,"_67":6250,"_69":6257,"_71":70},"NeKNDVFQ",{},[6251],{"_37":3795,"_233":6252,"_238":6254,"_43":6256,"_71":70},[6253],760,[6255],772,{},"On the other hand, since things can be done with a dynamic language that are difficult with a statically compiled one, I just decided to leave inheritance out as a feature in Smalltalk-72, knowing that we could simulate it back using Smalltalk's LISPlike flexibility. The biggest contributor to these AI ideas was Larry Tesler who used what is now called \"slot inheritance\" extensively in his various versions of early desktop publishing systems. Nowadays, this would be called a \"delegation-style\" inheritance scheme [Liberman 84]. Danny Bobrow and Terry Winograd during this period were designing a \"frame-based\" AI language called KRL which was \"object-oriented\" and I believe was influenced by early Smalltalk. It had a kind of multiple inheritance—called perspectives—which permitted an object to play multiple roles in a very clean way. Many of these ideas a few years later went into PIE, an interesting extension of Smalltalk to networks and higher level descriptions by Ira Goldstein and Bobrow [Goldstein & Bobrow 1980].",{"_33":6259,"_35":6260},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6261,"_41":862,"_43":6262,"_67":6263,"_69":6264,"_71":70},"HwCF961Y",{},[],"By the time Smalltalk-76 came along, Dan Ingalls had come up with a scheme that was Simula-like in its semantics but could be incrementally changed on the fly to be in accord with our goals of close interaction. I was not completely thrilled with it because it seemed that we needed a better theory about inheritance entirely (and still do). For example, inheritance and instancing (which is a kind of inheritance) muddles both pragmatics (such as factoring code to save space) and semantics (used for way too many tasks such as: specialization, generalization, speciation, etc.) Alan Borning employed a multiple inheritance scheme in Thinglab [Borning 1977] which was implemented in Smalltalk-76. But no comprehensive and clean multiple inheritance scheme appeared that was compelling enough to surmount Dan's original Simula-like design.",{"_33":6266,"_35":6267},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6268,"_41":862,"_43":6269,"_67":6270,"_69":6271,"_71":70},"qqJXs0Hp",{},[],"Meanwhile, the running battle with Xerox continued. There were now about 500 ALTOs linked with Ethernets to each other and to Laserprinter and file servers, that used ALTOs as controllers. I wrote many memos to the Xerox planners trying to get them to make plans that included personal computing as one of their main directions. Here is an example:",{"_33":6273,"_35":6274},[],{"_37":190,"_39":6275,"_41":862,"_43":6276,"_67":6277,"_69":6278,"_71":70},"T_2TQl_4",{},[],"A Simple Vision of the Future",{"_33":6280,"_35":6281},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6282,"_41":862,"_43":6283,"_67":6284,"_69":6289,"_71":70},"P-uLfS62",{},[6285],{"_37":3795,"_233":6286,"_238":6287,"_43":6288,"_71":70},[139],[4197],{},"A Brief Update Of My 1971 Pendery Paper",{"_33":6291,"_35":6292},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6293,"_41":862,"_43":6294,"_67":6295,"_69":6303,"_71":70},"ZHgImXbP",{},[6296],{"_37":3795,"_233":6297,"_238":6299,"_43":6302,"_71":70},[6298,4475],253,[6300,6301],258,285,{},"In the 1990's there will be millions of personal computers. They will be the size of notebooks of today, have high-resolution flat-screen reflective displays, weigh less than ten pounds, have ten to twenty times the computing and storage capacity of an Alto. Let's call them Dynabooks.",{"_33":6305,"_35":6306},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6307,"_41":862,"_43":6308,"_67":6309,"_69":6310,"_71":70},"ywhQdEyR",{},[],"The purchase price will be about that of a color television set of the era, although most of the machines will be given away by manufacturers who will be marketing the content rather than the container of personal computing.",{"_33":6312,"_35":6313},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6314,"_41":862,"_43":6315,"_67":6316,"_69":6317,"_71":70},"Duzu-Ei-",{},[],"...",{"_33":6319,"_35":6320},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6321,"_41":862,"_43":6322,"_67":6323,"_69":6328,"_71":70},"cSKHKAG5",{},[6324],{"_37":3795,"_233":6325,"_238":6326,"_43":6327,"_71":70},[452],[5367],{},"Though the Dynabook will have considerable local storage and will do most computing locally, it will spend a large percentage of its time hooked to various large, global information utilities which will permit communication with others of ideas, data, working models, as well as the daily chit-chat that organizations need in order to function. The communications link will be by private and public wire and by packet radio, Dynabooks will also by used as servers in the information utilities. They will have enough power to be entirely shaped by software.",{"_33":6330,"_35":6345},[6331,6338],{"_33":6332,"_35":6333},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6334,"_41":862,"_43":6335,"_67":6336,"_69":6337,"_71":70},"954htKdt",{},[],"There need only be a few hardware types to handle almost all of the processing activity of a system.",{"_33":6339,"_35":6340},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6341,"_41":862,"_43":6342,"_67":6343,"_69":6344,"_71":70},"n7ARiCQG",{},[],"Personal Computers, Communications Links, and Information Utilities are the three critical components of a Xerox future.",{"_37":190,"_39":6346,"_41":862,"_43":6347,"_67":6348,"_69":6349,"_71":70},"xP26i2ad",{"_194":3876},[],"The Main Points Of This Vision",{"_33":6351,"_35":6352},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6353,"_41":862,"_43":6354,"_67":6355,"_69":6317,"_71":70},"Zg-8sslc",{},[],{"_33":6357,"_35":6358},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6359,"_41":862,"_43":6360,"_67":6361,"_69":6376,"_71":70},"B1LlMIwX",{},[6362,6370],{"_37":3795,"_233":6363,"_238":6365,"_43":6369,"_71":70},[6084,6364,4688],85,[6366,6367,6368],28,92,105,{},{"_37":4625,"_233":6371,"_238":6373,"_43":6375,"_71":70},[6372],74,[6374],77,{},"In other words, the material of a computer system is the computer itself, all of the content and function is fashioned in software.",{"_33":6378,"_35":6446},[6379,6386],{"_33":6380,"_35":6381},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6382,"_41":862,"_43":6383,"_67":6384,"_69":6385,"_71":70},"gDAs5pFy",{},[],"Material: If the design and development of the hardware computer material is done as carefully and completely as Xerox's development of special light-sensitive alloys, then only one or two computer designs need to be built... Extra investment in development here will be vastly repaid by simplifying the manufacturing process and providing lower costs through increased volume.",{"_33":6387,"_35":6435},[6388,6404,6419],{"_33":6389,"_35":6390},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6391,"_41":862,"_43":6392,"_67":6393,"_69":6403,"_71":70},"6zjV73Uo",{},[6394,6398],{"_37":3795,"_233":6395,"_238":6396,"_43":6397,"_71":70},[4120],[3776],{},{"_37":4625,"_233":6399,"_238":6400,"_43":6402,"_71":70},[4033],[6401],59,{},"the replication time and cost of a content-function is zero",{"_33":6405,"_35":6406},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6407,"_41":862,"_43":6408,"_67":6409,"_69":6418,"_71":70},"L5ZTVkYR",{},[6410,6414],{"_37":3795,"_233":6411,"_238":6412,"_43":6413,"_71":70},[4120],[3776],{},{"_37":4625,"_233":6415,"_238":6416,"_43":6417,"_71":70},[4839],[3908],{},"the development time and cost for a content-function is high",{"_33":6420,"_35":6421},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6422,"_41":862,"_43":6423,"_67":6424,"_69":6434,"_71":70},"Rpk0DmXc",{},[6425,6429],{"_37":3795,"_233":6426,"_238":6427,"_43":6428,"_71":70},[4120],[4670],{},{"_37":4625,"_233":6430,"_238":6431,"_43":6433,"_71":70},[4033],[6432],58,{},"the change time and cost for a content-function can be low",{"_37":199,"_39":6436,"_41":862,"_43":6437,"_67":6438,"_69":6445,"_71":70},"WSZCmx8y",{"_194":3876},[6439],{"_37":3795,"_233":6440,"_238":6442,"_43":6444,"_71":70},[6441],117,[6443],125,{},"Content: Aside from the wonderful generality of being able to continuously shape new content from the same material, software has three important characteristics:",{"_37":199,"_39":6447,"_41":862,"_43":6448,"_67":6449,"_69":6450,"_71":70},"VhhurShj",{"_194":3876},[],"There are two important guidelines to be drawn from this:",{"_33":6452,"_35":6474},[6453,6460,6467],{"_33":6454,"_35":6455},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6456,"_41":862,"_43":6457,"_67":6458,"_69":6459,"_71":70},"4d5JOaDn",{},[],"Xerox has the financial base to cover the large development costs of a small number of very powerful computer-types and a large number of software functions.",{"_33":6461,"_35":6462},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6463,"_41":862,"_43":6464,"_67":6465,"_69":6466,"_71":70},"7zncwpJO",{},[],"Xerox has the marketing base to sell these functions on a wide enough scale to garner back to itself an incredible profit.",{"_33":6468,"_35":6469},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6470,"_41":862,"_43":6471,"_67":6472,"_69":6473,"_71":70},"dhSrmrpf",{},[],"Xerox has working for it an impressively large percentage of the best software designers in the world.",{"_37":199,"_39":6475,"_41":862,"_43":6476,"_67":6477,"_69":6482,"_71":70},"X8w14ZKY",{"_194":3876},[6478],{"_37":4625,"_233":6479,"_238":6480,"_43":6481,"_71":70},[624],[4670],{},"Xerox must take these several points seriously if it is to survive and prosper in its new business area of information media. If it does, the company has an excellent chance for several reasons:",{"_33":6484,"_35":6485},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6486,"_41":862,"_43":6487,"_67":6488,"_69":6489,"_71":70},"LMAX04vm",{},[],"In 1976, Chuck Thacker designed the ALTO III that would use the new 16k chips and be able to fit on a desktop. It could be marketed for about what the large cumbersome special purpose \"word-processors\" cost, yet could do so much more. Nevertheless, in August of 1976, Xerox made a fateful decision: not to bring the ALTO III to market. This was a huge blow to many of us—even I, who had never really, really thought of the ALTO as anything but a stepping stone to the \"real thing.\" In 1992, the world market for personal computers and workstations was $90 million—twice as much as the mainframe and mini market, and many times Xerox's 1992 gross. The most successful company of this era—Microsoft—is not a hardware company, but a software company.",{"_33":6491,"_35":6492},[],{"_37":190,"_39":6493,"_41":862,"_43":6494,"_67":6495,"_69":3999,"_71":70},"MTQ7Fugz",{},[],{"_33":6497,"_35":6498},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6499,"_41":862,"_43":6500,"_67":6501,"_69":6502,"_71":70},"z_1UuZMm",{},[],"I have been asked by several of the reviewers to say more about the development of the \"Smalltalk-style\" overlapping window user interface since there are now more than 20 million computers in the world that use its descendants. A decent history would be as long as this chapter, and none has been written so far. There is a summary of some of the ideas in [Kay 89]—let me add a few more points.",{"_33":6504,"_35":6505},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6506,"_41":862,"_43":6507,"_67":6508,"_69":6509,"_71":70},"9TRBzdr-",{},[],"All of the elements eventually used in the Smalltalk user interface were already to be found in the sixties—as different ways to access and invoke the functionality provided by an interactive system. The two major centers of ideas were Lincoln Labs and RAND corp—both ARPA funded. The big shift that consolidated these ideas into a powerful theory and long-lived examples came because the LRG focus was on children. Hence, we were thinking about learning as being one of the main effects we wanted to have happen. Early on, this led to a 90 degree rotation of the purpose of the user interface from \"access to functionality\" to \"environment in which users learn by doing.\" This new stance could now respond to the echoes of Montessori and Dewey, particularly the former, and got me, on rereading Jerome Bruner, to think beyond the children's curriculum to a \"curriculum of the user interface.\"",{"_33":6511,"_35":6512},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6513,"_41":862,"_43":6514,"_67":6515,"_69":6522,"_71":70},"RqLqBXPN",{},[6516],{"_37":3795,"_233":6517,"_238":6519,"_43":6521,"_71":70},[6518],691,[6520],709,{},"The particular aim of LRG was to find the equivalent of writing—that is learning and thinking by doing in a medium—our new \"pocket universe.\" For various reasons I had settled on \"iconic programming\" as the way to achieve this, drawing on the iconic representations used by many ARPA projects in the sixties. My friend Nicholas Negroponte, an architect, was extremely interested in how environments affected peoples' work and creativity. He was interested in embedding the new computer magic in familiar surroundings. I had quite a bit of theatrical experience in a past life, and remembered Coleridge's adage that \"people attend 'bad theatre' hoping to forget, people attend 'good theatre' aching to remember.\" In other words, it is the ability to evoke the audience's own intelligence and experiences that makes theatre work.",{"_33":6524,"_35":6525},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6526,"_41":862,"_43":6527,"_67":6528,"_69":70,"_71":3717},"k8Ck365u",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":6530,"_35":6531},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6532,"_41":862,"_43":6533,"_67":6534,"_69":70,"_71":3603},"R98xAbDO",{"_194":195,"_3508":3601},[],{"_33":6536,"_35":6537},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6538,"_41":862,"_43":6539,"_67":6540,"_69":6550,"_71":70},"kn3d3nFf",{},[6541],{"_37":3795,"_233":6542,"_238":6545,"_43":6549,"_71":70},[6543,5808,6544],196,220,[6546,6547,6548],201,213,227,{},"Putting all this together, we want an apparently free environment in which exploration causes desired sequences to happen (Montessori); one that allows kinesthetic, iconic, and symbolic learning—\"doing with images makes symbols\" (Piaget & Bruner); the user is never trapped in a mode (GRAIL); the magic is embedded in the familiar (Negroponte); and which acts as a magnifying mirror for the user's own intelligence (Coleridge). It would be a great finish to this story to say that having articulated this we were able to move straightforwardly to the design as we know it today. In fact, the UI design work happened in fits and starts in between feeding Smalltalk itself, designing children's experiments, trying to understand iconic construction, and just playing around. In spite of this meandering, the context almost forced a good design to turn out anyway. Just about everyone at PARC at this time had opinions about the UI, ours and theirs. It is impossible to give detailed credit for the hundreds of ideas and discussions. However, the consolidation can certainly be attributed to Dan Ingalls, for listening to everyone, contributing original ideas, and constantly building a design for user testing. I had a fair amount to do with setting the context, inventing overlapping windows, etc., and Adele and I designed most of the experiments. Beyond that, Ted Kaehler, and visitor Ron Baecker made highly valuable contributions. [Dan Halbert] designed SmallStar, the prototype iconic interface for the Xerox Star product.",{"_33":6552,"_35":6553},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6554,"_41":862,"_43":6555,"_67":6556,"_69":6561,"_71":70},"EO_TSWjN",{},[6557],{"_37":3795,"_233":6558,"_238":6559,"_43":6560,"_71":70},[4035],[2396],{},"Meanwhile, I had gotten Doug Fairbairn interested in the Notetaker. He designed a wonderful \"smart bus\" that could efficiently handle slow multiple processors and the system looked very promising, even though most of the rest of PARC thought I was nuts to abandon the fast bipolar hw of the ALTO. But I couldn't see that bipolar was ever going to make it into a laptop or Dynabook. On the other hand I hated the 8-bit micros that were just starting to appear, because of the silliness and naivete of their designs—there was no hint that anyone who had ever designed software was involved.",{"_33":6563,"_35":6564},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6565,"_41":862,"_43":6566,"_67":6567,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"oweWMkpO",{},[],{"_33":6569,"_35":6570},[],{"_37":190,"_39":6571,"_41":862,"_43":6572,"_67":6573,"_69":4061,"_71":70},"spZkA9o8",{},[],{"_33":6575,"_35":6576},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6577,"_41":862,"_43":6578,"_67":6579,"_69":70,"_71":3733},"n0Gg2qgb",{"_194":195,"_3508":3731},[],{"_33":6581,"_35":6582},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6583,"_41":862,"_43":6584,"_67":6585,"_69":6586,"_71":70},"IDo8vxtx",{},[],"Dan finished the Smalltalk-76 design November, and he, Dave Robson, Ted Kaehler, and Diana Merry, successfully implemented the system from scratch (which included rewriting all of the existing class definitions) in just seven months. this was such a wonderful achievement that I was bowled over in spite of my wanting to start over. It was fast, lively, could handle \"big\" problems, and was great fun. The system consisted of about 50 classes described in about 180 pages of source code. This included all of the OS functions, files, printing and other Ethernet services, the window interface, editors, graphics and painting systems, and two new contributions by Larry Tesler, the famous browsers for static methods in the inheritance hierarchy and dynamic contexts for debugging in the runtime environment. In every way it was the consolidation of all of our ideas and yearning about Smalltalk in one integrated package. All Smalltalks since have resembled this conception very closely. In many ways, as Tony Hoare once remarked about Algol, Dan's Smalltalk-76 was a great improvement on its successors!",{"_33":6588,"_35":6589},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6590,"_41":862,"_43":6591,"_67":6592,"_69":6593,"_71":70},"zkYhxl6F",{},[],"Here are two stylish ST-76 classes written by Dan.",{"_33":6595,"_35":6596},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6597,"_41":862,"_43":6598,"_67":6599,"_69":70,"_71":3710},"Nyl_FxWO",{"_194":195,"_3508":3708},[],{"_33":6601,"_35":6602},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6603,"_41":862,"_43":6604,"_67":6605,"_69":6612,"_71":70},"O9qTQqYe",{},[6606],{"_37":232,"_233":6607,"_238":6609,"_43":6611,"_71":70},[6608],595,[6610],603,{},"Notice, particularly in class Window, how the code is expressed as goals for other objects (or itself) to achieve. The superclass Window's main job is to notice events and distribute them as messages to its subclasses. In the example, a document window (a subclass of DocWindow) is going to deal with the effects of user interactions. The Window class will notice that the keyboard is active and send a message to itself which will be intercepted by the subclass method. If there is no method the character will be thrown away and the window will flash. In this case, it finds DocWindow method: keyboard, which tells the held document to check it out.",{"_33":6614,"_35":6615},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6616,"_41":862,"_43":6617,"_67":6618,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"hzicECFV",{},[],{"_33":6620,"_35":6621},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6622,"_41":862,"_43":6623,"_67":6624,"_69":70,"_71":3595},"RSqa1MNh",{"_194":195,"_3508":3593},[],{"_33":6626,"_35":6627},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6628,"_41":862,"_43":6629,"_67":6630,"_69":6637,"_71":70},"vT9lTZR2",{},[6631],{"_37":4625,"_233":6632,"_238":6634,"_43":6636,"_71":70},[6633],378,[6635],381,{},"In January of 1978 Smalltalk-76 had its first real test. CSL had invited the top ten executives of Xerox to PARC for a two day seminar on software, with a special emphasis on complexity and what could be done about it. LRG got asked to give them a hands-on experience in end-user programming so \"they could do 'something real' over two 1½ hour sessions.\" We immediately decided not to teach them Smalltalk-76 (my \"burn our disk packs\" point in spades), but to create in two months in Smalltalk-76 a rich system especially tailored for adult nonexpert users (Dan's point in trumps). We took our \"Simpula\" job shop simulation model as a starting point and decided to build a user interface for a generalized job shop simulation tool that the executives could make into specific dynamic simulations that would act out their changing states by animating graphics on the screen. We called it the Smalltalk SimKit. This was a maximum effort and everyone pitched in. Adele became the design leader in spite of the very recent appearance of a new baby. I have a priceless memory of her debugging away on the SimKit while simultaneously nursing Rachell.",{"_33":6639,"_35":6640},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6641,"_41":862,"_43":6642,"_67":6643,"_69":6644,"_71":70},"I9Zs_VZO",{},[],"There were many interesting problems to be solved. The system itself was straightforward but it had to be completely sealed off from Smalltalk proper, particularly with regard to error messages. Dave Robson came up with a nice scheme (almost an expert system) to capture complaints from the bowels of Smalltalk and translated them into meaningful SimKit terms. There were many user interface details—some workaday, like making new browsers that could only look at the four SimKit classes (Station, Worker, Job, Report), and some more surprising as when we tried it on ten PARC nontechnical adults of about the same age and found that they couldn't read the screen very well. The small fonts our thirtysomething year-old eyes were used to didn't work for those in their 50s. This led to a nice introduction to the system in which the executives were encouraged to customize the screen by choosing among different fonts and sizes with the side effect that they learned how to use the mouse unselfconsciously.",{"_33":6646,"_35":6647},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6648,"_41":862,"_43":6649,"_67":6650,"_69":6651,"_71":70},"xvlZSzQQ",{},[],"On the morning of the \"big day\" Ted Kaehler decided to make a change in the virtual memory system OOZE to speed it up a little. We all held our breaths, but such was the clarity of the design and the confidence of the implementers that it did work, and the executive hands-on was a howling success. About an hour into the first session one of the VPs (who had written a few programs in FORTRAN 15 years before) finally realized he was programming and mused \"so it's finally come to this.\" Nine out of the ten executives were able to finish a simulation problem that related to their specific interests. One of the most interesting and sophisticated was a PC board production line done by the head of a Xerox owned company using actual figures (that he carried around in his head) to prime a model that could not be solved easily by closed form mathematics—it revealed a serious flaw in the disposition of workers given the line's average probability of manufacturing defects.",{"_33":6653,"_35":6654},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6655,"_41":862,"_43":6656,"_67":6657,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"6lgPWe1p",{},[],{"_33":6659,"_35":6660},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6661,"_41":862,"_43":6662,"_67":6663,"_69":70,"_71":3587},"dHQzqjeK",{"_194":195,"_3508":3585},[],{"_33":6665,"_35":6666},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6667,"_41":862,"_43":6668,"_67":6669,"_69":6670,"_71":70},"lJZEeu0I",{},[],"Another important system done at this time was Alan Borning's Thinglab [Borning 1979]—the first serious attempt to go beyond Ivan Sutherland's Sketchpad. Alan devised a very nice approach for dealing with constraints that did not require the solver to be omniscient (or able to solve Fermat's last theorem).",{"_33":6672,"_35":6673},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6674,"_41":862,"_43":6675,"_67":6676,"_69":6677,"_71":70},"iRuGCb47",{},[],"We could see that the \"pushing\" style of Smalltalk could eventually be replaced by a \"pulling\" style that was driven by changes to values that different methods were based on. This was an old idea but Thinglab showed how the object-oriented definition could be used to automatically limit the contexts for event-driven processing. And we soon discovered that \"prototypes\" were more hospitable than classes, and that multiple inheritance would be well served if there were classes for methods that knew generally what they were supposed to be about (inspired by Pat Winston's 2nd order models).",{"_33":6679,"_35":6680},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6681,"_41":862,"_43":6682,"_67":6683,"_69":6688,"_71":70},"RW9iqnEg",{},[6684],{"_37":3795,"_233":6685,"_238":6686,"_43":6687,"_71":70},[3776],[3971],{},"Meanwhile, the NoteTaker was getting more real, bigger, and slower. By this time the Western Digital emulation-style chips I hoped to use showed signs of being \"diffusion-ware,\" and did not look like they would really show up. We started looking around for something that we could count on, even if it didn't have a good architecture. In 1978, the best candidate was the Intel 8086, a 16-bit chip (with many unfortunate remnants of the 8008 and 8080), but with (barely) enough capacity to do the job—we would need three of them to make up for the ALTO, one for the interpreter, one for bitmapped graphics, and one for i/o (networking, etc).",{"_33":6690,"_35":6691},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6692,"_41":862,"_43":6693,"_67":6694,"_69":6702,"_71":70},"WgxHFiHz",{},[6695],{"_37":3795,"_233":6696,"_238":6698,"_43":6701,"_71":70},[3778,4841,6697],645,[6699,6700,5423],40,139,{},"Dan had been interested in the NoteTaker all along and wanted to see if he could make a version of Smalltalk-76 that could be the NoteTaker system. In order for this to happen it would have to run in 256K, the maximum amount of RAM that we had planned for the machine. None of the NOVA-like emulated \"machine-code\" from the ALTO could be brought over, and it had to fit in memory as well—there would only be floppies, no swapping memory existed. This challenge led to some excellent improvements in the system design. Ted Kaehler's system tracer (which could write out new virtual memories from old ones) was used to clone Smalltalk-76 into the NoteTaker. The indexed object table (as was used in early Smalltalk-80) first appeared here to simplify object access. An experiment in stacking contexts contiguously was tried: to save space and gain speed. Most of the old machine code was rewritten in Smalltalk and the total machine kernel was reduced to 6K bytes of (the not very strong) 8086 code.",{"_33":6704,"_35":6705},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6706,"_41":862,"_43":6707,"_67":6708,"_69":6717,"_71":70},"iU9KYx9y",{},[6709],{"_37":3795,"_233":6710,"_238":6713,"_43":6716,"_71":70},[6711,6712],689,966,[6714,6715],698,975,{},"All of the re-engineering had an interesting effect. Though the 8086 was not as good at bitblt as the ALTO (and much of the former machine code to assist graphics was now in Smalltalk), the overall interpreter was about twice as fast as the ALTO version (because not all the Smalltalk byte-code interpreter would fit into the 4k microcode memory on the ALTO). With various kinds of tricks and tuning, graphics display was \"largely compensated\" (in Dan's words). This was mainly because the ALTO did not have enough microcode memory to take in all of the Smalltalk emulation code—some of it had to be rendered in emulated \"NOVA\" code which forced two layers of interpretation. In fact, the Notetaker worked extremely well, though it would have crushed any lap. It had hopped back on the desk, and looked suspiciously like miniCOM (and several computers that would appear a few years later). It really did run on batteries and several of us had the pleasure of taking NoteTaker on a plane and running an object-oriented system with a windowed interface at 35,000 feet.",{"_33":6719,"_35":6720},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6721,"_41":862,"_43":6722,"_67":6723,"_69":70,"_71":3618},"7Bbyb9tf",{"_194":195,"_3508":3616},[],{"_33":6725,"_35":6726},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6727,"_41":862,"_43":6728,"_67":6729,"_69":6730,"_71":70},"Y_HcM7xM",{},[],"We eventually built about 10 of the machines, and though in many senses an engineering success, what had to be done to make them had once again squeezed out the real end-users for whom it was originally aimed. If Xerox (and PARC) as a whole had believed in these smaller scale ideas, we could have put much more silicon muscle behind the dreams and successfully built them in the 70's when they were first possible. It was a bitter disappointment to have to get the wrong kind of CPU from Intel and the wrong kind of display from HP because there was not enough corporate will to take advantage of internal technological expertise.",{"_33":6732,"_35":6733},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6734,"_41":862,"_43":6735,"_67":6736,"_69":6742,"_71":70},"lek5lPu2",{},[6737],{"_37":3795,"_233":6738,"_238":6740,"_43":6741,"_71":70},[6739],223,[6548],{},"By now it was already 1979, and we found ourselves doing one of our many demos, but this time for a very interested audience: Steve Jobs, Jef Raskin, and other technical people from Apple. They had started a project called Lisa but weren't quite sure what it should be like, until Jef said to Steve, \"You should really come over to PARC and see what they are doing.\" Thus, more than eight years after overlapping windows had been invented and more than six years after the ALTO started running, the people who could really do something about the ideas, finally got to to see them. The machine used was the Dorado, a very fast \"big brother\" of the ALTO, whose Smalltalk microcode had been largely written by Bruce Horn, one of our original \"Smalltalk kids\" who was still only a teen-ager. Larry Tesler gave the main part of the demo with Dan sitting in the copilot's chair and Adele and I watched from the rear. One of the best parts of the demo was when Steve Jobs said he didn't like the blt-style scrolling we were using and asked if we could do it in a smooth continuous style. In less than a minute Dan found the methods involved, made the (relatively major) changes and scrolling was now continuous! This shocked the visitors, especially the programmers among them, as they had never seen a really powerful incremental system before.",{"_33":6744,"_35":6745},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6746,"_41":862,"_43":6747,"_67":6748,"_69":6754,"_71":70},"WZpuQaUx",{},[6749],{"_37":3795,"_233":6750,"_238":6751,"_43":6753,"_71":70},[6187],[6752],251,{},"Steve tried to get and/or buy the technology from Xerox (which was one of Apple's minority venture capitalists), but Xerox would neither part with it nor would come up with the resources to continue to develop it in house by funding a better NoteTaker cum Smalltalk.",{"_33":6756,"_35":6757},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6758,"_41":862,"_43":6759,"_67":6760,"_69":5643,"_71":70},"szD7SHPC",{},[],{"_33":6762,"_35":6763},[],{"_37":190,"_39":6764,"_41":862,"_43":6765,"_67":6766,"_69":6767,"_71":70},"4iHJG8Gz",{},[],"VI. 1980-83—The release version of Smalltalk (-80)",{"_33":6769,"_35":6770},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6771,"_41":862,"_43":6772,"_67":6773,"_69":6774,"_71":70},"zroYrYsb",{},[],"\"The greatest sin in Art is not Boredom,\nas is commonly supposed, but lack of\nProportion\" — Paul Hindemith",{"_33":6776,"_35":6777},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6778,"_41":862,"_43":6779,"_67":6780,"_69":6787,"_71":70},"jDx_rGuK",{},[6781],{"_37":3795,"_233":6782,"_238":6784,"_43":6786,"_71":70},[4098,6783],1011,[4033,6785],1015,{},"As Dan said \"the decision not to continue the NoteTaker project added motivation to release Smalltalk widely.\" But not for me. By this time I was both happy about the cleanliness and elegance of the Smalltalk conception as realized by Dan and the others, and sad that it was farther away than ever from the children—it came to me as a shock that no child had programmed in any Smalltalk since Smalltalk-76 made its debut. Xerox (and PARC) were now into \"workstations\" as things in themselves—but I still wanted \"playstations\". The romance of the Dynabook seemed less within grasp, paradoxically just when the various needed technologies were starting to be commercially feasible—some of them, unfortunately, like the flat-screen display, abandoned to the Japanese by the US companies who had invented them. This was a major case of \"snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.\" Larry Tesler decided that Xerox was never going to \"get it\" and was hired by Steve Jobs in May 1980 to be a principal designer of the Lisa. I agreed, had a sabbatical coming, and took it.",{"_33":6789,"_35":6790},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6791,"_41":862,"_43":6792,"_67":6793,"_69":6794,"_71":70},"jYK2aMNY",{},[],"Adele decided to drive the documentation and release process for a new Smalltalk that could be distributed widely almost regardless of the target hardware. Only a few changes had to be made to the NoteTaker Smalltalk-78 to make a releasable system. Perhaps the change that was most ironic was to turn the custom fonts that made Smalltalk more readable (and were a hallmark of the entire PARC culture) back into standard pedestrian ASCII characters. According to Peter Deutsch this \"met with heated opposition within the group at the time, but has turned out to be essential for the acceptance of the system in the world.\" Another change was to make blocks more like lambda expressions which, as Peter Deutsch was to observe nine years later: \"In retrospect, this proliferation of different kinds of instantiations and scoping was probably a bad idea.\" The most puzzling strange idea—at least to me as a new outsider—was the introduction of metaclasses (really just to make instance initialization a little easier—a very minor improvement over what Smalltalk-76 did quite reasonably already). Peter's 1989 comment is typical and true: \"metaclasses have proven confusing to many users, and perhaps in the balance more confusing than valuable.\" In fact, in their PIE system, Goldstein and Bobrow had already implemented in Smalltalk an \"observer language\", somewhat following the view-oriented approach I had been advocating and in some ways like the \"perspectives\" proposed in KRL [Goldstein *]. Once one can view an instance via multiple perspectives even \"semi-metaclasses\" like Class Class and Class Object are not really necessary since the object-role and instance-of-a-class-role are just different views and it is easy to deal with life-history issues including instantiation. This was there for the taking (along with quite a few other good ideas), but it wasn't adopted. My guess is that Smalltalk had moved into the final phase I mentioned at the beginning of this story, in which a way of doing things finally gets canonized into an inflexible belief structure.",{"_33":6796,"_35":6797},[],{"_37":190,"_39":6798,"_41":862,"_43":6799,"_67":6800,"_69":4123,"_71":70},"Pk4yEWv3",{},[],{"_33":6802,"_35":6803},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6804,"_41":862,"_43":6805,"_67":6806,"_69":6807,"_71":70},"11K1-27u",{},[],"One final comment. Hardware is really just software crystallized early. It is there to make program schemes run as efficiently as possible. But far too often the hardware has been presented as a given and it is up to software designers to make it appear reasonable. This has caused low-level techniques and excessive optimization to hold back progress in program design. As Bob Barton used to say: \"Systems programmers are high priests of a low cult.\"",{"_33":6809,"_35":6810},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6811,"_41":862,"_43":6812,"_67":6813,"_69":6819,"_71":70},"ZGR6iXFH",{},[6814],{"_37":3795,"_233":6815,"_238":6816,"_43":6818,"_71":70},[235],[6817],104,{},"One way to think about progress in software is that a lot of it has been about finding ways to late-bind, then waging campaigns to convince manufacturers to build the ideas into hardware. Early hardware had wired programs and parameters; random access memory was a scheme to late-bind them. Looping and indexing used to be done by address modification in storage; index registers were a way to late-bind. Over the years software designers have found ways to late-bind the locations of computations—this led to base/bounds registers, segment relocation, page MMUs, migratory processes, and so forth. Time-sharing was held back for years because it was \"inefficient\"— but the manufacturers wouldn't put MMUs on the machines, universities had to do it themselves! Recursion late-binds parameters to procedures, but it took years to get even rudimentary stack mechanisms into CPUs. Most machines still have no support for dynamic allocation and garbage collection and so forth. In short, most hardware designs today are just re-optimizations of moribund architectures.",{"_33":6821,"_35":6822},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6823,"_41":862,"_43":6824,"_67":6825,"_69":6839,"_71":70},"Ekbn1O0w",{},[6826],{"_37":3795,"_233":6827,"_238":6833,"_43":6838,"_71":70},[5996,6828,6829,6830,6831,6832,5941],179,203,225,234,256,[4848,6834,5808,6835,6836,6837,5768],184,229,237,261,{},"From the late-binding perspective, OOP can be viewed as a comprehensive technique for late-binding as many things as possible: the mix of state and process in a set of behaviors, where they are located, what they are called, when and why they are invoked, which HW is used, etc., and more subtle, the strategies used in the OOP scheme itself. The art of the wrap is the art of the trap.",{"_33":6841,"_35":6842},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6843,"_41":862,"_43":6844,"_67":6845,"_69":6861,"_71":70},"BIy5ekKY",{},[6846,6856],{"_37":3795,"_233":6847,"_238":6851,"_43":6855,"_71":70},[6441,6848,6849,6850],148,154,327,[6852,5058,6853,6854],122,155,330,{},{"_37":4625,"_233":6857,"_238":6858,"_43":6860,"_71":70},[283],[6859],135,{},"Consider the two cases that must be handled efficiently in order to completely wrap objects. It would be terrible if a + b incurred any overhead if a and b were bound, say, to \"3\" and \"4\" in a form that could be handled by the ALU. The operations should occur full speed using look-aside logic (in the simplest scheme a single and gate) to trap if the operands aren't compatible with the ALU. Now all elementary operations that have to happen fast have been wrapped without slowing down the machine.",{"_33":6863,"_35":6864},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6865,"_41":862,"_43":6866,"_67":6867,"_69":6874,"_71":70},"JZ7xhBWn",{},[6868],{"_37":3795,"_233":6869,"_238":6871,"_43":6873,"_71":70},[6870],342,[6872],357,{},"The second case happens if the trap has determined the objects in questions are too complicated for the ALU. Now the HW has to dynamically find a method that can handle the objects. This is very similar to indexing—the class of one of the objects is \"indexed\" by the desired method-selector in a slightly more general way. In other words the virtual-address of a method is . Since most HW today does a virtual address translation of some kind to find the real address—a trap—it is quite possible to hide the overhead of the OOP dispatch in the MMU overhead that has already been rationalized.",{"_33":6876,"_35":6877},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6878,"_41":862,"_43":6879,"_67":6880,"_69":6894,"_71":70},"OTq2nRpc",{},[6881,6887],{"_37":4625,"_233":6882,"_238":6883,"_43":6886,"_71":70},[5379,6543,4812],[6884,6829,6885],36,280,{},{"_37":3795,"_233":6888,"_238":6891,"_43":6893,"_71":70},[6889,6890],68,150,[6372,6892],156,{},"Again, the whole point of OOP is not to have to worry about what is inside an object. Objects made on different machines and with different languages should be able to talk to each other—and will have to in the future. Late-binding here involves trapping incompatibilities into recompatibility methods—a good discussion of some of the issues is found in [Popek 1984].",{"_33":6896,"_35":6897},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6898,"_41":862,"_43":6899,"_67":6900,"_69":6912,"_71":70},"RfgJanN4",{},[6901,6906],{"_37":3795,"_233":6902,"_238":6903,"_43":6905,"_71":70},[6828],[6904],198,{},{"_37":4625,"_233":6907,"_238":6909,"_43":6911,"_71":70},[6908],402,[6910],407,{},"Staying with the metaphor of late-binding, what further late-binding schemes might we expect to see? One of the nicest late-binding schemes that is being experimented with is the metaobject protocol work at Xerox PARC [Kiczales 1991]. The notion is that the language designer's choice for the internal representation of instances, variables, etc., may not cover what the implementer needs, so within a fixed semantics they allow the implementer to give the system strategies—for example, using a hashed lookup for slots in an instance instead of direct indexing. These are then efficiently compiled and extend the base implementation of the system. This is a direct descendant of similar directions from the past of Simula, FLEX, CDL, Smalltalk, and Actors.",{"_33":6914,"_35":6915},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6916,"_41":862,"_43":6917,"_67":6918,"_69":6925,"_71":70},"j4RjKi-K",{},[6919],{"_37":3795,"_233":6920,"_238":6922,"_43":6924,"_71":70},[6921],491,[6923],500,{},"Another late-binding scheme that is already necessary is to get away from direct protocol matching when a new object shows up in a system of objects. In other words, if someone sends you an object from halfway around the world it will be unusual if it conforms to your local protocols. At some point it will be easier to have it carry even more information about itself—enough so its specifications can be \"understood\" and its configuration into your mix done by the more subtle matching of inference.",{"_33":6927,"_35":6928},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6929,"_41":862,"_43":6930,"_67":6931,"_69":6938,"_71":70},"-dAOPnr0",{},[6932],{"_37":232,"_233":6933,"_238":6935,"_43":6937,"_71":70},[6934],189,[6936],324,{},"A look beyond OOP as we know it today can also be done by thinking about late-binding. Prolog's great idea is that it doesn't need binding to values in order to carry out computations [Col ]. The variable is an object and a web of partial results can be built to be filled in when a binding is finally found. Eurisko [Lenat ] constructs its methods—and modifies its basic strategies—as it tries to solve a problem. Instead of a problem looking for methods, the methods look for problems—and Eurisko looks for the methods of the methods. This has been called \"opportunistic programming\"—I think of it as a drive for more enlightenment, in which problems get resolved as part of the process.",{"_33":6940,"_35":6941},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6942,"_41":862,"_43":6943,"_67":6944,"_69":6957,"_71":70},"lOTjAuvJ",{},[6945,6951],{"_37":3795,"_233":6946,"_238":6948,"_43":6950,"_71":70},[6947],546,[6949],557,{},{"_37":232,"_233":6952,"_238":6954,"_43":6956,"_71":70},[6953],644,[6955],653,{},"This higher computational finesse will be needed as the next paradigm shift—that of pervasive networking—takes place over the next five years. Objects will gradually become active agents and will travel the networks in search of useful information and tools for their managers. Objects brought back into a computational environment from halfway around the world will not be able to configure themselves by direct protocol matching as do objects today. Instead, the objects will carry much more information about themselves in a form that permits inferential docking. Some of the ongoing work in specification can be turned to this task [Guttag ][Goguen ].",{"_33":6959,"_35":6960},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6961,"_41":862,"_43":6962,"_67":6963,"_69":6964,"_71":70},"Cufrw-mS",{},[],"Tongue in cheek, I once characterized progress in programming languages as kind of \"sunspot\" theory, in which major advances took place about every 11 years. We started with machine code in 1950, then in 1956 FORTRAN came along as a \"better old thing\" which if looked at as \"almost a new thing\" became the precursor of ALGOL-60 in 1961. In 1966, SIMULA was the \"better old thing,\" which if looked at as \"almost a new thing\" became the precursor of Smalltalk in 1972.",{"_33":6966,"_35":6967},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6968,"_41":862,"_43":6969,"_67":6970,"_69":6971,"_71":70},"kSjfTBEx",{},[],"Everything seemed set up to confirm the \"theory\" once more: in 1978 Eurisko was in place as the \"better old thing\" that was \"almost a new thing\". But 1983—and the whole decade—came and went without the \"new thing\". Of course, such a theory is silly anyway—and yet, I think the enormous commercialization of personal computing has smothered much of the kind of work that used to go on in universities and research labs, by sucking the talented kids towards practical applications. With companies so risk-adverse towards doing their own HW, and the HW companies betraying no real understanding of SW, the result has been a great step backwards in most respects.",{"_33":6973,"_35":6974},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6975,"_41":862,"_43":6976,"_67":6977,"_69":6983,"_71":70},"FM1FfIfr",{},[6978],{"_37":3795,"_233":6979,"_238":6981,"_43":6982,"_71":70},[6980],93,[4692],{},"A twentieth century problem is that technology has become too \"easy\". When it was hard to do anything whether good or bad, enough time was taken so that the result was usually good. Now we can make things almost trivially, especially in software, but most of the designs are trivial as well. This is inverse vandalism: the making of things because you can. Couple this to even less sophisticated buyers and you have generated an exploitation marketplace similar to that set up for teenagers. A counter to this is to generate enormous dissatisfaction with one's designs using the entire history of human art as a standard and goal. Then the trick is to decouple the dissatisfaction from self worth—otherwise it is either too depressing or one stops too soon with trivial results.",{"_33":6985,"_35":6986},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":6987,"_41":862,"_43":6988,"_67":6989,"_69":70,"_71":3565},"KE0xuR8o",{"_194":195,"_3508":3563},[],{"_33":6991,"_35":6992},[],{"_37":199,"_39":6993,"_41":862,"_43":6994,"_67":6995,"_69":7003,"_71":70},"45QynNtU",{},[6996],{"_37":3795,"_233":6997,"_238":7000,"_43":7002,"_71":70},[6998,6999],120,403,[4847,7001],408,{},"I will leave the story of early Smalltalk in 1981 when an extensive series of articles on Smalltalk-80 was published in Byte magazine, [Byte 1981] followed by Adele's and Dave Robson's books [Goldberg 1983] and the official release of the system in 1983. Now programmers could easily implement the virtual machine without having to reinvent it, and, in several cases, groups were able to roll their own image of basic classes. In spite of having to run almost everywhere on moribund HW architectures, Smalltalk has proliferated amazingly well (in part because of tremendous optimization efforts on these machines) [Deutsch 83]. As far as I can tell, it still seems to be the most widely used system that claims to be object-oriented. It is incredible to me that no one since has come up with a qualitatively better idea that is as simple, elegant, easy to program, practical, and comprehensive. (It's a pity that we didn't know about PROLOG then or vice versa, the combinations of the two languages done subsequently are quite intriguing.)",{"_33":7005,"_35":7006},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7007,"_41":862,"_43":7008,"_67":7009,"_69":7010,"_71":70},"S2vBgEXJ",{},[],"While justly applauding Dan, Adele and the others that made Smalltalk possible, we must wonder at the same time: where are the Dans and the Adeles of the '80s and '90s that will take us to the next stage?",{"_33":7012,"_35":7013},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7014,"_41":862,"_43":7015,"_67":7016,"_69":70,"_71":3557},"NTNhqFl8",{"_194":195,"_3508":3555},[],[55],"/private-notes/the-early-history-of-smalltalk",{"_83":878,"_879":880},{},{"_39":859,"_97":55,"_56":7022,"_72":862,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,861],1772124423744,[151,859,862],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/the-early-history-of-smalltalk\",\"bafy2bzacecjoy45pfstjoybf47gnkham5nxahhznif2nx2645gqpfhck4hp4s\"]",{"_112":7027,"_149":7178,"_152":7179},{"_114":7028,"_133":134,"_135":7177,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7029,"_39":7175},{"_30":7030,"_72":886,"_73":55,"_74":7170,"_56":7171,"_77":895,"_79":7172,"_81":7173,"_86":7174,"_88":896,"_90":91},[7031,7044,7051,7058,7065,7072,7079,7086,7100],{"_33":7032,"_35":7033},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7034,"_41":7035,"_43":7036,"_67":7037,"_69":7043,"_71":70},"FeCkaY8N","bafy2bzacea3456sy6rjzwijdyxsx4t3mrsedpt5rujnw32jyg2g2bphm6iehi",{},[7038],{"_37":286,"_233":7039,"_238":7040,"_43":7041,"_71":7042},[139],[4157],{},"https://youtu.be/8_DfwEpHE88?si=T9dE8Uq-PPMmSuUQ&t=1345","Martin Kleppman Codemesh 2016",{"_33":7045,"_35":7046},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7047,"_41":896,"_43":7048,"_67":7049,"_69":7050,"_71":70},"XK3qiLeQ",{},[],"How Google Docs works. Funnel all the operations through one server.",{"_33":7052,"_35":7053},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7054,"_41":896,"_43":7055,"_67":7056,"_69":70,"_71":7057},"Qjy5d5LT",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeie2urocjvgfxsnn42dc647ws3ykekcb7rmm45uvglmtwagbcanggi",{"_33":7059,"_35":7060},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7061,"_41":896,"_43":7062,"_67":7063,"_69":70,"_71":7064},"bO2ubGL_",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeiegtrg2gpq2wagc637mo3t7evlnwwlvghlguyeewmm3a2gu24jjre",{"_33":7066,"_35":7067},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7068,"_41":896,"_43":7069,"_67":7070,"_69":7071,"_71":70},"fuIsrvy2",{},[],"Another option. CRDTs:",{"_33":7073,"_35":7074},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7075,"_41":896,"_43":7076,"_67":7077,"_69":70,"_71":7078},"lyK2wwdK",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeicunbfrkarm6tjumvkhv6okzrbehc45xlsneeba7vwqdkdv4672z4",{"_33":7080,"_35":7081},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7082,"_41":896,"_43":7083,"_67":7084,"_69":70,"_71":7085},"isreyVpZ",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeih35unale56nubnaamngiavdzdwiiyzjahaulemxqdowesgcm2tr4",{"_33":7087,"_35":7095},[7088],{"_33":7089,"_35":7090},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7091,"_41":896,"_43":7092,"_67":7093,"_69":70,"_71":7094},"l63QryB8",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeifczzfsrkpxm6tniamfyzp7ocm6ul4hyxhakiwgwtvyof6jvla3ym",{"_37":199,"_39":7096,"_41":896,"_43":7097,"_67":7098,"_69":7099,"_71":70},"W7EawtB2",{"_194":195},[],"Tombstone",{"_33":7101,"_35":7165},[7102,7109,7116,7123,7130,7137],{"_33":7103,"_35":7104},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7105,"_41":7035,"_43":7106,"_67":7107,"_69":70,"_71":7108},"o5tNUTWT",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeiay7shklcqxzutjhtcazyahr7hcrvblxuj6hqxygxhl7r7267g5gu",{"_33":7110,"_35":7111},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7112,"_41":7035,"_43":7113,"_67":7114,"_69":70,"_71":7115},"_qn77-Fm",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeiawlph7poyjnjj34nlrsjtmai5ehfo6z7lvrjvtncuykctasjiv34",{"_33":7117,"_35":7118},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7119,"_41":7035,"_43":7120,"_67":7121,"_69":70,"_71":7122},"6AuAMrE-",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeibnaz76qoa3sys6hhq7f35gjy3szrewbe2a46bnzsifkj5n7foshi",{"_33":7124,"_35":7125},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7126,"_41":7035,"_43":7127,"_67":7128,"_69":70,"_71":7129},"WcUACvrP",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeiakhhazjwx6bh6vgkv7nspwbkxuigpuiaeygyt3aeqnlgbqc7yxqi",{"_33":7131,"_35":7132},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7133,"_41":7035,"_43":7134,"_67":7135,"_69":70,"_71":7136},"XazL5XEl",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeigrqmmblwb446xw27ehtx2p445w7rkxln54lqqna7pvjbno3ytks4",{"_33":7138,"_35":7160},[7139,7146,7153],{"_33":7140,"_35":7141},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7142,"_41":886,"_43":7143,"_67":7144,"_69":7145,"_71":70},"MuMPBp51",{},[],"A design methodology instead of describing updates to our database in terms of these mutable operations, we are going to have a log of events that describe in factual terms the thing that happened, and any state updates are then purely derived in some deterministic way from that log of immutable events.",{"_33":7147,"_35":7148},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7149,"_41":886,"_43":7150,"_67":7151,"_69":7152,"_71":70},"3V-3Z-K7",{},[],"For relational database business applications are that event sourcing was design around that works really well.",{"_33":7154,"_35":7155},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7156,"_41":886,"_43":7157,"_67":7158,"_69":7159,"_71":70},"Wt7wiavO",{},[],"In the document editing domain it is a human providing input into the system as I want to change this to a document. Thinks about the document as mutable thing. It is hard to translate the immutable paradigm to a document.",{"_37":190,"_39":7161,"_41":886,"_43":7162,"_67":7163,"_69":7164,"_71":70},"QSTl_lK-",{"_194":195},[],"Event Sourcing",{"_37":3505,"_39":7166,"_41":7035,"_43":7167,"_67":7168,"_69":70,"_71":7169},"9yqtM62g",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeibkopugusyjd4jvyzt33ytrclb2uvelem7w4i2e2tpwehmij5wxgi",[55],"/private-notes/document-crdt-overview-from-martin-kleppmann","2026-02-09T17:54:48.259Z",{"_83":909},{},{"_39":883,"_97":55,"_56":7176,"_72":886,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,885],1772124423036,[151,883,886],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/document-crdt-overview-from-martin-kleppmann\",\"bafy2bzacebhcl4vpfxeyx66nri4oqr26fn5sll6765jjimykc5bimmowkp4oq\"]",{"_112":7181,"_149":7200,"_152":7201},{"_114":7182,"_133":134,"_135":7199,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7183,"_39":7197},{"_30":7184,"_72":915,"_73":55,"_74":7193,"_56":7194,"_77":922,"_79":922,"_81":7195,"_86":7196,"_88":915,"_90":91},[7185],{"_33":7186,"_35":7187},[],{"_37":166,"_39":7188,"_41":915,"_43":7189,"_67":7191,"_69":70,"_71":7192},"ZGjzT1L4",{"_170":7190},"Content",[],"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/alan-kay-on-simplicity?v=bafy2bzaceb26442bzf6behywkepek5eyhcgrfxyup5apic2kbpqflpbnjbcqa#q-aLhY4E+",[55],"/private-notes/ideas-for-a-programming-framework-for-the-web",{"_83":936},{},{"_39":912,"_97":55,"_56":7198,"_72":915,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,914],1772124423112,[151,912,915],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/ideas-for-a-programming-framework-for-the-web\",\"bafy2bzaceby6jiotug42gwaaubf7cah7wxk4wbyurkdkasbqmhgdljagedt6w\"]",{"_112":7203,"_149":7337,"_152":7338},{"_114":7204,"_133":134,"_135":7336,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7205,"_39":7334},{"_30":7206,"_72":942,"_73":55,"_74":7329,"_56":7330,"_77":951,"_79":7331,"_81":7332,"_86":7333,"_88":952,"_90":91},[7207,7214,7235,7256,7291],{"_33":7208,"_35":7209},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7210,"_41":952,"_43":7211,"_67":7212,"_69":7213,"_71":70},"t24mxwLJ",{},[],"Novum organum, as suggested by its name, is focused just as much on a rejection of received doctrine as it is on a forward-looking progression. In Bacon's Idols are found his most critical examination of man-made impediments which mislead the mind's objective reasoning. They appear in previous works but were never fully fleshed out until their formulation in Novum organum:",{"_33":7215,"_35":7230},[7216,7223],{"_33":7217,"_35":7218},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7219,"_41":952,"_43":7220,"_67":7221,"_69":7222,"_71":70},"GT0HUJQh",{},[],"\"Idols of the Tribe are rooted in human nature itself and in the very tribe or race of men. For people falsely claim that human sense is the measure of things, whereas in fact all perceptions of sense and mind are built to the scale of man and not the universe.\" (Aphorism 41).",{"_33":7224,"_35":7225},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7226,"_41":952,"_43":7227,"_67":7228,"_69":7229,"_71":70},"HDgBI1tp",{},[],"Bacon includes in this idol the predilection of the human imagination to presuppose otherwise unsubstantiated regularities in nature. An example might be the common historical astronomical assumption that planets move in perfect circles.",{"_37":190,"_39":7231,"_41":952,"_43":7232,"_67":7233,"_69":7234,"_71":70},"AMPBo6Je",{"_194":195},[],"Idols of the Tribe (Idola tribus)",{"_33":7236,"_35":7251},[7237,7244],{"_33":7238,"_35":7239},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7240,"_41":952,"_43":7241,"_67":7242,"_69":7243,"_71":70},"jXY0HnIx",{},[],"These \"belong to the particular individual. For everyone has (besides vagaries of human nature in general) his own special cave or den which scatters and discolours the light of nature. Now this comes either of his own unique and singular nature; or his education and association with others, or the books he reads and the several authorities of those whom he cultivates and admires, or the different impressions as they meet in the soul, be the soul possessed and prejudiced, or steady and settled, or the like; so that the human spirit (as it is allotted to particular individuals) is evidently a variable thing, all muddled, and so to speak a creature of chance...\" (Aphorism 42).",{"_33":7245,"_35":7246},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7247,"_41":952,"_43":7248,"_67":7249,"_69":7250,"_71":70},"BfA8NCSm",{},[],"This type of idol stems from the particular life experiences of the individual. Variable educations can lead the individual to a preference for specific concepts or methods, which then corrupt their subsequent philosophies. Bacon himself gives the example of Aristotle, \"who made his natural philosophy a mere slave to his logic\" (Aphorism 54).",{"_37":190,"_39":7252,"_41":952,"_43":7253,"_67":7254,"_69":7255,"_71":70},"LWPRKk8O",{"_194":195},[],"Idols of the Cave (Idola specus)",{"_33":7257,"_35":7286},[7258,7265,7272,7279],{"_33":7259,"_35":7260},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7261,"_41":952,"_43":7262,"_67":7263,"_69":7264,"_71":70},"s0OcSqo8",{},[],"These are \"derived as if from the mutual agreement and association of the human race, which I call Idols of the Market on account of men's commerce and partnerships. For men associate through conversation, but words are applied according to the capacity of ordinary people. Therefore shoddy and inept application of words lays siege to the intellect in wondrous ways\" (Aphorism 43).",{"_33":7266,"_35":7267},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7268,"_41":952,"_43":7269,"_67":7270,"_69":7271,"_71":70},"b09MLxiQ",{},[],"Bacon considered these \"the greatest nuisances of them all\" (Aphorism 59). Because humans reason through the use of words they are particularly dangerous, because the received definitions of words, which are often falsely derived, can cause confusion. He outlines two subsets of this kind of idol and provides examples (Aphorism 60).",{"_33":7273,"_35":7274},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7275,"_41":952,"_43":7276,"_67":7277,"_69":7278,"_71":70},"cgChWYqF",{},[],"First, there are those words which spring from fallacious theories, such as the element of fire or the concept of a first mover. These are easy to dismantle because their inadequacy can be traced back to the fault of their derivation in a faulty theory.",{"_33":7280,"_35":7281},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7282,"_41":952,"_43":7283,"_67":7284,"_69":7285,"_71":70},"wA8rGdee",{},[],"Second, there are those words that are the result of imprecise abstraction. Earth, for example, is a vague term that may include many different substances the commonality of which is questionable. These terms are often used elliptically, or from a lack of information or definition of the term.",{"_37":190,"_39":7287,"_41":952,"_43":7288,"_67":7289,"_69":7290,"_71":70},"Jvmhf1Ge",{"_194":195},[],"Idols of the Market (Idola fori)",{"_33":7292,"_35":7324},[7293,7300,7307],{"_33":7294,"_35":7295},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7296,"_41":952,"_43":7297,"_67":7298,"_69":7299,"_71":70},"ECaASgXS",{},[],"\"Lastly, there are the Idols which have misguided into men's souls from the dogmas of the philosophers and misguided laws of demonstration as well; I call these Idols of the Theatre, for in my eyes the philosophies received and discovered are so many stories made up and acted out stories which have created sham worlds worth of the stage.\" (Aphorism 44).",{"_33":7301,"_35":7302},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7303,"_41":952,"_43":7304,"_67":7305,"_69":7306,"_71":70},"Zc1EnRPR",{},[],"These idols manifest themselves in the unwise acceptance of certain philosophical dogmas, namely Aristotle's sophistical natural philosophy (named specifically in Aphorism 63), which was corrupted by his passion for logic, and Plato's superstitious philosophy, which relied too heavily on theological principles.",{"_33":7308,"_35":7320},[7309],{"_33":7310,"_35":7311},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7312,"_41":942,"_43":7313,"_67":7314,"_69":7319,"_71":70},"4qbcbqL5",{},[7315],{"_37":286,"_233":7316,"_238":7317,"_43":7318,"_71":7319},[139],[4098],{},"https://fs.blog/francis-bacon-four-idols-mind/",{"_37":190,"_39":7321,"_41":942,"_43":7322,"_67":7323,"_69":2386,"_71":70},"CpZCvHVg",{"_194":195},[],{"_37":190,"_39":7325,"_41":952,"_43":7326,"_67":7327,"_69":7328,"_71":70},"Wiqgona6",{"_194":195},[],"Idols of the Theatre (Idola theatri)",[55],"/private-notes/francis-bacon-novum-organum","2026-02-09T16:45:30.232Z",{"_83":961},{},{"_39":939,"_97":55,"_56":7335,"_72":942,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,941],1772124423083,[151,939,942],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/francis-bacon-novum-organum\",\"bafy2bzaceaz2gyzvtbauji5vk572mkkebibu25orppsxw5jjxc4jiayfsnwn6\"]",{"_112":7340,"_149":7383,"_152":7384},{"_114":7341,"_133":134,"_135":7382,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7342,"_39":7380},{"_30":7343,"_72":967,"_73":55,"_74":7376,"_56":7377,"_77":974,"_79":974,"_81":7378,"_86":7379,"_88":967,"_90":91},[7344,7356,7363],{"_33":7345,"_35":7346},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7347,"_41":967,"_43":7348,"_67":7349,"_69":7355,"_71":70},"sG72lg4x",{},[7350],{"_37":286,"_233":7351,"_238":7352,"_43":7353,"_71":7354},[2395],[5381],{},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/francis-bacon-novum-organum#jXY0HnIx","I mentioned Francis Bacon's four idols from his book, The New Organization of Science. Philosophical structure that underpinned the invention of Science. Scientists don't give you science because science needs other people to debug. You need to have a social system to debug your ideas.",{"_33":7357,"_35":7358},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7359,"_41":967,"_43":7360,"_67":7361,"_69":7362,"_71":70},"Ve93_BJX",{},[],"He defined a set of heuristics for getting around our bad brains. A Set of methods to think more clearly. This is how any scholarly system should work.",{"_33":7364,"_35":7365},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7366,"_41":967,"_43":7367,"_67":7368,"_69":7375,"_71":70},"cj-N4Enf",{},[7369],{"_37":286,"_233":7370,"_238":7371,"_43":7373,"_71":7374},[3776],[7372],23,{},"https://youtu.be/fhOHn9TClXY?si=nhGotev1STz03P8i&t=3839","Interview with Alan Kay.",[55],"/private-notes/scientists-dont-give-you-science",{"_83":983,"_879":984},{},{"_39":964,"_97":55,"_56":7381,"_72":967,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,966],1772124423185,[151,964,967],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/scientists-dont-give-you-science\",\"bafy2bzacednmb2dmdhqq2wfihebikuwmecxut6jdg56oyl67mcpl6i7ectoi2\"]",{"_112":7386,"_149":7427,"_152":7428},{"_114":7387,"_133":134,"_135":7426,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7388,"_39":7424},{"_30":7389,"_72":990,"_73":55,"_74":7419,"_56":7420,"_77":999,"_79":7421,"_81":7422,"_86":7423,"_88":1000,"_90":91},[7390,7397,7404,7412],{"_33":7391,"_35":7392},[],{"_37":3447,"_39":7393,"_41":1000,"_43":7394,"_67":7395,"_69":70,"_71":7396},"k5OBXzgt",{"_194":195},[],"https://www.youtube.com/embed/aXC19T5sJ1U",{"_33":7398,"_35":7399},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7400,"_41":1000,"_43":7401,"_67":7402,"_69":7403,"_71":70},"oFWuH5M5",{},[],"As a system, I like the US Constitution because it is based on principles not it rules, allowing millions of incompatible parts interoperate without crashing.",{"_33":7405,"_35":7406},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7407,"_41":7408,"_43":7409,"_67":7410,"_69":7411,"_71":70},"jX_XuVLB","bafy2bzacebhklchcv3t4hzuqxtcstah7dhgzj7kvgrf44jubggfdhhst25zkk",{},[],"Engelbart was in another plane.",{"_33":7413,"_35":7414},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7415,"_41":990,"_43":7416,"_67":7417,"_69":7418,"_71":70},"q-aLhY4E",{},[],"The mental image here was: Wow It is all about Messages. The reasons about messages and not about objects so much is that the messages are the abstractions. min 45:20",[55],"/private-notes/alan-kay-on-simplicity","2026-02-02T21:26:11.491Z",{"_83":1013},{},{"_39":987,"_97":55,"_56":7425,"_72":990,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,989],1772124423192,[151,987,990],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/alan-kay-on-simplicity\",\"bafy2bzaceb26442bzf6behywkepek5eyhcgrfxyup5apic2kbpqflpbnjbcqa\"]",{"_112":7430,"_149":7441,"_152":7442},{"_114":7431,"_133":134,"_135":7440,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7432,"_39":7438},{"_30":7433,"_72":1019,"_73":55,"_74":7434,"_56":7435,"_77":1026,"_79":1026,"_81":7436,"_86":7437,"_88":1019,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/humans-are-the-bottleneck",{"_83":1035},{},{"_39":1016,"_97":55,"_56":7439,"_72":1019,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1018],1772124425262,[151,1016,1019],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/humans-are-the-bottleneck\",\"bafy2bzaceauvgzvbg7f43cpckqaaq23n5elsbsdwyzyfhwjkn7wid232vvklu\"]",{"_112":7444,"_149":7455,"_152":7456},{"_114":7445,"_133":134,"_135":7454,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7446,"_39":7452},{"_30":7447,"_72":1041,"_73":55,"_74":7448,"_56":7449,"_77":1048,"_79":1048,"_81":7450,"_86":7451,"_88":1041,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/education-and-ai",{"_83":1057},{},{"_39":1038,"_97":55,"_56":7453,"_72":1041,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1040],1772124423253,[151,1038,1041],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/education-and-ai\",\"bafy2bzacecgzc3o2y7uj3o6ycpcxowqusp2yql46gwldayqoxh6ilwpmi7keu\"]",{"_112":7458,"_149":7768,"_152":7769},{"_114":7459,"_133":134,"_135":7767,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7460,"_39":7765},{"_30":7461,"_72":1063,"_73":55,"_74":7760,"_56":7761,"_77":1072,"_79":7762,"_81":7763,"_86":7764,"_88":1073,"_90":91},[7462,7476,7483,7490,7496,7546,7595,7646,7676,7694,7700,7707,7713,7720,7726],{"_33":7463,"_35":7471},[7464],{"_33":7465,"_35":7466},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7467,"_41":1063,"_43":7468,"_67":7469,"_69":7470,"_71":70},"o1TboAcQ",{},[],"Twitter has the same ",{"_37":199,"_39":7472,"_41":1063,"_43":7473,"_67":7474,"_69":7475,"_71":70},"9kR3fT5j",{"_194":195},[],"What is the difference between a Comment Section and a feed?",{"_33":7477,"_35":7478},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7479,"_41":1063,"_43":7480,"_67":7481,"_69":7482,"_71":70},"kEP8XqQf",{},[],"Why should we have the Comment Box at the top or bottom?",{"_33":7484,"_35":7485},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7486,"_41":1063,"_43":7487,"_67":7488,"_69":7489,"_71":70},"VI__peDu",{},[],"Threads and Bluesky had incredible growth just by replicating the Twitter Feed. Should we do the same thing?",{"_33":7491,"_35":7492},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7493,"_41":1063,"_43":7494,"_67":7495,"_69":70,"_71":70},"yRlS8iKm",{},[],{"_33":7497,"_35":7536},[7498,7509,7525],{"_33":7499,"_35":7500},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7501,"_41":1063,"_43":7502,"_67":7503,"_69":7508,"_71":70},"lAaIsLEk",{},[7504],{"_37":232,"_233":7505,"_238":7506,"_43":7507,"_71":70},[139],[3776],{},"Primary action: Sending a message.",{"_33":7510,"_35":7511},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7512,"_41":1063,"_43":7513,"_67":7514,"_69":7524,"_71":70},"Kg15LPVC",{},[7515,7519],{"_37":3795,"_233":7516,"_238":7517,"_43":7518,"_71":70},[4120],[3776],{},{"_37":232,"_233":7520,"_238":7522,"_43":7523,"_71":70},[7521],42,[5511],{},"The comment box (message input) is at the bottom because that’s where your thumbs naturally rest on a phone, making it faster and more ergonomic for continuous conversation.",{"_33":7526,"_35":7527},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7528,"_41":1063,"_43":7529,"_67":7530,"_69":7535,"_71":70},"pfE_Glua",{},[7531],{"_37":232,"_233":7532,"_238":7533,"_43":7534,"_71":70},[2395],[5549],{},"The flow is read → type → send → read again, all in a single continuous vertical scroll anchored at the bottom.",{"_37":199,"_39":7537,"_41":1063,"_43":7538,"_67":7539,"_69":7545,"_71":70},"VpGDgIZI",{"_194":3876},[7540],{"_37":232,"_233":7541,"_238":7542,"_43":7544,"_71":70},[139],[7543],8,{},"WhatsApp",{"_33":7547,"_35":7586},[7548,7574],{"_33":7549,"_35":7565},[7550],{"_33":7551,"_35":7552},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7553,"_41":1063,"_43":7554,"_67":7555,"_69":7564,"_71":70},"5rrq2TYo",{},[7556,7560],{"_37":232,"_233":7557,"_238":7558,"_43":7559,"_71":70},[4185],[4033],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":7561,"_238":7562,"_43":7563,"_71":70},[6367],[5723],{},"The comment box is often at the top of the comment list (under the post) so you can respond before scrolling through other comments, or after reading the post headline/content.",{"_37":199,"_39":7566,"_41":1063,"_43":7567,"_67":7568,"_69":7573,"_71":70},"vuuts0WV",{"_194":3876},[7569],{"_37":232,"_233":7570,"_238":7571,"_43":7572,"_71":70},[139],[3776],{},"Primary action: Consuming content first.",{"_33":7575,"_35":7576},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7577,"_41":1063,"_43":7578,"_67":7579,"_69":7585,"_71":70},"h8beRXAc",{},[7580],{"_37":232,"_233":7581,"_238":7582,"_43":7584,"_71":70},[2395],[7583],88,{},"The flow is read the post → decide to comment → optionally scroll through other comments. The positioning encourages engagement without forcing you to see every other comment first.",{"_37":199,"_39":7587,"_41":1063,"_43":7588,"_67":7589,"_69":7594,"_71":70},"SOrKG8ff",{"_194":3876},[7590],{"_37":232,"_233":7591,"_238":7592,"_43":7593,"_71":70},[139],[3802],{},"Facebook (posts & comments)",{"_33":7596,"_35":7637},[7597,7608,7619,7626],{"_33":7598,"_35":7599},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7600,"_41":1063,"_43":7601,"_67":7602,"_69":7607,"_71":70},"lIcMieU5",{},[7603],{"_37":232,"_233":7604,"_238":7605,"_43":7606,"_71":70},[139],[3776],{},"Primary action: Reading the post and its context first.",{"_33":7609,"_35":7610},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7611,"_41":1063,"_43":7612,"_67":7613,"_69":7618,"_71":70},"r-sdUoeK",{},[7614],{"_37":232,"_233":7615,"_238":7616,"_43":7617,"_71":70},[4096],[4035],{},"Reddit’s design assumes you want to see the original post before writing your own comment.",{"_33":7620,"_35":7621},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7622,"_41":1063,"_43":7623,"_67":7624,"_69":7625,"_71":70},"2nlHFAAt",{},[],"The comment input is right under the post (above all other comments) so you can reply immediately without scrolling past potentially hundreds of comments.",{"_33":7627,"_35":7628},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7629,"_41":1063,"_43":7630,"_67":7631,"_69":7636,"_71":70},"Mnbo7afv",{},[7632],{"_37":232,"_233":7633,"_238":7634,"_43":7635,"_71":70},[5288],[4098],{},"This also subtly encourages top-level comments, which help start new discussion branches, rather than burying new contributions deep in the thread.",{"_37":199,"_39":7638,"_41":1063,"_43":7639,"_67":7640,"_69":7645,"_71":70},"nrCiH8TW",{"_194":3876},[7641],{"_37":232,"_233":7642,"_238":7643,"_43":7644,"_71":70},[139],[4839],{},"Why Reddit puts the comment box at the top of the thread",{"_33":7647,"_35":7667},[7648,7655],{"_33":7649,"_35":7650},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7651,"_41":1063,"_43":7652,"_67":7653,"_69":7654,"_71":70},"PKJQ4bko",{},[],"Facebook threads are usually shorter and more conversational, so the “comment at top” is about quick engagement.",{"_33":7656,"_35":7657},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7658,"_41":1063,"_43":7659,"_67":7660,"_69":7666,"_71":70},"Pk5s1fE0",{},[7661],{"_37":232,"_233":7662,"_238":7663,"_43":7665,"_71":70},[3880],[7664],81,{},"Reddit threads can be huge, so the “comment at top” is also a navigation shortcut for people who just want to contribute without reading it all.",{"_37":199,"_39":7668,"_41":1063,"_43":7669,"_67":7670,"_69":7675,"_71":70},"zfBNuqv6",{"_194":3876},[7671],{"_37":232,"_233":7672,"_238":7673,"_43":7674,"_71":70},[139],[3971],{},"Difference from Facebook",{"_33":7677,"_35":7685},[7678],{"_33":7679,"_35":7680},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7681,"_41":1063,"_43":7682,"_67":7683,"_69":70,"_71":7684},"NkO0lKzf",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreif6e3exk3yfnwmvujgfj6eoiuaychmtb2cflfclthcrkhg5lmdhmu",{"_37":199,"_39":7686,"_41":1063,"_43":7687,"_67":7688,"_69":7693,"_71":70},"cRUAjPQj",{"_194":195},[7689],{"_37":232,"_233":7690,"_238":7691,"_43":7692,"_71":70},[139],[931],{},"Twitter",{"_33":7695,"_35":7696},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7697,"_41":1063,"_43":7698,"_67":7699,"_69":70,"_71":70},"CJzpFKUS",{},[],{"_33":7701,"_35":7702},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7703,"_41":1063,"_43":7704,"_67":7705,"_69":7706,"_71":70},"5Ry5nkgc",{},[],"Hypothesis",{"_33":7708,"_35":7709},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7710,"_41":1063,"_43":7711,"_67":7712,"_69":70,"_71":70},"XCukuS38",{},[],{"_33":7714,"_35":7715},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7716,"_41":1063,"_43":7717,"_67":7718,"_69":7719,"_71":70},"Z4YaEZ8p",{},[],"Async versus Sync",{"_33":7721,"_35":7722},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7723,"_41":1063,"_43":7724,"_67":7725,"_69":70,"_71":70},"aoj_DAb3",{},[],{"_33":7727,"_35":7755},[7728,7735,7742,7749],{"_33":7729,"_35":7730},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7731,"_41":1063,"_43":7732,"_67":7733,"_69":7734,"_71":70},"TnL_NOJI",{},[],"0-100",{"_33":7736,"_35":7737},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7738,"_41":1063,"_43":7739,"_67":7740,"_69":7741,"_71":70},"oinrsieu",{},[],"100-1000",{"_33":7743,"_35":7744},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7745,"_41":1063,"_43":7746,"_67":7747,"_69":7748,"_71":70},"rbKJVm-7",{},[],"1000-1000",{"_33":7750,"_35":7751},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7752,"_41":1063,"_43":7753,"_67":7754,"_69":70,"_71":70},"YImc_Rih",{},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7756,"_41":1063,"_43":7757,"_67":7758,"_69":7759,"_71":70},"VhCHA_Ab",{"_194":195},[],"Community Size",[55],"/private-notes/thoughts-on-comment-sections","2026-01-23T11:11:46.538Z",{"_83":1086},{},{"_39":1060,"_97":55,"_56":7766,"_72":1063,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1062],1772124423336,[151,1060,1063],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/thoughts-on-comment-sections\",\"bafy2bzacea5yis3sofdk4tg65j3slub42yxud4mdne7ttai6qcvgmgvm7vsym\"]",{"_112":7771,"_149":7836,"_152":7837},{"_114":7772,"_133":134,"_135":7835,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7773,"_39":7833},{"_30":7774,"_72":1092,"_73":55,"_74":7828,"_56":7829,"_77":1100,"_79":7830,"_81":7831,"_86":7832,"_88":1101,"_90":91},[7775,7796,7809,7821],{"_33":7776,"_35":7791},[7777,7784],{"_33":7778,"_35":7779},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7780,"_41":1101,"_43":7781,"_67":7782,"_69":7783,"_71":70},"oCybNZaE",{},[],"If you want to move a paragraph, you drag it instead of remembering and summoning the transpose command. ",{"_33":7785,"_35":7786},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7787,"_41":1092,"_43":7788,"_67":7789,"_69":7790,"_71":70},"Qlpb7cMg",{},[],"To see comments or the master directory, click a menu button.",{"_37":199,"_39":7792,"_41":1101,"_43":7793,"_67":7794,"_69":7795,"_71":70},"FadmVj54",{"_194":5405},[],"Menus, mouse clicks, and mouse drags instead of Commands:",{"_33":7797,"_35":7798},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":7799,"_41":1101,"_43":7800,"_67":7801,"_69":7807,"_71":7808},"gke_O3ZV",{"_194":195},[7802],{"_37":286,"_233":7803,"_238":7804,"_43":7805,"_71":7806},[5284],[4157],{},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=py2uuYdXFfc","Screenshot from Frode Hegland","ipfs://bafybeihgm3wijmxpnb46s5hccxf2jitoa5vbrws6efcbcvmjmtpnhh6vrq",{"_33":7810,"_35":7811},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7812,"_41":1092,"_43":7813,"_67":7814,"_69":7820,"_71":70},"G-rH0M51",{},[7815],{"_37":286,"_233":7816,"_238":7817,"_43":7818,"_71":7819},[4670],[5367],{},"https://youtu.be/py2uuYdXFfc?si=tvXif3mfybgOPyMt&t=585","Actually, Doug said he considered menus, but he thought moving the cursor up to a menu instead of using commands was very time-consuming. B",{"_33":7822,"_35":7823},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7824,"_41":1092,"_43":7825,"_67":7826,"_69":7827,"_71":70},"dWouHp8p",{},[],"Moving a whole chapter is very hard right now until we add an outline or a table of contents view spec.",[55],"/private-notes/changes-to-augment","2026-01-22T16:27:17.150Z",{"_83":1110},{},{"_39":1089,"_97":55,"_56":7834,"_72":1092,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1091],1772124423392,[151,1089,1092],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/changes-to-augment\",\"bafy2bzaceb3grlezctgvirvp2towqbnbij6w4ryuqkljxyvumzn22rzxm2zau\"]",{"_112":7839,"_149":7872,"_152":7873},{"_114":7840,"_133":134,"_135":7871,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7841,"_39":7869},{"_30":7842,"_72":1116,"_73":55,"_74":7864,"_56":7865,"_77":1125,"_79":7866,"_81":7867,"_86":7868,"_88":1126,"_90":91},[7843,7850,7857],{"_33":7844,"_35":7845},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7846,"_41":1126,"_43":7847,"_67":7848,"_69":7849,"_71":70},"eWkuNw2o",{},[],"jfasklfjaskljfiowjfi",{"_33":7851,"_35":7852},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7853,"_41":1126,"_43":7854,"_67":7855,"_69":7856,"_71":70},"-nv6UIIz",{},[],"/",{"_33":7858,"_35":7859},[],{"_37":166,"_39":7860,"_41":1116,"_43":7861,"_67":7862,"_69":70,"_71":7863},"QyvCjsPI",{"_170":7190},[],"hm://z6MkuBbsB1HbSNXLvJCRCrPhimY6g7tzhr4qvcYKPuSZzhno/human-interface-library/ux-review#eE5Yzq9F+",[55],"/private-notes/adfasdfasdf","2026-01-14T14:19:08.452Z",{"_83":1135},{},{"_39":1113,"_97":55,"_56":7870,"_72":1116,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1115],1772124423347,[151,1113,1116],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/adfasdfasdf\",\"bafy2bzacecloet77vhvk55cud6wb7ic4sacnhq77cdvhzqinf5tidz6euibow\"]",{"_112":7875,"_149":8089,"_152":8090},{"_114":7876,"_133":134,"_135":8088,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":7877,"_39":8086},{"_30":7878,"_72":1141,"_73":55,"_74":8081,"_56":8082,"_77":520,"_79":8083,"_81":8084,"_86":8085,"_88":521,"_90":91},[7879,7902,7946,7981,8017],{"_33":7880,"_35":7897},[7881,7889],{"_33":7882,"_35":7883},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7884,"_41":7885,"_43":7886,"_67":7887,"_69":7888,"_71":70},"BTMuimWK","bafy2bzaceajz4eychwwm675covwnndphd2ueq5f36uw2xastuymutnkhepiom",{},[],"Seed Hypermedia potencia el pensamiento humano y el trabajo colaborativo mediante un protocolo web extraordinariamente abierto y escalable que respeta los derechos digitales, diseñado para cualquier comunidad de conocimiento —desde editoriales y periódicos hasta universidades, congresos y creadores.",{"_33":7890,"_35":7891},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7892,"_41":7893,"_43":7894,"_67":7895,"_69":7896,"_71":70},"nDaZ9b7b","bafy2bzaceajsiyrzdnxk5izdv443h3lk7u3by4fmrq5cpc6mzjzc4vv7zuv4a",{},[],"Imaginad Wikipedia, Twitter y Substack juntos en la web, bajo el control de la propia comunidad.",{"_37":190,"_39":7898,"_41":7885,"_43":7899,"_67":7900,"_69":7901,"_71":70},"XG1UVPtK",{"_194":195},[],"¿Qué es Seed?",{"_33":7903,"_35":7941},[7904,7916,7929],{"_33":7905,"_35":7906},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7907,"_41":521,"_43":7908,"_67":7909,"_69":7915,"_71":70},"V7jdd3Is",{},[7910],{"_37":286,"_233":7911,"_238":7912,"_43":7913,"_71":7914},[139],[3776],{},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/hypertext/as-we-may-think","As We May Think",{"_33":7917,"_35":7918},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7919,"_41":521,"_43":7920,"_67":7921,"_69":7928,"_71":70},"gPOAjgDA",{},[7922],{"_37":286,"_233":7923,"_238":7924,"_43":7926,"_71":7927},[139],[7925],50,{},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/hypertext/doug-engelbart/augmenting-human-intellect-a-conceptual-framework","Augmenting Human Intellect: A Conceptual Framework",{"_33":7930,"_35":7931},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7932,"_41":521,"_43":7933,"_67":7934,"_69":7940,"_71":70},"Ef9SZ5oQ",{},[7935],{"_37":286,"_233":7936,"_238":7937,"_43":7938,"_71":7939},[139],[3971],{},"hm://z6MkuBbsB1HbSNXLvJCRCrPhimY6g7tzhr4qvcYKPuSZzhno/tech-talks/xanadu-original-17-rules?l","Xanadu Original 17 Rules",{"_37":190,"_39":7942,"_41":7885,"_43":7943,"_67":7944,"_69":7945,"_71":70},"oNsq8898",{"_194":3876},[],"Hypermedia. La Promesa.",{"_33":7947,"_35":7976},[7948,7955,7962,7969],{"_33":7949,"_35":7950},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7951,"_41":7885,"_43":7952,"_67":7953,"_69":7954,"_71":70},"mP6sBGSw",{},[],"Identidad criptográfica.",{"_33":7956,"_35":7957},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7958,"_41":7885,"_43":7959,"_67":7960,"_69":7961,"_71":70},"Ju2dzc7N",{},[],"Control de versiones.",{"_33":7963,"_35":7964},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7965,"_41":7885,"_43":7966,"_67":7967,"_69":7968,"_71":70},"hNgDQplA",{},[],"Links Irrompibles.",{"_33":7970,"_35":7971},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7972,"_41":7885,"_43":7973,"_67":7974,"_69":7975,"_71":70},"Opk1929N",{},[],"Red de servidores de hipermedia.",{"_37":190,"_39":7977,"_41":7885,"_43":7978,"_67":7979,"_69":7980,"_71":70},"d3fm3Dvw",{"_194":3876},[],"Seed Hypermedia. Protocolo para la web.",{"_33":7982,"_35":8012},[7983,7991,7998,8005],{"_33":7984,"_35":7985},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7986,"_41":7987,"_43":7988,"_67":7989,"_69":7990,"_71":70},"bcLgacHf","bafy2bzaceb6erd7ou3ftcoe7girrhnoz5z4m5fsti2o73nvfjcco424uq6cpm",{},[],"Red Social sin Big Tech.",{"_33":7992,"_35":7993},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7994,"_41":7987,"_43":7995,"_67":7996,"_69":7997,"_71":70},"AegdniWr",{},[],"Discusiones. Argumentación.",{"_33":7999,"_35":8000},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8001,"_41":1141,"_43":8002,"_67":8003,"_69":8004,"_71":70},"g1Krn3Cx",{},[],"Repositorio de conocimiento. Soporte documental.",{"_33":8006,"_35":8007},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8008,"_41":7885,"_43":8009,"_67":8010,"_69":8011,"_71":70},"JIGqUABS",{},[],"Publicaciones.",{"_37":190,"_39":8013,"_41":7885,"_43":8014,"_67":8015,"_69":8016,"_71":70},"ozEpZo81",{"_194":3876},[],"Comunidades de conocimiento",{"_33":8018,"_35":8076},[8019,8031,8043,8054,8065],{"_33":8020,"_35":8021},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8022,"_41":1164,"_43":8023,"_67":8024,"_69":8030,"_71":70},"I_cTDJdv",{},[8025],{"_37":166,"_233":8026,"_238":8027,"_43":8028,"_71":8029},[139],[134],{},"hm://z6MkuBbsB1HbSNXLvJCRCrPhimY6g7tzhr4qvcYKPuSZzhno?l"," ",{"_33":8032,"_35":8033},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8034,"_41":1164,"_43":8035,"_67":8036,"_69":8042,"_71":70},"JHDus20V",{},[8037],{"_37":166,"_233":8038,"_238":8039,"_43":8040,"_71":8041},[139],[134],{},"hm://z6MktVp5dhtDpWgGJYBHq8yabM1EbaXEpKn8uVk3tvEoUuUb?l"," ",{"_33":8044,"_35":8045},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8046,"_41":1164,"_43":8047,"_67":8048,"_69":8042,"_71":70},"QwHGHrU5",{},[8049],{"_37":166,"_233":8050,"_238":8051,"_43":8052,"_71":8053},[139],[134],{},"hm://z6MkqVcjAoZdXwADByEaySwERtcbZtJHn3GkmhpdwiSErwUu?l",{"_33":8055,"_35":8056},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8057,"_41":1164,"_43":8058,"_67":8059,"_69":8042,"_71":70},"tCSVQ5wV",{},[8060],{"_37":166,"_233":8061,"_238":8062,"_43":8063,"_71":8064},[139],[134],{},"hm://z6MkgAtUyLGa8nUn3xDbvfWprE58pYMDeuhD8sH59T6NYiuj?l",{"_33":8066,"_35":8067},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8068,"_41":1164,"_43":8069,"_67":8070,"_69":8030,"_71":70},"gcirBzhf",{},[8071],{"_37":166,"_233":8072,"_238":8073,"_43":8074,"_71":8075},[139],[134],{},"hm://z6Mkusu8KBMXe52JC9fnEFzwdsAF2SXGvnxoAyVTXBhGfRDR?l",{"_37":190,"_39":8077,"_41":7885,"_43":8078,"_67":8079,"_69":8080,"_71":70},"3v1uGX9O",{"_194":195},[],"Ejemplos",[55],"/private-notes/demo-seed-espanol","2025-12-18T10:54:10.792Z",{"_83":1158},{},{"_39":1138,"_97":55,"_56":8087,"_72":1141,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1140],1772124423454,[151,1138,1141],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/demo-seed-espanol\",\"bafy2bzaceca2yngzwddg5owvyxb52tmfjxzoytwdkxqpbdz22tzynvzv3p4vk\"]",{"_112":8092,"_149":8242,"_152":8243},{"_114":8093,"_133":134,"_135":8241,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":8094,"_39":8239},{"_30":8095,"_72":1164,"_73":55,"_74":8234,"_56":8235,"_77":520,"_79":8236,"_81":8237,"_86":8238,"_88":521,"_90":91},[8096,8109,8142,8172,8183],{"_33":8097,"_35":8105},[8098],{"_33":8099,"_35":8100},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8101,"_41":521,"_43":8102,"_67":8103,"_69":8104,"_71":70},"90n2H190",{},[],"Seed Hypermedia supports human thought and collaborative work with an extraordinarily open and scalable web protocol that respects digital rights, designed for any knowledge community — from publishers and newspapers to universities, conferences, and creators.",{"_37":190,"_39":7898,"_41":521,"_43":8106,"_67":8107,"_69":8108,"_71":70},{"_194":195},[],"What is Seed?",{"_33":8110,"_35":8138},[8111,8120,8129],{"_33":8112,"_35":8113},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7907,"_41":521,"_43":8114,"_67":8115,"_69":7915,"_71":70},{},[8116],{"_37":286,"_233":8117,"_238":8118,"_43":8119,"_71":7914},[139],[3776],{},{"_33":8121,"_35":8122},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7919,"_41":521,"_43":8123,"_67":8124,"_69":7928,"_71":70},{},[8125],{"_37":286,"_233":8126,"_238":8127,"_43":8128,"_71":7927},[139],[7925],{},{"_33":8130,"_35":8131},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7932,"_41":521,"_43":8132,"_67":8133,"_69":7940,"_71":70},{},[8134],{"_37":286,"_233":8135,"_238":8136,"_43":8137,"_71":7939},[139],[3971],{},{"_37":190,"_39":7942,"_41":521,"_43":8139,"_67":8140,"_69":8141,"_71":70},{"_194":3876},[],"Hypermedia Promise",{"_33":8143,"_35":8168},[8144,8150,8156,8162],{"_33":8145,"_35":8146},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7951,"_41":521,"_43":8147,"_67":8148,"_69":8149,"_71":70},{},[],"Cryptographic Identity.",{"_33":8151,"_35":8152},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7958,"_41":521,"_43":8153,"_67":8154,"_69":8155,"_71":70},{},[],"Version Control.",{"_33":8157,"_35":8158},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7965,"_41":521,"_43":8159,"_67":8160,"_69":8161,"_71":70},{},[],"Better Links.",{"_33":8163,"_35":8164},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7972,"_41":521,"_43":8165,"_67":8166,"_69":8167,"_71":70},{},[],"Network.",{"_37":190,"_39":7977,"_41":521,"_43":8169,"_67":8170,"_69":8171,"_71":70},{"_194":3876},[],"Properties",{"_33":8173,"_35":8179},[8174],{"_33":8175,"_35":8176},[],{"_37":199,"_39":7994,"_41":1164,"_43":8177,"_67":8178,"_69":70,"_71":70},{},[],{"_37":190,"_39":8013,"_41":1164,"_43":8180,"_67":8181,"_69":8182,"_71":70},{"_194":3876},[],"Knowledge Communities",{"_33":8184,"_35":8230},[8185,8194,8203,8212,8221],{"_33":8186,"_35":8187},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8022,"_41":1164,"_43":8188,"_67":8189,"_69":8030,"_71":70},{},[8190],{"_37":166,"_233":8191,"_238":8192,"_43":8193,"_71":8029},[139],[134],{},{"_33":8195,"_35":8196},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8034,"_41":1164,"_43":8197,"_67":8198,"_69":8042,"_71":70},{},[8199],{"_37":166,"_233":8200,"_238":8201,"_43":8202,"_71":8041},[139],[134],{},{"_33":8204,"_35":8205},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8046,"_41":1164,"_43":8206,"_67":8207,"_69":8042,"_71":70},{},[8208],{"_37":166,"_233":8209,"_238":8210,"_43":8211,"_71":8053},[139],[134],{},{"_33":8213,"_35":8214},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8057,"_41":1164,"_43":8215,"_67":8216,"_69":8042,"_71":70},{},[8217],{"_37":166,"_233":8218,"_238":8219,"_43":8220,"_71":8064},[139],[134],{},{"_33":8222,"_35":8223},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8068,"_41":1164,"_43":8224,"_67":8225,"_69":8030,"_71":70},{},[8226],{"_37":166,"_233":8227,"_238":8228,"_43":8229,"_71":8075},[139],[134],{},{"_37":190,"_39":8077,"_41":1164,"_43":8231,"_67":8232,"_69":8233,"_71":70},{"_194":195},[],"Examples",[55],"/private-notes/demo-seed","2025-12-18T10:27:17.071Z",{"_83":1179},{},{"_39":1161,"_97":55,"_56":8240,"_72":1164,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1163],1772124423367,[151,1161,1164],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/demo-seed\",\"bafy2bzacecny3hm7jpt4ics4pyzwrksd7wjf425qyhihek34xnlq2ahxadogm\"]",{"_112":8245,"_149":8397,"_152":8398},{"_114":8246,"_133":134,"_135":8396,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":8247,"_39":8394},{"_30":8248,"_72":1185,"_73":55,"_74":8390,"_56":2657,"_77":1194,"_79":8391,"_81":8392,"_86":8393,"_88":1195,"_90":91},[8249,8261,8282,8289,8296,8345,8357,8368,8379],{"_33":8250,"_35":8251},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8252,"_41":8253,"_43":8254,"_67":8255,"_69":8030,"_71":70},"AN_OBX3A","bafy2bzacea5poaueac6s5vcuwunk6bo2guqh4uiud5t7x5uw53z4kdu3meiqw",{},[8256],{"_37":166,"_233":8257,"_238":8258,"_43":8259,"_71":8260},[139],[134],{},"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/personal-productivity/productivity-text-file?l",{"_33":8262,"_35":8263},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8264,"_41":8265,"_43":8266,"_67":8267,"_69":8281,"_71":70},"f19lIQl-","bafy2bzacebnblh4raxjbyzl7n6ui65ijroq23t44t3uljr3ql6aatoacdyj3i",{},[8268,8274],{"_37":232,"_233":8269,"_238":8271,"_43":8273,"_71":70},[8270],183,[8272],188,{},{"_37":286,"_233":8275,"_238":8277,"_43":8279,"_71":8280},[8276],286,[8278],290,{},"https://talk.macpowerusers.com/t/my-productivity-app-for-the-past-12-years-has-been-a-single-txt-file/26954/4","You may be right. I may have misinterpreted it. I read it as he was using his calendar for unscheduled tasks. If so, I would consider that bad practice. Obviously, scheduling time to think about a project is appropriate, similar to my example of scheduling time for strategic planning. Link",{"_33":8283,"_35":8284},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8285,"_41":8265,"_43":8286,"_67":8287,"_69":8288,"_71":70},"eKguIGQB",{},[],"GTD: Get Things Done.",{"_33":8290,"_35":8291},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8292,"_41":8265,"_43":8293,"_67":8294,"_69":8295,"_71":70},"QrZ11q0U",{},[],"OBTF: One Big Text File.",{"_33":8297,"_35":8340},[8298,8305,8312,8319,8326,8333],{"_33":8299,"_35":8300},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8301,"_41":8265,"_43":8302,"_67":8303,"_69":8304,"_71":70},"iGvowobC",{},[],"Appointments",{"_33":8306,"_35":8307},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8308,"_41":8265,"_43":8309,"_67":8310,"_69":8311,"_71":70},"NedYh1TX",{},[],"Tasks",{"_33":8313,"_35":8314},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8315,"_41":8265,"_43":8316,"_67":8317,"_69":8318,"_71":70},"nO6AIJc8",{},[],"Ideas",{"_33":8320,"_35":8321},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8322,"_41":8265,"_43":8323,"_67":8324,"_69":8325,"_71":70},"2wjm1meL",{},[],"Thoughts",{"_33":8327,"_35":8328},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8329,"_41":8265,"_43":8330,"_67":8331,"_69":8332,"_71":70},"eUa0xk9w",{},[],"People",{"_33":8334,"_35":8335},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8336,"_41":8265,"_43":8337,"_67":8338,"_69":8339,"_71":70},"yz34MX5v",{},[],"Meet to",{"_37":199,"_39":8341,"_41":8265,"_43":8342,"_67":8343,"_69":8344,"_71":70},"xagkglz0",{"_194":195},[],"Definitions:",{"_33":8346,"_35":8347},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8348,"_41":1185,"_43":8349,"_67":8350,"_69":8356,"_71":70},"ft3P1NI0",{},[8351],{"_37":286,"_233":8352,"_238":8353,"_43":8355,"_71":8356},[139],[8354],72,{},"https://ellanew.com/2025/04/14/ptpl-152-append-obtf-to-craft-a-dashboard",{"_33":8358,"_35":8359},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8360,"_41":8265,"_43":8361,"_67":8362,"_69":8367,"_71":70},"2BDGTHpq",{},[8363],{"_37":286,"_233":8364,"_238":8365,"_43":8366,"_71":8367},[139],[4169],{},"https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25995838",{"_33":8369,"_35":8370},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8371,"_41":8265,"_43":8372,"_67":8373,"_69":8378,"_71":70},"pRQToyEm",{},[8374],{"_37":286,"_233":8375,"_238":8376,"_43":8377,"_71":8378},[139],[6980],{},"https://medium.com/@geetduggal/tech-habits-one-big-text-file-obtf-after-24-hours-27672f999949",{"_33":8380,"_35":8381},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8382,"_41":8265,"_43":8383,"_67":8384,"_69":8389,"_71":70},"RVgZiXh1",{},[8385],{"_37":286,"_233":8386,"_238":8387,"_43":8388,"_71":8389},[139],[6884],{},"https://craphound.com/lifehacks2.txt",[55],"2025-12-14T21:19:46.541Z",{"_83":1204},{},{"_39":1182,"_97":55,"_56":8395,"_72":1185,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1184],1772124423375,[151,1182,1185],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/personal-productivity\",\"bafy2bzaceageqzrnyq4e2vwty6tbihwug5ics5pk2nd3rzvfp24lklr5jzpm2\"]",{"_112":8400,"_149":8683,"_152":8684},{"_114":8401,"_133":134,"_135":8682,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":8402,"_39":8680},{"_30":8403,"_72":2642,"_73":55,"_74":8675,"_56":8676,"_77":2651,"_79":8677,"_81":8678,"_86":8679,"_88":2652,"_90":91},[8404,8415,8427,8434,8441,8448,8459,8471,8485,8500,8507,8514,8525,8537,8548,8555,8608,8654,8661,8668],{"_33":8405,"_35":8406},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8407,"_41":2652,"_43":8408,"_67":8409,"_69":8414,"_71":70},"iMQDX-qS",{},[8410],{"_37":286,"_233":8411,"_238":8412,"_43":8413,"_71":8414},[139],[4169],{},"https://jeffhuang.com/productivity_text_file/",{"_33":8416,"_35":8417},[],{"_37":190,"_39":8418,"_41":2652,"_43":8419,"_67":8420,"_69":8426,"_71":70},"duL_cvOa",{},[8421],{"_37":286,"_233":8422,"_238":8423,"_43":8424,"_71":8425},[48],[3851],{},"https://jeffhuang.com/","By Jeff Huang, updated on 2022-03-21",{"_33":8428,"_35":8429},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8430,"_41":2652,"_43":8431,"_67":8432,"_69":8433,"_71":70},"6CSmsQBi",{},[],"The biggest transition for me when I started college was learning to get organized. There was a point when I couldn't just remember everything in my head. And having to constantly keep track of things was distracting me from whatever task I was doing at the moment.",{"_33":8435,"_35":8436},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8437,"_41":2652,"_43":8438,"_67":8439,"_69":8440,"_71":70},"iIylMVCn",{},[],"So I tried various forms of todo lists, task trackers, and productivity apps. They were all discouraging because the things to do kept getting longer, and there were too many interrelated things like past meeting notes, calendar appointments, idea lists, and lab notebooks, which were all on different systems.",{"_33":8442,"_35":8443},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8444,"_41":2652,"_43":8445,"_67":8446,"_69":8447,"_71":70},"sQex4XqR",{},[],"I gave up and started just tracking in a single text file and have been using it as my main productivity system for 14 years now. It is so essential to my work now, and has surprisingly scaled with a growing set of responsibilities, that I wanted to share this system. It's been my secret weapon.",{"_33":8449,"_35":8450},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8451,"_41":2652,"_43":8452,"_67":8453,"_69":8458,"_71":70},"ZTzFRNgP",{},[8454],{"_37":232,"_233":8455,"_238":8456,"_43":8457,"_71":70},[139],[2395],{},"Prerequisite: A calendar. The one outside tool I use is an online calendar, and I put everything on this calendar, even things that aren't actually for a fixed time like \"make a coffee table at the workshop\" or \"figure out how to recruit new PhD students\" — I'll schedule them on a date when I want to think about it. That way all my future plans and schedule are together, and not a bunch of lists I have to keep track of.",{"_33":8460,"_35":8461},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8462,"_41":2652,"_43":8463,"_67":8464,"_69":8470,"_71":70},"b_7YEC5K",{},[8465],{"_37":232,"_233":8466,"_238":8467,"_43":8469,"_71":70},[139],[8468],21,{},"Making the Daily List: Every night before I go to bed, I take all the items on my calendar for the next day and append it to the end of the text file as a daily todo list, so I know exactly what I'm doing when I wake up. This list contains scheduled tasks (2pm meeting with Madonna, 4pm office hours), errands (sign a form, return a book), and work items (review a paper, prepare a presentation). It also lets me think about whether I've got the right amount of work for a day.",{"_33":8472,"_35":8480},[8473],{"_33":8474,"_35":8475},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":8476,"_41":2652,"_43":8477,"_67":8478,"_69":8479,"_71":70},"1xAfr70P",{"_4659":70},[],"2021-11-31 11am meet with Head TAs - where are things at with inviting portfolio reviewers? 11:30am meet with student Enya (interested in research) review and release A/B Testing assignment grading 12pm HCI group meeting - vote for lab snacks send reminders for CHI external reviewers read Sketchy draft Zelda pick up eye tracker - have her sign for it update biosketch for Co-PI 3:15pm join call with Umbrella Corp and industry partnership staff 3:45pm advising meet with Oprah 4pm Rihanna talk (368 CIT) 5pm 1:1 with Beyonce #phdadvisee 6pm faculty interview dinner with Madonna",{"_37":199,"_39":8481,"_41":2652,"_43":8482,"_67":8483,"_69":8484,"_71":70},"MnLsgB5V",{"_194":195},[],"Anything I don't want to do tomorrow, I'll shuffle back into my calendar on later dates. If the task is too big, I'll break it down into a piece for tomorrow, and the rest for another date. After years of doing this, I've gotten pretty good at estimating what I can finish in a day. Here's an example with names replaced so you can see what it looks like when I move a day's schedule from my calendar.",{"_33":8486,"_35":8487},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8488,"_41":2652,"_43":8489,"_67":8490,"_69":8499,"_71":70},"fqUtMPjY",{},[8491,8495],{"_37":232,"_233":8492,"_238":8493,"_43":8494,"_71":70},[139],[452],{},{"_37":4625,"_233":8496,"_238":8497,"_43":8498,"_71":70},[8354,4692],[6374,5528],{},"As a Record: That daily todo list is where I also take notes, so it's a to do list that turns into a what done list. The best thing about these daily lists is I keep them all in a single text file separated by dates, so I have a record of everything I have ever done and when I did it.",{"_33":8501,"_35":8502},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8503,"_41":2652,"_43":8504,"_67":8505,"_69":8506,"_71":70},"7vumgD5g",{},[],"My current file was created 9 years ago when I started my current job. It serves as a research notebook, and as meeting minutes. I have 51,690 handwritten lines in one file now, documenting everything I have done as a professor, and nearly every person I have met with, along with notes about what we discussed or ideas I had. Here's what my list looks like at the end of the day, representing work accomplished.",{"_33":8508,"_35":8509},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":8510,"_41":2642,"_43":8511,"_67":8512,"_69":8513,"_71":70},"Nkq9UTsU",{"_4659":70},[],"2021-11-31 11am meet with Head TAs - where are things at with inviting portfolio reviewers? A: got 7/29 replies - need 3 TAs for Thursday lab - Redesign assignment handout will be done by Monday, ship Thursday 11:30am meet with student Enya (interested in research) - they're a little inexperienced, suggested applying next year review and release A/B Testing assignment grading 12pm HCI group meeting - automatically generate thumbnails from zoom behavior on web pages - #idea subliminal audio that leads you to dream about websites - Eminem presenting Nov 24 - vote for lab snacks. A: popcorn and seaweed thing got unofficial notification ARO YIP funding award #annual #cv read Sketchy paper draft - needs 1 more revision - send to Gandalf to look at? Zelda pick up eye tracker - have her sign for it update biosketch for Co-PI unexpected drop in from Coolio! #alumni - now a PM working on TravelAdvisor, thinking about applying to grad school 3:15pm join call with Umbrella Corp and industry partnership staff - they want to hire 20 data science + SWE interns (year 3), 4 alums there as SWE 3:45pm advising meet with Oprah - enjoyed CS 33 - interning at Facebook 4pm Rihanna talk (368 CIT) 5pm 1:1 with Beyonce #phdadvisee - stuck on random graph generating crash \t- monitor memory/swap/disk? \t- ask Mario to help? - got internship at MSR with Cher \t- start May 15 or 22 - will send me study design outline before next meeting - interviewing Spartacus as potential RA for next semester 6pm faculty interview dinner with Madonna (Gracie's) - ask about connection with computer vision - cool visual+audio unsupervised comparison, thoughtful about missing data, would work with ugrads (?), likes biking, teach compvis + graphics - vote #HIRE #note maybe visit Monsters University next spring, Bono does related work",{"_33":8515,"_35":8516},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8517,"_41":2652,"_43":8518,"_67":8519,"_69":8524,"_71":70},"SHML4Bk0",{},[8520],{"_37":232,"_233":8521,"_238":8522,"_43":8523,"_71":70},[139],[4023],{},"Shortcuts and Features: I use a consistent writing style so things are easily searchable, with a few shorthands. When I search for \"meet with\", it shows that I have had over 3,000 scheduled meetings. I have some tags like #idea for new ideas to revisit when I want project ideas, #annual for things to put on my next annual report, #nextui for things to add the next time I run my next UI course.",{"_33":8526,"_35":8527},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8528,"_41":2652,"_43":8529,"_67":8530,"_69":8536,"_71":70},"6sMEYOzR",{},[8531],{"_37":286,"_233":8532,"_238":8533,"_43":8534,"_71":8535},[5016],[6171],{},"https://www.ultraedit.com/","A text file is incredibly flexible, and at any point, I can quickly glance to see what I've done that day and what's left. I usually keep an empty line between tasks completed and upcoming tasks. When a task is completed, I move the empty line. Any leftover tasks from the current day can go back into the calendar for when I may want to tackle it again, but that is rare because tasks were already sized into what I can do on that day. I can calculate aggregate statistics using the search box, or list all the lines containing a tag, and other operations using my text editor. I use Ultraedit because I'm familiar with it, but any text editor would have similar capabilities.",{"_33":8538,"_35":8539},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8540,"_41":2652,"_43":8541,"_67":8542,"_69":8547,"_71":70},"PTUlUyXY",{},[8543],{"_37":232,"_233":8544,"_238":8545,"_43":8546,"_71":70},[139],[792],{},"Email: Email is obviously a part of my workflow. Everyone has all sorts of productivity advice about handling it, but I find a simple flagging system is sufficient — flag Red if it's something I need to deal with, flag Orange if I need to deal with it eventually but requires some thinking or someone else to handle it, and flag Yellow for emails I send that I am waiting on a reply for, so I know to follow up later. I'll flag emails as they come in, whenever it's convenient.",{"_33":8549,"_35":8550},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8551,"_41":2652,"_43":8552,"_67":8553,"_69":8554,"_71":70},"SlfavTwH",{},[],"At the end of the day, I'll do a quick review of the Orange and Yellows to see if any need to be followed up or should become Red. Some peoples' workflows revolve around obsessively cleaning their Inbox. I don't really care about keeping my inbox empty because then I feel like I have new work to do whenever email comes in.",{"_33":8556,"_35":8599},[8557,8564,8571,8578,8585,8592],{"_33":8558,"_35":8559},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8560,"_41":2652,"_43":8561,"_67":8562,"_69":8563,"_71":70},"098i0j5w",{},[],"look at the daily todo list I wrote last night to find out what I'm doing today",{"_33":8565,"_35":8566},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8567,"_41":2652,"_43":8568,"_67":8569,"_69":8570,"_71":70},"3iIeHF-H",{},[],"do scheduled things on that list during the day",{"_33":8572,"_35":8573},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8574,"_41":2652,"_43":8575,"_67":8576,"_69":8577,"_71":70},"PoJ45fBD",{},[],"when I have free (unscheduled) time, do the floating tasks on my list and work on Red-flagged emails",{"_33":8579,"_35":8580},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8581,"_41":2652,"_43":8582,"_67":8583,"_69":8584,"_71":70},"P6zpY71T",{},[],"at the end of the day",{"_33":8586,"_35":8587},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8588,"_41":2652,"_43":8589,"_67":8590,"_69":8591,"_71":70},"1ftUZOhu",{},[],"do a quick review of Orange/Yellow emails to see if they need any handling",{"_33":8593,"_35":8594},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8595,"_41":2652,"_43":8596,"_67":8597,"_69":8598,"_71":70},"o5UOW9a4",{},[],"copy the next day's calendar items to the bottom of the text file",{"_37":199,"_39":8600,"_41":2652,"_43":8601,"_67":8602,"_69":8607,"_71":70},"zHGIMV_s",{"_194":5405},[8603],{"_37":232,"_233":8604,"_238":8605,"_43":8606,"_71":70},[624],[5367],{},"So my daily routine looks like",{"_33":8609,"_35":8645},[8610,8617,8624,8631,8638],{"_33":8611,"_35":8612},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8613,"_41":2652,"_43":8614,"_67":8615,"_69":8616,"_71":70},"9mHYJLQl",{},[],"It's easy to immediately see what to do when I wake up",{"_33":8618,"_35":8619},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8620,"_41":2652,"_43":8621,"_67":8622,"_69":8623,"_71":70},"Xf5itZbY",{},[],"I don't need to remember in my head the things to do later (following up on emails, future tasks)",{"_33":8625,"_35":8626},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8627,"_41":2652,"_43":8628,"_67":8629,"_69":8630,"_71":70},"bsO6vpDc",{},[],"It's easy to recall what happened in the past and see how much I can actually accomplish in a day",{"_33":8632,"_35":8633},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8634,"_41":2652,"_43":8635,"_67":8636,"_69":8637,"_71":70},"iKWuQiBg",{},[],"There's no running \"todo\" list with items that keep pushed back day after day",{"_33":8639,"_35":8640},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8641,"_41":2652,"_43":8642,"_67":8643,"_69":8644,"_71":70},"tFZPXMkm",{},[],"I use Remote Desktop so everything is accessible from every device",{"_37":199,"_39":8646,"_41":2652,"_43":8647,"_67":8648,"_69":8653,"_71":70},"B_HSzgTX",{"_194":3876},[8649],{"_37":232,"_233":8650,"_238":8651,"_43":8652,"_71":70},[7372],[5381],{},"This process has a few nice properties:",{"_33":8655,"_35":8656},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8657,"_41":2652,"_43":8658,"_67":8659,"_69":8660,"_71":70},"5tP8n7Vk",{},[],"My daily workload is completely under my control the night before; whenever I feel overwhelmed with my long-term commitments, I reduce it by aggressively unflagging emails, removing items from my calendar that I am no longer excited about doing, and reducing how much work I assign myself in the future.",{"_33":8662,"_35":8663},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8664,"_41":2652,"_43":8665,"_67":8666,"_69":8667,"_71":70},"7Lczr7sM",{},[],"It does mean sometimes I miss some questions or don't pursue an interesting research question, but helps me maintain a manageable workload.",{"_33":8669,"_35":8670},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8671,"_41":2652,"_43":8672,"_67":8673,"_69":8674,"_71":70},"vaozZOsG",{},[],"So that's it. I would love to hear from you if you try my system, or have some ideas about it!",[55],"/private-notes/personal-productivity/productivity-text-file","2025-12-14T18:44:48.778Z",{"_83":2663,"_879":2664},{},{"_39":2639,"_97":55,"_56":8681,"_72":2642,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1184,2641],1772124423510,[151,2639,2642],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/personal-productivity/productivity-text-file\",\"bafy2bzacedgeqfvbo76tgcxo3ak52fkbnivuoqfmhqpue7ipevgwj2p6likxg\"]",{"_112":8686,"_149":8905,"_152":8906},{"_114":8687,"_133":134,"_135":8904,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":8688,"_39":8902},{"_30":8689,"_72":1210,"_73":55,"_74":8898,"_56":8899,"_77":1216,"_79":1216,"_81":8900,"_86":8901,"_88":1210,"_90":91},[8690,8697,8703,8738,8745,8767,8773,8793,8800,8807,8863,8870],{"_33":8691,"_35":8692},[],{"_37":3447,"_39":8693,"_41":1210,"_43":8694,"_67":8695,"_69":70,"_71":8696},"Ikn_Xurc",{"_194":195},[],"https://www.youtube.com/embed/Qp0rCU49lMs",{"_33":8698,"_35":8699},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8700,"_41":1210,"_43":8701,"_67":8702,"_69":70,"_71":70},"Be6pN6Wv",{},[],{"_33":8704,"_35":8733},[8705,8712],{"_33":8706,"_35":8707},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8708,"_41":1210,"_43":8709,"_67":8710,"_69":8711,"_71":70},"ZLicgP65",{},[],"Intelligence is the degree of ingenuity that it has in overcoming barriers between it and its goal.",{"_33":8713,"_35":8714},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8715,"_41":1210,"_43":8716,"_67":8717,"_69":8732,"_71":70},"IXMqpK3m",{},[8718,8723,8727],{"_37":286,"_233":8719,"_238":8720,"_43":8721,"_71":8722},[139],[3851],{},"https://www.google.com/search?q=Michael+Levin&rlz=1C5CHFA_enES1104ES1106&oq=light+cone+michael+levin&gs_lcrp=EgZjaHJvbWUyBggAEEUYOdIBCDQwMDNqMGo3qAIAsAIA&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&ved=2ahUKEwiphKKtw6mRAxWqBdsEHZY6DzoQgK4QegQIARAD",{"_37":4625,"_233":8724,"_238":8725,"_43":8726,"_71":70},[139],[3851],{},{"_37":232,"_233":8728,"_238":8729,"_43":8731,"_71":70},[7521],[8730],112,{},"Michael Levin's \"cognitive light cone\" is a model for understanding intelligence and goals across living systems, defining the spatial and temporal scale of what an organism (or collective of cells) can care about and work toward, like a bacterium's focus on local sugar vs. a human's global concerns, essentially mapping an entity's potential goals onto a spacetime diagram to compare cognitive reach and computational limits. He uses this concept, linked to developmental bioelectricity and collective intelligence, to explain how life scales up problem-solving, from single cells to complex organisms, by expanding these goal-directed boundaries. ",{"_37":190,"_39":8734,"_41":1210,"_43":8735,"_67":8736,"_69":8737,"_71":70},"ib6V5MzM",{"_194":195},[],"Michael Levin",{"_33":8739,"_35":8740},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8741,"_41":1210,"_43":8742,"_67":8743,"_69":8744,"_71":70},"6vmpnUHc",{},[],"Michael levin advocates for eliminating the categorization of things and move to a continuum.",{"_33":8746,"_35":8762},[8747],{"_33":8748,"_35":8757},[8749],{"_33":8750,"_35":8751},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":8752,"_41":1210,"_43":8753,"_67":8755,"_69":70,"_71":8756},"WajpK8wN",{"_194":195,"_3508":8754},476,[],"ipfs://bafybeidtwzkkihg6vudv5edfgafzxmywgfxsjhjuxooncfmicd3bklzyia",{"_37":190,"_39":8758,"_41":1210,"_43":8759,"_67":8760,"_69":8761,"_71":70},"wIXIDmW9",{"_194":195},[],"Spiders webs depending on the effect of substances",{"_37":199,"_39":8763,"_41":1210,"_43":8764,"_67":8765,"_69":8766,"_71":70},"4QmRfg2L",{"_194":195},[],"Science is great because it allows to say something with a few words.",{"_33":8768,"_35":8769},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8770,"_41":1210,"_43":8771,"_67":8772,"_69":70,"_71":70},"COZrKzs4",{},[],{"_33":8774,"_35":8788},[8775],{"_33":8776,"_35":8784},[8777],{"_33":8778,"_35":8779},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8780,"_41":1210,"_43":8781,"_67":8782,"_69":8783,"_71":70},"WAtYOAHv",{},[],"Synthetic biology and bioengineering provide the opportunity to create novel embodied cognitive systems (otherwise known as minds) in a very wide variety of chimeric architectures combining evolved and designed material and software. These advances are disrupting familiar concepts in the philosophy of mind, and require new ways of thinking about and comparing truly diverse intelligences, whose composition and origin are not like any of the available natural model species. In this Perspective, I introduce TAME – Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere – a framework for understanding and manipulating cognition in unconventional substrates. TAME formalizes a non-binary (continuous), empirically-based approach to strongly embodied agency. When applied to regenerating/developmental systems, TAME suggests a perspective on morphogenesis as an example of basal cognition. The deep symmetry between problem-solving in anatomical, physiological, transcriptional, and 3D (traditional behavioral) spaces drives specific hypotheses by which cognitive capacities can scale during evolution. An important medium exploited by evolution for joining active subunits into greater agents is developmental bioelectricity, implemented by pre-neural use of ion channels and gap junctions to scale cell-level feedback loops into anatomical homeostasis. This architecture of multi-scale competency of biological systems has important implications for plasticity of bodies and minds, greatly potentiating evolvability. Considering classical and recent data from the perspectives of computational science, evolutionary biology, and basal cognition, reveals a rich research program with many implications for cognitive science, evolutionary biology, regenerative medicine, and artificial intelligence.",{"_37":190,"_39":8785,"_41":1210,"_43":8786,"_67":8787,"_69":3820,"_71":70},"2011lEiI",{"_194":195},[],{"_37":190,"_39":8789,"_41":1210,"_43":8790,"_67":8791,"_69":8792,"_71":70},"i_Is7qhZ",{"_194":195},[],"Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere (Tame): an experimentally-grounded framework for understanding diverse bodies and minds.",{"_33":8794,"_35":8795},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8796,"_41":1210,"_43":8797,"_67":8798,"_69":8799,"_71":70},"GWXjwRaq",{},[],"Cognitive claims are really protocol claims.",{"_33":8801,"_35":8802},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8803,"_41":1210,"_43":8804,"_67":8805,"_69":8806,"_71":70},"_c8gprW2",{},[],"When you tell me that something has some degree of intelligence, what you're really saying is, \"This is the set of tools I'm going to deploy and",{"_33":8808,"_35":8858},[8809,8816,8823,8830,8837,8844,8851],{"_33":8810,"_35":8811},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8812,"_41":1210,"_43":8813,"_67":8814,"_69":8815,"_71":70},"U55N__Qe",{},[],"Intelligence is a fixed goal with variable means of achieving it.",{"_33":8817,"_35":8818},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8819,"_41":1210,"_43":8820,"_67":8821,"_69":8822,"_71":70},"2jz4bXj8",{},[],"Automata fixed rules don't have the variable means of achieving a goal. Automata and the secret of life don't explain intelligence. When you block these entities from their goal, they will change their behaviour to achieve it. Homeostecic system?",{"_33":8824,"_35":8825},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8826,"_41":1210,"_43":8827,"_67":8828,"_69":8829,"_71":70},"WKLRT082",{},[],"Level of ingenuity. Having affordances to get across barriers are higher intelgience",{"_33":8831,"_35":8832},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8833,"_41":1210,"_43":8834,"_67":8835,"_69":8836,"_71":70},"9A5siEhQ",{},[],"Memories.",{"_33":8838,"_35":8839},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8840,"_41":1210,"_43":8841,"_67":8842,"_69":8843,"_71":70},"EGVgdYdv",{},[],"Patterns on excitable mediums.",{"_33":8845,"_35":8846},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8847,"_41":1210,"_43":8848,"_67":8849,"_69":8850,"_71":70},"gQotdAAK",{},[],"Platonic State.",{"_33":8852,"_35":8853},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8854,"_41":1210,"_43":8855,"_67":8856,"_69":8857,"_71":70},"QWGoGGoL",{},[],"Mind-mind relationship has the same relationship than math-physics.",{"_37":190,"_39":8859,"_41":1210,"_43":8860,"_67":8861,"_69":8862,"_71":70},"W9M3p3GP",{"_194":195},[],"William James Definition of Intelligence",{"_33":8864,"_35":8865},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8866,"_41":1210,"_43":8867,"_67":8868,"_69":8869,"_71":70},"77coBn2F",{},[],"You can only see the patterns once they reveal themselves through the physical world. They need an interface.",{"_33":8871,"_35":8893},[8872,8879,8886],{"_33":8873,"_35":8874},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8875,"_41":1210,"_43":8876,"_67":8877,"_69":8878,"_71":70},"WZuZytt3",{},[],"I think minds are not produced by physics. I don't think we create consciousness when we create a baby. Nobody's creating consciousness. What you create interface through which specifc patterns, we call minds, are going to ingress.",{"_33":8880,"_35":8881},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8882,"_41":1210,"_43":8883,"_67":8884,"_69":8885,"_71":70},"1mzjw9gr",{},[],"In Newtons world physicalism was already dead. The were already knew that there are non-physical properties that matter in the physical world.",{"_33":8887,"_35":8888},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8889,"_41":1210,"_43":8890,"_67":8891,"_69":8892,"_71":70},"XBwAO1dB",{},[],"What is Amplituhedron?",{"_37":190,"_39":8894,"_41":1210,"_43":8895,"_67":8896,"_69":8897,"_71":70},"xaphKfVd",{"_194":195},[],"A brain is a Think Client to this world",[55],"/private-notes/cognitive-light-cone",{"_83":1225},{},{"_39":1207,"_97":55,"_56":8903,"_72":1210,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1209],1772124423424,[151,1207,1210],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/cognitive-light-cone\",\"bafy2bzacebikx7yj6hq2fntm3hqjlkbede67ms2kf7y3elxjqzwxbtevijd5y\"]",{"_112":8908,"_149":8933,"_152":8934},{"_114":8909,"_133":134,"_135":8932,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":8910,"_39":8930},{"_30":8911,"_72":1231,"_73":55,"_74":8926,"_56":8927,"_77":1238,"_79":1238,"_81":8928,"_86":8929,"_88":1231,"_90":91},[8912,8919],{"_33":8913,"_35":8914},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8915,"_41":1231,"_43":8916,"_67":8917,"_69":8918,"_71":70},"pgG9AIcU",{},[],"What is Hyperlocal Journalism? How can growing communities on the Web help?",{"_33":8920,"_35":8921},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":8922,"_41":1231,"_43":8923,"_67":8924,"_69":70,"_71":8925},"IOs0YJ1z",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreihze4gvhbzovwayuhnce4stpo5aq7qxoa3pmsngzt3crk4xdd4xu4",[55],"/private-notes/hyperlocal-journalism-and-seed-hypermedia-protocol",{"_83":1247},{},{"_39":1228,"_97":55,"_56":8931,"_72":1231,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1230],1772124423518,[151,1228,1231],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/hyperlocal-journalism-and-seed-hypermedia-protocol\",\"bafy2bzacea3ii6ouwzcinjb4jyu65gejt2udur7czcgx4nwoy7k5utyhjj3xm\"]",{"_112":8936,"_149":8953,"_152":8954},{"_114":8937,"_133":134,"_135":8952,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":8938,"_39":8950},{"_30":8939,"_72":1253,"_73":55,"_74":8946,"_56":8947,"_77":1260,"_79":1260,"_81":8948,"_86":8949,"_88":1253,"_90":91},[8940],{"_33":8941,"_35":8942},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8943,"_41":1253,"_43":8944,"_67":8945,"_69":1269,"_71":70},"GyvAFg_v",{},[],[55],"/private-notes/flood-or-gossip-comparing-decentralized-protocols",{"_83":1269},{},{"_39":1250,"_97":55,"_56":8951,"_72":1253,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1252],1772124423528,[151,1250,1253],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/flood-or-gossip-comparing-decentralized-protocols\",\"bafy2bzacecfy64ukqspye4pq2hpffkulzxw7ep4onngl2q7potlj4dcwvzgra\"]",{"_112":8956,"_149":9258,"_152":9259},{"_114":8957,"_133":134,"_135":9257,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":8958,"_39":9255},{"_30":8959,"_72":1275,"_73":55,"_74":9250,"_56":9251,"_77":1285,"_79":9252,"_81":9253,"_86":9254,"_88":1286,"_90":91},[8960,8972,8991,9034,9088],{"_33":8961,"_35":8962},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8963,"_41":1286,"_43":8964,"_67":8965,"_69":8971,"_71":70},"1CitI2kl",{},[8966],{"_37":4656,"_233":8967,"_238":8968,"_43":8970,"_71":70},[6892],[8969],167,{},"Go 1.23 introduced standard iterators (range functions), a powerful feature that simplifies looping over sequences of data. However, the standard library's iter.Seq[T] doesn't have a built-in support for error handling. This can be a significant limitation when dealing with I/O operations like database queries, or any sequence where things might go wrong.",{"_33":8973,"_35":8974},[],{"_37":199,"_39":8975,"_41":1286,"_43":8976,"_67":8977,"_69":8990,"_71":70},"X4CcAvpp",{},[8978,8983],{"_37":286,"_233":8979,"_238":8980,"_43":8981,"_71":8982},[2395],[4185],{},"https://sinclairtarget.com/blog/2025/07/error-handling-with-iterators-in-go/",{"_37":286,"_233":8984,"_238":8986,"_43":8988,"_71":8989},[8985],277,[8987],315,{},"https://github.com/burdiyan/go-erriter","Some people have been discussing this problem before, and I also had a few attempts at solving this in my own work. Finally, I came up with something that I'm quite happy with — it's composable, and handles all the errors accurately, and I ended up publishing it as a library: https://github.com/burdiyan/go-erriter. I wish something like this was built into the standard library.",{"_33":8992,"_35":9029},[8993,9008,9015],{"_33":8994,"_35":9003},[8995],{"_33":8996,"_35":8997},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":8998,"_41":1286,"_43":8999,"_67":9001,"_69":9002,"_71":70},"FhMV0UWq",{"_4659":9000},"go",[],"func(yield func(T) bool)",{"_37":199,"_39":9004,"_41":1275,"_43":9005,"_67":9006,"_69":9007,"_71":70},"piNX2kXG",{"_194":195},[],"Imagine you're iterating over rows from a database or lines from a network connection. Standard Go iterators look like this:",{"_33":9009,"_35":9010},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9011,"_41":1286,"_43":9012,"_67":9013,"_69":9014,"_71":70},"w0y4QKv-",{},[],"There's no return value for the iterator function itself, which means there's no obvious channel to communicate an error back to the caller if the iteration fails midway or if cleanup (like closing a connection) fails.",{"_33":9016,"_35":9017},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9018,"_41":1286,"_43":9019,"_67":9020,"_69":9028,"_71":70},"ZOz4Dd42",{},[9021],{"_37":4656,"_233":9022,"_238":9025,"_43":9027,"_71":70},[9023,9024],160,169,[9026,3661],165,{},"You might try to work around this by capturing errors in a closure variable, but handling cleanup correctly — especially when the loop is terminated early with break or return becomes tricky and boilerplate-heavy.",{"_37":190,"_39":9030,"_41":1286,"_43":9031,"_67":9032,"_69":9033,"_71":70},"vGVPzHGi",{"_194":195},[],"The Problem: Iterators That Can Fail",{"_33":9035,"_35":9079},[9036,9054,9061,9068],{"_33":9037,"_35":9045},[9038],{"_33":9039,"_35":9040},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":9041,"_41":1286,"_43":9042,"_67":9043,"_69":9044,"_71":70},"4ztA1O1B",{"_4659":9000},[],"type Seq[T any] func(yield func(T) bool) error",{"_37":199,"_39":9046,"_41":1275,"_43":9047,"_67":9048,"_69":9053,"_71":70},"3OQBs5KT",{"_194":195},[9049],{"_37":4656,"_233":9050,"_238":9051,"_43":9052,"_71":70},[7543],[553],{},"Package go-erriter introduces a simple extension to the standard pattern:",{"_33":9055,"_35":9056},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9057,"_41":1286,"_43":9058,"_67":9059,"_69":9060,"_71":70},"vj5HtPfF",{},[],"It allows the iterator function to return an error — be it at the beginning, at the middle, or at the end of the iteration.",{"_33":9062,"_35":9063},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9064,"_41":1286,"_43":9065,"_67":9066,"_69":9067,"_71":70},"Lr-Ee695",{},[],"The great benefit of this is composability — you can easily chain multiple error-aware iterators together — for example one iterator reads raw database values, while a higher-level iterator does the unmarshaling, all while correctly handling the potential errors.",{"_33":9069,"_35":9070},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9071,"_41":1286,"_43":9072,"_67":9073,"_69":9078,"_71":70},"AUc5L-sK",{},[9074],{"_37":4656,"_233":9075,"_238":9076,"_43":9077,"_71":70},[3802,4035],[4185,3908],{},"Of course you can't simply range over this iterator in a for loop — you'd need to call a method first (reminder that Go allows for function types to have methods too). More on that below.",{"_37":190,"_39":9080,"_41":1286,"_43":9081,"_67":9082,"_69":9087,"_71":70},"RTliVyjJ",{"_194":195},[9083],{"_37":4656,"_233":9084,"_238":9085,"_43":9086,"_71":70},[3853],[6366],{},"The Solution: erriter.Seq[T]",{"_33":9089,"_35":9245},[9090,9108,9152,9168,9181,9194,9220],{"_33":9091,"_35":9099},[9092],{"_33":9093,"_35":9094},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":9095,"_41":1286,"_43":9096,"_67":9097,"_69":9098,"_71":70},"MEXcDLHn",{"_4659":9000},[],"func (iter Seq[T]) All() (it iter.Seq[T], discard func(*error), check func() error)",{"_37":199,"_39":9100,"_41":1275,"_43":9101,"_67":9102,"_69":9107,"_71":70},"8hMTq5Ec",{"_194":195},[9103],{"_37":4656,"_233":9104,"_238":9105,"_43":9106,"_71":70},[3778,4264],[6699,6441],{},"The core of the library is the Seq.All() method, which bridges our error-aware iterators, with Go's standard iter.Seq iterators:",{"_33":9109,"_35":9147},[9110,9125,9136],{"_33":9111,"_35":9112},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9113,"_41":1286,"_43":9114,"_67":9115,"_69":9124,"_71":70},"RX6Urfx_",{},[9116,9120],{"_37":232,"_233":9117,"_238":9118,"_43":9119,"_71":70},[139],[7543],{},{"_37":4656,"_233":9121,"_238":9122,"_43":9123,"_71":70},[8468,3798],[4185,4839],{},"Iterator: A standard iter.Seq[T] safe for use in a range loop.",{"_33":9126,"_35":9127},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9128,"_41":1286,"_43":9129,"_67":9130,"_69":9135,"_71":70},"krpqn25z",{},[9131],{"_37":232,"_233":9132,"_238":9133,"_43":9134,"_71":70},[139],[5284],{},"Discard function: A cleanup helper that captures errors if you exit the loop early.",{"_33":9137,"_35":9138},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9139,"_41":1286,"_43":9140,"_67":9141,"_69":9146,"_71":70},"Ma6G2AzH",{},[9142],{"_37":232,"_233":9143,"_238":9144,"_43":9145,"_71":70},[139],[3853],{},"Check function: A final error check to run after the loop completes.",{"_37":199,"_39":9148,"_41":1286,"_43":9149,"_67":9150,"_69":9151,"_71":70},"YDKuij5x",{"_194":5405},[],"It returns three values:",{"_33":9153,"_35":9154},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9155,"_41":1286,"_43":9156,"_67":9157,"_69":9167,"_71":70},"ydmvJa0e",{},[9158],{"_37":4656,"_233":9159,"_238":9163,"_43":9166,"_71":70},[9160,6849,9161,9162],82,193,209,[9164,288,6904,9165],89,216,{},"Important point here is that the actual error check only happens once — either at discard step if you exit the loop early, or at the end of the loop with check if you finish it normally. After check is called discard is a no-op.",{"_33":9169,"_35":9170},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9171,"_41":1286,"_43":9172,"_67":9173,"_69":9180,"_71":70},"DsMJ5mLb",{},[9174],{"_37":4656,"_233":9175,"_238":9176,"_43":9179,"_71":70},[4120,6998],[9177,9178],9,127,{},"The check function allows you to close the iterator explicitly after iterating, without having to wait for the deferred discard. This can be useful to free up resources sooner, if your function needs to do some extra work after consuming the iterator.",{"_33":9182,"_35":9183},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9184,"_41":1286,"_43":9185,"_67":9186,"_69":9193,"_71":70},"pbO13bQu",{},[9187],{"_37":4656,"_233":9188,"_238":9190,"_43":9192,"_71":70},[9189,6853],144,[9191,9023],151,{},"The fact that it returns three values instead of a struct with methods lets us take advantage of the compiler — it won't let you forget to call discard or check, making it harder to misuse them.",{"_33":9195,"_35":9215},[9196],{"_33":9197,"_35":9205},[9198],{"_33":9199,"_35":9200},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":9201,"_41":1286,"_43":9202,"_67":9203,"_69":9204,"_71":70},"SmkeKclQ",{"_4659":9000},[],"func processStream(it erriter.Seq[string]) (err error) {\n // 1. Get the iterator and control functions.\n items, discard, check := it.All()\n \n // 2. Defer discard to handle cleanup errors if we return early.\n defer discard(&err)\n\n for item := range items {\n if err := handleItem(item); err != nil {\n // 3. Safe early return: discard will catch any cleanup errors\n // from the iterator and join them with your error.\n return err\n }\n }\n\n // 4. Check for errors that occurred during natural completion.\n if err := check(); err != nil {\n return err\n }\n\n // Possibly do something else here...\n\n return nil\n}",{"_37":199,"_39":9206,"_41":1275,"_43":9207,"_67":9208,"_69":9214,"_71":70},"BmfWiho_",{"_194":195},[9209],{"_37":4656,"_233":9210,"_238":9211,"_43":9213,"_71":70},[5059],[9212],185,{},"Here is an example of consuming the error-aware iterator inside a function. Notice how we can handle the errors normally and simply return from inside the loop as usual, letting discard take care of the iterator cleanup errors.",{"_37":190,"_39":9216,"_41":1286,"_43":9217,"_67":9218,"_69":9219,"_71":70},"X64C6xiM",{"_194":195},[],"Example: Consuming an Iterator",{"_33":9221,"_35":9240},[9222],{"_33":9223,"_35":9231},[9224],{"_33":9225,"_35":9226},[],{"_37":4656,"_39":9227,"_41":1286,"_43":9228,"_67":9229,"_69":9230,"_71":70},"C3cIUnIC",{"_4659":9000},[],"func queryUsers(db *Database) erriter.Seq[User] {\n return erriter.Make(func(yield func(User) bool) error {\n cursor, err := db.Query(\"SELECT * FROM users\")\n if err != nil {\n return err\n }\n \n // Ensure we close the cursor, even if the user breaks the loop.\n defer func() {\n if closeErr := cursor.Close(); closeErr != nil {\n err = errors.Join(err, closeErr)\n }\n }()\n\n for cursor.Next() {\n user := cursor.User()\n // Standard yield pattern.\n if !yield(user) {\n break\n }\n }\n\n // Return any error that happened during iteration.\n return cursor.Err()\n })\n}",{"_37":199,"_39":9232,"_41":1275,"_43":9233,"_67":9234,"_69":9239,"_71":70},"6Smy2coR",{"_194":195},[9235],{"_37":4656,"_233":9236,"_238":9237,"_43":9238,"_71":70},[2396],[5062],{},"Creating an error-aware iterator is just as straightforward using erriter.Make.",{"_37":190,"_39":9241,"_41":1286,"_43":9242,"_67":9243,"_69":9244,"_71":70},"GfJb_yxL",{"_194":195},[],"Example: Producing an Iterator",{"_37":190,"_39":9246,"_41":1286,"_43":9247,"_67":9248,"_69":9249,"_71":70},"KAQEVTYG",{"_194":195},[],"How It Works",[1278,55],"/private-notes/handling-errors-in-gos-range-functions-iterators","2025-11-26T16:53:39.865Z",{"_83":1294},{},{"_39":1272,"_97":55,"_56":9256,"_72":1275,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1274],1772124423542,[151,1272,1275],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/handling-errors-in-gos-range-functions-iterators\",\"bafy2bzacedl2xhupaazhaaa4fwknmlvzq3bzqxssm5mfbu3lm6fwumyb6wpuy\"]",{"_112":9261,"_149":9316,"_152":9317},{"_114":9262,"_133":134,"_135":9315,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":9263,"_39":9313},{"_30":9264,"_72":1300,"_73":55,"_74":9309,"_56":9310,"_77":1307,"_79":1307,"_81":9311,"_86":9312,"_88":1300,"_90":91},[9265],{"_33":9266,"_35":9304},[9267],{"_33":9268,"_35":9269},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9270,"_41":1300,"_43":9271,"_67":9272,"_69":9303,"_71":70},"YbcZ0T2_",{},[9273,9277,9284,9290,9297],{"_37":232,"_233":9274,"_238":9275,"_43":9276,"_71":70},[139],[5288],{},{"_37":286,"_233":9278,"_238":9280,"_43":9282,"_71":9283},[9279],205,[9281],215,{},"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Help:Talk_pages",{"_37":286,"_233":9285,"_238":9287,"_43":9288,"_71":9289},[9286],602,[4698],{},"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Talk_page_guidelines",{"_37":286,"_233":9291,"_238":9293,"_43":9295,"_71":9296},[9292],697,[9294],711,{},"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reference_desk",{"_37":286,"_233":9298,"_238":9299,"_43":9301,"_71":9302},[4612],[9300],742,{},"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reference_desk/Guidelines","Discussion forums. Stay on the task of creating an encyclopedia. You can chat with people about Wikipedia-related topics on their user talk pages, and should resolve problems with articles on the relevant talk pages, but do not take discussion into articles. In addition, bear in mind that article talk pages exist solely to discuss how to improve articles; they are not for general discussion or voicing opinions about the article topic or anything else. Nor are they a help desk for obtaining instructions or technical assistance. Material unsuitable for talk pages may be subject to removal per the talk page guidelines. If you wish to ask a question on a topic other than Wikipedia there is a Reference desk with Reference Desk guidelines.",{"_37":166,"_39":9305,"_41":1300,"_43":9306,"_67":9307,"_69":70,"_71":9308},"5wk19pTw",{"_194":195,"_170":7190},[],"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/hypertext/wikipedia-editing-policy?v=bafy2bzacecdjv5zgxoaqqnggfwe3yvcgpqeyfgi5rvg6vbyopxennu7qjolx4#kspXZMqQ+",[55],"/private-notes/wikipedia-is-not-a-forum",{"_83":1316},{},{"_39":1297,"_97":55,"_56":9314,"_72":1300,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1299],1772124423514,[151,1297,1300],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/wikipedia-is-not-a-forum\",\"bafy2bzaceb5kgbjr6yxyeivgc4wf5u3lffc2v7hlg3pxlsrg3sp2aeo2ed6ce\"]",{"_112":9319,"_149":9556,"_152":9557},{"_114":9320,"_133":134,"_135":9555,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":9321,"_39":9553},{"_30":9322,"_72":1322,"_73":55,"_74":9549,"_56":3400,"_77":1331,"_79":9550,"_81":9551,"_86":9552,"_88":1332,"_90":91},[9323,9330,9338,9345,9353,9360,9367,9374,9382,9388,9395,9402,9409,9416,9423,9430,9437,9444,9521],{"_33":9324,"_35":9325},[],{"_37":3447,"_39":9326,"_41":1322,"_43":9327,"_67":9328,"_69":70,"_71":9329},"pJ0KHRw9",{"_194":195},[],"https://www.youtube.com/embed/NAfjEnu6R2g",{"_33":9331,"_35":9332},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9333,"_41":9334,"_43":9335,"_67":9336,"_69":9337,"_71":70},"kHfKapzw","bafy2bzaceazzoy6j5unfd4l5zwr5c2cgrm53f5hftmsvyus4pa2pnikaldnry",{},[],"Robust to attacks and open for strangers. ",{"_33":9339,"_35":9340},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9341,"_41":9334,"_43":9342,"_67":9343,"_69":9344,"_71":70},"wKtbHWrm",{},[],"Knowledge collaboration with strangers. Offer Software services on an open network.",{"_33":9346,"_35":9347},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":9348,"_41":1322,"_43":9349,"_67":9351,"_69":70,"_71":9352},"f9GbxiOX",{"_194":195,"_3508":9350},336,[],"ipfs://bafybeifp6diigxr5ejmswoynfr6wqckfibawba2ufmtogu4i3s7a2kanky",{"_33":9354,"_35":9355},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9356,"_41":9334,"_43":9357,"_67":9358,"_69":9359,"_71":70},"u9rEeXzm",{},[],"The problem comes when the bad actors attack the network we need to move to our central services for safety. We want to fight back to keep the network open.",{"_33":9361,"_35":9362},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":9363,"_41":1322,"_43":9364,"_67":9365,"_69":70,"_71":9366},"4HaV2iJL",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreieqynbgpa6hkjf3j25drvnsw42r4iog2jg26p7x5hucodu7zwu7jq",{"_33":9368,"_35":9369},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9370,"_41":9334,"_43":9371,"_67":9372,"_69":9373,"_71":70},"1Phvcqrd",{},[],"In the early days of the Internet, everyone was naively cooperating because no one was attacking. when bad actors started attacking, we moved to safety, sacrificing cooperation. ",{"_33":9375,"_35":9376},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":9377,"_41":1322,"_43":9378,"_67":9380,"_69":70,"_71":9381},"ApMwZPDE",{"_194":195,"_3508":9379},526,[],"ipfs://bafkreiaw2msbxtad3c7axc7ulcbcoi4x6hhqdh62i3kckaumy6cg47hbgm",{"_33":9383,"_35":9384},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9385,"_41":9334,"_43":9386,"_67":9387,"_69":70,"_71":70},"_fHwgeFP",{},[],{"_33":9389,"_35":9390},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9391,"_41":9334,"_43":9392,"_67":9393,"_69":9394,"_71":70},"8VAFe6NX",{},[],"How are we doing this with hardware Giving us Address Space boundaries, memory-safe languages, Object encapsulation, and Modern Cryptography giving us crypto primitives for safety.",{"_33":9396,"_35":9397},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":9398,"_41":1322,"_43":9399,"_67":9400,"_69":70,"_71":9401},"fkMxy7PZ",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreidfptp5ovs2zbshidcwxf7wgvepxlnkhibmq4ivisprkzmlwpprwy",{"_33":9403,"_35":9404},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9405,"_41":9334,"_43":9406,"_67":9407,"_69":9408,"_71":70},"nQKBukta",{},[],"Impersonation: No one can seem to be you.",{"_33":9410,"_35":9411},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9412,"_41":9334,"_43":9413,"_67":9414,"_69":9415,"_71":70},"KdyMjrXz",{},[],"Censorship: No one can take your \"name\" away from you.",{"_33":9417,"_35":9418},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9419,"_41":9334,"_43":9420,"_67":9421,"_69":9422,"_71":70},"4GxvKcck",{},[],"A successful example is Bitcoin. Your key pair is your account and holder of the coins. No one can spend your Bitcoin, and no one can prevent you from spending it.",{"_33":9424,"_35":9425},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9426,"_41":9334,"_43":9427,"_67":9428,"_69":9429,"_71":70},"fpI_Uwyb",{},[],"We did the same thing for our knowledge and ability to communicate with each other.",{"_33":9431,"_35":9432},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9433,"_41":9334,"_43":9434,"_67":9435,"_69":9436,"_71":70},"QyJDqLlB",{},[],"We need to solve two Kinds of Safety. Proactive and Reactive.",{"_33":9438,"_35":9439},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":9440,"_41":1322,"_43":9441,"_67":9442,"_69":70,"_71":9443},"AD5mtodd",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeiddot2lbhtmao5mdppj6vmszp2fta65ww5dswzrdexxu7c67xdqzm",{"_33":9445,"_35":9516},[9446],{"_33":9447,"_35":9511},[9448,9455,9462,9469,9483],{"_33":9449,"_35":9450},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9451,"_41":9334,"_43":9452,"_67":9453,"_69":9454,"_71":70},"l3hfZq3X",{},[],"Is this right?",{"_33":9456,"_35":9457},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9458,"_41":9334,"_43":9459,"_67":9460,"_69":9461,"_71":70},"52b4jUwW",{},[],"We have a Subscritpion Lists.",{"_33":9463,"_35":9464},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9465,"_41":9334,"_43":9466,"_67":9467,"_69":9468,"_71":70},"q9j8B1ch",{},[],"We have Contact Lists.",{"_33":9470,"_35":9478},[9471],{"_33":9472,"_35":9473},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9474,"_41":9334,"_43":9475,"_67":9476,"_69":9477,"_71":70},"MO-O8Eu2",{},[],"Collaborators goes with the",{"_37":199,"_39":9479,"_41":1332,"_43":9480,"_67":9481,"_69":9482,"_71":70},"F3Ewhcys",{"_194":3876},[],"How are we going to store Passkeys? Or members? Or Paid Subscriber Or Collaborator.",{"_33":9484,"_35":9506},[9485,9492],{"_33":9486,"_35":9487},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9488,"_41":9334,"_43":9489,"_67":9490,"_69":9491,"_71":70},"uUdQA1fp",{},[],"Twitter Proof.",{"_33":9493,"_35":9501},[9494],{"_33":9495,"_35":9496},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9497,"_41":9334,"_43":9498,"_67":9499,"_69":9500,"_71":70},"gD9S6vu0",{},[],"Who",{"_37":199,"_39":9502,"_41":1332,"_43":9503,"_67":9504,"_69":9505,"_71":70},"U4Ub2v4Z",{"_194":3876},[],"Email Proofs",{"_37":199,"_39":9507,"_41":1332,"_43":9508,"_67":9509,"_69":9510,"_71":70},"_A8_Ia5k",{"_194":3876},[],"Contact are Set of Proofs:",{"_37":199,"_39":9512,"_41":1332,"_43":9513,"_67":9514,"_69":9515,"_71":70},"8fVihB1Z",{"_194":3876},[],"up to now, everything is p2p content. ",{"_37":199,"_39":9517,"_41":1332,"_43":9518,"_67":9519,"_69":9520,"_71":70},"6ZUiIQ8v",{"_194":3876},[],"Are we storing passkeys or emails on a node?",{"_33":9522,"_35":9544},[9523,9530,9537],{"_33":9524,"_35":9525},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9526,"_41":9334,"_43":9527,"_67":9528,"_69":9529,"_71":70},"06NQMXvv",{},[],"Add a reputation system that can contain abusive activities.",{"_33":9531,"_35":9532},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9533,"_41":9334,"_43":9534,"_67":9535,"_69":9536,"_71":70},"6mdQsIA8",{},[],"Object Capabilities to improve the security and performance of the network.",{"_33":9538,"_35":9539},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9540,"_41":9334,"_43":9541,"_67":9542,"_69":9543,"_71":70},"Co-kpzNv",{},[],"(together with an efficient Pub Sub gossiping and peer exchange protocols should be enough to provide with a Robust and Open Seed Web Network)",{"_37":190,"_39":9545,"_41":9334,"_43":9546,"_67":9547,"_69":9548,"_71":70},"OqNqvGbN",{"_194":195},[],"Conclusion",[55],"2025-11-24T12:55:14.225Z",{"_83":1341},{},{"_39":1319,"_97":55,"_56":9554,"_72":1322,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1321],1772124423768,[151,1319,1322],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/robust-opennes\",\"bafy2bzaceddjds4z7klrw7v2o5sy572ow5vegsur3jjoi5gfkyl6vjucpzliw\"]",{"_112":9559,"_149":9570,"_152":9571},{"_114":9560,"_133":134,"_135":9569,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":9561,"_39":9567},{"_30":9562,"_72":1347,"_73":55,"_74":9563,"_56":9564,"_77":1354,"_79":1354,"_81":9565,"_86":9566,"_88":1347,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/glucose-spikes",{"_83":1363},{},{"_39":1344,"_97":55,"_56":9568,"_72":1347,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1346],1772124423522,[151,1344,1347],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/glucose-spikes\",\"bafy2bzaceal477qcnot3ikdodtguvfiqcw5x3faocdruc4knq43a45m4fnz3o\"]",{"_112":9573,"_149":9584,"_152":9585},{"_114":9574,"_133":134,"_135":9583,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":9575,"_39":9581},{"_30":9576,"_72":1369,"_73":55,"_74":9577,"_56":9578,"_77":1376,"_79":1376,"_81":9579,"_86":9580,"_88":1369,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/testing-new-seed-app",{"_83":1385},{},{"_39":1366,"_97":55,"_56":9582,"_72":1369,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1368],1772124423532,[151,1366,1369],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/testing-new-seed-app\",\"bafy2bzacedlbhmcmzoyss35yq5zu4npmopte24ezfbz2muyklrhdu2lynjzly\"]",{"_112":9587,"_149":9612,"_152":9613},{"_114":9588,"_133":134,"_135":9611,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":9589,"_39":9609},{"_30":9590,"_72":1391,"_73":55,"_74":9605,"_56":9606,"_77":1398,"_79":1398,"_81":9607,"_86":9608,"_88":1391,"_90":91},[9591,9598],{"_33":9592,"_35":9593},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9594,"_41":1391,"_43":9595,"_67":9596,"_69":9597,"_71":70},"KLNGNLCc",{},[],"OLIVIA: Por nosotros, que seguimos en camino: para que sepamos vivir con fe, con amor y con entrega, recordando que nuestra vida está en manos de Dios, y un día todos nos encontraremos en su luz.",{"_33":9599,"_35":9600},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9601,"_41":1391,"_43":9602,"_67":9603,"_69":9604,"_71":70},"URdmxKE7",{},[],"R. Te rogamos, óyenos.",[55],"/private-notes/peticion-olivia",{"_83":1407},{},{"_39":1388,"_97":55,"_56":9610,"_72":1391,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1390],1772124423546,[151,1388,1391],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/peticion-olivia\",\"bafy2bzacebgnvvnvhk7edmirgq3dnvj4sgcddkc665wbrkahi2jwvladjtmia\"]",{"_112":9615,"_149":9805,"_152":9806},{"_114":9616,"_133":134,"_135":9804,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":9617,"_39":9802},{"_30":9618,"_72":1413,"_73":55,"_74":9798,"_56":9799,"_77":1420,"_79":1420,"_81":9800,"_86":9801,"_88":1413,"_90":91},[9619,9725,9736,9787],{"_33":9620,"_35":9712},[9621,9644,9667,9689],{"_33":9622,"_35":9635},[9623],{"_33":9624,"_35":9625},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9626,"_41":1413,"_43":9627,"_67":9628,"_69":9634,"_71":70},"MQqJjRj5",{},[9629],{"_37":3795,"_233":9630,"_238":9632,"_43":9633,"_71":70},[9631],86,[5057],{},"“Information” is a very broad, academic-sounding word. It doesn’t carry the nuance of knowledge, insight, or community updates. It can feel dry compared to “Publish” or “Curate.”",{"_37":199,"_39":9636,"_41":1413,"_43":9637,"_67":9638,"_69":9643,"_71":70},"lT8sQeao",{"_194":3876},[9639],{"_37":232,"_233":9640,"_238":9641,"_43":9642,"_71":70},[139],[452],{},"Too Generic",{"_33":9645,"_35":9658},[9646],{"_33":9647,"_35":9648},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9649,"_41":1413,"_43":9650,"_67":9651,"_69":9657,"_71":70},"avUkdoWx",{},[9652],{"_37":3795,"_233":9653,"_238":9654,"_43":9656,"_71":70},[3971],[9655],75,{},"A feed is usually about updates, activity, discussions, knowledge in motion. “Information” sounds static — like looking something up in a database — not navigating living community activity.",{"_37":199,"_39":9659,"_41":1413,"_43":9660,"_67":9661,"_69":9666,"_71":70},"zovYCD8T",{"_194":3876},[9662],{"_37":232,"_233":9663,"_238":9664,"_43":9665,"_71":70},[139],[6366],{},"Lacks Connection to the Feed",{"_33":9668,"_35":9680},[9669],{"_33":9670,"_35":9671},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9672,"_41":1413,"_43":9673,"_67":9674,"_69":9679,"_71":70},"0x-PVDaL",{},[9675],{"_37":3795,"_233":9676,"_238":9677,"_43":9678,"_71":70},[5063],[4848],{},"“Seek Information” can sound bureaucratic, like something from a library science manual, instead of something you want to do every day in Seed.",{"_37":199,"_39":9681,"_41":1413,"_43":9682,"_67":9683,"_69":9688,"_71":70},"RkPavD4N",{"_194":3876},[9684],{"_37":232,"_233":9685,"_238":9686,"_43":9687,"_71":70},[139],[553],{},"Old-fashioned Tone",{"_33":9690,"_35":9703},[9691],{"_33":9692,"_35":9693},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9694,"_41":1413,"_43":9695,"_67":9696,"_69":9702,"_71":70},"LllZLVMu",{},[9697],{"_37":3795,"_233":9698,"_238":9699,"_43":9701,"_71":70},[9655],[9700],128,{},"Seeking information is about finding raw data. In Seed, the deeper goal is making sense, surfacing insights, or connecting ideas. “Information” doesn’t capture that higher-level activity.",{"_37":199,"_39":9704,"_41":1413,"_43":9705,"_67":9706,"_69":9711,"_71":70},"59HhUfyL",{"_194":3876},[9707],{"_37":232,"_233":9708,"_238":9709,"_43":9710,"_71":70},[139],[4143],{},"Missing Agency on Meaning",{"_37":199,"_39":9713,"_41":1413,"_43":9714,"_67":9715,"_69":9724,"_71":70},"4Ua-WVb6",{"_194":5405},[9716,9720],{"_37":232,"_233":9717,"_238":9718,"_43":9719,"_71":70},[452],[4157],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":9721,"_238":9722,"_43":9723,"_71":70},[6884],[3804],{},"The phrase “Seek Information” isn’t wrong — it’s actually quite strong — but here are the issues that might make it feel off in your context:",{"_33":9726,"_35":9727},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9728,"_41":1413,"_43":9729,"_67":9730,"_69":9735,"_71":70},"i1rFm2x5",{},[9731],{"_37":3795,"_233":9732,"_238":9733,"_43":9734,"_71":70},[5290,5056],[3804,5723],{},"👉 So the main problem isn’t the verb Seek (which is active and strong) — it’s the noun Information. That’s what weakens it.",{"_33":9737,"_35":9782},[9738,9749,9760,9771],{"_33":9739,"_35":9740},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9741,"_41":1413,"_43":9742,"_67":9743,"_69":9748,"_71":70},"Lv83nrct",{},[9744],{"_37":232,"_233":9745,"_238":9746,"_43":9747,"_71":70},[139],[3853],{},"Seek Knowledge",{"_33":9750,"_35":9751},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9752,"_41":1413,"_43":9753,"_67":9754,"_69":9759,"_71":70},"MGKMewpq",{},[9755],{"_37":232,"_233":9756,"_238":9757,"_43":9758,"_71":70},[139],[3851],{},"Seek Insights",{"_33":9761,"_35":9762},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9763,"_41":1413,"_43":9764,"_67":9765,"_69":9770,"_71":70},"9qwa2UAb",{},[9766],{"_37":232,"_233":9767,"_238":9768,"_43":9769,"_71":70},[139],[5288],{},"Seek What Matters",{"_33":9772,"_35":9773},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9774,"_41":1413,"_43":9775,"_67":9776,"_69":9781,"_71":70},"LDDnZjuH",{},[9777],{"_37":232,"_233":9778,"_238":9779,"_43":9780,"_71":70},[139],[4670],{},"Seek Ideas",{"_37":199,"_39":9783,"_41":1413,"_43":9784,"_67":9785,"_69":9786,"_71":70},"8ReNfNF1",{"_194":3876},[],"If you love the verb, you could sharpen the object:",{"_33":9788,"_35":9789},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9790,"_41":1413,"_43":9791,"_67":9792,"_69":9797,"_71":70},"WzICEl_o",{},[9793],{"_37":232,"_233":9794,"_238":9795,"_43":9796,"_71":70},[4143],[3804],{},"Do you want me to rework Seek Information into 3–4 sharper alternatives that keep the spirit of “seeking” but align better with Seed’s voice?",[55],"/private-notes/fixed",{"_83":1428},{},{"_39":1410,"_97":55,"_56":9803,"_72":1413,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1412],1772124423754,[151,1410,1413],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/fixed\",\"bafy2bzacecpos2zpz2nk7bdkhhiz5aa4lypvwk37si6muuudxpwgouh37nw5u\"]",{"_112":9808,"_149":10036,"_152":10037},{"_114":9809,"_133":134,"_135":10035,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":9810,"_39":10033},{"_30":9811,"_72":1434,"_73":55,"_74":10029,"_56":10030,"_77":1441,"_79":1441,"_81":10031,"_86":10032,"_88":1434,"_90":91},[9812],{"_33":9813,"_35":10020},[9814],{"_33":9815,"_35":10015},[9816,9869,9887,9898,9972,10004],{"_33":9817,"_35":9860},[9818,9846,9853],{"_33":9819,"_35":9841},[9820,9827,9834],{"_33":9821,"_35":9822},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9823,"_41":1434,"_43":9824,"_67":9825,"_69":9826,"_71":70},"gqAYf_Dm",{},[],"On Seed Community. (preferred way)",{"_33":9828,"_35":9829},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9830,"_41":1434,"_43":9831,"_67":9832,"_69":9833,"_71":70},"cuj7DbbI",{},[],"Informal conversations through other mediums.",{"_33":9835,"_35":9836},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9837,"_41":1434,"_43":9838,"_67":9839,"_69":9840,"_71":70},"BAN-5XlB",{},[],"Structured UX interviews.",{"_37":199,"_39":9842,"_41":1434,"_43":9843,"_67":9844,"_69":9845,"_71":70},"-OBLg9Nv",{"_194":5405},[],"Medium for communication:",{"_33":9847,"_35":9848},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9849,"_41":1434,"_43":9850,"_67":9851,"_69":9852,"_71":70},"X5rArIjQ",{},[],"This process applies to new User Actions or Old User Actions (existing features).",{"_33":9854,"_35":9855},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9856,"_41":1434,"_43":9857,"_67":9858,"_69":9859,"_71":70},"SdUa1Quk",{},[],"All the conversations and conclusions must be documented on Seed.",{"_37":199,"_39":9861,"_41":1434,"_43":9862,"_67":9863,"_69":9868,"_71":70},"NFV3DT_M",{"_194":3876},[9864],{"_37":232,"_233":9865,"_238":9866,"_43":9867,"_71":70},[139],[3851],{},"Talk to users. Talk to users and identify pains, ideas, and opportunities under the Story Map structure:",{"_33":9870,"_35":9878},[9871],{"_33":9872,"_35":9873},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9874,"_41":1434,"_43":9875,"_67":9876,"_69":9877,"_71":70},"9pl-9bxC",{},[],"We also structure the Story Map to build a shared understanding of the product narrative across all the team members.",{"_37":199,"_39":9879,"_41":1434,"_43":9880,"_67":9881,"_69":9886,"_71":70},"PvLuojjJ",{"_194":195},[9882],{"_37":232,"_233":9883,"_238":9884,"_43":9885,"_71":70},[139],[5290],{},"Task Analysis and Story Map Building. Based on this information we build new Stories or change existing Stories through argumentation based on these user conversations.",{"_33":9888,"_35":9889},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9890,"_41":1434,"_43":9891,"_67":9892,"_69":9897,"_71":70},"VYZUU8pa",{},[9893],{"_37":232,"_233":9894,"_238":9895,"_43":9896,"_71":70},[139],[5290],{},"Identify the Opportunities and Ideas.",{"_33":9899,"_35":9963},[9900,9935,9942],{"_33":9901,"_35":9930},[9902,9909,9916,9923],{"_33":9903,"_35":9904},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9905,"_41":1434,"_43":9906,"_67":9907,"_69":9908,"_71":70},"avLl44OA",{},[],"Personas.",{"_33":9910,"_35":9911},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9912,"_41":1434,"_43":9913,"_67":9914,"_69":9915,"_71":70},"PLdPxwLd",{},[],"Activities, Stories, and Goals.",{"_33":9917,"_35":9918},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9919,"_41":1434,"_43":9920,"_67":9921,"_69":9922,"_71":70},"2n95EAq9",{},[],"Information required by the user to performed the user task.",{"_33":9924,"_35":9925},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9926,"_41":1434,"_43":9927,"_67":9928,"_69":9929,"_71":70},"rZZ_EVvM",{},[],"Design.",{"_37":199,"_39":9931,"_41":1434,"_43":9932,"_67":9933,"_69":9934,"_71":70},"zlLY7P4S",{"_194":5405},[],"The Design needs to include:",{"_33":9936,"_35":9937},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9938,"_41":1434,"_43":9939,"_67":9940,"_69":9941,"_71":70},"eTFJMgA9",{},[],"Write Concepts and Definitions of the User Model.",{"_33":9943,"_35":9958},[9944,9951],{"_33":9945,"_35":9946},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9947,"_41":1434,"_43":9948,"_67":9949,"_69":9950,"_71":70},"6ZYFEu5k",{},[]," Protobuf and Schemas.",{"_33":9952,"_35":9953},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9954,"_41":1434,"_43":9955,"_67":9956,"_69":9957,"_71":70},"kazqzLcP",{},[],"Overview of the main ideas in the implementation.",{"_37":199,"_39":9959,"_41":1434,"_43":9960,"_67":9961,"_69":9962,"_71":70},"yYCyJhCg",{"_194":5405},[],"Technical Description:",{"_37":199,"_39":9964,"_41":1434,"_43":9965,"_67":9966,"_69":9971,"_71":70},"VrBahRzA",{"_194":5405},[9967],{"_37":232,"_233":9968,"_238":9969,"_43":9970,"_71":70},[139],[3776],{},"Write a Pitch. Writing projects should normally fast, as we will already have most of the required information in the repository, unless we are breaking ground.",{"_33":9973,"_35":9995},[9974,9981,9988],{"_33":9975,"_35":9976},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9977,"_41":1434,"_43":9978,"_67":9979,"_69":9980,"_71":70},"jX7b5z8C",{},[],"Greenlight projects.",{"_33":9982,"_35":9983},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9984,"_41":1434,"_43":9985,"_67":9986,"_69":9987,"_71":70},"mfAHKcwO",{},[],"Cancel projects.",{"_33":9989,"_35":9990},[],{"_37":199,"_39":9991,"_41":1434,"_43":9992,"_67":9993,"_69":9994,"_71":70},"bqEECgGn",{},[],"Reorder priorities.",{"_37":199,"_39":9996,"_41":1434,"_43":9997,"_67":9998,"_69":10003,"_71":70},"QPp3RAs8",{"_194":3876},[9999],{"_37":232,"_233":10000,"_238":10001,"_43":10002,"_71":70},[139],[6884],{},"Evaluate the Roadmap - Betting Table.",{"_33":10005,"_35":10006},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10007,"_41":1434,"_43":10008,"_67":10009,"_69":10014,"_71":70},"Smegmo2g",{},[10010],{"_37":232,"_233":10011,"_238":10012,"_43":10013,"_71":70},[139],[6084],{},"Talk to users again. Weekly Learning, evaluate outcome.",{"_37":199,"_39":10016,"_41":1434,"_43":10017,"_67":10018,"_69":10019,"_71":70},"Ng9tLGby",{"_194":5405},[],"Weekly learning and Build Less.",{"_37":190,"_39":10021,"_41":1434,"_43":10022,"_67":10023,"_69":10028,"_71":70},"DgxubZE9",{"_194":195},[10024],{"_37":232,"_233":10025,"_238":10026,"_43":10027,"_71":70},[139],[4143],{},"Methodology Feedback Loop",[55],"/private-notes/methodology",{"_83":1450},{},{"_39":1431,"_97":55,"_56":10034,"_72":1434,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1433],1772124423780,[151,1431,1434],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/methodology\",\"bafy2bzaceayxvmdfu477a4bsyyawhiwwn6vlqeet54wzhbgsuxlrzm4dcgvaa\"]",{"_112":10039,"_149":10642,"_152":10643},{"_114":10040,"_133":134,"_135":10641,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":10041,"_39":10639},{"_30":10042,"_72":1456,"_73":55,"_74":10635,"_56":10636,"_77":1463,"_79":1463,"_81":10637,"_86":10638,"_88":1456,"_90":91},[10043,10050,10057,10064,10071,10078,10113,10155,10161,10168,10175,10181,10202,10208,10214,10247,10463,10513,10534,10541,10552,10587,10594,10601,10608,10614,10628],{"_33":10044,"_35":10045},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10046,"_41":1456,"_43":10047,"_67":10048,"_69":10049,"_71":70},"9Gn7X6Ty",{},[],"Humans use language, tools, and methodologies in which they are trained as means to augment their intellect and cooperative work. The source of intelligence is the better organization of more complex processes. Our software is the artifact that aims to enable better processes and their usage. ",{"_33":10051,"_35":10052},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10053,"_41":1456,"_43":10054,"_67":10055,"_69":10056,"_71":70},"uj4-Z6yp",{},[],"The team has different skillsets and different tasks; designers, developers, and business managers need to collaborate, but if we don't create a common language of concepts, processes, and goals, it's hard to communicate. We end up with violent discussions and low effectiveness. Better ideas, better documents, and methods will make our work more effective and less violent.",{"_33":10058,"_35":10059},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10060,"_41":1456,"_43":10061,"_67":10062,"_69":10063,"_71":70},"sv7cOPfA",{},[],"The way developers work — their pace, languages, and rhythm — is quite different from that of interaction designers or business managers who are talking to users. It is challenging to articulate a development issue in design or business terms, and vice versa.",{"_33":10065,"_35":10066},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10067,"_41":1456,"_43":10068,"_67":10069,"_69":10070,"_71":70},"dRi4H-qZ",{},[],"The Idea of the Story Map is to bridge this chasm. by mapping we can retain the narrative structure, during the implementation and testing with users. Maintaining intact and enabling the argumentation if our the implementation is correct, the best one and overall, to test our hypothesis. The Process is fundamental to have a correct iteration loop and achieve our desperately desired product market fit.",{"_33":10072,"_35":10073},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10074,"_41":1456,"_43":10075,"_67":10076,"_69":10077,"_71":70},"EJEMdk89",{},[],"Suppose someone lacks the ability to understand concepts, write documents, structure processes, and engage in argumentation. In that case, we must let them go, because this is the core of our cooperative work and the tool we are building to assist it. Or we can train them until to learn the methodology.",{"_33":10079,"_35":10108},[10080,10087,10094,10101],{"_33":10081,"_35":10082},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10083,"_41":1456,"_43":10084,"_67":10085,"_69":10086,"_71":70},"AvFCEn2S",{},[],"Building a shared understanding. Most of the time, each team member has a different idea of every feature, concept, definition, user, and user goal we are building. We need to develop a common understanding quickly.",{"_33":10088,"_35":10089},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10090,"_41":1456,"_43":10091,"_67":10092,"_69":10093,"_71":70},"eRFEU5Kw",{},[],"Communication problem. We need better conversations.",{"_33":10095,"_35":10096},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10097,"_41":1456,"_43":10098,"_67":10099,"_69":10100,"_71":70},"N2p_yqxH",{},[],"We are not focused on users and their experience. We need a better product.",{"_33":10102,"_35":10103},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10104,"_41":1456,"_43":10105,"_67":10106,"_69":10107,"_71":70},"dJRTSna4",{},[],"Our development process is ineffective and slow. We need to deliver fast and iteratively.",{"_37":199,"_39":10109,"_41":1456,"_43":10110,"_67":10111,"_69":10112,"_71":70},"gZPCGh2l",{"_194":5405},[],"What are our problems, and what do we need?",{"_33":10114,"_35":10150},[10115,10122,10129,10136,10143],{"_33":10116,"_35":10117},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10118,"_41":1456,"_43":10119,"_67":10120,"_69":10121,"_71":70},"7l21ooD6",{},[],"In this Company, we read and comprehend structured documents and arguments from the rest of the team.",{"_33":10123,"_35":10124},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10125,"_41":1456,"_43":10126,"_67":10127,"_69":10128,"_71":70},"TJlXmw8V",{},[],"In this Company, we engage in argumentation and writing structured and living documents.",{"_33":10130,"_35":10131},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10132,"_41":1456,"_43":10133,"_67":10134,"_69":10135,"_71":70},"cMeDQxqb",{},[],"In this Company, we structure methodologies and processes.",{"_33":10137,"_35":10138},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10139,"_41":1456,"_43":10140,"_67":10141,"_69":10142,"_71":70},"ydiW-5w7",{},[],"In this Company, we create and work with concepts.",{"_33":10144,"_35":10145},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10146,"_41":1456,"_43":10147,"_67":10148,"_69":10149,"_71":70},"T_ljn152",{},[],"In this Company, we treat everybody with respect.",{"_37":190,"_39":10151,"_41":1456,"_43":10152,"_67":10153,"_69":10154,"_71":70},"pX5Kk1dE",{"_194":5405},[],"Principles",{"_33":10156,"_35":10157},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10158,"_41":1456,"_43":10159,"_67":10160,"_69":70,"_71":70},"5Pvq0Orw",{},[],{"_33":10162,"_35":10163},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10164,"_41":1456,"_43":10165,"_67":10166,"_69":10167,"_71":70},"BqfpVubj",{},[],"Jeff Patton creator of the concept of story mapping",{"_33":10169,"_35":10170},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":10171,"_41":1456,"_43":10172,"_67":10173,"_69":70,"_71":10174},"v08Ftwp3",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreieia4mtyholdstmricyz54nz5jpnb5xolgar3ag4xyhpmkxvimjzm",{"_33":10176,"_35":10177},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10178,"_41":1456,"_43":10179,"_67":10180,"_69":70,"_71":70},"ueHYmcyI",{},[],{"_33":10182,"_35":10197},[10183,10190],{"_33":10184,"_35":10185},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10186,"_41":1456,"_43":10187,"_67":10188,"_69":10189,"_71":70},"n4lO_5iz",{},[],"Design",{"_33":10191,"_35":10192},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10193,"_41":1456,"_43":10194,"_67":10195,"_69":10196,"_71":70},"z4JbONym",{},[],"Project: one to three weeks.",{"_37":199,"_39":10198,"_41":1456,"_43":10199,"_67":10200,"_69":10201,"_71":70},"vBRovVmR",{"_194":5405},[],"Development",{"_33":10203,"_35":10204},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10205,"_41":1456,"_43":10206,"_67":10207,"_69":70,"_71":70},"tm0oEMDG",{},[],{"_33":10209,"_35":10210},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10211,"_41":1456,"_43":10212,"_67":10213,"_69":70,"_71":70},"jG4U2yH1",{},[],{"_33":10215,"_35":10242},[10216,10228,10235],{"_33":10217,"_35":10218},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10219,"_41":1456,"_43":10220,"_67":10221,"_69":10227,"_71":70},"EpVPpgl9",{},[10222],{"_37":3795,"_233":10223,"_238":10224,"_43":10226,"_71":70},[139],[10225],91,{},"Shared Understanding is when we both understand what the other person is imagining and why.",{"_33":10229,"_35":10230},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10231,"_41":1456,"_43":10232,"_67":10233,"_69":10234,"_71":70},"iOI0yfSa",{},[],"In Seed, we don't have the proper argumentation to build shared understanding. We need to have conversations around the right concepts and processes. We need to have them first!",{"_33":10236,"_35":10237},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10238,"_41":1456,"_43":10239,"_67":10240,"_69":10241,"_71":70},"0yZh2Umw",{},[],"The original ideas of stories was focus away from shared documents and toward shared understanding.",{"_37":190,"_39":10243,"_41":1456,"_43":10244,"_67":10245,"_69":10246,"_71":70},"u9ufLjuj",{"_194":195},[],"Building Share Understanding with Seed",{"_33":10248,"_35":10458},[10249,10267,10285,10303,10328,10346,10396,10407,10438,10445,10452],{"_33":10250,"_35":10258},[10251],{"_33":10252,"_35":10253},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10254,"_41":1456,"_43":10255,"_67":10256,"_69":10257,"_71":70},"7VtPkIRr",{},[],"Story Maps are for breaking down big stories as you tell them",{"_37":199,"_39":10259,"_41":1456,"_43":10260,"_67":10261,"_69":10266,"_71":70},"pmtTWVXg",{"_194":195},[10262],{"_37":232,"_233":10263,"_238":10264,"_43":10265,"_71":70},[139],[4670],{},"Story Maps",{"_33":10268,"_35":10276},[10269],{"_33":10270,"_35":10271},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10272,"_41":1456,"_43":10273,"_67":10274,"_69":10275,"_71":70},"pT6i_ZvF",{},[],"It is when we both understand what the other person is imagining and why.",{"_37":199,"_39":10277,"_41":1456,"_43":10278,"_67":10279,"_69":10284,"_71":70},"VwK2twWp",{"_194":195},[10280],{"_37":232,"_233":10281,"_238":10282,"_43":10283,"_71":70},[139],[8468],{},"Shared Understanding ",{"_33":10286,"_35":10294},[10287],{"_33":10288,"_35":10289},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10290,"_41":1456,"_43":10291,"_67":10292,"_69":10293,"_71":70},"nNTCIWp3",{},[],"Everything between the idea and the delivery. ",{"_37":199,"_39":10295,"_41":1456,"_43":10296,"_67":10297,"_69":10302,"_71":70},"HX2Ipsd3",{"_194":195},[10298],{"_37":232,"_233":10299,"_238":10300,"_43":10301,"_71":70},[139],[624],{},"Output",{"_33":10304,"_35":10319},[10305,10312],{"_33":10306,"_35":10307},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10308,"_41":1456,"_43":10309,"_67":10310,"_69":10311,"_71":70},"lLdgaM9F",{},[],"We measure what people actually do differently to reach their goals as a consequence of what you've built, and most importantly, whether you've made their lives better. You've changed the world.",{"_33":10313,"_35":10314},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10315,"_41":1456,"_43":10316,"_67":10317,"_69":10318,"_71":70},"7m_2akpV",{},[],"What have you put in the world that has changed the way people can reach their goals, and when they use it, the world is different for them?",{"_37":199,"_39":10320,"_41":1456,"_43":10321,"_67":10322,"_69":10327,"_71":70},"gd9OnI1k",{"_194":195},[10323],{"_37":232,"_233":10324,"_238":10325,"_43":10326,"_71":70},[139],[931],{},"Outcome",{"_33":10329,"_35":10337},[10330],{"_33":10331,"_35":10332},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10333,"_41":1456,"_43":10334,"_67":10335,"_69":10336,"_71":70},"SyFNkDQh",{},[],"A tool to tell stories through collaboration with words and pictures as a mechanism that builds shared understanding. Stories are the discussions about solving problems to people that lead to agreements on what to build.",{"_37":199,"_39":10338,"_41":1456,"_43":10339,"_67":10340,"_69":10345,"_71":70},"7optGitb",{"_194":195},[10341],{"_37":232,"_233":10342,"_238":10343,"_43":10344,"_71":70},[139],[931],{},"Stories",{"_33":10347,"_35":10387},[10348,10376],{"_33":10349,"_35":10371},[10350,10357,10364],{"_33":10351,"_35":10352},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10353,"_41":1456,"_43":10354,"_67":10355,"_69":10356,"_71":70},"NuBsKomx",{},[],"Who it's for.",{"_33":10358,"_35":10359},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10360,"_41":1456,"_43":10361,"_67":10362,"_69":10363,"_71":70},"jPtKSywG",{},[],"What they do now.",{"_33":10365,"_35":10366},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10367,"_41":1456,"_43":10368,"_67":10369,"_69":10370,"_71":70},"J5BZ83MD",{},[],"How things will change for them later.",{"_37":199,"_39":10372,"_41":1456,"_43":10373,"_67":10374,"_69":10375,"_71":70},"2_ZgTL7I",{"_194":5405},[],"When you have conversations about a feature, you will talk about the following points",{"_33":10377,"_35":10378},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10379,"_41":1456,"_43":10380,"_67":10381,"_69":10386,"_71":70},"buZjLlIq",{},[10382],{"_37":3795,"_233":10383,"_238":10384,"_43":10385,"_71":70},[139],[4839],{},"Good conversations are about who and why, not just what.",{"_37":199,"_39":10388,"_41":1456,"_43":10389,"_67":10390,"_69":10395,"_71":70},"kpyCbjmh",{"_194":195},[10391],{"_37":232,"_233":10392,"_238":10393,"_43":10394,"_71":70},[139],[5367],{},"Story Conversations",{"_33":10397,"_35":10398},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10399,"_41":1456,"_43":10400,"_67":10401,"_69":10406,"_71":70},"7GVj6jax",{},[10402],{"_37":232,"_233":10403,"_238":10404,"_43":10405,"_71":70},[139],[553],{},"Pains and Problems",{"_33":10408,"_35":10430},[10409,10416,10423],{"_33":10410,"_35":10411},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10412,"_41":1456,"_43":10413,"_67":10414,"_69":10415,"_71":70},"ETcoidLY",{},[],"Ideas for New Products",{"_33":10417,"_35":10418},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10419,"_41":1456,"_43":10420,"_67":10421,"_69":10422,"_71":70},"gJl-TZkK",{},[],"Features to add to an existing product",{"_33":10424,"_35":10425},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10426,"_41":1456,"_43":10427,"_67":10428,"_69":10429,"_71":70},"pzPHYpJo",{},[],"Enhancements to products that you've built",{"_37":199,"_39":10431,"_41":1456,"_43":10432,"_67":10433,"_69":8318,"_71":70},"1Vk2wuEP",{"_194":195},[10434],{"_37":232,"_233":10435,"_238":10436,"_43":10437,"_71":70},[139],[792],{},{"_33":10439,"_35":10440},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10441,"_41":1456,"_43":10442,"_67":10443,"_69":10444,"_71":70},"85TV-YE-",{},[],"This Ideas once they are delivered they should make the people who were initially unhappy, mad, frustrated, or confused will become happy when the software lands.",{"_33":10446,"_35":10447},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":10448,"_41":1456,"_43":10449,"_67":10450,"_69":70,"_71":10451},"JqwZnKOI",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeifgh6be6yxsrarflvlj77rqrvtjy47x6h47kg5bd6dxatomxh3m4m",{"_33":10453,"_35":10454},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10455,"_41":1456,"_43":10456,"_67":10457,"_69":70,"_71":70},"Dhc-cRl3",{},[],{"_37":190,"_39":10459,"_41":1456,"_43":10460,"_67":10461,"_69":10462,"_71":70},"7Vw2DirV",{"_194":195},[],"Concepts and Processes",{"_33":10464,"_35":10508},[10465,10472],{"_33":10466,"_35":10467},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10468,"_41":1456,"_43":10469,"_67":10470,"_69":10471,"_71":70},"akFMU_Ws",{},[],"What if, through our discussion experience and structured documents, we can provide the same experience as being in the same room, writing down sticky notes, and rearranging to build shared understanding?",{"_33":10473,"_35":10503},[10474,10485],{"_33":10475,"_35":10476},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10477,"_41":1456,"_43":10478,"_67":10479,"_69":10484,"_71":70},"RAKIQTXs",{},[10480],{"_37":3795,"_233":10481,"_238":10482,"_43":10483,"_71":70},[139],[6187],{},"The talking goes better if we can externalize our thinking by drawing pictures or organizing our ideas using index cards or sticky notes. If we give each other time to explain our thoughts with words and images, we build shared understanding.",{"_33":10486,"_35":10494},[10487],{"_33":10488,"_35":10489},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":10490,"_41":1456,"_43":10491,"_67":10492,"_69":70,"_71":10493},"_-jfYhnU",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeihf7wkin2zwrck7ww4psrg4xsaw5tkgtec3drach4pe34o6g7kioq",{"_37":199,"_39":10495,"_41":1456,"_43":10496,"_67":10497,"_69":10502,"_71":70},"ytxuHuC-",{"_194":195},[10498],{"_37":3795,"_233":10499,"_238":10500,"_43":10501,"_71":70},[139],[6921],{},"It's not that one person is right or wrong, but that we all see different and important aspects. Through combining and refining our different ideas, we end up with a common understanding that includes all our best ideas. That's is why externalizing our ideas is so important. We can redraw sketches or move sticky notes around, and the cool thing is that we're really moving ideas around. What we're really doing is evolving our shared understanding. That's super-hard with just words alone.",{"_37":199,"_39":10504,"_41":1456,"_43":10505,"_67":10506,"_69":10507,"_71":70},"2k_mpk6P",{"_194":195},[],"This is the process of building Shared Understanding in the User Story Mapping Methodology:",{"_37":190,"_39":10509,"_41":1456,"_43":10510,"_67":10511,"_69":10512,"_71":70},"iMVCKyIB",{"_194":195},[],"The tool to build the Shared Understanding",{"_33":10514,"_35":10529},[10515,10522],{"_33":10516,"_35":10517},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10518,"_41":1456,"_43":10519,"_67":10520,"_69":10521,"_71":70},"F5NztUJR",{},[],"From the User Story Mapping",{"_33":10523,"_35":10524},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10525,"_41":1456,"_43":10526,"_67":10527,"_69":10528,"_71":70},"uQw7iMHQ",{},[],"There are a great number of people who believe that there's some ideal way to document—that, when people read documents and come away with different understandings, it's either the reader's fault or ",{"_37":190,"_39":10530,"_41":1456,"_43":10531,"_67":10532,"_69":10533,"_71":70},"1nCcPqaV",{"_194":195},[],"Structuring Documents evolves forever",{"_33":10535,"_35":10536},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10537,"_41":1456,"_43":10538,"_67":10539,"_69":10540,"_71":70},"k80WFmlz",{},[],"I have been watching these problems for two years, and I am not waiting any longer. We are fixing this now.",{"_33":10542,"_35":10543},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10544,"_41":1456,"_43":10545,"_67":10546,"_69":10551,"_71":70},"xZcIafRP",{},[10547],{"_37":3795,"_233":10548,"_238":10549,"_43":10550,"_71":70},[139],[4848],{},"Story mapping keeps us focused on users and their experience, and the result is a better conversation and ultimately a better product.",{"_33":10553,"_35":10582},[10554,10561,10568],{"_33":10555,"_35":10556},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10557,"_41":1456,"_43":10558,"_67":10559,"_69":10560,"_71":70},"EKQhwsEx",{},[],"There's always more to build than we have time or resources to build—always. Minimize output, and maximize outcome and impact. The trick is paying close attention to the people whose problems you're trying to solve.",{"_33":10562,"_35":10563},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10564,"_41":1456,"_43":10565,"_67":10566,"_69":10567,"_71":70},"msdOdc40",{},[],"Our job isn't to build software faster: it's to maximize the outcome and impact you get from what you choose to build.",{"_33":10569,"_35":10577},[10570],{"_33":10571,"_35":10572},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":10573,"_41":1456,"_43":10574,"_67":10575,"_69":70,"_71":10576},"awp28fa2",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeicte7kwy4rlbejujfj3utvdpyqh67lr6scocs3dmkojp77z6nv6zq",{"_37":199,"_39":10578,"_41":1456,"_43":10579,"_67":10580,"_69":10581,"_71":70},"7KfXr8lZ",{"_194":195},[],"Our job is to change the world, not work on the output!",{"_37":190,"_39":10583,"_41":1456,"_43":10584,"_67":10585,"_69":10586,"_71":70},"KfplE5Qc",{"_194":195},[],"Build less",{"_33":10588,"_35":10589},[],{"_37":190,"_39":10590,"_41":1456,"_43":10591,"_67":10592,"_69":10593,"_71":70},"_bKhbFQb",{},[],"Process",{"_33":10595,"_35":10596},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":10597,"_41":1456,"_43":10598,"_67":10599,"_69":70,"_71":10600},"Iz2otIfr",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeidyd5lgdxcxxizvbubchqiibdnk5cumjh2hjy4u4hjy57hc5ak62u",{"_33":10602,"_35":10603},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":10604,"_41":1456,"_43":10605,"_67":10606,"_69":70,"_71":10607},"6xYuIKsf",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeicyzwiqkc37iw7bngiq3yc2vsjqjrlg6tjkuhvfxyms7htiwxit54",{"_33":10609,"_35":10610},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10611,"_41":1456,"_43":10612,"_67":10613,"_69":70,"_71":70},"N28DQFYt",{},[],{"_33":10615,"_35":10623},[10616],{"_33":10617,"_35":10618},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10619,"_41":1456,"_43":10620,"_67":10621,"_69":10622,"_71":70},"-cclR4O7",{},[],"Site ",{"_37":190,"_39":10624,"_41":1456,"_43":10625,"_67":10626,"_69":10627,"_71":70},"PpxRFbcH",{"_194":195},[],"Personas",{"_33":10629,"_35":10630},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10631,"_41":1456,"_43":10632,"_67":10633,"_69":10634,"_71":70},"AU1jVsQD",{},[],"Ethosfera",[55],"/private-notes/methodologies",{"_83":1472},{},{"_39":1453,"_97":55,"_56":10640,"_72":1456,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1455],1772124424051,[151,1453,1456],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/methodologies\",\"bafy2bzacech4ifkbgqkjko3odxbvt5rryn6r5fqyxq2cexrk6c56g445nci2e\"]",{"_112":10645,"_149":10663,"_152":10664},{"_114":10646,"_133":134,"_135":10662,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":10647,"_39":10660},{"_30":10648,"_72":1478,"_73":55,"_74":10656,"_56":10657,"_77":1485,"_79":1485,"_81":10658,"_86":10659,"_88":1478,"_90":91},[10649],{"_33":10650,"_35":10651},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10652,"_41":1478,"_43":10653,"_67":10654,"_69":10655,"_71":70},"f-J0yRSb",{},[],"z",[55],"/private-notes/hayek",{"_83":1494,"_331":1495},{},{"_39":1475,"_97":55,"_56":10661,"_72":1478,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1477],1772124423758,[151,1475,1478],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/hayek\",\"bafy2bzaceareylhplnlnywhzd3xgo36uyfuqb7jx4oa5ki4vxtsj7r5jowfou\"]",{"_112":10666,"_149":10711,"_152":10712},{"_114":10667,"_133":134,"_135":10710,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":10668,"_39":10708},{"_30":10669,"_72":1501,"_73":55,"_74":10703,"_56":10704,"_77":325,"_79":10705,"_81":10706,"_86":10707,"_88":1510,"_90":91},[10670,10678,10690],{"_33":10671,"_35":10672},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10673,"_41":10674,"_43":10675,"_67":10676,"_69":10677,"_71":70},"yvao_Uf2","bafy2bzaceb4jznumunnqvge2k32qstknpbc7a4a6xgbekw6pzebdkjsin2sfw",{},[],"Hola que tal",{"_33":10679,"_35":10680},[],{"_37":190,"_39":10681,"_41":10682,"_43":10683,"_67":10684,"_69":10689,"_71":70},"1N9aJ5Y3","bafy2bzacec4lwbzzah55fubbb7pluw7b3j35gewakv5puxsdjlem32l6xl7c6",{},[10685],{"_37":4625,"_233":10686,"_238":10687,"_43":10688,"_71":70},[139],[9177],{},"Servicios",{"_33":10691,"_35":10692},[],{"_37":38,"_39":10693,"_41":1501,"_43":10694,"_67":10702,"_69":70,"_71":70},"XWHJjAtb",{"_45":46,"_47":134,"_49":10695,"_66":6},{"_51":10696,"_60":10699},[10697],{"_54":1504,"_56":10698,"_58":800},"services",[10700],{"_63":8,"_64":10701},"DisplayTime",[],[1504,55],"/private-notes/luis-","2025-06-16T15:26:09.296Z",{"_83":1523},{},{"_39":1498,"_97":55,"_56":10709,"_72":1501,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1500],1772124423786,[151,1498,1501],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/luis-\",\"bafy2bzacecfdecmkukzru4exkfpolhkk4w4socrfuefi6qaangmwqaceo6d5i\"]",{"_112":10714,"_149":10762,"_152":10763},{"_114":10715,"_133":134,"_135":10761,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":10716,"_39":10759},{"_30":10717,"_72":1529,"_73":55,"_74":10754,"_56":10755,"_77":1538,"_79":10756,"_81":10757,"_86":10758,"_88":1539,"_90":91},[10718,10725,10733,10739,10746],{"_33":10719,"_35":10720},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10721,"_41":1539,"_43":10722,"_67":10723,"_69":10724,"_71":70},"y8KO2vQY",{},[],"oh yeah!",{"_33":10726,"_35":10727},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10728,"_41":10729,"_43":10730,"_67":10731,"_69":10732,"_71":70},"3ubMgCCz","bafy2bzacec33su5wfte4hipk2y76hwthrlffj3zh6ciwmf7eahtcu3ybijq3k",{},[],"version 2",{"_33":10734,"_35":10735},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10736,"_41":1529,"_43":10737,"_67":10738,"_69":70,"_71":70},"lHVgOnug",{},[],{"_33":10740,"_35":10741},[],{"_37":166,"_39":10742,"_41":1529,"_43":10743,"_67":10744,"_69":70,"_71":10745},"rHyiqL_v",{"_170":7190},[],"hm://z6Mko238YMK8YUQDcHtC2zJPwxMJ8NDTiEMsCz3NYiYmbR9t?v=bafy2bzaceb4jznumunnqvge2k32qstknpbc7a4a6xgbekw6pzebdkjsin2sfw#yvao_Uf2+",{"_33":10747,"_35":10748},[],{"_37":166,"_39":10749,"_41":10750,"_43":10751,"_67":10752,"_69":70,"_71":10753},"SbAYanam","bafy2bzacec564wwhw6jvovdmon3pebfpgfpu6fhtgkvdc6b6gcyyoqcybniys",{"_170":7190},[],"hm://z6MkgAtUyLGa8nUn3xDbvfWprE58pYMDeuhD8sH59T6NYiuj/noticias/los-inquilinos-de-san-ildefonso-20-denuncian-acoso-inmobiliario-por-parte-de-la-propiedad-del-edificio?v=bafy2bzacebhvtk4rgoel7wm4fwzhnozud2trxafl4q2mcg2vwe2oo6zby3ypm#2Zc7dig2",[55],"/private-notes/gabo-is-amazing","2025-06-16T14:48:50.177Z",{"_83":1548},{},{"_39":1526,"_97":55,"_56":10760,"_72":1529,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1528],1772124423792,[151,1526,1529],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/gabo-is-amazing\",\"bafy2bzacebam7b5s6zmdyhcfnefqrlhunaqsdbkkaqxfrb475hdlcosyny274\"]",{"_112":10765,"_149":10783,"_152":10784},{"_114":10766,"_133":134,"_135":10782,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":10767,"_39":10780},{"_30":10768,"_72":1554,"_73":55,"_74":10776,"_56":10777,"_77":1561,"_79":1561,"_81":10778,"_86":10779,"_88":1554,"_90":91},[10769],{"_33":10770,"_35":10771},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10772,"_41":1554,"_43":10773,"_67":10774,"_69":10775,"_71":70},"oMqA-KCc",{},[],"Me pregunto quién le ha puesto el nombre de \"Los Cantizales\". Desde luego tiene sentido porque el terreno cuenta con muchos cantos y piedras, pero ya se llama así? o es un nombre inventado recientemente?",[55],"/private-notes/de-donde-sale-el-nombre-de-los-cantizales",{"_83":1574},{},{"_39":1551,"_97":55,"_56":10781,"_72":1554,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1553],1772124423796,[151,1551,1554],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/de-donde-sale-el-nombre-de-los-cantizales\",\"bafy2bzacecjiu3jurwrzly73ujjkql7oijlwey7mwc5uplrylluwrjsuee77e\"]",{"_112":10786,"_149":10924,"_152":10925},{"_114":10787,"_133":134,"_135":10923,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":10788,"_39":10921},{"_30":10789,"_72":1580,"_73":55,"_74":10916,"_56":10917,"_77":1588,"_79":10918,"_81":10919,"_86":10920,"_88":1589,"_90":91},[10790,10797,10804,10811,10818,10825,10832,10839,10846,10853,10860,10867,10874,10881,10888,10895,10902,10909],{"_33":10791,"_35":10792},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10793,"_41":1589,"_43":10794,"_67":10795,"_69":10796,"_71":70},"h73iSDrN",{},[],"For me, it's a definite no, although I am curious to explore the arguments in favor of a yes.",{"_33":10798,"_35":10799},[],{"_37":3483,"_39":10800,"_41":1589,"_43":10801,"_67":10802,"_69":70,"_71":10803},"sBU2Nskd",{},[],"https://x.com/mbauwens/status/1923363137182372209",{"_33":10805,"_35":10806},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10807,"_41":1580,"_43":10808,"_67":10809,"_69":10810,"_71":70},"zxk74E5M",{},[],"In the final chapter, Van Bavel summarizes his findings, and the title speaks volumes: “Why Market Economies Are Fundamentally Incompatible with Prosperity, Equality, and Broad-Based Decision-Making in the Long Run.” To support this conclusion, he outlines the cycle he has identified in general terms, divided into four phases (also summarized in a chart on pp. 384–85):",{"_33":10812,"_35":10813},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10814,"_41":1580,"_43":10815,"_67":10816,"_69":10817,"_71":70},"7rUr9OFv",{},[],"In response to social uprisings against feudal conditions, a (more) open society emerges, with increasing freedom and self-organization among ordinary people (e.g., guilds, common lands). This implies a new social balance, with a broad distribution of property and political influence. It leads to open institutions that enable the growth of markets—first in goods and services, but also in land and labor—positively affecting living standards. ",{"_33":10819,"_35":10820},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10821,"_41":1580,"_43":10822,"_67":10823,"_69":10824,"_71":70},"uDAnrIo8",{},[],"Markets become the dominant mechanism for allocating land, labor, and capital, pushing aside systems of self-organization, often through state power. Values such as mutual trust, cooperation, and equality are displaced by market values. Prosperity continues to grow. ",{"_33":10826,"_35":10827},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10828,"_41":1580,"_43":10829,"_67":10830,"_69":10831,"_71":70},"XBPdQYwb",{},[],"Financial markets expand, and both citizens and states become increasingly dependent on market elites. Through the market, disparities in wealth translate into growing economic inequality, which in turn becomes political inequality. Market elites are able to influence policy-making and regulation in their own favor. Living standards stagnate.",{"_33":10833,"_35":10834},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10835,"_41":1580,"_43":10836,"_67":10837,"_69":10838,"_71":70},"AvJtK09t",{},[],"For market elites, it becomes more profitable to invest in financial operations (e.g., government debt) than in the real economy. Both wealth inequality and GDP peak, but living standards begin to decline, and access to political organizations and civil rights diminishes. There may be uprisings, but they are easily suppressed by mercenary armies. Eventually, markets stagnate, followed by relative or even absolute decline. ",{"_33":10840,"_35":10841},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10842,"_41":1580,"_43":10843,"_67":10844,"_69":10845,"_71":70},"zT9Tw0fU",{},[],"According to Van Bavel’s analysis, the United States is currently in the final phase of this cycle. The cycle in Northwestern Europe began later, with a mixed economy that left considerable room for both government and civil society. However, neoliberal policies aligned Europe with the American cycle, accelerating it and putting it on a path toward the same decline. Van Bavel sees (too) little societal resistance to this trend so far. ",{"_33":10847,"_35":10848},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10849,"_41":1580,"_43":10850,"_67":10851,"_69":10852,"_71":70},"w41fegwz",{},[],"These descriptions may not sound entirely unfamiliar. Let’s highlight a few further aspects. First, the causality between increasing freedom and markets is the reverse of what is commonly asserted. The rise in individual freedom and opportunities for self-organization, coupled with a relatively high standard of living, actually preceded the development of factor markets: ",{"_33":10854,"_35":10855},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10856,"_41":1580,"_43":10857,"_67":10858,"_69":10859,"_71":70},"VqoZEw_3",{},[],"Freedom is not a result of markets, but rather an essential precondition for their emergence. Once markets become dominant, freedom is consumed and hollowed out by economic unfreedom. Factor markets, in this sense, parasitize freedom, rather than ushering it in or encouraging it. (p. 377) ",{"_33":10861,"_35":10862},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10863,"_41":1580,"_43":10864,"_67":10865,"_69":10866,"_71":70},"z71yK0GO",{},[],"As more surplus is accumulated and the rise of financial markets becomes inevitable, the nature and effects of markets change:",{"_33":10868,"_35":10869},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10870,"_41":1580,"_43":10871,"_67":10872,"_69":10873,"_71":70},"P-30igNW",{},[],"They became an end in themselves—that is, the simplest and safest way to make accumulated capital yield returns. As a result, financial markets began to dominate and suffocate the real economy. (p. 379)",{"_33":10875,"_35":10876},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10877,"_41":1580,"_43":10878,"_67":10879,"_69":10880,"_71":70},"kZ98EMJU",{},[],"Furthermore, centralizing governments also seek greater control over society and find natural allies in market elites:",{"_33":10882,"_35":10883},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10884,"_41":1580,"_43":10885,"_67":10886,"_69":10887,"_71":70},"E9KNAjCE",{},[],"Factor markets and their market elites, and states and their state elites, worked in close cooperation to destroy the self-organizing structures of ordinary people. The states needed strong markets to strengthen themselves […] and the market elites needed strong states to protect their property rights.",{"_33":10889,"_35":10890},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10891,"_41":1580,"_43":10892,"_67":10893,"_69":10894,"_71":70},"qPMgZ8fW",{},[],".to protect their property rights, since growing inequality increased the need to keep the losers in check. (p. 403) ",{"_33":10896,"_35":10897},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10898,"_41":1580,"_43":10899,"_67":10900,"_69":10901,"_71":70},"DTL7xMcw",{},[],"A paradoxical effect, however, is that the reliance on financial markets leads to rising public debt, causing governments themselves to fall under the (political) control of market elites. To repay these debts, governments do not resort to taxes on wealth, but instead impose taxes on labor and consumption. ",{"_33":10903,"_35":10904},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10905,"_41":1580,"_43":10906,"_67":10907,"_69":10908,"_71":70},"wGTa7N91",{},[],"\"[T]hen the tax system effectively functioned as a transfer of money from the poor to the rich.\" ",{"_33":10910,"_35":10911},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10912,"_41":1580,"_43":10913,"_67":10914,"_69":10915,"_71":70},"mTWf__CT",{},[],"(translated from a review by Jef Peeters, in Oikos, #105)",[55],"/private-notes/are-market-economies-incompatible-with-prosperity-equality-and-broad-based-decision-making-in-the-long-run","2025-05-16T17:49:51.779Z",{"_83":1602},{},{"_39":1577,"_97":55,"_56":10922,"_72":1580,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1579],1772124423817,[151,1577,1580],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/are-market-economies-incompatible-with-prosperity-equality-and-broad-based-decision-making-in-the-long-run\",\"bafy2bzaceaaynr53unb44jq6gi3fuv2ul4w3i45fadc4jrs6pipc3eps6htbg\"]",{"_112":10927,"_149":10953,"_152":10954},{"_114":10928,"_133":134,"_135":10952,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":10929,"_39":10950},{"_30":10930,"_72":1608,"_73":55,"_74":10946,"_56":10947,"_77":1615,"_79":1615,"_81":10948,"_86":10949,"_88":1608,"_90":91},[10931,10939],{"_33":10932,"_35":10933},[],{"_37":10934,"_39":10935,"_41":1608,"_43":10936,"_67":10937,"_69":10938,"_71":70},"Math","j8UwogMU",{"_194":195},[],"\\sqrt{\\pi}=\\int_{-\\infty}^{+\\infty} e^{-x^2} \\ dx",{"_33":10940,"_35":10941},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10942,"_41":1608,"_43":10943,"_67":10944,"_69":10945,"_71":70},"pZCLEb0j",{},[],"Exponential Period Formula",[55],"/private-notes/exponential-period",{"_83":1624},{},{"_39":1605,"_97":55,"_56":10951,"_72":1608,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1607],1772124423803,[151,1605,1608],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/exponential-period\",\"bafy2bzacebikvdlvyde2ygpa4s4dp5mjvw6tq2f7b6ayrh2ghjxsgojri3lws\"]",{"_112":10956,"_149":11029,"_152":11030},{"_114":10957,"_133":134,"_135":11028,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":10958,"_39":11026},{"_30":10959,"_72":1630,"_73":55,"_74":11022,"_56":11023,"_77":1637,"_79":1637,"_81":11024,"_86":11025,"_88":1630,"_90":91},[10960,10967,10974,10999,11010],{"_33":10961,"_35":10962},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10963,"_41":1630,"_43":10964,"_67":10965,"_69":10966,"_71":70},"CFc31gkg",{},[],"I didn't know about the story of Citizendium, a similar project from Wikipedia from one of its cofounders, Larry Sanger.",{"_33":10968,"_35":10969},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10970,"_41":1630,"_43":10971,"_67":10972,"_69":10973,"_71":70},"dl_d_nwn",{},[],"I understand that Larry was against the direction Wikipedia took at some time. Here are Citizendium Charter :",{"_33":10975,"_35":10988},[10976],{"_33":10977,"_35":10978},[],{"_37":199,"_39":10979,"_41":1630,"_43":10980,"_67":10981,"_69":10987,"_71":70},"7BcHfYMz",{},[10982],{"_37":3795,"_233":10983,"_238":10984,"_43":10986,"_71":70},[139],[10985],186,{},"'Nobody should trust Wikipedia,' its co-founder warns: Larry Sanger says site has been taken over by left-wing 'volunteers' who write off sources that don't fit their agenda as fake news",{"_37":199,"_39":10989,"_41":1630,"_43":10990,"_67":10991,"_69":10998,"_71":70},"fSzIgInV",{"_194":4785},[10992],{"_37":286,"_233":10993,"_238":10995,"_43":10996,"_71":10997},[10994],284,[4479],{},"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer-review","It planned to achieve this by requiring virtually all contributors to use their real names, by strictly moderating the project for unprofessional behavior, by providing \"gentle expert oversight\" of everyday contributors, and through \"approved articles\" which have undergone a form of peer-review by topic experts with credentials.",{"_33":11000,"_35":11001},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11002,"_41":1630,"_43":11003,"_67":11004,"_69":11009,"_71":70},"vhnsE5-o",{},[11005],{"_37":286,"_233":11006,"_238":11007,"_43":11008,"_71":11009},[139],[281],{},"https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9793263/Nobody-trust-Wikipedia-founder-Larry-Sanger-warns.html",{"_33":11011,"_35":11012},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11013,"_41":1630,"_43":11014,"_67":11015,"_69":11021,"_71":70},"-_CWBIlI",{},[11016],{"_37":286,"_233":11017,"_238":11018,"_43":11019,"_71":11020},[139],[3778],{},"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Neutral_point_of_view","Wikipedia:Neutral point of view",[55],"/private-notes/citizendium",{"_83":1646},{},{"_39":1627,"_97":55,"_56":11027,"_72":1630,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1629],1772124424055,[151,1627,1630],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/citizendium\",\"bafy2bzacec3qcafvnrchm2bvj62qevflqhmgxibpywlwdeeudivko44hycqiu\"]",{"_112":11032,"_149":11064,"_152":11065},{"_114":11033,"_133":134,"_135":11063,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11034,"_39":11061},{"_30":11035,"_72":1652,"_73":55,"_74":11057,"_56":11058,"_77":1659,"_79":1659,"_81":11059,"_86":11060,"_88":1652,"_90":91},[11036,11043,11050],{"_33":11037,"_35":11038},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11039,"_41":1652,"_43":11040,"_67":11041,"_69":11042,"_71":70},"d2hgpMVl",{},[],"The Future of Innovation Journalism",{"_33":11044,"_35":11045},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11046,"_41":1652,"_43":11047,"_67":11048,"_69":11049,"_71":70},"eGfHXsA_",{},[],"Minute 7:50 Media has lost minde share to independant journalists",{"_33":11051,"_35":11052},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11053,"_41":1652,"_43":11054,"_67":11055,"_69":11056,"_71":70},"a7cSYpCv",{},[],"![](https://www.youtube.com/embed/J2VwO2_jCBY \"width=\")",[55],"/private-notes/media",{"_83":1672},{},{"_39":1649,"_97":55,"_56":11062,"_72":1652,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1651],1772124423807,[151,1649,1652],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/media\",\"bafy2bzacebcmghf5p5pbudcnvmzws4aizivmttk5kvwdbn52zzhyq7wrrigto\"]",{"_112":11067,"_149":11200,"_152":11201},{"_114":11068,"_133":134,"_135":11199,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11069,"_39":11197},{"_30":11070,"_72":1678,"_73":55,"_74":11193,"_56":11194,"_77":1685,"_79":1685,"_81":11195,"_86":11196,"_88":1678,"_90":91},[11071,11078,11089,11096,11103,11110,11117,11128,11135,11146,11181],{"_33":11072,"_35":11073},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":11074,"_41":1678,"_43":11075,"_67":11076,"_69":70,"_71":11077},"nKjiokfc",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeiczeilne47ucp4onzianwp5txgb3idqb5lnsql32p4k57tfb5hjba",{"_33":11079,"_35":11080},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11081,"_41":1678,"_43":11082,"_67":11083,"_69":11088,"_71":70},"UKGypge-",{},[11084],{"_37":232,"_233":11085,"_238":11086,"_43":11087,"_71":70},[139],[7543],{},"Historia",{"_33":11090,"_35":11091},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11092,"_41":1678,"_43":11093,"_67":11094,"_69":11095,"_71":70},"_ckoCKeB",{},[],"La revolución de la Web comenzó en 1989 gracias a su creador Tim Berners-Lee. Por primera vez, la Web permitía la publicación descentralizada de contenido, sin pedir permiso a una autoridad central y con acceso al mundo entero.",{"_33":11097,"_35":11098},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11099,"_41":1678,"_43":11100,"_67":11101,"_69":11102,"_71":70},"nKH0cfhl",{},[],"Pero la Web nace con dos problemas. Por un lado sus limitaciones técnicas como sistema de hipertexto impide la colaboración descentralizada, enviando el progreso humano a la esclavitud de las Big Tech de Silicon Valley. Por otro lado, la falta de un sistema de micropagos embebido en el navegador impide cobrar en el navegador. Este problema fue acuñado por Marc Andreessen, creador de Netscape, como el pecado original de la Web porque impidió la generación de modelos de negocio distintos a la publicidad. Esto nos ha llevado a la economía de la atención donde el incentivo es el anunciante y no la colaboración.",{"_33":11104,"_35":11105},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11106,"_41":1678,"_43":11107,"_67":11108,"_69":11109,"_71":70},"lHHElwpo",{},[],"En los años 60, los grandes visionarios del hypertexto y de la interaccion humano-computadora, Doug Engelbart y Ted Nelson, se imaginaron sistemas descentralizados de colaboración, más avanzados que los que usamos actualmente. Sistemas como Xanadu de Ted Nelson permitían la reutilización de contenido, manteniendo las autorías y royalties, gracias al uso de sistemas de almacenamiento y de micropagos descentralizados.",{"_33":11111,"_35":11112},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11113,"_41":1678,"_43":11114,"_67":11115,"_69":11116,"_71":70},"p9vaV47i",{},[],"Por fin, 60 anos después de la concepción de Xanadu, la vision de Ted es posible gracias a Bitcoin y a tecnologías como IPFS y Nostr.",{"_33":11118,"_35":11119},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11120,"_41":1678,"_43":11121,"_67":11122,"_69":11127,"_71":70},"thCnjeoE",{},[11123],{"_37":232,"_233":11124,"_238":11125,"_43":11126,"_71":70},[139],[8468],{},"Meetup de hace un año",{"_33":11129,"_35":11130},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11131,"_41":1678,"_43":11132,"_67":11133,"_69":11134,"_71":70},"BwpJmond",{},[],"Hace un año, Gabo y Julio revisaron como IPFS y Lightning network pueden crear una web descentralizada; cómo funciona IPFS, sus diferencias con Nostr y por qué pensamos que son tecnologías complementarias.",{"_33":11136,"_35":11137},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11138,"_41":1678,"_43":11139,"_67":11140,"_69":11145,"_71":70},"yYku_7cP",{},[11141],{"_37":232,"_233":11142,"_238":11143,"_43":11144,"_71":70},[139],[4023],{},"Introducción a Mintter",{"_33":11147,"_35":11176},[11148,11155,11162,11169],{"_33":11149,"_35":11150},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11151,"_41":1678,"_43":11152,"_67":11153,"_69":11154,"_71":70},"9F_cT4L7",{},[],"Cómo crear tu espacio in-censurable de deliberación.",{"_33":11156,"_35":11157},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11158,"_41":1678,"_43":11159,"_67":11160,"_69":11161,"_71":70},"6hws5PnG",{},[],"Cómo crear tu Comunidad del Conocimiento.",{"_33":11163,"_35":11164},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11165,"_41":1678,"_43":11166,"_67":11167,"_69":11168,"_71":70},"cJG8GWUq",{},[],"Cómo montar tu propio Site Hypermedia.",{"_33":11170,"_35":11171},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11172,"_41":1678,"_43":11173,"_67":11174,"_69":11175,"_71":70},"dqrP7kC-",{},[],"Cómo monetizar tu contenido con tu Site.",{"_37":199,"_39":11177,"_41":1678,"_43":11178,"_67":11179,"_69":11180,"_71":70},"yy0FGShS",{"_194":3876},[],"En este Meetup Gabo y Julio entraran a fondo a explicar la herramienta descentralizada:",{"_33":11182,"_35":11183},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11184,"_41":1678,"_43":11185,"_67":11186,"_69":11192,"_71":70},"Dybd1iBm",{},[11187],{"_37":232,"_233":11188,"_238":11189,"_43":11191,"_71":70},[8468,4692],[6366,11190],107,{},"El evento se hará en español con algunos bitcoiners presentes que puedan ayudar con la traducción al inglés.",[55],"/private-notes/introduccion-a-mintter-hypermedia-bienvenidos-a-la-web-p2p",{"_83":1694},{},{"_39":1675,"_97":55,"_56":11198,"_72":1678,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1677],1772124424061,[151,1675,1678],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/introduccion-a-mintter-hypermedia-bienvenidos-a-la-web-p2p\",\"bafy2bzacecx32jo5eb7cryzto4ap3arb76mtzrarton2lh3mypp7da5zu4pvy\"]",{"_112":11203,"_149":11228,"_152":11229},{"_114":11204,"_133":134,"_135":11227,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11205,"_39":11225},{"_30":11206,"_72":1700,"_73":55,"_74":11221,"_56":11222,"_77":1707,"_79":1707,"_81":11223,"_86":11224,"_88":1700,"_90":91},[11207],{"_33":11208,"_35":11216},[11209],{"_33":11210,"_35":11211},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11212,"_41":1700,"_43":11213,"_67":11214,"_69":11215,"_71":70},"BygqdjMe",{},[],"How do you listen? Do you listen with your projections, through your projection, through your ambitions, desires, fears, anxieties, through hearing only what you want to hear, only what will be satisfactory, what will gratify, what will give comfort, what will for the moment alleviate your suffering? If you listen through the screen of your desires, then you obviously listen to your own voice; you are listening to your own desires. And is there any other form of listening? Is it not important to find out how to listen not only to what is being said but to everything— to the noise in the streets, to the chatter of birds, to the noise of the tramcar, to the restless sea, to the voice of your husband, to your wife, to your friends, to the cry of a baby? Listening has importance only when one is not projecting one’s own desires through which one listens. Can one put aside all these screens through which we listen, and really listen?",{"_37":190,"_39":11217,"_41":1700,"_43":11218,"_67":11219,"_69":11220,"_71":70},"jxhf3Hc2",{"_194":195},[],"Putting aside screens?",[55],"/private-notes/krishnamurti-the-book-of-life",{"_83":1716},{},{"_39":1697,"_97":55,"_56":11226,"_72":1700,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1699],1772124425310,[151,1697,1700],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/krishnamurti-the-book-of-life\",\"bafy2bzaceckttgxza2rvnsbv7hhwzkuvuql2s6awjqeocyqu5x7t4o7xlph42\"]",{"_112":11231,"_149":11298,"_152":11299},{"_114":11232,"_133":134,"_135":11297,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11233,"_39":11295},{"_30":11234,"_72":1722,"_73":55,"_74":11291,"_56":11292,"_77":1729,"_79":1729,"_81":11293,"_86":11294,"_88":1722,"_90":91},[11235,11242,11249,11256,11263,11270,11277,11284],{"_33":11236,"_35":11237},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11238,"_41":1722,"_43":11239,"_67":11240,"_69":11241,"_71":70},"IbnKp6DP",{},[],"Es verdad, pues: reprimamos esta fiera condición, esta furia, esta ambición, por si alguna vez soñamos. Y sí haremos, pues estamos en mundo tan singular, que el vivir sólo es soñar; y la experiencia me enseña, que el hombre que vive, sueña lo que es, hasta despertar.",{"_33":11243,"_35":11244},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11245,"_41":1722,"_43":11246,"_67":11247,"_69":11248,"_71":70},"vwgUBo-q",{},[],"Sueña el rey que es rey, y vive con este engaño mandando, disponiendo y gobernando; y este aplauso, que recibe prestado, en el viento escribe y en cenizas le convierte la muerte (¡desdicha fuerte!): ¡que hay quien intente reinar viendo que ha de despertar en el sueño de la muerte!",{"_33":11250,"_35":11251},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11252,"_41":1722,"_43":11253,"_67":11254,"_69":11255,"_71":70},"RJVK5KGB",{},[],"Sueña el rico en su riqueza, que más cuidados le ofrece; sueña el pobre que padece su miseria y su pobreza; sueña el que a medrar empieza, sueña el que afana y pretende, sueña el que agravia y ofende, y en el mundo, en conclusión, todos sueñan lo que son, aunque ninguno lo entiende.",{"_33":11257,"_35":11258},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11259,"_41":1722,"_43":11260,"_67":11261,"_69":11262,"_71":70},"LC6AbFoy",{},[],"Yo sueño que estoy aquí, destas prisiones cargado; y soñé que en otro estado más lisonjero me vi. ¿Qué es la vida? Un frenesí. ¿Qué es la vida? Una ilusión, una sombra, una ficción, y el mayor bien es pequeño; que toda la vida es sueño, y los sueños, sueños son.",{"_33":11264,"_35":11265},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11266,"_41":1722,"_43":11267,"_67":11268,"_69":11269,"_71":70},"NI6q2d4R",{},[],"Pedro Calderón de la Barca 1635",{"_33":11271,"_35":11272},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11273,"_41":1722,"_43":11274,"_67":11275,"_69":11276,"_71":70},"ftfu8bTI",{},[],"Azlen",{"_33":11278,"_35":11279},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11280,"_41":1722,"_43":11281,"_67":11282,"_69":11283,"_71":70},"mqrYPaBX",{},[],"version 4",{"_33":11285,"_35":11286},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11287,"_41":1722,"_43":11288,"_67":11289,"_69":11290,"_71":70},"B5tfdvtz",{},[],"Branching!!",[55],"/private-notes/la-vida-es-sueno-1635",{"_83":1738},{},{"_39":1719,"_97":55,"_56":11296,"_72":1722,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1721],1772124424065,[151,1719,1722],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/la-vida-es-sueno-1635\",\"bafy2bzacebzkuq4eph6kmmllkn3f3asr2j36bzg5r3ua6u6ysk56e73dbck7k\"]",{"_112":11301,"_149":11424,"_152":11425},{"_114":11302,"_133":134,"_135":11423,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11303,"_39":11421},{"_30":11304,"_72":1744,"_73":55,"_74":11417,"_56":11418,"_77":1751,"_79":1751,"_81":11419,"_86":11420,"_88":1744,"_90":91},[11305,11317,11342,11356,11370],{"_33":11306,"_35":11307},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11308,"_41":1744,"_43":11309,"_67":11310,"_69":11316,"_71":70},"k43w1zPV",{},[11311],{"_37":286,"_233":11312,"_238":11313,"_43":11314,"_71":11315},[7543],[4131],{},"https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstl/about","Source: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/rstl/about",{"_33":11318,"_35":11337},[11319],{"_33":11320,"_35":11321},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11322,"_41":1744,"_43":11323,"_67":11324,"_69":11336,"_71":70},"Mf1HS7pG",{},[11325,11331],{"_37":3795,"_233":11326,"_238":11328,"_43":11330,"_71":70},[139,11327],138,[3973,11329],140,{},{"_37":286,"_233":11332,"_238":11333,"_43":11334,"_71":11335},[235],[281],{},"https://royalsocietypublishing.org/toc/rstl/1/1","Philosophical Transactions is the world’s first and longest-running scientific journal. It was launched in March 1665 by Henry Oldenburg (c.1619-1677), the Society’s first Secretary, who acted as publisher and editor. Oldenburg spun his wide-ranging network of European natural-philosophical contacts, the activity of the Royal Society, and his skills as a linguist and scientific editor into a new form of print intended to promote the enterprise of early modern science and perhaps make some money on the side. The journal appeared monthly, selling for one shilling.",{"_37":190,"_39":11338,"_41":1744,"_43":11339,"_67":11340,"_69":11341,"_71":70},"EaFAPhF3",{"_194":195},[],"Foundation, early tribulations, and success",{"_33":11343,"_35":11351},[11344],{"_33":11345,"_35":11346},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11347,"_41":1744,"_43":11348,"_67":11349,"_69":11350,"_71":70},"rerWK-z5",{},[],"The enterprise was widely valued by natural philosophers and the Royal Society in particular and, after Oldenburg died, editorial and financial responsibility for the journal was unofficially assumed by his Secretarial successors (Edmond Halley and Hans Sloane among them.) A crisis in the affairs of the Society in 1752, however, precipitated by the President’s illness, the death of the incumbent editor-secretary, and particularly by a series of harsh satires on the Society and its works, prompted an institutional takeover of the journal.",{"_37":190,"_39":11352,"_41":1744,"_43":11353,"_67":11354,"_69":11355,"_71":70},"rc34smR_",{"_194":195},[],"Inheriting the journal",{"_33":11357,"_35":11365},[11358],{"_33":11359,"_35":11360},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11361,"_41":1744,"_43":11362,"_67":11363,"_69":11364,"_71":70},"cAtMBUqJ",{},[],"Under Royal Society control the journal settled into a slower publication rhythm and its content became fundamentally linked to what went on in the Society’s scientific meetings every Thursday. New procedures of collective editorship were put in place, with papers selected by a 21-person committee, while the secretary was responsible for seeing the journal through the press. ",{"_37":190,"_39":11366,"_41":1744,"_43":11367,"_67":11368,"_69":11369,"_71":70},"METPJnMt",{"_194":195},[],"The Society takes over",{"_33":11371,"_35":11412},[11372],{"_33":11373,"_35":11374},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11375,"_41":1744,"_43":11376,"_67":11377,"_69":11411,"_71":70},"NOCWhTkx",{},[11378,11387,11394,11399,11405],{"_37":3795,"_233":11379,"_238":11382,"_43":11386,"_71":70},[3851,5456,11380,11381],550,674,[4197,11383,11384,11385],422,577,685,{},{"_37":286,"_233":11388,"_238":11390,"_43":11392,"_71":11393},[11389],339,[11391],350,{},"http://blogs.royalsociety.org/publishing/transparency-in-peer-review/",{"_37":286,"_233":11395,"_238":11396,"_43":11397,"_71":11398},[5456],[11383],{},"https://royalsocietypublishing.org/journal/rspl",{"_37":286,"_233":11400,"_238":11401,"_43":11403,"_71":11404},[5019],[11402],590,{},"https://royalsocietypublishing.org/journal/rsta",{"_37":286,"_233":11406,"_238":11407,"_43":11409,"_71":11410},[5017],[11408],598,{},"https://royalsocietypublishing.org/journal/rstb","By the 1830s Philosophical Transactions was facing increased competition for the best scientific papers from commercial journals with a more rapid publication schedule, as well as from the proceedings and transactions of more specialised scientific societies. The Royal Society responded by introducing more rigorous and systematic expert peer review, and by launching an abstract journal, Proceedings of the Royal Society, procedures which were reinforced and extended during the long tenure of George Gabriel Stokes as editor. Later in the century Philosophical Transactions split into ‘A’ and ‘B’ series (physical and biological sciences respectively), and from 1893 the Proceedings began to include full research papers in its own right.",{"_37":190,"_39":11413,"_41":1744,"_43":11414,"_67":11415,"_69":11416,"_71":70},"jRV1pbo_",{"_194":195},[],"The 19th century: Reform and professionalisation",[55],"/private-notes/philosophical-transactions-of-the-royal-society-of-london",{"_83":1760},{},{"_39":1741,"_97":55,"_56":11422,"_72":1744,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1743],1772124423902,[151,1741,1744],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/philosophical-transactions-of-the-royal-society-of-london\",\"bafy2bzaceaaz6g7honcfmsczssg6palsn5psyv24ymphuowkflsg2gwduwpug\"]",{"_112":11427,"_149":11513,"_152":11514},{"_114":11428,"_133":134,"_135":11512,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11429,"_39":11510},{"_30":11430,"_72":1766,"_73":55,"_74":11506,"_56":11507,"_77":1772,"_79":1772,"_81":11508,"_86":11509,"_88":1766,"_90":91},[11431,11443,11450,11457,11464,11471,11499],{"_33":11432,"_35":11433},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11434,"_41":1766,"_43":11435,"_67":11436,"_69":11442,"_71":70},"Lf2SA8O6",{},[11437],{"_37":286,"_233":11438,"_238":11439,"_43":11440,"_71":11441},[7521],[3910],{},"https://x.com/bustalter","In a recent conversation on X, journalist Santiago Bustamante raised a legitimate concern: the widespread demonization of alternative information channels, labeling them as \"hoaxes.\" Instead of restricting access, he proposes something more valuable: educating in critical thinking and encouraging cross-referencing between sources.",{"_33":11444,"_35":11445},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11446,"_41":1766,"_43":11447,"_67":11448,"_69":11449,"_71":70},"J7rn-AKp",{},[],"But... what about channels that lack any form of editorial or scientific review? Can they be considered valid?",{"_33":11451,"_35":11452},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11453,"_41":1766,"_43":11454,"_67":11455,"_69":11456,"_71":70},"IIO50zHV",{},[],"The truth is that peer review remains crucial, especially in science and complex topics. However, we also recognize that during moments of high informational intensity—such as a crisis or unexpected event—editorial timelines may be insufficient. In that chaotic scenario, what tools do we have?",{"_33":11458,"_35":11459},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11460,"_41":1766,"_43":11461,"_67":11462,"_69":11463,"_71":70},"VLsGzjRs",{},[],"The answer points to the future: we need better digital tools. Systems that allow us to verify, cross-reference, and collectively discuss information without relying solely on centralized structures.",{"_33":11465,"_35":11466},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11467,"_41":1766,"_43":11468,"_67":11469,"_69":11470,"_71":70},"ke1_EXRr",{},[],"I propose the hypermedia protocol, which enables the discussion of topics while the article is updated in real time. The same process as Wikipedia but more dynamic in managing identities, permissions, and information tools.",{"_33":11472,"_35":11494},[11473,11480,11487],{"_33":11474,"_35":11475},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11476,"_41":1766,"_43":11477,"_67":11478,"_69":11479,"_71":70},"qO-Rxj2P",{},[],"Someone poses a question or problem to solve.",{"_33":11481,"_35":11482},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11483,"_41":1766,"_43":11484,"_67":11485,"_69":11486,"_71":70},"X28N-GOB",{},[],"The community begins to deliberate by sharing references.",{"_33":11488,"_35":11489},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11490,"_41":1766,"_43":11491,"_67":11492,"_69":11493,"_71":70},"Sz_K9fqa",{},[],"The article is updated as sufficient veracity is achieved.",{"_37":199,"_39":11495,"_41":1766,"_43":11496,"_67":11497,"_69":11498,"_71":70},"k6K-sNeT",{"_194":5405},[],"The process should work as follows:",{"_33":11500,"_35":11501},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11502,"_41":1766,"_43":11503,"_67":11504,"_69":11505,"_71":70},"ZD2VPbYJ",{},[],"What do you think of this feedback process?",[55],"/private-notes/can-we-trust-information-without-editorial-review",{"_83":1781},{},{"_39":1763,"_97":55,"_56":11511,"_72":1766,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1765],1772124423882,[151,1763,1766],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/can-we-trust-information-without-editorial-review\",\"bafy2bzacebjlowawqkd4nvqs232ompyacozgpa77glt7rb4om5td3duhmlwtu\"]",{"_112":11516,"_149":11625,"_152":11626},{"_114":11517,"_133":134,"_135":11624,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11518,"_39":11622},{"_30":11519,"_72":1787,"_73":55,"_74":11617,"_56":11618,"_77":1796,"_79":11619,"_81":11620,"_86":11621,"_88":1797,"_90":91},[11520,11540,11547,11558,11570,11582,11611],{"_33":11521,"_35":11522},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11523,"_41":11524,"_43":11525,"_67":11526,"_69":11539,"_71":70},"kFrA87X5","bafy2bzaceay64jgxxhousv722wyv5lulo5ea5dtbzssl2qu5n7yep7qaj2ese",{},[11527,11532],{"_37":286,"_233":11528,"_238":11530,"_43":11531,"_71":11441},[11529],49,[6889],{},{"_37":232,"_233":11533,"_238":11536,"_43":11538,"_71":70},[11534,11535],106,264,[4277,11537],334,{},"En una conversación reciente en X, el periodista Santiago Bustamante planteaba una preocupación legítima: la demonización generalizada de los canales alternativos de información, etiquetándolos como \"bulos\". En lugar de cerrar el acceso, propone algo más valioso: educar en el pensamiento crítico y fomentar el contraste entre fuentes.",{"_33":11541,"_35":11542},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11543,"_41":1797,"_43":11544,"_67":11545,"_69":11546,"_71":70},"MH83vpU0",{},[],"Pero... ¿qué pasa con los canales que no tienen ningún tipo de revisión editorial ni científica? ¿Pueden ser considerados válidos?",{"_33":11548,"_35":11549},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11550,"_41":1797,"_43":11551,"_67":11552,"_69":11557,"_71":70},"MEjRcc2T",{},[11553],{"_37":232,"_233":11554,"_238":11555,"_43":11556,"_71":70},[5288],[6401],{},"Lo cierto es que la revisión por pares sigue siendo crucial, especialmente en ciencia y temas complejos. Pero también reconocemos que en momentos de alta intensidad informativa —como una crisis o evento inesperado—, los tiempos editoriales pueden ser insuficientes. En ese escenario caótico, ¿qué herramientas tenemos?",{"_33":11559,"_35":11560},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11561,"_41":1797,"_43":11562,"_67":11563,"_69":11569,"_71":70},"njjae91C",{},[11564],{"_37":232,"_233":11565,"_238":11566,"_43":11568,"_71":70},[5290],[11567],79,{},"La respuesta apunta hacia el futuro: necesitamos mejores herramientas digitales. Sistemas que nos permitan verificar, contrastar y discutir colectivamente la información sin depender únicamente de estructuras centralizadas.",{"_33":11571,"_35":11572},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11573,"_41":1797,"_43":11574,"_67":11575,"_69":11581,"_71":70},"jIUu6b1u",{},[11576],{"_37":286,"_233":11577,"_238":11578,"_43":11579,"_71":11580},[2395],[4797],{},"hm://z6MkfzKMhF9k1oPaQsShWAg8xJzbWf5kaZgn1MkeZvhcAsmB/protocol","Propongo el protocolo de hipermedia, que permite discutir temas al mismo tiempo que se va actualizando el artículo en tiempo real. Mismo proceso que Wikipedia pero más dinámico en la gestión de identidades, permisos y herramienta de información.",{"_33":11583,"_35":11606},[11584,11592,11599],{"_33":11585,"_35":11586},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11587,"_41":11588,"_43":11589,"_67":11590,"_69":11591,"_71":70},"y2U-tCUQ","bafy2bzacebefffb5qvr45yjqq2jevpmptw7mh7fwrlo5eqobt6fhovsxuni6e",{},[],"alguien establece un pregunta o problema a resolver.",{"_33":11593,"_35":11594},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11595,"_41":11588,"_43":11596,"_67":11597,"_69":11598,"_71":70},"k3AmxyZT",{},[],"la comunidad empieza a deliberar compartiendo referencias.",{"_33":11600,"_35":11601},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11602,"_41":11588,"_43":11603,"_67":11604,"_69":11605,"_71":70},"ncqGIO-1",{},[],"el artículo se va actualizando a medida que se va alcanzando veracidad suficiente.",{"_37":199,"_39":11607,"_41":11588,"_43":11608,"_67":11609,"_69":11610,"_71":70},"VSurC5On",{"_194":5405},[],"El proceso debería funcionar así:",{"_33":11612,"_35":11613},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11614,"_41":1787,"_43":11615,"_67":11616,"_69":7856,"_71":70},"BYCu1uyj",{},[],[55],"/private-notes/podemos-confiar-en-la-informacion-sin-revision-editorial","2025-05-01T15:31:51.141Z",{"_83":1810},{},{"_39":1784,"_97":55,"_56":11623,"_72":1787,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1786],1772124423865,[151,1784,1787],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/podemos-confiar-en-la-informacion-sin-revision-editorial\",\"bafy2bzacebogtnsh4sznxhi5o2yijamz2ngy2lgh5wuuqvnvusek7w25motcg\"]",{"_112":11628,"_149":11714,"_152":11715},{"_114":11629,"_133":134,"_135":11713,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11630,"_39":11711},{"_30":11631,"_72":1816,"_73":55,"_74":11706,"_56":11707,"_77":1825,"_79":11708,"_81":11709,"_86":11710,"_88":1826,"_90":91},[11632,11639,11660,11668,11681,11692,11699],{"_33":11633,"_35":11634},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11635,"_41":1826,"_43":11636,"_67":11637,"_69":11638,"_71":70},"K27RgMNA",{},[],"The early history of Bitcoin is still full of mystery—even regarding the involvement of Hal Finney, one of Satoshi’s first known correspondents.",{"_33":11640,"_35":11641},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11642,"_41":1826,"_43":11643,"_67":11644,"_69":11659,"_71":70},"MGcnt4ur",{},[11645,11650],{"_37":286,"_233":11646,"_238":11647,"_43":11648,"_71":11649},[3778],[3804],{},"https://x.com/raw_avocado",{"_37":232,"_233":11651,"_238":11654,"_43":11658,"_71":70},[11652,4277,11653],52,249,[11655,11656,11657],100,212,268,{},"In a recent thread, researcher Alex Waltz digs into debug logs, private emails, and early block data to piece together a timeline. Contrary to popular belief, evidence suggests Hal didn’t run Bitcoin from block 1, but likely joined slightly later — not before block 49, according to the data.",{"_33":11661,"_35":11662},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":11663,"_41":11664,"_43":11665,"_67":11666,"_69":70,"_71":11667},"m3VKsFYo","bafy2bzaceaoqphqtgflcoxkx2nvdswbtbztyr6k5werxvzgazxmncvia6xijs",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeifvibzuj5opcuqqktxbiatn3bi2iabemuhbv2yiqtdxryxkxesc7e",{"_33":11669,"_35":11670},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11671,"_41":1826,"_43":11672,"_67":11673,"_69":11680,"_71":70},"G3NPADWh",{},[11674],{"_37":232,"_233":11675,"_238":11677,"_43":11679,"_71":70},[5057,11676],153,[5058,11678],181,{},"This detail may seem minor, but it reminds us how much of Bitcoin’s origin is still obscured, misunderstood, or debated. From block propagation clues to forgotten mailing list posts, every byte of history matters when you're tracing the roots of the most important financial protocol of our time.",{"_33":11682,"_35":11683},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11684,"_41":1826,"_43":11685,"_67":11686,"_69":11691,"_71":70},"2dvVWr-O",{},[11687],{"_37":232,"_233":11688,"_238":11689,"_43":11690,"_71":70},[4183],[7664],{},"So, was Hal there at genesis?\nNot exactly — and that’s what makes it interesting.",{"_33":11693,"_35":11694},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11695,"_41":1816,"_43":11696,"_67":11697,"_69":11698,"_71":70},"k5r74Ck7",{},[],"More on Alex Twitter Thread:",{"_33":11700,"_35":11701},[],{"_37":3483,"_39":11702,"_41":1816,"_43":11703,"_67":11704,"_69":70,"_71":11705},"hD-aM7mg",{},[],"https://x.com/raw_avocado/status/1917629692883918925",[55],"/private-notes/when-exactly-did-hal-start-running-bitcoin","2025-05-01T10:17:34.849Z",{"_83":1835},{},{"_39":1813,"_97":55,"_56":11712,"_72":1816,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1815],1772124423937,[151,1813,1816],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/when-exactly-did-hal-start-running-bitcoin\",\"bafy2bzaceahv4bmmc4cmcm5uzvulbxf66f2lblff3sktl6envvwwhd27t3ej6\"]",{"_112":11717,"_149":11836,"_152":11837},{"_114":11718,"_133":134,"_135":11835,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11719,"_39":11833},{"_30":11720,"_72":1841,"_73":55,"_74":11828,"_56":11829,"_77":1850,"_79":11830,"_81":11831,"_86":11832,"_88":1851,"_90":91},[11721,11733,11740,11751,11786,11797,11809,11822],{"_33":11722,"_35":11723},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11724,"_41":1851,"_43":11725,"_67":11726,"_69":11732,"_71":70},"hdXFYOsR",{},[11727],{"_37":286,"_233":11728,"_238":11729,"_43":11730,"_71":11731},[3853],[4157],{},"https://x.com/latinapaterson","El trabajo de @latinapaterson recuperando y coloreando imágenes poco conocidas de nuestra historia reciente es, sencillamente, patrimonio cultural. Sus hilos en X muestran fotos datadas, firmadas y muchas veces olvidadas, que ahora reviven con una nueva fuerza visual.",{"_33":11734,"_35":11735},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11736,"_41":1851,"_43":11737,"_67":11738,"_69":11739,"_71":70},"3R7p0dMw",{},[],"Pero los hilos se pierden. Las plataformas cambian.",{"_33":11741,"_35":11742},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11743,"_41":1851,"_43":11744,"_67":11745,"_69":11750,"_71":70},"cPc4dV8x",{},[11746],{"_37":232,"_233":11747,"_238":11748,"_43":11749,"_71":70},[139],[4169],{},"¿No merecen estas imágenes un archivo propio?",{"_33":11752,"_35":11781},[11753,11760,11767,11774],{"_33":11754,"_35":11755},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11756,"_41":1851,"_43":11757,"_67":11758,"_69":11759,"_71":70},"m5uBOcqn",{},[],"📚 Reunir las imágenes en colecciones temáticas",{"_33":11761,"_35":11762},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11763,"_41":1851,"_43":11764,"_67":11765,"_69":11766,"_71":70},"aftwT8no",{},[],"📝 Añadir contexto histórico, fechas, autores y fuentes",{"_33":11768,"_35":11769},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11770,"_41":1851,"_43":11771,"_67":11772,"_69":11773,"_71":70},"gKSwTiA-",{},[],"🔗 Relacionar las imágenes entre sí y con otros documentos",{"_33":11775,"_35":11776},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11777,"_41":1851,"_43":11778,"_67":11779,"_69":11780,"_71":70},"Z2Zt_2Cf",{},[],"🧑‍🤝‍🧑 Invitar a historiadores, fotógrafos y lectores a colaborar y comentar",{"_37":199,"_39":11782,"_41":1851,"_43":11783,"_67":11784,"_69":11785,"_71":70},"v65S-piv",{"_194":3876},[],"Un Site (como los de Seed Hypermedia) permitiría:",{"_33":11787,"_35":11788},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11789,"_41":1851,"_43":11790,"_67":11791,"_69":11796,"_71":70},"7HQIYxJG",{},[11792],{"_37":232,"_233":11793,"_238":11794,"_43":11795,"_71":70},[11567],[4692],{},"Tina ya ha hecho el trabajo difícil: rescatar la memoria.\nAhora falta darle un hogar digital duradero.",{"_33":11798,"_35":11799},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11800,"_41":1851,"_43":11801,"_67":11802,"_69":11808,"_71":70},"heb3aBi_",{},[11803],{"_37":286,"_233":11804,"_238":11805,"_43":11806,"_71":11807},[139],[2395],{},"https://x.com/latinapaterson/status/1085541897903525888","Primer Tweet del archivo:",{"_33":11810,"_35":11811},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11812,"_41":1851,"_43":11813,"_67":11814,"_69":11821,"_71":70},"TFCS_jsa",{},[11815],{"_37":286,"_233":11816,"_238":11818,"_43":11819,"_71":11820},[11817],224,[6831],{},"https://x.com/hashtag/colorized?src=hashtag_click","Resumen de hilos basados en imágenes que he coloreado de nuestra historia reciente. En la medida de lo posible están datadas y firmadas y se tratan de imágenes poco conocidas, perdidas/halladas o digitalizadas recientemente #colorized ",{"_33":11823,"_35":11824},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":11825,"_41":1851,"_43":11826,"_67":11827,"_69":70,"_71":1865},"0w4x1zGU",{"_194":195},[],[55],"/private-notes/y-si-tina-paterson-tuviera-su-propio-archivo-digital","2025-05-01T10:13:35.373Z",{"_83":1864,"_331":1865},{},{"_39":1838,"_97":55,"_56":11834,"_72":1841,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1840],1772124423921,[151,1838,1841],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/y-si-tina-paterson-tuviera-su-propio-archivo-digital\",\"bafy2bzaceahij6hayckj6tukfsicknc4mu44r32z5ts55bl6whn3n45bhmk7k\"]",{"_112":11839,"_149":11930,"_152":11931},{"_114":11840,"_133":134,"_135":11929,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11841,"_39":11927},{"_30":11842,"_72":1871,"_73":55,"_74":11923,"_56":11924,"_77":1878,"_79":1878,"_81":11925,"_86":11926,"_88":1871,"_90":91},[11843,11855,11867,11916],{"_33":11844,"_35":11845},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11846,"_41":1871,"_43":11847,"_67":11848,"_69":11854,"_71":70},"KPM6qQwe",{},[11849],{"_37":286,"_233":11850,"_238":11851,"_43":11852,"_71":11853},[139],[4670],{},"https://x.com/marcvidal","Marc Vidal, plantea la pregunta y planteamiento que copio a continuación. El ejercicio sería más potente si una vez la comunidad empezase a dar argumentos y explicaciones el artículo fuese mejorando hasta alcanzar un alto grado de veracidad.",{"_33":11856,"_35":11857},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11858,"_41":1871,"_43":11859,"_67":11860,"_69":11866,"_71":70},"jQcxw6Zi",{},[11861],{"_37":286,"_233":11862,"_238":11863,"_43":11864,"_71":11865},[452],[3776],{},"https://x.com/marcvidal/status/1917615480568963335","Este es el post:",{"_33":11868,"_35":11911},[11869,11876,11883,11890,11897,11904],{"_33":11870,"_35":11871},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11872,"_41":1871,"_43":11873,"_67":11874,"_69":11875,"_71":70},"pMoJQfeD",{},[],"Sabemos que hubo una caída enorme e inesperada en el sistema eléctrico que sorprendió a las compañías eléctricas. Entiendo que era algo inédito.",{"_33":11877,"_35":11878},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11879,"_41":1871,"_43":11880,"_67":11881,"_69":11882,"_71":70},"k8VdTbPJ",{},[],"Normalmente, cuando hay un exceso de electricidad, se ordena apagar ciertas plantas para evitar sobrecargas. Entiendo que si es así es porque los sistemas detectaron que iba a entrar una gran cantidad de energía renovable (como la solar o eólica), y entiendo que se ordenó prepararse apagando otras plantas. (Aquí tengo dudas)",{"_33":11884,"_35":11885},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11886,"_41":1871,"_43":11887,"_67":11888,"_69":11889,"_71":70},"gxWc3ZXm",{},[],"La pregunta es ¿esa energía renovable nunca llegó realmente? Si no llegó, ¿porque se siguió adelante con los apagones? ¿hasta cuando se actuó como si fuera a entrar? ¿cuándo contactaron con el regulador del sistema? entiendo que normalmente da las instrucciones clave en esos casos. ¿Las dio? ¿Cuándo?",{"_33":11891,"_35":11892},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11893,"_41":1871,"_43":11894,"_67":11895,"_69":11896,"_71":70},"MOXerbzL",{},[],"En todo caso el resultado fue que la red eléctrica se colapsó sin que nadie entendiera por qué si atendemos a las explicaciones que se han dado o yo he podido escuchar.",{"_33":11898,"_35":11899},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11900,"_41":1871,"_43":11901,"_67":11902,"_69":11903,"_71":70},"c4dB_lbV",{},[],"¿Se perdieron las comunicaciones con los principales centros de control del sistema nacional justo antes de que todo fallara? ¿Fue esto lo que hizo pensar que podía tratarse de una ciberamenaza inicialmente atendiendo a algunos mensajes que se dieron por autoridades en Portugal y Andalucía?",{"_33":11905,"_35":11906},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11907,"_41":1871,"_43":11908,"_67":11909,"_69":11910,"_71":70},"w9FeNHV2",{},[],"Y si no me equivoco, corríjanme si es así, al final, se ordenó reiniciar todo poco a poco, aunque lo más desconcertante es que no parece que hubiera ningún fallo físico visible, ni en las redes ni en las plantas eléctricas. Lo que me carcome es saber si esa llegada masiva de oferta eléctrica llegó o no realmente.",{"_37":199,"_39":11912,"_41":1871,"_43":11913,"_67":11914,"_69":11915,"_71":70},"t8BD6R74",{"_194":5405},[],"Tengo una duda que espero los expertos puedan ayudarme a resolver. Igual es una tontería colosal lo que digo, pero...",{"_33":11917,"_35":11918},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11919,"_41":1871,"_43":11920,"_67":11921,"_69":11922,"_71":70},"vCvCS9oR",{},[],"¿Alguien que trabaje en uno de estos centros de control puede certificar un error tan grande entre la electricidad que se esperaba y la que realmente entró en su carrera profesional?",[55],"/private-notes/la-energia-renovable-nunca-llego-realmente-",{"_83":1891},{},{"_39":1868,"_97":55,"_56":11928,"_72":1871,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1870],1772124423932,[151,1868,1871],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/la-energia-renovable-nunca-llego-realmente-\",\"bafy2bzaceab4lrg5svq3ifqhn32fcrcrchu3nrwmhv2ff3sxx6jgfdxvfzivc\"]",{"_112":11933,"_149":11944,"_152":11945},{"_114":11934,"_133":134,"_135":11943,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11935,"_39":11941},{"_30":11936,"_72":1897,"_73":55,"_74":11937,"_56":11938,"_77":1904,"_79":1904,"_81":11939,"_86":11940,"_88":1897,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/se-puede-resolver-el-problema-de-la-inercia-solo-con-renovables",{"_83":1913},{},{"_39":1894,"_97":55,"_56":11942,"_72":1897,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1896],1772124423941,[151,1894,1897],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/se-puede-resolver-el-problema-de-la-inercia-solo-con-renovables\",\"bafy2bzacecnctjo6zohg2gn7b4rbaf3hbxqohtb4hquiosfohtcyzu7ge3q6c\"]",{"_112":11947,"_149":11958,"_152":11959},{"_114":11948,"_133":134,"_135":11957,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11949,"_39":11955},{"_30":11950,"_72":1919,"_73":55,"_74":11951,"_56":11952,"_77":1926,"_79":1926,"_81":11953,"_86":11954,"_88":1919,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/espana-necesita-energia-nuclear",{"_83":1935},{},{"_39":1916,"_97":55,"_56":11956,"_72":1919,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1918],1772124423945,[151,1916,1919],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/espana-necesita-energia-nuclear\",\"bafy2bzacedp37s3s2ljl6c4hvxj3t56hyqufreoonac2u3wxp2edkh4scb45s\"]",{"_112":11961,"_149":12007,"_152":12008},{"_114":11962,"_133":134,"_135":12006,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":11963,"_39":12004},{"_30":11964,"_72":1941,"_73":55,"_74":11999,"_56":12000,"_77":1950,"_79":12001,"_81":12002,"_86":12003,"_88":1951,"_90":91},[11965,11972,11992],{"_33":11966,"_35":11967},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11968,"_41":1951,"_43":11969,"_67":11970,"_69":11971,"_71":70},"2CWvpaxM",{},[],"I want a fast service, no bs, no ads, and cheap. :) Does it exist?",{"_33":11973,"_35":11987},[11974],{"_33":11975,"_35":11976},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11977,"_41":11978,"_43":11979,"_67":11980,"_69":11986,"_71":70},"eSRai9XK","bafy2bzaced6bgfgarjyeqkkl65hr66xmvm664exieygjlx7rhrudzses34owa",{},[11981],{"_37":286,"_233":11982,"_238":11983,"_43":11985,"_71":11986},[139],[11984],65,{},"https://archive.org/details/keeponrolling_thedreamoftheautomobile",{"_37":199,"_39":11988,"_41":1941,"_43":11989,"_67":11990,"_69":11991,"_71":70},"jxD4UgaN",{"_194":195},[],"I want to offer this video from my site. It is hosted on Internet Archive, but the streaming quality isn't good enough.",{"_33":11993,"_35":11994},[],{"_37":199,"_39":11995,"_41":1941,"_43":11996,"_67":11997,"_69":11998,"_71":70},"0hdoWihU",{},[],"How does IPFS plays out here? I could just upload the video to my Site, but only if we add a delete/caching video soon for videos and audio. Otherwise, It will be very heavy to users!\n",[55],"/private-notes/what-is-the-best-video-hosting-service","2025-04-28T08:52:12.976Z",{"_83":1964},{},{"_39":1938,"_97":55,"_56":12005,"_72":1941,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1940],1772124423951,[151,1938,1941],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/what-is-the-best-video-hosting-service\",\"bafy2bzacecq7x6hy3ilmvnrkawi5rqrclwuciyq73wcwhw2i3yebqnngoce74\"]",{"_112":12010,"_149":12028,"_152":12029},{"_114":12011,"_133":134,"_135":12027,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":12012,"_39":12025},{"_30":12013,"_72":1970,"_73":55,"_74":12021,"_56":12022,"_77":1976,"_79":1976,"_81":12023,"_86":12024,"_88":1970,"_90":91},[12014],{"_33":12015,"_35":12016},[],{"_37":166,"_39":12017,"_41":1970,"_43":12018,"_67":12019,"_69":70,"_71":12020},"EaL0fJEB",{"_170":7190},[],"hm://z6MkkNK4HGRgVgdXYLYuT4K91WqLBN1tVBRooEXrM17MweSR/equipamiento?v=bafy2bzacebv6usg65v7ojrjtifp3gzelrjg25qzyb4ljz7v3abucuwlsppisi#0_H8XZOo",[55],"/private-notes/competicion-de-tenis-en-canal",{"_83":1985},{},{"_39":1967,"_97":55,"_56":12026,"_72":1970,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1969],1772124423956,[151,1967,1970],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/competicion-de-tenis-en-canal\",\"bafy2bzaceakrbu4foooftr5fluzqqhrncqisp6l4y6nilxmn4iypltm4bfj7o\"]",{"_112":12031,"_149":12627,"_152":12628},{"_114":12032,"_133":134,"_135":12626,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":12033,"_39":12624},{"_30":12034,"_72":1991,"_73":55,"_74":12619,"_56":12620,"_77":2001,"_79":12621,"_81":12622,"_86":12623,"_88":2002,"_90":91},[12035,12042,12054,12065,12072,12079,12085,12129,12135,12142,12205,12322,12396,12470,12534,12598,12604],{"_33":12036,"_35":12037},[],{"_37":190,"_39":12038,"_41":2002,"_43":12039,"_67":12040,"_69":12041,"_71":70},"9x6dzBeq",{},[],"Introducción",{"_33":12043,"_35":12044},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12045,"_41":12046,"_43":12047,"_67":12048,"_69":12053,"_71":70},"OWhYUrp7","bafy2bzaceanfvg7lq7jgdsvjgg66jrzro3mjyat2lxzswbjohrs6jmplrwruw",{},[12049],{"_37":232,"_233":12050,"_238":12051,"_43":12052,"_71":70},[11652],[6889],{},"En esta guía voy a intentar ponerte a funcionar con bitcoin de test en los mínimos pasos posibles. ",{"_33":12055,"_35":12056},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12057,"_41":12046,"_43":12058,"_67":12059,"_69":12064,"_71":70},"aL31pmS_",{},[12060],{"_37":232,"_233":12061,"_238":12062,"_43":12063,"_71":70},[139],[6884],{},"No te va a costar ni un dólar o euro porque como digo es bitcoin de test que podrás pedir en una web, te lo enviarán acto seguido y podrás hacer todas las pruebas que quieras. Así te familiarizas con el funcionamiento de Bitcoin y cuando estés preparado das el salto a Mainnet (la red principal de Bitcoin donde 1 moneda tiene un valor en dólares de 85.000,00$ a fecha de escritura de esta guía en bloque 892421). ",{"_33":12066,"_35":12067},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12068,"_41":2002,"_43":12069,"_67":12070,"_69":12071,"_71":70},"SNdv761N",{},[],"Así que ¿empezamos? ",{"_33":12073,"_35":12074},[],{"_37":190,"_39":12075,"_41":2002,"_43":12076,"_67":12077,"_69":12078,"_71":70},"AEJz6YXM",{},[],"Paso 1: Instalar Nunchuk e inicializarla",{"_33":12080,"_35":12081},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":12082,"_41":1991,"_43":12083,"_67":12084,"_69":70,"_71":2012},"9aSiPmwH",{"_194":195},[],{"_33":12086,"_35":12124},[12087,12099,12106,12117],{"_33":12088,"_35":12089},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12090,"_41":2002,"_43":12091,"_67":12092,"_69":12098,"_71":70},"m3b9Hm8k",{},[12093],{"_37":286,"_233":12094,"_238":12095,"_43":12096,"_71":12097},[6890],[9024],{},"https://nunchuk.io/","Nunchuk —una billetera bitcoin-only y de código abierto— está disponible tanto para Android como para iOS y podéis encontrar sus respectivos links en https://nunchuk.io/. La guía se ha hecho con pantallazos de Android pero espero que en iOS no diste mucho de lo aquí visto. ",{"_33":12100,"_35":12101},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12102,"_41":2002,"_43":12103,"_67":12104,"_69":12105,"_71":70},"eJPNftiG",{},[],"Con Nunchuk descargada la ejecutamos",{"_33":12107,"_35":12108},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12109,"_41":2002,"_43":12110,"_67":12111,"_69":12116,"_71":70},"QVrTGqY3",{},[12112],{"_37":232,"_233":12113,"_238":12114,"_43":12115,"_71":70},[5056],[6817],{},"En esta primera ventana en la que nos piden un email, lo pasamos por alto y le damos a Continue as guest (continuar como invitado)",{"_33":12118,"_35":12119},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12120,"_41":2002,"_43":12121,"_67":12122,"_69":12123,"_71":70},"Tmt-XfDl",{},[],"En la siguiente ventana nos va a ofrecer activar las notificaciones, yo no las activo, pero puede interesarte ahora que estás aprendiendo. ",{"_37":199,"_39":12125,"_41":2002,"_43":12126,"_67":12127,"_69":12128,"_71":70},"LG2IZ6Sp",{"_194":5405},[],"La guía funciona siempre igual. Aparecen unas imágenes como las de aquí arriba y yo te indico que hacer en cada una de ellas (punto 1 = imagen 1, etc).",{"_33":12130,"_35":12131},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12132,"_41":2002,"_43":12133,"_67":12134,"_69":70,"_71":70},"9iavColj",{},[],{"_33":12136,"_35":12137},[],{"_37":190,"_39":12138,"_41":2002,"_43":12139,"_67":12140,"_69":12141,"_71":70},"NPLvRMhz",{},[],"Paso 2: Cambiar a Testnet",{"_33":12143,"_35":12200},[12144,12156,12168,12189],{"_33":12145,"_35":12146},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12147,"_41":1991,"_43":12148,"_67":12149,"_69":12155,"_71":70},"MZr3m3iM",{},[12150],{"_37":232,"_233":12151,"_238":12153,"_43":12154,"_71":70},[12152],271,[4812],{},"Nada más acceder vamos a ignorar todo lo que nos aparece y vamos a poner la billetera a funcionar en Testnet. Ahora mismo, si no hacemos nada, estamos en Mainnet —la red principal de Bitcoin— y no es lo que queremos, así que vamos abajo a la izquierda y hacemos click en Profile",{"_33":12157,"_35":12158},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12159,"_41":12160,"_43":12161,"_67":12162,"_69":12167,"_71":70},"DYaCFvLs","bafy2bzaceamplq6vbyct4rfvreviyokmwuuidu6ibdwkrx3lv22lb4vwfa3g2",{},[12163],{"_37":232,"_233":12164,"_238":12165,"_43":12166,"_71":70},[6084],[6884],{},"2 Allí le daremos a Network settings",{"_33":12169,"_35":12170},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12171,"_41":12160,"_43":12172,"_67":12173,"_69":12188,"_71":70},"qJyfRHDo",{},[12174,12179,12183],{"_37":3795,"_233":12175,"_238":12177,"_43":12178,"_71":70},[12176],64,[5062],{},{"_37":4656,"_233":12180,"_238":12181,"_43":12182,"_71":70},[4320],[9189],{},{"_37":232,"_233":12184,"_238":12186,"_43":12187,"_71":70},[12185],255,[8985],{},"3 En la siguiente ventana marcaremos el puntito a la derecha de Testnet server y teclearemos la siguiente información ssl://mempool.space:40002 Este servidor nos funcionará en testnet4 (nada importante ni que debas entender ahora). Al terminar le damos a Save network settings (guardar los ajustes de red)",{"_33":12190,"_35":12191},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12192,"_41":12160,"_43":12193,"_67":12194,"_69":12199,"_71":70},"ykz_Joru",{},[12195],{"_37":232,"_233":12196,"_238":12197,"_43":12198,"_71":70},[10225],[5723],{},"4 Al hacer cambios en la red nos va a pedir que reiniciemos la billetera. Hacemos click en Restart",{"_37":3505,"_39":12201,"_41":1991,"_43":12202,"_67":12203,"_69":70,"_71":12204},"TNX6Uw_L",{"_194":5405},[],"ipfs://bafybeibpdnakas2mxadrh2k25eascqbo66v2rds6pofk5d2k5uc43aimxy",{"_33":12206,"_35":12317},[12207,12261],{"_33":12208,"_35":12256},[12209,12221,12232,12244],{"_33":12210,"_35":12211},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12212,"_41":12160,"_43":12213,"_67":12214,"_69":12220,"_71":70},"DSoG7fv9",{},[12215],{"_37":232,"_233":12216,"_238":12217,"_43":12219,"_71":70},[9160,9161],[12218,6546],99,{},"1 Cuando se nos vuelve a iniciar la billetera —ahora ya sí en testnet— le damos a Create hot wallet. Acto seguido nos aparecerá otra pantalla que aquí no aparece pero solo le tenemos que dar a Continue",{"_33":12222,"_35":12223},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12224,"_41":12160,"_43":12225,"_67":12226,"_69":12231,"_71":70},"7ZrqIKm1",{},[12227],{"_37":3795,"_233":12228,"_238":12229,"_43":12230,"_71":70},[3973,6443],[3778,11327],{},"2 Cuando volvamos al menú Home donde están nuestras billeteras (podemos tener más de una) veremos que nos aparece en marrón \"My hot wallet\" en pantalla. Le damos. ",{"_33":12233,"_35":12234},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12235,"_41":12160,"_43":12236,"_67":12237,"_69":12243,"_71":70},"RkIW24BB",{},[12238],{"_37":232,"_233":12239,"_238":12241,"_43":12242,"_71":70},[12240],180,[6934],{},"3 Al abrirse veremos que arriba nos aparece un cartel que nos alerta que no hemos hecho el respaldo/backup/copia de seguridad de nuestra Frase Mnemónica caliente. Hacemos click en Do it now",{"_33":12245,"_35":12246},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12247,"_41":12160,"_43":12248,"_67":12249,"_69":12255,"_71":70},"neg2w03M",{},[12250],{"_37":232,"_233":12251,"_238":12252,"_43":12254,"_71":70},[6853],[12253],163,{},"4 En la siguiente ventana nos advierte que este paso, una vez hecho, no lo podremos hacer después. Lo haremos ahora y lo haremos bien 👌 así que le damos a Continue",{"_37":3505,"_39":12257,"_41":1991,"_43":12258,"_67":12259,"_69":70,"_71":12260},"8xF2gMoM",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeigwx3l6wgfloncsvoxymafurqqvkvl36rdbkur33h5nsja22ahrua",{"_33":12262,"_35":12312},[12263,12276,12287,12299],{"_33":12264,"_35":12265},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12266,"_41":12160,"_43":12267,"_67":12268,"_69":12275,"_71":70},"voH3YAw-",{},[12269],{"_37":232,"_233":12270,"_238":12272,"_43":12274,"_71":70},[12271],197,[12273],206,{},"1 Nos aparecerán en pantalla nuestras palabras de la Frase Mnemónica. Aunque sea de una billetera de test, es una buena práctica apuntarla para acostumbrarse. La apuntamos en un papel y le damos a Continue (prohibidísimo guardarla en un pantallazo. ¡Prohibido prohibido!)",{"_33":12277,"_35":12278},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12279,"_41":12160,"_43":12280,"_67":12281,"_69":12286,"_71":70},"7zC6kfBp",{},[12282],{"_37":232,"_233":12283,"_238":12284,"_43":12285,"_71":70},[6980],[4692],{},"2 Acto seguido Nunchuk nos hará un test para ver si la hemos apuntado bien. Lo completamos y Continue",{"_33":12288,"_35":12289},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12290,"_41":12160,"_43":12291,"_67":12292,"_69":12298,"_71":70},"E4bn1Avd",{},[12293],{"_37":232,"_233":12294,"_238":12296,"_43":12297,"_71":70},[12295],192,[9162],{},"3 En la siguiente pantalla nos vuelve a recordar que no podremos volver a ver esta información más tarde y nos pregunta si queremos volverla a revisar. Como la hemos apuntado bien, le damos a I've backed it up",{"_33":12300,"_35":12301},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12302,"_41":12160,"_43":12303,"_67":12304,"_69":12311,"_71":70},"byrPAtwH",{},[12305],{"_37":232,"_233":12306,"_238":12308,"_43":12310,"_71":70},[12307],152,[12309],161,{},"4 Felicidades, ya has hecho una copia de seguridad de tu Frase. Después de esto aterrizaremos en una pantalla de poca utilidad, con lo que le daremos a la flecha de \"hacia atrás\" que encontraremos arriba a la izquierda. ",{"_37":3505,"_39":12313,"_41":1991,"_43":12314,"_67":12315,"_69":70,"_71":12316},"g-5cwB2P",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeiak4s4os32hhjp3ny4jsdoatkxh4itjrtntefj5qxx5322qih7dwm",{"_37":190,"_39":12318,"_41":2002,"_43":12319,"_67":12320,"_69":12321,"_71":70},"QQhsHKsZ",{"_194":195},[],"Paso 3: Copia de seguridad de billetera",{"_33":12323,"_35":12391},[12324],{"_33":12325,"_35":12386},[12326,12338,12353,12374],{"_33":12327,"_35":12328},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12329,"_41":12160,"_43":12330,"_67":12331,"_69":12337,"_71":70},"gYL58nJY",{},[12332],{"_37":232,"_233":12333,"_238":12334,"_43":12336,"_71":70},[6836],[12335],244,{},"1 Ahora ya nuestra billetera luce mejor, en color azul confianza 🙃 pero no tiene bitcoin. Vamos a recibirlos. Siempre que queramos recibir bitcoin le pediremos a nuestra billetera que nos genere una dirección. Para ello hacemos click en Receive",{"_33":12339,"_35":12340},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12341,"_41":12160,"_43":12342,"_67":12343,"_69":12352,"_71":70},"OxJwfWZh",{},[12344,12348],{"_37":3795,"_233":12345,"_238":12346,"_43":12347,"_71":70},[5063],[9700],{},{"_37":232,"_233":12349,"_238":12350,"_43":12351,"_71":70},[6848],[12309],{},"2 En esta ventana ya vemos que tenemos 1 dirección lista para ser usada (porque está en la pestaña de no-usadas o Unused address). Hacemos click en Copy address (copiar dirección). (NOTA, las direcciones de testnet empiezan por \"tb1\", mientras que las de Mainnet empiezan por \"bc1\")",{"_33":12354,"_35":12355},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12356,"_41":12160,"_43":12357,"_67":12358,"_69":12373,"_71":70},"F9i7FHto",{},[12359,12365,12369],{"_37":286,"_233":12360,"_238":12362,"_43":12363,"_71":12364},[12361],166,[9212],{},"faucet.testnet4.dev",{"_37":232,"_233":12366,"_238":12367,"_43":12368,"_71":70},[4693],[4850],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":12370,"_238":12371,"_43":12372,"_71":70},[4649],[6174],{},"3 Con la dirección copiada vamos a un Faucet de Testnet4 (una web en la que podemos pedir monedas de testnet, en concreto de la testnet número 4). Os recomeindo usar faucet.testnet4.dev . Una vez dentro de la web, pegas la dirección que habías copiado de tu wallet, superas el dichoso Captcha y le das a Get 0.005 tBTC (la \"t\" es de testnet). Cuando te lo hayan enviado saldrá un cartelito en verde debajo con el texto \"Success TXID:...\"",{"_33":12375,"_35":12376},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12377,"_41":12160,"_43":12378,"_67":12379,"_69":12385,"_71":70},"mEpmvUzB",{},[12380],{"_37":232,"_233":12381,"_238":12383,"_43":12384,"_71":70},[12382],383,[5456],{},"4 Cuando vuelvas a tu billetera verás que todavía se ve mejor (ya no aparece un código QR en primera plana) y ya te sale un balance positivo de 0.00500000 BTC. Pero como esto de los decimales es un lio, en lugar de verlo a BTCs, vamos a ajustar nuestra wallet para verlo en Sats, la unidad más pequeña de bitcoin (1 BTC = 100.000.000 Sats (o Satoshis)). Así que terminamos dándole a Profile abajo a la derecha",{"_37":3505,"_39":12387,"_41":1991,"_43":12388,"_67":12389,"_69":70,"_71":12390},"XnJ8Oh3n",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeicuhekssgmipdnafbbpfaqg3q7fkra2guispqtiwe4qguhdwyktvy",{"_37":190,"_39":12392,"_41":2002,"_43":12393,"_67":12394,"_69":12395,"_71":70},"rN2KFLon",{"_194":195},[],"Paso 4: Recibir tus primeros bitcoin de test",{"_33":12397,"_35":12465},[12398],{"_33":12399,"_35":12460},[12400,12412,12423,12439],{"_33":12401,"_35":12402},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12403,"_41":12160,"_43":12404,"_67":12405,"_69":12411,"_71":70},"-OELfaLn",{},[12406],{"_37":232,"_233":12407,"_238":12408,"_43":12410,"_71":70},[5381],[12409],54,{},"1 Desde profile hacemos click ahora a Display settings",{"_33":12413,"_35":12414},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12415,"_41":12160,"_43":12416,"_67":12417,"_69":12422,"_71":70},"U1EVXAlq",{},[12418],{"_37":232,"_233":12419,"_238":12420,"_43":12421,"_71":70},[6366],[4098],{},"2 En la siguiente ventana a Display unit (BTC)",{"_33":12424,"_35":12425},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12426,"_41":12160,"_43":12427,"_67":12428,"_69":12438,"_71":70},"u7TOY4xY",{},[12429,12433],{"_37":3795,"_233":12430,"_238":12431,"_43":12432,"_71":70},[3882],[8354],{},{"_37":232,"_233":12434,"_238":12435,"_43":12437,"_71":70},[5530,3661],[12436,12240],119,{},"3 Y en la siguiente hacemos click en la bolita a la derecha de satoshi. Con eso hacemos click hacia atrás con la flecha de arriba a la izquierda y volvemos a nuestra wallet en Home (abajo a la izquierda)",{"_33":12440,"_35":12441},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12442,"_41":12160,"_43":12443,"_67":12444,"_69":12459,"_71":70},"OftMzQ4K",{},[12445,12453],{"_37":232,"_233":12446,"_238":12449,"_43":12452,"_71":70},[12447,5238,12448],191,356,[6904,12450,12451],292,360,{},{"_37":3795,"_233":12454,"_238":12456,"_43":12458,"_71":70},[12455],236,[12457],241,{},"4 Ahora, vemos como nuestra billetera ya nos muestra 500.000 sat y no BTC. Más digerible así. Así que... ¿te animas a hacer tu primer envío de bitcoin? Para ello copia una nueva dirección en Receive como ya hicimos en los pasos 1&2 del Paso4 y luego, vuelve hacia atrás haciendo click en la X de arriba a la izquierda y de vuelta en la wallet haz click en Send",{"_37":3505,"_39":12461,"_41":1991,"_43":12462,"_67":12463,"_69":70,"_71":12464},"el2DO95r",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeicltuaenyllvsxtioazusyhkce7thst7jpv3b6phquxkejbahdyai",{"_37":190,"_39":12466,"_41":2002,"_43":12467,"_67":12468,"_69":12469,"_71":70},"u9HvtMss",{"_194":195},[],"Paso 5: Configurar Nunchuk en Sats",{"_33":12471,"_35":12529},[12472],{"_33":12473,"_35":12524},[12474,12487,12502,12513],{"_33":12475,"_35":12476},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12477,"_41":12160,"_43":12478,"_67":12479,"_69":12486,"_71":70},"Rlz6inFw",{},[12480],{"_37":232,"_233":12481,"_238":12483,"_43":12485,"_71":70},[12482,5066],121,[4848,12484],210,{},"1 En la siguiente ventana definimos la cantidad de sats a enviar. También puedes cambiar a valor dólar haciendo click en Switch to USD si así lo prefieres. Al terminar de definir la cantidad le damos a Continue",{"_33":12488,"_35":12489},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12490,"_41":12160,"_43":12491,"_67":12492,"_69":12501,"_71":70},"WGmswoXK",{},[12493,12497],{"_37":3795,"_233":12494,"_238":12495,"_43":12496,"_71":70},[4688],[5063],{},{"_37":232,"_233":12498,"_238":12499,"_43":12500,"_71":70},[6836],[12185],{},"2 En la siguiente ventana pegamos la dirección que hemos copiado de receive. También ponemos una Transaction note o anotación sobre la transacción. Algo así como \"autoenvío hecho para test\". Esto solo lo verás tú. Al terminar le damos a Create transaction",{"_33":12503,"_35":12504},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12505,"_41":12160,"_43":12506,"_67":12507,"_69":12512,"_71":70},"rdvUNL46",{},[12508],{"_37":232,"_233":12509,"_238":12510,"_43":12511,"_71":70},[12309],[12361],{},"3 En la siguiente ventana podemos verificar que estemos enviando donde queremos. Lo hacemos haciendo click en More details. Cuando lo tengamos claro, le damos a Sign (firmar la transacción)",{"_33":12514,"_35":12515},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12516,"_41":12160,"_43":12517,"_67":12518,"_69":12523,"_71":70},"-d3l5lPc",{},[12519],{"_37":232,"_233":12520,"_238":12521,"_43":12522,"_71":70},[9160],[281],{},"4 En la siguiente ventana y ya con la transacción firmada, solo nos falta darle a Broadcast transaction. Esto la retransmitirá a la red y ya empezará a viajar nodo a nodo para poder ser minada. ¡¡Yay!! ¡Esto es mágico! ✨",{"_37":3505,"_39":12525,"_41":1991,"_43":12526,"_67":12527,"_69":70,"_71":12528},"f7ijfH9t",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafybeibzzoajf4vuqp3wd5lzpczyzvqzydq3nck6k6n7wapwof57dk5nee",{"_37":190,"_39":12530,"_41":2002,"_43":12531,"_67":12532,"_69":12533,"_71":70},"l16_z8xU",{"_194":195},[],"Paso 6: Tu primer envío (autoenvío)",{"_33":12535,"_35":12593},[12536,12543,12554],{"_33":12537,"_35":12538},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":12539,"_41":1991,"_43":12540,"_67":12541,"_69":70,"_71":12542},"aBPEf1Wb",{"_194":195},[],"ipfs://bafkreid4urufe7ml2efotpncbwcgqon2lz6rymaz5tg2tusosngx5tmt7a",{"_33":12544,"_35":12545},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12546,"_41":2002,"_43":12547,"_67":12548,"_69":12553,"_71":70},"h-uY8WQr",{},[12549],{"_37":3795,"_233":12550,"_238":12551,"_43":12552,"_71":70},[7664],[4692],{},"Ahora al volver a tu wallet ya te aparece una nueva transacción con la etiqueta \"Pending confirmation\" que indica que todavía está \"llegando\", pero ya está, ya has hecho tu primera transacción. ¡Felicidades!",{"_33":12555,"_35":12588},[12556,12569],{"_33":12557,"_35":12558},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12559,"_41":2002,"_43":12560,"_67":12561,"_69":12568,"_71":70},"rsFHX3Mh",{},[12562],{"_37":3795,"_233":12563,"_238":12565,"_43":12567,"_71":70},[12564],164,[12566],170,{},"Reto1: Borra la billetera (puedes borrar toda la aplicación directamente) y vuélvela a instalar. Al hacerlo, vuelve a conectarte a testnet siguiendo los puntos del Paso2 y cuando vuelvas a estar dentro, busca la forma de recuperar tu antigua billetera con las 24 palabras de recuperación que has apuntado. Deberías poder volver a acceder a los fondos que recibiste y ver el historial de transacciones. ",{"_33":12570,"_35":12578},[12571],{"_33":12572,"_35":12573},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12574,"_41":2002,"_43":12575,"_67":12576,"_69":12577,"_71":70},"xdYeo8t-",{},[],"NOTA: Como todo en la vida, ve con cuidado en grupos de Telegram (incluso en el mío). Hay muchos estafadores (incluso algunos que se hacen pasar por mi). Desconfía de todos, y solo utiliza esos medios para hacer pruebas con monedas de test. Yo personalmente NUNCA te pediré dinero por privado ni ningún tipo de inversión. Si alguien lo hace en mi nombre seguramente es alguien que me está suplantando la identidad. ",{"_37":199,"_39":12579,"_41":2002,"_43":12580,"_67":12581,"_69":12587,"_71":70},"2k9SzJf7",{"_194":3876},[12582],{"_37":286,"_233":12583,"_238":12584,"_43":12585,"_71":12586},[12457],[12152],{},"https://t.me/lunaticoinpodcast","Reto2: Únete a mi canal de Telegram y busca alguien con quien enviarte tus primeras transacciones de testnet4. Que tu contraparte te pase una dirección y tu le pases una a ella. Así os envíais bitcoin de testnet4. Aquí el canal de telegram: https://t.me/lunaticoinpodcast",{"_37":199,"_39":12589,"_41":2002,"_43":12590,"_67":12591,"_69":12592,"_71":70},"iFsc-gEL",{"_194":5405},[],"¿Qué hacer ahora? Te propongo 2 retos: ",{"_37":190,"_39":12594,"_41":2002,"_43":12595,"_67":12596,"_69":12597,"_71":70},"MMnw4z4a",{"_194":195},[],"Fin",{"_33":12599,"_35":12600},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12601,"_41":2002,"_43":12602,"_67":12603,"_69":70,"_71":70},"a-ut3Hw1",{},[],{"_33":12605,"_35":12606},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12607,"_41":12608,"_43":12609,"_67":12610,"_69":12618,"_71":70},"XSApHjHB","bafy2bzaceb6q4r57bnpppmonpgsj6kk2ydhbgzqa7dezu6jquxkrkppeea33a",{},[12611],{"_37":286,"_233":12612,"_238":12614,"_43":12616,"_71":12617},[12613],474,[12615],492,{},"https://semillabitcoin.com","Felicidades por haber llegado hasta aquí y bienvenido a la Madriguera. Cuando te sientas preparado puedes animarte con crear tu primera billetara Mainnet en Nunchuk. Pero recuerda, es una hot wallet. No pongas más que un salario. Llegado ese punto es hora de aprender sobre Hardware Wallets y si quieres que te acompañe de la mano en 28 días que cambiarán la forma en la que entiendes y dominas bitcoin, échale un vistazo a la Mentoría de Custodia que hago junto a Arkad en semillabitcoin.com",[1994,55],"/private-notes/nunchuk-tu-primera-wallet-bitcoin-de-testnet","2025-04-23T08:50:55.052Z",{"_83":2011,"_331":2012},{},{"_39":1988,"_97":55,"_56":12625,"_72":1991,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1990],1772124424116,[151,1988,1991],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/nunchuk-tu-primera-wallet-bitcoin-de-testnet\",\"bafy2bzacedsscdkre244u3xhpps45yyanvkjmmjpuwv6gvx5p2sr5t5ktlwhg\"]",{"_112":12630,"_149":12802,"_152":12803},{"_114":12631,"_133":134,"_135":12801,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":12632,"_39":12799},{"_30":12633,"_72":2018,"_73":55,"_74":12795,"_56":12796,"_77":2025,"_79":2025,"_81":12797,"_86":12798,"_88":2018,"_90":91},[12634,12647,12788],{"_33":12635,"_35":12636},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12637,"_41":2018,"_43":12638,"_67":12639,"_69":12646,"_71":70},"QgRROanP",{},[12640],{"_37":286,"_233":12641,"_238":12642,"_43":12644,"_71":12645},[7543],[12643],67,{},"http://www.thetednelson.com/computerlibanddreammachines.php","Source: http://www.thetednelson.com/computerlibanddreammachines.php",{"_33":12648,"_35":12778},[12649,12664,12679,12695,12706,12717,12728,12739,12750,12761],{"_33":12650,"_35":12651},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12652,"_41":2018,"_43":12653,"_67":12654,"_69":12663,"_71":70},"bj1lbiwc",{},[12655,12659],{"_37":232,"_233":12656,"_238":12657,"_43":12658,"_71":70},[139],[3778],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":12660,"_238":12661,"_43":12662,"_71":70},[7925,6367],[4035,12218],{},"DECIDE WHAT YOU WANT TO LEARN.\nBut you can’t know exactly, because of course you don’t know exactly how any field is structured until you know all about it.",{"_33":12665,"_35":12666},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12667,"_41":2018,"_43":12668,"_67":12669,"_69":12678,"_71":70},"hPPn8wlp",{},[12670,12674],{"_37":232,"_233":12671,"_238":12672,"_43":12673,"_71":70},[139],[7372],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":12675,"_238":12676,"_43":12677,"_71":70},[4143],[4797],{},"READ EVERYTHING YOU CAN, especially what you enjoy, since that way you can read more of it and faster.",{"_33":12680,"_35":12681},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12682,"_41":2018,"_43":12683,"_67":12684,"_69":12694,"_71":70},"y--cs1mY",{},[12685,12690],{"_37":232,"_233":12686,"_238":12688,"_43":12689,"_71":70},[139,12687],366,[5367,6633],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":12691,"_238":12692,"_43":12693,"_71":70},[5975],[11329],{},"GRAB FOR INSIGHTS.\nRegardless of points others are trying to make, when you recognize an insight that has meaning for you, make it your own. It may have to do with the shape of molecules, or the personality of a specific emperor, or the quirks of a Great Man in the field. Its importance is not how central it is, but how clear and interesting and memorable to you. REMEMBER IT. Then go for another.",{"_33":12696,"_35":12697},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12698,"_41":2018,"_43":12699,"_67":12700,"_69":12705,"_71":70},"MYxa4j0S",{},[12701],{"_37":232,"_233":12702,"_238":12703,"_43":12704,"_71":70},[139],[7372],{},"TIE INSIGHTS TOGETHER.\nSoon you will have your own string of insights in a field, like the string of lights around a Christmas tree.",{"_33":12707,"_35":12708},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12709,"_41":2018,"_43":12710,"_67":12711,"_69":12716,"_71":70},"Qqg_a7QR",{},[12712],{"_37":232,"_233":12713,"_238":12714,"_43":12715,"_71":70},[139],[5290],{},"CONCENTRATE ON MAGAZINES, NOT BOOKS.\nMagazines have far more insights per inch of text, and can be read much faster. But when a book really speaks to you, lavish attention on it.",{"_33":12718,"_35":12719},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12720,"_41":2018,"_43":12721,"_67":12722,"_69":12727,"_71":70},"lOPGO3Fl",{},[12723],{"_37":232,"_233":12724,"_238":12725,"_43":12726,"_71":70},[139],[4098],{},"FIND YOUR OWN SPECIAL TOPICS, AND PURSUE THEM.",{"_33":12729,"_35":12730},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12731,"_41":2018,"_43":12732,"_67":12733,"_69":12738,"_71":70},"wvGHdiMJ",{},[12734],{"_37":232,"_233":12735,"_238":12736,"_43":12737,"_71":70},[139],[5367],{},"GO TO CONVENTIONS.\nFor some reason, conventions are a splendid concentrated way to learn things; talking to people helps. Don’t think you have to be anybody special to go to a convention; just plunk down your money. But you have to have a handle. Calling yourself a Consultant is good; “Student” is perfectly honorable.",{"_33":12740,"_35":12741},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12742,"_41":2018,"_43":12743,"_67":12744,"_69":12749,"_71":70},"Az1fo8Im",{},[12745],{"_37":232,"_233":12746,"_238":12747,"_43":12748,"_71":70},[139],[5288],{},"“FIND YOUR MAN.”\nSomewhere in the world is someone who will answer your questions extraordinarily well. If you find him, dog him. He may be a janitor or a teenage kid, no matter. Follow him with your begging-bowl, if that’s what he wants, or take him to expensive restaurants, or whatever.",{"_33":12751,"_35":12752},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12753,"_41":2018,"_43":12754,"_67":12755,"_69":12760,"_71":70},"0zqVYZ1Y",{},[12756],{"_37":232,"_233":12757,"_238":12758,"_43":12759,"_71":70},[139],[3778],{},"KEEP IMPROVING YOUR QUESTIONS.\nProbably in your head there are questions that don’t seem to line up with what you’re hearing. Don’t assume that you don’t understand; keep adjusting the questions till you can get an answer that relates to what you wanted.",{"_33":12762,"_35":12763},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12764,"_41":2018,"_43":12765,"_67":12766,"_69":12777,"_71":70},"S5t0AFca",{},[12767,12771],{"_37":232,"_233":12768,"_238":12769,"_43":12770,"_71":70},[139],[4171],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":12772,"_238":12774,"_43":12776,"_71":70},[12773],246,[12775],395,{},"YOUR FIELD IS BOUNDED WHERE YOU WANT IT TO BE.\nJust because others group and stereotype things in conventional ways does not mean they are necessarily right. Intellectual subjects are connected every whichway; your field is what you think it is. (Again, this is one of the things that will give you insights and keep you motivated, but it will get you into trouble if you try to go for degrees.)",{"_37":199,"_39":12779,"_41":2018,"_43":12780,"_67":12781,"_69":12787,"_71":70},"ucqiVidt",{"_194":5405},[12782],{"_37":232,"_233":12783,"_238":12784,"_43":12786,"_71":70},[6039],[12785],362,{},"As far as I can tell, these are the techniques used by bright people who want to learn something other than by taking courses in it. It’s the way Ph.D.’s pick up a second field; it’s the way journalists and “geniuses” operate; it brings the general understandings of a field that children of eminent people in that field get as a birthright; it’s the way anybody can learn anything, if he has the nerve.",{"_33":12789,"_35":12790},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12791,"_41":2018,"_43":12792,"_67":12793,"_69":12794,"_71":70},"L5hC6pcG",{},[],"There are limitations. This doesn’t give you lab experience, and you will continually have to be making up for gaps. But for alertness and the ability to use his mind, give me the man who’s learned this way, rather than been blinkered and cliched to death within the educational system.",[55],"/private-notes/how-to-learn-anything",{"_83":2034},{},{"_39":2015,"_97":55,"_56":12800,"_72":2018,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2017],1772124423967,[151,2015,2018],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/how-to-learn-anything\",\"bafy2bzacec7675em6o5cipug27oaxwbzcotadhwcsn66jreiidqi6av7mfqqc\"]",{"_112":12805,"_149":12847,"_152":12848},{"_114":12806,"_133":134,"_135":12846,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":12807,"_39":12844},{"_30":12808,"_72":2040,"_73":55,"_74":12839,"_56":12840,"_77":2049,"_79":12841,"_81":12842,"_86":12843,"_88":2050,"_90":91},[12809,12824,12831],{"_33":12810,"_35":12811},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12812,"_41":2050,"_43":12813,"_67":12814,"_69":12823,"_71":70},"iSMvOjR7",{},[12815,12819],{"_37":232,"_233":12816,"_238":12817,"_43":12818,"_71":70},[139],[5381],{},{"_37":3795,"_233":12820,"_238":12821,"_43":12822,"_71":70},[139],[4197],{},"Newspaper Business is a great business, 2003 Warren Buffett. ",{"_33":12825,"_35":12826},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12827,"_41":2040,"_43":12828,"_67":12829,"_69":12830,"_71":70},"dcB2Gyaq",{},[],"I wonder if the Internet or the Big Tech Platforms broke Newspapers. If we return to a decentralized web, will newspapers be a great business again?",{"_33":12832,"_35":12833},[],{"_37":3447,"_39":12834,"_41":2040,"_43":12835,"_67":12837,"_69":70,"_71":12838},"RvI5OSxc",{"_83":12836},"NewspaperPublishingBusinessIsFantastic.mp4",[],"ipfs://bafybeievsnyl7zvrueqgp2t5b2bs6jmsyj5t4pogwkodxh4hykc6hpioai",[55],"/private-notes/newspaper-is-a-great-business","2025-04-12T09:15:18.882Z",{"_83":2059},{},{"_39":2037,"_97":55,"_56":12845,"_72":2040,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2039],1772124423960,[151,2037,2040],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/newspaper-is-a-great-business\",\"bafy2bzaceb7zbnoftclkntwhthifbxmsdnw22na3nvgsqjx6ralh2vhcungcs\"]",{"_112":12850,"_149":13116,"_152":13117},{"_114":12851,"_133":134,"_135":13115,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":12852,"_39":13113},{"_30":12853,"_72":2065,"_73":55,"_74":13109,"_56":13110,"_77":2072,"_79":2072,"_81":13111,"_86":13112,"_88":2065,"_90":91},[12854,12861,12868,12879,12886,12893,12900,12907,12914,12921,12928,12939,12946,12957,12964,12971,12982,12989,12996,13003,13014,13021,13032,13039,13046,13053,13064,13071,13078,13089,13096],{"_33":12855,"_35":12856},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12857,"_41":2065,"_43":12858,"_67":12859,"_69":12860,"_71":70},"cqGWrs8E",{},[],"Explore the frontiers of knowledge together",{"_33":12862,"_35":12863},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12864,"_41":2065,"_43":12865,"_67":12866,"_69":12867,"_71":70},"Xsv5BZVM",{},[],"Mintter is a decentralized knowledge collaboration application for open communities powered by a knowledge graph.",{"_33":12869,"_35":12870},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12871,"_41":2065,"_43":12872,"_67":12873,"_69":12878,"_71":70},"q2TnobIS",{},[12874],{"_37":232,"_233":12875,"_238":12876,"_43":12877,"_71":70},[139],[2395],{},"Why Mintter?",{"_33":12880,"_35":12881},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12882,"_41":2065,"_43":12883,"_67":12884,"_69":12885,"_71":70},"pQahCYR5",{},[],"Humans need better collaboration and thought tools to solve ever more complex problems. However, the goal of most content companies today, basically social media or click-bait media, is to generate advertising by competing for our attention through emotional manipulation.",{"_33":12887,"_35":12888},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12889,"_41":2065,"_43":12890,"_67":12891,"_69":12892,"_71":70},"SC_7kMZk",{},[],"More than ever, the public sphere has become a platform for advertising instead of a platform for constructive dialogue and critical debate. Conversations are fragmented, divisive, and plagued with disinformation, leading us to polarization.",{"_33":12894,"_35":12895},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12896,"_41":2065,"_43":12897,"_67":12898,"_69":12899,"_71":70},"KghJVMRu",{},[],"An example of how the world of publishing works nowadays:",{"_33":12901,"_35":12902},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12903,"_41":2065,"_43":12904,"_67":12905,"_69":12906,"_71":70},"1KM3Jmxi",{},[],"An epidemiologist expert writes an article about COVID-19 in your city's online newspaper. Many people will read it. Some trolls will comment on the article, and others will share it through a messenger app, igniting heated conversations.",{"_33":12908,"_35":12909},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12910,"_41":2065,"_43":12911,"_67":12912,"_69":12913,"_71":70},"1TTag4Ig",{},[],"The expert's knowledge will slowly fade away without any educative reviews, challenging responses, or other informative perspectives. No one will learn anything—the policymakers, the audience, or even th",{"_33":12915,"_35":12916},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12917,"_41":2065,"_43":12918,"_67":12919,"_69":12920,"_71":70},"B3qzmIKu",{},[],"e author. The article will become another failed opportunity for society to solve a complex problem.",{"_33":12922,"_35":12923},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12924,"_41":2065,"_43":12925,"_67":12926,"_69":12927,"_71":70},"u1sXQJSt",{},[],"The main drawback is the actual silence of the expert, which will shy away from all the noise. The social dialogue that brings learning and progress to society is impossible with current digital tools.",{"_33":12929,"_35":12930},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12931,"_41":2065,"_43":12932,"_67":12933,"_69":12938,"_71":70},"jEfo4uoX",{},[12934],{"_37":232,"_233":12935,"_238":12936,"_43":12937,"_71":70},[139],[5290],{},"Decentralized knowledge collaboration",{"_33":12940,"_35":12941},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12942,"_41":2065,"_43":12943,"_67":12944,"_69":12945,"_71":70},"OjbUKRXf",{},[],"In Mintter, we believe a decentralized knowledge collaboration network can spark human cooperation to solve our most challenging problems.",{"_33":12947,"_35":12948},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12949,"_41":2065,"_43":12950,"_67":12951,"_69":12956,"_71":70},"iF4CX4jS",{},[12952],{"_37":232,"_233":12953,"_238":12954,"_43":12955,"_71":70},[139],[5381],{},"Decentralized access and participation",{"_33":12958,"_35":12959},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12960,"_41":2065,"_43":12961,"_67":12962,"_69":12963,"_71":70},"dCx8M3A4",{},[],"The application uses decentralized identity with public key cryptography instead of any logins. Decentralized identity allows users to sign their content and maintain their attribution in a network of computers without needing a central server; consequently, other users can reuse content while keeping the original authorship.",{"_33":12965,"_35":12966},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12967,"_41":2065,"_43":12968,"_67":12969,"_69":12970,"_71":70},"qd4aiFuL",{},[],"A computer network stores the user's information, providing open access to permanent and immutable information through a DAG of changes.-- we use IPFS Framework. Users can connect to the network without asking permission and contribute to the existing knowledge base or public conversations.",{"_33":12972,"_35":12973},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12974,"_41":2065,"_43":12975,"_67":12976,"_69":12981,"_71":70},"WEKJj8oe",{},[12977],{"_37":232,"_233":12978,"_238":12979,"_43":12980,"_71":70},[139],[5379],{},"Immutable intertwingled knowledge",{"_33":12983,"_35":12984},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12985,"_41":2065,"_43":12986,"_67":12987,"_69":12988,"_71":70},"O4gdVwpW",{},[],"We have developed a decentralized knowledge graph that allows users to change their content on top of an immutable set of changes inspired by the version control system git. Content immutability gives confidence to the knowledge experts that they can work on others' author work without the common web broken links.",{"_33":12990,"_35":12991},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12992,"_41":2065,"_43":12993,"_67":12994,"_69":12995,"_71":70},"9rYpPIIX",{},[],"This versionable knowledge graph based on CRDTs brings about the uncensorship character of Mintter, as the collaboration happens without a central server by allowing peer-to-peer direct human interactions.",{"_33":12997,"_35":12998},[],{"_37":199,"_39":12999,"_41":2065,"_43":13000,"_67":13001,"_69":13002,"_71":70},"zkOLNzvD",{},[],"We also provide a complete set of hypertext properties, such as fine-grained linking, transclusion, visible connections, parallel pages, and hierarchical documents, allowing the software to express and play how humans think and collaborate. Also, a star-structured discussion functionality brings the system a whole discussion experience.",{"_33":13004,"_35":13005},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13006,"_41":2065,"_43":13007,"_67":13008,"_69":13013,"_71":70},"z9d5JCZW",{},[13009],{"_37":232,"_233":13010,"_238":13011,"_43":13012,"_71":70},[139],[553],{},"Open collaboration",{"_33":13015,"_35":13016},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13017,"_41":2065,"_43":13018,"_67":13019,"_69":13020,"_71":70},"pNA0Et_5",{},[],"Build your knowledge open communities: for tech discussions across your development community, for academics, their group's discussions, and for public servants to have their open deliberation. Mintter makes your ideas exponential through a better collaboration dialogue within your community, with syncable and signed libraries of material that produce unique knowledge bases.",{"_33":13022,"_35":13023},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13024,"_41":2065,"_43":13025,"_67":13026,"_69":13031,"_71":70},"v5GPHcYY",{},[13027],{"_37":232,"_233":13028,"_238":13029,"_43":13030,"_71":70},[139],[4670],{},"Tech Stack",{"_33":13033,"_35":13034},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13035,"_41":2065,"_43":13036,"_67":13037,"_69":13038,"_71":70},"gM_NUZPv",{},[],"We are building an application, a protocol, and a decentralized network for content creation and publishing for which we lean heavily on libp2p and IPFS.",{"_33":13040,"_35":13041},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13042,"_41":2065,"_43":13043,"_67":13044,"_69":13045,"_71":70},"lJxj8EkJ",{},[],"We derive significant inspirations from SSB, Dat, BitTorrent, and other P2P protocols. We like the great possibilities of the gossip protocol together with the nature of social connections.",{"_33":13047,"_35":13048},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13049,"_41":2065,"_43":13050,"_67":13051,"_69":13052,"_71":70},"9BTAUbrI",{},[],"The backend is in Go. The frontend is in TypeScript with React, and for the Editor, we are using Slate JS.",{"_33":13054,"_35":13055},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13056,"_41":2065,"_43":13057,"_67":13058,"_69":13063,"_71":70},"u1RjkQRn",{},[13059],{"_37":232,"_233":13060,"_238":13061,"_43":13062,"_71":70},[139],[4670],{},"Who are we",{"_33":13065,"_35":13066},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13067,"_41":2065,"_43":13068,"_67":13069,"_69":13070,"_71":70},"kv3SR-9H",{},[],"We are a team of four founders, Alex, Gabriel, Julio and Horacio, passionate about innovation, social progress, and open protocols. Previously, we have created socks, advertising, solar, and sustainable mobility companies. We are committed to many open-source software projects, education, and mentoring.",{"_33":13072,"_35":13073},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13074,"_41":2065,"_43":13075,"_67":13076,"_69":13077,"_71":70},"m3J45ZHM",{},[],"We work remotely, and we come from distant places in the world: Iberia, Siberia, and Central America. We are always looking for nomads all over the world to become part of the Mintter Revolution.",{"_33":13079,"_35":13080},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13081,"_41":2065,"_43":13082,"_67":13083,"_69":13088,"_71":70},"uxR1kd6r",{},[13084],{"_37":232,"_233":13085,"_238":13086,"_43":13087,"_71":70},[139],[3776],{},"Building a Team",{"_33":13090,"_35":13091},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13092,"_41":2065,"_43":13093,"_67":13094,"_69":13095,"_71":70},"Iq8xLIBO",{},[],"We are a small team with a strong vision and highly execution-oriented capacity. We work remotely and asynchronously. We are technologists, always fascinated by the latest technologies out there.",{"_33":13097,"_35":13098},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13099,"_41":2065,"_43":13100,"_67":13101,"_69":13108,"_71":70},"3vosokkI",{},[13102],{"_37":286,"_233":13103,"_238":13104,"_43":13106,"_71":13107},[6837],[13105],274,{},"mailto:team@mintter.com","We are looking for people that share our vision and our strong feeling of purpose in building a critical collective intelligence through reliable, collaborative networks of knowledge. If you feel inspired by our mission, please, we would love you to contact us team@mintter.com .",[55],"/private-notes/about-mintter",{"_83":2081,"_336":2082,"_340":676},{},{"_39":2062,"_97":55,"_56":13114,"_72":2065,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2064],1772124424427,[151,2062,2065],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/about-mintter\",\"bafy2bzacecyauo2rgpz6iibecbqo5bzsxp3r5pxwiqwb43jkjdynnkg2qvn22\"]",{"_112":13119,"_149":13149,"_152":13150},{"_114":13120,"_133":134,"_135":13148,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13121,"_39":13146},{"_30":13122,"_72":2088,"_73":55,"_74":13141,"_56":13142,"_77":2098,"_79":13143,"_81":13144,"_86":13145,"_88":2099,"_90":91},[13123,13130],{"_33":13124,"_35":13125},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13126,"_41":2099,"_43":13127,"_67":13128,"_69":13129,"_71":70},"lNU935Ki",{},[],"Seed Hypermedia brings distributed storage to the web. We were inspired by Ted Nelson. Let's review his different projects:",{"_33":13131,"_35":13132},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13133,"_41":2099,"_43":13134,"_67":13135,"_69":13140,"_71":70},"hKYXsvVb",{},[13136],{"_37":286,"_233":13137,"_238":13138,"_43":13139,"_71":13140},[139],[4096],{},"https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/800197.806036",[2091,55],"/private-notes/an-archival-system-for-the-web","2025-04-09T11:17:52.014Z",{"_83":2108},{},{"_39":2085,"_97":55,"_56":13147,"_72":2088,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2087],1772124423977,[151,2085,2088],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/an-archival-system-for-the-web\",\"bafy2bzacebl4uhek6tbjcemk2l74mrs5yugbadkuxibmnwrptsyecjxetb6o4\"]",{"_112":13152,"_149":13207,"_152":13208},{"_114":13153,"_133":134,"_135":13206,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13154,"_39":13204},{"_30":13155,"_72":2114,"_73":55,"_74":13199,"_56":13200,"_77":2124,"_79":13201,"_81":13202,"_86":13203,"_88":2125,"_90":91},[13156,13164,13171,13178,13185,13192],{"_33":13157,"_35":13158},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13159,"_41":13160,"_43":13161,"_67":13162,"_69":13163,"_71":70},"WUbkrF1b","bafy2bzacedixfghuke64ksvrrjwza6c2xpvscd3q23czpcvivgnta4r6oghh4",{},[],"how not to silo information: ",{"_33":13165,"_35":13166},[],{"_37":166,"_39":13167,"_41":13160,"_43":13168,"_67":13169,"_69":70,"_71":13170},"3J4TZjQf",{"_170":7190},[],"hm://z6MkeeXibqWALS7hJ8ZQYLSuY62xo1LKYhm7d5i9soF2edx4?v=bafy2bzaceamtayv3ggag5hx4f7csgd5p2xigsqyqljclllmcfmbsvkpqhekq4#F5kXQBB2+",{"_33":13172,"_35":13173},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13174,"_41":13160,"_43":13175,"_67":13176,"_69":13177,"_71":70},"EDuzn60b",{},[],"What are really Ted Nelson Trails? For me, trails are the edit decision list and not the net of links. ",{"_33":13179,"_35":13180},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13181,"_41":13160,"_43":13182,"_67":13183,"_69":13184,"_71":70},"Jeztoq0y",{},[],"What makes an Information system open? Intertwingled? Should discussion threads be moderated to stick to a topic?",{"_33":13186,"_35":13187},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13188,"_41":13160,"_43":13189,"_67":13190,"_69":13191,"_71":70},"wf8znL0I",{},[],"now that that's above here, how do I resume using this 'page' without dealing with it. … \"this issue is text fills up the space of meaning, without being 'digested' the way our central nervous system does?",{"_33":13193,"_35":13194},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13195,"_41":2114,"_43":13196,"_67":13197,"_69":13198,"_71":70},"YNSR9m0E",{},[],"hey the key are bi-directional links here! and republishing p2p",[2091,2117,55],"/private-notes/what-are-siloed-information-systems","2025-04-03T16:19:50.812Z",{"_83":2134},{},{"_39":2111,"_97":55,"_56":13205,"_72":2114,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2113],1772124425216,[151,2111,2114],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/what-are-siloed-information-systems\",\"bafy2bzaceatvxjv4ptzpfppqgyvo6rrzsmwginsiirgqcmmlmzmvz5jivpak6\"]",{"_112":13210,"_149":13281,"_152":13282},{"_114":13211,"_133":134,"_135":13280,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13212,"_39":13278},{"_30":13213,"_72":2140,"_73":55,"_74":13273,"_56":13274,"_77":325,"_79":13275,"_81":13276,"_86":13277,"_88":2148,"_90":91},[13214,13221,13239,13248,13254],{"_33":13215,"_35":13216},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13217,"_41":13218,"_43":13219,"_67":13220,"_69":70,"_71":70},"PjTqOgBQ","bafy2bzacedntm67veylbega73nb6qgla22pyg6xdvviqktjkww2ijpvfimgnu",{},[],{"_33":13222,"_35":13230},[13223],{"_33":13224,"_35":13225},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13226,"_41":13218,"_43":13227,"_67":13228,"_69":13229,"_71":70},"yfmrhDmB",{},[],"Explore in-depth articles, practical guides, and thought-provoking ideas to help you [solve a problem, learn something, or stay inspired].",{"_37":190,"_39":13231,"_41":13218,"_43":13232,"_67":13233,"_69":13238,"_71":70},"Yh3URRIV",{"_194":195},[13234],{"_37":232,"_233":13235,"_238":13236,"_43":13237,"_71":70},[139],[6884],{},"Build a Blog That Sparks Inspiration",{"_33":13240,"_35":13241},[],{"_37":310,"_39":13242,"_41":13243,"_43":13244,"_67":13246,"_69":70,"_71":13247},"gcDl14j0","bafy2bzacebzezrshxfmsqkjlqbzt4lflzdvesamkzxannnc2pefecfi7dtlly",{"_83":13245},"Start Reading Now",[],"hm://z6MkrvMBtbQHQX1YyYE9k5oNcTURbV9fPr4UPencXcLG1Y4X/guides",{"_33":13249,"_35":13250},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13251,"_41":13218,"_43":13252,"_67":13253,"_69":70,"_71":70},"FoazC6XT",{},[],{"_33":13255,"_35":13268},[13256],{"_33":13257,"_35":13258},[],{"_37":38,"_39":13259,"_41":2140,"_43":13260,"_67":13267,"_69":70,"_71":70},"qCTGGK9T",{"_45":46,"_47":48,"_49":13261,"_66":6},{"_51":13262,"_60":13265},[13263],{"_54":2143,"_56":13264,"_58":800},"guides",[13266],{"_63":8,"_64":65},[],{"_37":190,"_39":13269,"_41":2140,"_43":13270,"_67":13271,"_69":13272,"_71":70},"IsHnYH4I",{"_194":195},[],"Featured Articles",[55,2143],"/private-notes/blog-templet","2025-04-03T13:58:33.453Z",{"_83":2157,"_329":2158,"_338":2159,"_339":8},{},{"_39":2137,"_97":55,"_56":13279,"_72":2140,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2139],1772124424531,[151,2137,2140],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/blog-templet\",\"bafy2bzacebwz7pvcwgagm6xtljnwy37dv3urbkhcaugpoomtmvkj4e4s4hf42\"]",{"_112":13284,"_149":13302,"_152":13303},{"_114":13285,"_133":134,"_135":13301,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13286,"_39":13299},{"_30":13287,"_72":2165,"_73":55,"_74":13295,"_56":13296,"_77":2172,"_79":2172,"_81":13297,"_86":13298,"_88":2165,"_90":91},[13288],{"_33":13289,"_35":13290},[],{"_37":166,"_39":13291,"_41":2165,"_43":13292,"_67":13293,"_69":70,"_71":13294},"ReeHOZIx",{"_170":7190},[],"hm://z6MkpHiG87oJnyMajxKyJcEwNRTbrHWjKSnmVxuuxq7bP3nb/podcasts/l255-nos-hacemos-prestamistas-con-ambroid?v=bafy2bzacebn5rtsu2fkdgngfu7wxci6borfvkcacuch542fcetnkqx63v7ara",[55],"/private-notes/republished-a-lunaticoin-post",{"_83":2181},{},{"_39":2162,"_97":55,"_56":13300,"_72":2165,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2164],1772124424163,[151,2162,2165],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/republished-a-lunaticoin-post\",\"bafy2bzacedxano3hetuxijr4a47r5ki6wpplklorfnfn4fho7sjho2zmcxozw\"]",{"_112":13305,"_149":13332,"_152":13333},{"_114":13306,"_133":134,"_135":13331,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13307,"_39":13329},{"_30":13308,"_72":2186,"_73":55,"_74":13324,"_56":13325,"_77":2195,"_79":13326,"_81":13327,"_86":13328,"_88":2196,"_90":91},[13309,13316],{"_33":13310,"_35":13311},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13312,"_41":2186,"_43":13313,"_67":13314,"_69":13315,"_71":70},"GCuXzUwd",{},[],"Object Capabilities doesn't have a global state.",{"_33":13317,"_35":13318},[],{"_37":3447,"_39":13319,"_41":2196,"_43":13320,"_67":13322,"_69":70,"_71":13323},"IKFpKDSR",{"_83":13321},"Object capabilities programming.mp4",[],"ipfs://bafybeihpqb5zmiazmdxuwng6fnxzujsife4p5g3e7q7mbu3ekqlsflk54a",[55],"/private-notes/test","2025-03-10T11:46:04.340Z",{"_83":2205},{},{"_39":2184,"_97":55,"_56":13330,"_72":2186,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1135],1772124424213,[151,2184,2186],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/test\",\"bafy2bzacedoxitriwtlnmet7cddafy6xfimd2ey5mfdgzxpanxtzgwonymwc6\"]",{"_112":13335,"_149":13360,"_152":13361},{"_114":13336,"_133":134,"_135":13359,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13337,"_39":13357},{"_30":13338,"_72":2211,"_73":55,"_74":13353,"_56":13354,"_77":2217,"_79":2217,"_81":13355,"_86":13356,"_88":2211,"_90":91},[13339,13346],{"_33":13340,"_35":13341},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13342,"_41":2211,"_43":13343,"_67":13344,"_69":13345,"_71":70},"y0RO9mhS",{},[],"Slack",{"_33":13347,"_35":13348},[],{"_37":3505,"_39":13349,"_41":2211,"_43":13350,"_67":13351,"_69":70,"_71":13352},"HIKwHtw7",{},[],"ipfs://bafkreigsedc7uf6odq6jjz2m6axgl6xnsv57z7e4vjj6mzwkanz2rczkl4",[55],"/private-notes/b2b-sales",{"_83":2226},{},{"_39":2208,"_97":55,"_56":13358,"_72":2211,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2210],1772124424253,[151,2208,2211],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/b2b-sales\",\"bafy2bzacebedntzqjtsk2uet3unna4eioy33hmyl7sru6qlattvvu3vxdb4uo\"]",{"_112":13363,"_149":13403,"_152":13404},{"_114":13364,"_133":134,"_135":13402,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13365,"_39":13400},{"_30":13366,"_72":2232,"_73":55,"_74":13396,"_56":13397,"_77":2239,"_79":2239,"_81":13398,"_86":13399,"_88":2232,"_90":91},[13367,13378,13385],{"_33":13368,"_35":13369},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13370,"_41":2232,"_43":13371,"_67":13372,"_69":13377,"_71":70},"QMxsqB5P",{},[13373],{"_37":232,"_233":13374,"_238":13375,"_43":13376,"_71":70},[5284],[4143],{},"I like the word Openness.",{"_33":13379,"_35":13380},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13381,"_41":2232,"_43":13382,"_67":13383,"_69":13384,"_71":70},"VdOw7Mho",{},[],"“Openness” was the kind of multipurpose term that allowed one to look political while advancing an agenda that had very little to do with politics.",{"_33":13386,"_35":13387},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13388,"_41":2232,"_43":13389,"_67":13390,"_69":13395,"_71":70},"ZtkHGScM",{},[13391],{"_37":286,"_233":13392,"_238":13393,"_43":13394,"_71":13395},[139],[12409],{},"https://reader.exacteditions.com/issues/93978/page/132",[55],"/private-notes/openness",{"_83":2248},{},{"_39":2229,"_97":55,"_56":13401,"_72":2232,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2231],1772124424301,[151,2229,2232],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/openness\",\"bafy2bzaceduowa5qkfppyncerepllqfqhmuqcalwred5mq7nbpaiqtfdfs4ji\"]",{"_112":13406,"_149":13418,"_152":13419},{"_114":13407,"_133":134,"_135":13417,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13408,"_39":13415},{"_30":13409,"_72":2254,"_73":55,"_74":13410,"_56":13411,"_77":2263,"_79":13412,"_81":13413,"_86":13414,"_88":2264,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/ads","2025-02-26T10:23:07.636Z",{"_83":2273},{},{"_39":2251,"_97":55,"_56":13416,"_72":2254,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2253],1772124424454,[151,2251,2254],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/ads\",\"bafy2bzaceaws73bj5sq4n6f7f2lcnbo3gsgzfygl24d2pldmrbvesp7qqel3a\"]",{"_112":13421,"_149":13495,"_152":13496},{"_114":13422,"_133":134,"_135":13494,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13423,"_39":13492},{"_30":13424,"_72":2279,"_73":55,"_74":13487,"_56":13488,"_77":2288,"_79":13489,"_81":13490,"_86":13491,"_88":2289,"_90":91},[13425,13431,13437,13443,13449,13455,13461,13467,13473,13480],{"_33":13426,"_35":13427},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13428,"_41":2279,"_43":13429,"_67":13430,"_69":70,"_71":70},"n9O8EXSo",{},[],{"_33":13432,"_35":13433},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13434,"_41":2279,"_43":13435,"_67":13436,"_69":70,"_71":70},"yACjWWfH",{},[],{"_33":13438,"_35":13439},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13440,"_41":2279,"_43":13441,"_67":13442,"_69":70,"_71":70},"TnBdd5MT",{},[],{"_33":13444,"_35":13445},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13446,"_41":2279,"_43":13447,"_67":13448,"_69":70,"_71":70},"RzjZIc_7",{},[],{"_33":13450,"_35":13451},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13452,"_41":2279,"_43":13453,"_67":13454,"_69":70,"_71":70},"3Djlor2J",{},[],{"_33":13456,"_35":13457},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13458,"_41":2279,"_43":13459,"_67":13460,"_69":70,"_71":70},"oDXoAHhn",{},[],{"_33":13462,"_35":13463},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13464,"_41":2279,"_43":13465,"_67":13466,"_69":70,"_71":70},"z1ZeKRT3",{},[],{"_33":13468,"_35":13469},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13470,"_41":2279,"_43":13471,"_67":13472,"_69":70,"_71":70},"aIAPH7R3",{},[],{"_33":13474,"_35":13475},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13476,"_41":2279,"_43":13477,"_67":13478,"_69":13479,"_71":70},"hEOcMm4d",{},[],"#Politica",{"_33":13481,"_35":13482},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13483,"_41":2279,"_43":13484,"_67":13485,"_69":13486,"_71":70},"JjCkP3VR",{},[],"#Social",[55],"/private-notes/keywords","2025-02-26T10:22:46.389Z",{"_83":2298},{},{"_39":2276,"_97":55,"_56":13493,"_72":2279,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2278],1772124424609,[151,2276,2279],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/keywords\",\"bafy2bzaceauwvbxmi4taz7oz4mlml3khvml4xbar6euj36podll5ou6hutxji\"]",{"_112":13498,"_149":13804,"_152":13805},{"_114":13499,"_133":134,"_135":13803,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13500,"_39":13801},{"_30":13501,"_72":2304,"_73":55,"_74":13797,"_56":13798,"_77":2311,"_79":2311,"_81":13799,"_86":13800,"_88":2304,"_90":91},[13502,13634,13640,13710,13738,13744,13750,13757,13763,13770,13776,13783,13790],{"_33":13503,"_35":13629},[13504,13511,13532,13560,13574,13588,13608],{"_33":13505,"_35":13506},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13507,"_41":2304,"_43":13508,"_67":13509,"_69":13510,"_71":70},"8oE8e-h7",{},[],"Mentir con intencion de manipulación.",{"_33":13512,"_35":13527},[13513,13520],{"_33":13514,"_35":13515},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13516,"_41":2304,"_43":13517,"_67":13518,"_69":13519,"_71":70},"qze2NwYt",{},[],"Recesión de la democracia. Estamos en un intento de cambio de régimen? Necesitamos una modernización de la democracia, existe una gran desconfianza entre los ciudadanos.",{"_33":13521,"_35":13522},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13523,"_41":2304,"_43":13524,"_67":13525,"_69":13526,"_71":70},"25LUXc0G",{},[],"Hay que crear organizaciones paralelas a los partidos politicos, que eliminen la polarización.",{"_37":190,"_39":13528,"_41":2304,"_43":13529,"_67":13530,"_69":13531,"_71":70},"ftXv7SGQ",{"_194":195},[],"Seguimos en la crisis del 2008",{"_33":13533,"_35":13555},[13534],{"_33":13535,"_35":13550},[13536,13543],{"_33":13537,"_35":13538},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13539,"_41":2304,"_43":13540,"_67":13541,"_69":13542,"_71":70},"4w6PqbzC",{},[],"Todos podemos ser agentes de desinformación.",{"_33":13544,"_35":13545},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13546,"_41":2304,"_43":13547,"_67":13548,"_69":13549,"_71":70},"BZukeOKq",{},[],"que es intensidad de opiniones distintas de la desinfromacion?",{"_37":199,"_39":13551,"_41":2304,"_43":13552,"_67":13553,"_69":13554,"_71":70},"SVW0izfR",{"_194":3876},[],"Estamos en un situación de todos con todos, creando un escenario apabullante de desinformación.",{"_37":190,"_39":13556,"_41":2304,"_43":13557,"_67":13558,"_69":13559,"_71":70},"mAyORzrA",{"_194":195},[],"Desafío del Cambio Tecnológico",{"_33":13561,"_35":13569},[13562],{"_33":13563,"_35":13564},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13565,"_41":2304,"_43":13566,"_67":13567,"_69":13568,"_71":70},"7nIMOivr",{},[],"Las empresas tienen contribuir a nivel general y político y no solo en lo que respecta a su propio caso.",{"_37":190,"_39":13570,"_41":2304,"_43":13571,"_67":13572,"_69":13573,"_71":70},"2R4p4aat",{"_194":195},[],"La desinformación y la empresa",{"_33":13575,"_35":13583},[13576],{"_33":13577,"_35":13578},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13579,"_41":2304,"_43":13580,"_67":13581,"_69":13582,"_71":70},"bxF2oqZ7",{},[],"Hay que tener cuidado con aprovechar la actual situación para cerciorar la libertad de expresión.",{"_37":190,"_39":13584,"_41":2304,"_43":13585,"_67":13586,"_69":13587,"_71":70},"yDvZq2OD",{"_194":195},[],"Liberalismo: el derecho a la libertad de expresión es fundamental",{"_33":13589,"_35":13603},[13590,13597],{"_33":13591,"_35":13592},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13593,"_41":2304,"_43":13594,"_67":13595,"_69":13596,"_71":70},"kC_Eg6yV",{},[],"Practicas cercanas a la desinformacion por parte de los medios de comunicacion y de los partidos politicos",{"_33":13598,"_35":13599},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13600,"_41":2304,"_43":13601,"_67":13602,"_69":70,"_71":70},"JcXexVc5",{},[],{"_37":190,"_39":13604,"_41":2304,"_43":13605,"_67":13606,"_69":13607,"_71":70},"QgJBO3St",{"_194":195},[],"Ya no hacen falta generar ideas solo emociones.",{"_33":13609,"_35":13624},[13610,13617],{"_33":13611,"_35":13612},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13613,"_41":2304,"_43":13614,"_67":13615,"_69":13616,"_71":70},"-e6nCxLK",{},[],"Qué es desinformación y qué no? ",{"_33":13618,"_35":13619},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13620,"_41":2304,"_43":13621,"_67":13622,"_69":13623,"_71":70},"M7gr3bHm",{},[],"Inteligencia artificial va a incrementar la desinformación",{"_37":190,"_39":13625,"_41":2304,"_43":13626,"_67":13627,"_69":13628,"_71":70},"Y0hoO5un",{"_194":195},[],"Necesitamos reglas sobre desinformación claras",{"_37":190,"_39":13630,"_41":2304,"_43":13631,"_67":13632,"_69":13633,"_71":70},"6xdRJXTV",{"_194":195},[],"Desinformación y Democracia",{"_33":13635,"_35":13636},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13637,"_41":2304,"_43":13638,"_67":13639,"_69":70,"_71":70},"vrniDb0r",{},[],{"_33":13641,"_35":13705},[13642,13649,13656,13670],{"_33":13643,"_35":13644},[],{"_37":190,"_39":13645,"_41":2304,"_43":13646,"_67":13647,"_69":13648,"_71":70},"kyrSm6UO",{},[],"Dispersion of Authority",{"_33":13650,"_35":13651},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13652,"_41":2304,"_43":13653,"_67":13654,"_69":13655,"_71":70},"KBNi4ptj",{},[],"Se espera que lideran aborden la colision entre la tecnoligai y los riesgos emergentes.",{"_33":13657,"_35":13665},[13658],{"_33":13659,"_35":13660},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13661,"_41":2304,"_43":13662,"_67":13663,"_69":13664,"_71":70},"lFgTyb5N",{},[],"La utilización maliciosa de Internet no es un fenómeno nuevo. Agentes maliciosos realizan acciones coordinadas con inversiones importantes.",{"_37":190,"_39":13666,"_41":2304,"_43":13667,"_67":13668,"_69":13669,"_71":70},"dFTyRyAI",{"_194":195},[],"Operaciones de Información",{"_33":13671,"_35":13700},[13672,13679],{"_33":13673,"_35":13674},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13675,"_41":2304,"_43":13676,"_67":13677,"_69":13678,"_71":70},"S08mEQOG",{},[],"Contenido, comportatimiento, identidades sintéticas",{"_33":13680,"_35":13695},[13681,13688],{"_33":13682,"_35":13683},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13684,"_41":2304,"_43":13685,"_67":13686,"_69":13687,"_71":70},"c7lAV8TA",{},[],"The origins of Totalitarianism",{"_33":13689,"_35":13690},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13691,"_41":2304,"_43":13692,"_67":13693,"_69":13694,"_71":70},"iVcc6Lin",{},[],"La muerte de la verdad",{"_37":190,"_39":13696,"_41":2304,"_43":13697,"_67":13698,"_69":13699,"_71":70},"f8QrNOF0",{"_194":5405},[],"Referencias:",{"_37":190,"_39":13701,"_41":2304,"_43":13702,"_67":13703,"_69":13704,"_71":70},"k3gBIOWQ",{"_194":195},[],"Realidad Sintética",{"_37":190,"_39":13706,"_41":2304,"_43":13707,"_67":13708,"_69":13709,"_71":70},"_MfBUMAr",{"_194":195},[],"Desinformación no, operaciones de información",{"_33":13711,"_35":13733},[13712,13719,13726],{"_33":13713,"_35":13714},[],{"_37":190,"_39":13715,"_41":2304,"_43":13716,"_67":13717,"_69":13718,"_71":70},"yVaSmhaL",{},[],"Reforzar las relaciones con los stake holders",{"_33":13720,"_35":13721},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13722,"_41":2304,"_43":13723,"_67":13724,"_69":13725,"_71":70},"01HbJWf5",{},[],"Refuerza la reputación y la relación de confianza; informa a los grupos de interés antes de que llegue el ataque. Lo grupos de interes nos tienen que conocer, nos aprecien, y tengan acceso a los nudos de información.",{"_33":13727,"_35":13728},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13729,"_41":2304,"_43":13730,"_67":13731,"_69":13732,"_71":70},"XckZL1Ig",{},[],"Empleados, bancos, financiadores, los medios de comunicación.",{"_37":190,"_39":13734,"_41":2304,"_43":13735,"_67":13736,"_69":13737,"_71":70},"3_3mY-jh",{"_194":195},[],"Para la empresa la solucion no es técnica.",{"_33":13739,"_35":13740},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13741,"_41":2304,"_43":13742,"_67":13743,"_69":70,"_71":70},"FQB0JHZd",{},[],{"_33":13745,"_35":13746},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13747,"_41":2304,"_43":13748,"_67":13749,"_69":70,"_71":70},"tw5hmOqv",{},[],{"_33":13751,"_35":13752},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13753,"_41":2304,"_43":13754,"_67":13755,"_69":13756,"_71":70},"bd3j8rDv",{},[],"El estado nos debe protoger, es imposible como individuos o empresas pequenas protegernos de campanas de desifnormacion.",{"_33":13758,"_35":13759},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13760,"_41":2304,"_43":13761,"_67":13762,"_69":70,"_71":70},"8Zmn6JGs",{},[],{"_33":13764,"_35":13765},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13766,"_41":2304,"_43":13767,"_67":13768,"_69":13769,"_71":70},"DfO2Gw71",{},[],"Es muy importante que la Policia denuncie y comunique que mensajes forman parte de Operaciones de Información",{"_33":13771,"_35":13772},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13773,"_41":2304,"_43":13774,"_67":13775,"_69":70,"_71":70},"B3U741tc",{},[],{"_33":13777,"_35":13778},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13779,"_41":2304,"_43":13780,"_67":13781,"_69":13782,"_71":70},"uvBYseHj",{},[],"Los actuales modelos de negocio predisponen la desinformacion",{"_33":13784,"_35":13785},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13786,"_41":2304,"_43":13787,"_67":13788,"_69":13789,"_71":70},"v2ljgOAC",{},[],"las limitaciones de la web impide su uso, un espacio descentralizado sin planificiacion central seria mas resiliente",{"_33":13791,"_35":13792},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13793,"_41":2304,"_43":13794,"_67":13795,"_69":13796,"_71":70},"FQUXTZaZ",{},[],"los conflictos de interes con la propiedad de las plataformas tecnologicas",[55],"/private-notes/desinformacion",{"_83":2320},{},{"_39":2301,"_97":55,"_56":13802,"_72":2304,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2303],1772124424803,[151,2301,2304],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/desinformacion\",\"bafy2bzacedb6ktx3h34m4oz5o5mhmjlsg3vmkzetvj3oi4kshkhiqcyzcml4i\"]",{"_112":13807,"_149":14004,"_152":14005},{"_114":13808,"_133":134,"_135":14003,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":13809,"_39":14001},{"_30":13810,"_72":3336,"_73":55,"_74":13997,"_56":13998,"_77":3343,"_79":3343,"_81":13999,"_86":14000,"_88":3336,"_90":91},[13811,13818,13990],{"_33":13812,"_35":13813},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13814,"_41":3336,"_43":13815,"_67":13816,"_69":13817,"_71":70},"GZ41HUbN",{},[],"Uber founder Travis Kalanick: “Every angel deal that gets done is a momentum play”",{"_33":13819,"_35":13985},[13820,13831,13842,13853,13864,13875,13886,13897,13908,13919,13930,13941,13952,13963,13974],{"_33":13821,"_35":13822},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13823,"_41":3336,"_43":13824,"_67":13825,"_69":13830,"_71":70},"LHIQ_fJw",{},[13826],{"_37":232,"_233":13827,"_238":13828,"_43":13829,"_71":70},[139],[5288],{},"Priming the Pump. “Go to angel gatherings, industry conferences, any and all networking events. Meet people who are angels or who know angels. Give ‘em the elevator pitch… make sure you’re meeting with somebody new EVERY DAY.”",{"_33":13832,"_35":13833},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13834,"_41":3336,"_43":13835,"_67":13836,"_69":13841,"_71":70},"1KZQfeJ9",{},[13837],{"_37":232,"_233":13838,"_238":13839,"_43":13840,"_71":70},[139],[3776],{},"Intro meetings. “Informal discussion where you pitch the company over a lunch/coffee/etc., and expand potential angel network through referrals. Get your pitch down to 5-10 minutes, and prepare a tight FAQ in your head so that you have tight answers to the top 20 questions. Let them pay. Be proud of your scrappiness.”",{"_33":13843,"_35":13844},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13845,"_41":3336,"_43":13846,"_67":13847,"_69":13852,"_71":70},"3t6QFo8e",{},[13848],{"_37":232,"_233":13849,"_238":13850,"_43":13851,"_71":70},[139],[3973],{},"ABC’s – Always Be Closing. ”At the end of every meeting, get a clear understanding of where they stand on your deal opportunity.”",{"_33":13854,"_35":13855},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13856,"_41":3336,"_43":13857,"_67":13858,"_69":13863,"_71":70},"05JkeWAv",{},[13859],{"_37":232,"_233":13860,"_238":13861,"_43":13862,"_71":70},[139],[553],{},"Referrals are key. “Most angels will immediately offer up a couple folks they can hook you up with… always ask for more folks you can connect with.”",{"_33":13865,"_35":13866},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13867,"_41":3336,"_43":13868,"_67":13869,"_69":13874,"_71":70},"2b1EUYBU",{},[13870],{"_37":232,"_233":13871,"_238":13872,"_43":13873,"_71":70},[139],[9177],{},"Advisors: ”Turn a couple of these potential angels into advisors. Having a few top-notch people in your corner can make all the difference in turning the tide in an angel round.”",{"_33":13876,"_35":13877},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13878,"_41":3336,"_43":13879,"_67":13880,"_69":13885,"_71":70},"cu5GeKFR",{},[13881],{"_37":232,"_233":13882,"_238":13883,"_43":13884,"_71":70},[139],[5284],{},"Thought Partner: ”Pick one advisor, co-founder, or mentor who will be your thought partner in managing the process.”",{"_33":13887,"_35":13888},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13889,"_41":3336,"_43":13890,"_67":13891,"_69":13896,"_71":70},"uieGPGWG",{},[13892],{"_37":232,"_233":13893,"_238":13894,"_43":13895,"_71":70},[139],[7543],{},"TheList: ”Keep a list (aka pipeline) of the people you’re meeting with, the referrals that they provide you, and the level of their interest in the seed round. Stay on the ball…Always follow up.”",{"_33":13898,"_35":13899},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13900,"_41":3336,"_43":13901,"_67":13902,"_69":13907,"_71":70},"vFQ3S2aY",{},[13903],{"_37":232,"_233":13904,"_238":13905,"_43":13906,"_71":70},[139],[5288],{},"Passion/Charisma. “Focus on the positive, have confidence, be amped, bring passion to your game, and share the love with the person across from you.”",{"_33":13909,"_35":13910},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13911,"_41":3336,"_43":13912,"_67":13913,"_69":13918,"_71":70},"OCmgENgm",{},[13914],{"_37":232,"_233":13915,"_238":13916,"_43":13917,"_71":70},[139],[3851],{},"Credibility. ”DO NOT FIGHT THE TRUTH… Do not try to spin out of what your weak points are. Do not try to make something certain that is not. Do not pretend to know something that you don’t. Credibility is the name of the game in fundraising.”",{"_33":13920,"_35":13921},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13922,"_41":3336,"_43":13923,"_67":13924,"_69":13929,"_71":70},"hKSRPJDl",{},[13925],{"_37":232,"_233":13926,"_238":13927,"_43":13928,"_71":70},[139],[8468],{},"Momentum and Urgency. ”Investors are fickle creatures, they are motivated by fear and greed… Time IS NOT YOUR FRIEND! The longer the process drags out, the more it seems that nobody is interested in your deal, and the less likely you are to actually get one.”",{"_33":13931,"_35":13932},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13933,"_41":3336,"_43":13934,"_67":13935,"_69":13940,"_71":70},"rJMmZGOa",{},[13936],{"_37":232,"_233":13937,"_238":13938,"_43":13939,"_71":70},[139],[5288],{},"Getting the Lead. ”Until you have a lead, you don’t have a deal… The way to get a lead is to spur one of the larger, most interested investors into making an offer.”",{"_33":13942,"_35":13943},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13944,"_41":3336,"_43":13945,"_67":13946,"_69":13951,"_71":70},"qxTFk6yl",{},[13947],{"_37":232,"_233":13948,"_238":13949,"_43":13950,"_71":70},[139],[7521],{},"The Competitive Deal – The Need for Speed. ”The second you have a single term sheet, you need to move very quickly to get a second one. You don’t have a lot of time, because momentum at this point is crucial to closing… Your second term sheet will be easier to get than your first, but it will make a HUGE impact on your deal. Without a second termsheet, you will be in a position to take whatever crappy terms the original lead provided, and it’s quite possible that the terms could get worse (or even go away!) as the one-termsheet deal drags out.”",{"_33":13953,"_35":13954},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13955,"_41":3336,"_43":13956,"_67":13957,"_69":13962,"_71":70},"tsxhFeye",{},[13958],{"_37":232,"_233":13959,"_238":13960,"_43":13961,"_71":70},[139],[5367],{},"Herding the cattle. ”Once you start working the competitive leads, you need to start getting word out to ALL of the interested parties, that this deal is getting hot, and that you could start moving to close in very short order… This makes them anxious about the competitive situation you’ve created b/c now your deal has been validated.”",{"_33":13964,"_35":13965},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13966,"_41":3336,"_43":13967,"_67":13968,"_69":13973,"_71":70},"GdXy30um",{},[13969],{"_37":232,"_233":13970,"_238":13971,"_43":13972,"_71":70},[139],[3776],{},"Anti-Collusion. ”The heavyweights in your deal will have the inclination to collude to make the terms better… Keep it short and sweet with each potential colluder, and draw a very straight firm line that the material terms are not changing.”",{"_33":13975,"_35":13976},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13977,"_41":3336,"_43":13978,"_67":13979,"_69":13984,"_71":70},"-wXvUEAa",{},[13980],{"_37":232,"_233":13981,"_238":13982,"_43":13983,"_71":70},[139],[4143],{},"Sprint through the close. ”Until the deal is closed, you have at best a 50/50 shot of it happening. Keep working new seed investors, keep the competitive leads warm, get your deal oversubscribed, because until your deal is done, it’s just a nice fantasy in your head.”",{"_37":199,"_39":13986,"_41":3336,"_43":13987,"_67":13988,"_69":13989,"_71":70},"DIWY4CGQ",{"_194":5405},[],"Below are the key excerpts from Travis’s blog post Startup Seed Raising Skillzzz:",{"_33":13991,"_35":13992},[],{"_37":199,"_39":13993,"_41":3336,"_43":13994,"_67":13995,"_69":13996,"_71":70},"v_KQ2kpz",{},[],"Video source: @TechCoHQ (2010)",[55],"/private-notes/fund-raising/travis-kalanick",{"_83":3354},{},{"_39":3333,"_97":55,"_56":14002,"_72":3336,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2325,3335],1772124425413,[151,3333,3336],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/fund-raising/travis-kalanick\",\"bafy2bzaceaytcpmfcwqgqlhpb72igiakeptlwouhx4uzstyrozw4dh4a2dcgm\"]",{"_112":14007,"_149":14017,"_152":14018},{"_114":14008,"_133":134,"_135":14016,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":14009,"_39":14014},{"_30":14010,"_72":2326,"_73":55,"_74":14011,"_56":3348,"_77":2333,"_79":2333,"_81":14012,"_86":14013,"_88":2326,"_90":91},[],[55],{"_83":2342},{},{"_39":2323,"_97":55,"_56":14015,"_72":2326,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2325],1772124424834,[151,2323,2326],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/fund-raising\",\"bafy2bzacebxkfjbxbhcygqbysjv2k2eqlpg5gf7tuv5m6oyratki7qzfoy4o4\"]",{"_112":14020,"_149":14031,"_152":14032},{"_114":14021,"_133":134,"_135":14030,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":14022,"_39":14028},{"_30":14023,"_72":2348,"_73":55,"_74":14024,"_56":14025,"_77":2355,"_79":2355,"_81":14026,"_86":14027,"_88":2348,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/document-1",{"_83":2364},{},{"_39":2345,"_97":55,"_56":14029,"_72":2348,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2347],1772124424876,[151,2345,2348],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/document-1\",\"bafy2bzacedkn3mzizqno7ikx6gh5accy4q33jyuqbj6pincsu5lpmmunpxnkg\"]",{"_112":14034,"_149":14424,"_152":14425},{"_114":14035,"_133":134,"_135":14423,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":14036,"_39":14421},{"_30":14037,"_72":3388,"_73":55,"_74":14417,"_56":14418,"_77":3395,"_79":3395,"_81":14419,"_86":14420,"_88":3388,"_90":91},[14038,14045,14097,14210,14290],{"_33":14039,"_35":14040},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14041,"_41":3388,"_43":14042,"_67":14043,"_69":14044,"_71":70},"N7nYmB4o",{},[],"Here’s an improved version with better readability, clarity, and flow:",{"_33":14046,"_35":14092},[14047],{"_33":14048,"_35":14082},[14049,14060,14071],{"_33":14050,"_35":14051},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14052,"_41":3388,"_43":14053,"_67":14054,"_69":14059,"_71":70},"MeLTcg-4",{},[14055],{"_37":232,"_233":14056,"_238":14057,"_43":14058,"_71":70},[139],[3973],{},"Public key pairs as \"egos\" to identify users.",{"_33":14061,"_35":14062},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14063,"_41":3388,"_43":14064,"_67":14065,"_69":14070,"_71":70},"lGjc3DCZ",{},[14066],{"_37":232,"_233":14067,"_238":14068,"_43":14069,"_71":70},[139],[4185],{},"Multiple alter-egos (pseudonyms) per user, enabling identity separation.",{"_33":14072,"_35":14073},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14074,"_41":3388,"_43":14075,"_67":14076,"_69":14081,"_71":70},"mSe2ktqx",{},[14077],{"_37":232,"_233":14078,"_238":14079,"_43":14080,"_71":70},[139],[4185],{},"Independent from peer identities, meaning network addresses do not determine user identities.",{"_37":199,"_39":14083,"_41":3388,"_43":14084,"_67":14085,"_69":14091,"_71":70},"3a-ymkZu",{"_194":3876},[14086],{"_37":286,"_233":14087,"_238":14088,"_43":14089,"_71":14090},[139],[6366],{},"https://grothoff.org/christian/psc2015.pdf","GNUnet's identity management is built around the following principles:",{"_37":190,"_39":14093,"_41":3388,"_43":14094,"_67":14095,"_69":14096,"_71":70},"1tVOdhQ7",{"_194":195},[],"Identity Management in GNUnet",{"_33":14098,"_35":14205},[14099],{"_33":14100,"_35":14200},[14101,14112,14123,14134,14145,14156,14167],{"_33":14102,"_35":14103},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14104,"_41":3388,"_43":14105,"_67":14106,"_69":14111,"_71":70},"htEqUjKU",{},[14107],{"_37":232,"_233":14108,"_238":14109,"_43":14110,"_71":70},[139],[7372],{},"Secure, memorable names in a fully decentralized system.",{"_33":14113,"_35":14114},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14115,"_41":3388,"_43":14116,"_67":14117,"_69":14122,"_71":70},"P5NQKQmT",{},[14118],{"_37":232,"_233":14119,"_238":14120,"_43":14121,"_71":70},[139],[4670],{},"Delegation to achieve transitive trust.",{"_33":14124,"_35":14125},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14126,"_41":3388,"_43":14127,"_67":14128,"_69":14133,"_71":70},"Pn72dBbX",{},[14129],{"_37":232,"_233":14130,"_238":14131,"_43":14132,"_71":70},[139],[4797],{},"Globally unique, secure identifiers for names.",{"_33":14135,"_35":14136},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14137,"_41":3388,"_43":14138,"_67":14139,"_69":14144,"_71":70},"j5uemrnp",{},[14140],{"_37":232,"_233":14141,"_238":14142,"_43":14143,"_71":70},[139],[5381],{},"Privacy-focused queries and responses.",{"_33":14146,"_35":14147},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14148,"_41":3388,"_43":14149,"_67":14150,"_69":14155,"_71":70},"4EFstOp8",{},[14151],{"_37":232,"_233":14152,"_238":14153,"_43":14154,"_71":70},[139],[6401],{},"Alternative to traditional public key infrastructure (PKI).",{"_33":14157,"_35":14158},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14159,"_41":3388,"_43":14160,"_67":14161,"_69":14166,"_71":70},"an1grO96",{},[14162],{"_37":232,"_233":14163,"_238":14164,"_43":14165,"_71":70},[139],[7372],{},"Interoperable with DNS.",{"_33":14168,"_35":14191},[14169,14180],{"_33":14170,"_35":14171},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14172,"_41":3388,"_43":14173,"_67":14174,"_69":14179,"_71":70},"CtUWrIX8",{},[14175],{"_37":4656,"_233":14176,"_238":14177,"_43":14178,"_71":70},[139],[6084],{},"GNUNET_GNS_connect()",{"_33":14181,"_35":14182},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14183,"_41":3388,"_43":14184,"_67":14185,"_69":14190,"_71":70},"dteXLPbd",{},[14186],{"_37":4656,"_233":14187,"_238":14188,"_43":14189,"_71":70},[139],[5367],{},"GNUNET_GNS_lookup()",{"_37":199,"_39":14192,"_41":3388,"_43":14193,"_67":14194,"_69":14199,"_71":70},"gFEFjPCm",{"_194":3876},[14195],{"_37":232,"_233":14196,"_238":14197,"_43":14198,"_71":70},[139],[452],{},"Simple API:",{"_37":199,"_39":14201,"_41":3388,"_43":14202,"_67":14203,"_69":14204,"_71":70},"l90a47vo",{"_194":3876},[],"GNUnet includes a decentralized Name System with key features:",{"_37":190,"_39":14206,"_41":3388,"_43":14207,"_67":14208,"_69":14209,"_71":70},"zbFZepI4",{"_194":195},[],"GNUnet Name System (GNS)",{"_33":14211,"_35":14285},[14212],{"_33":14213,"_35":14280},[14214,14225,14236,14247],{"_33":14215,"_35":14216},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14217,"_41":3388,"_43":14218,"_67":14219,"_69":14224,"_71":70},"iVN0Orv5",{},[14220],{"_37":232,"_233":14221,"_238":14222,"_43":14223,"_71":70},[139],[553],{},"Instant revocation at all peers that the network permits to receive it.",{"_33":14226,"_35":14227},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14228,"_41":3388,"_43":14229,"_67":14230,"_69":14235,"_71":70},"ruOgares",{},[14231],{"_37":232,"_233":14232,"_238":14233,"_43":14234,"_71":70},[139],[4143],{},"Highly efficient protocol for propagation.",{"_33":14237,"_35":14238},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14239,"_41":3388,"_43":14240,"_67":14241,"_69":14246,"_71":70},"eYRPGk54",{},[14242],{"_37":232,"_233":14243,"_238":14244,"_43":14245,"_71":70},[139],[3802],{},"Offline revocation messages—can be pre-generated and stored.",{"_33":14248,"_35":14271},[14249,14260],{"_33":14250,"_35":14251},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14252,"_41":3388,"_43":14253,"_67":14254,"_69":14259,"_71":70},"ADVyPUXN",{},[14255],{"_37":4656,"_233":14256,"_238":14257,"_43":14258,"_71":70},[139],[3973],{},"GNUNET_REVOCATION_revoke()",{"_33":14261,"_35":14262},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14263,"_41":3388,"_43":14264,"_67":14265,"_69":14270,"_71":70},"ve1oxZiT",{},[14266],{"_37":4656,"_233":14267,"_238":14268,"_43":14269,"_71":70},[139],[4143],{},"GNUNET_REVOCATION_query()",{"_37":199,"_39":14272,"_41":3388,"_43":14273,"_67":14274,"_69":14279,"_71":70},"hNoN8-bM",{"_194":3876},[14275],{"_37":232,"_233":14276,"_238":14277,"_43":14278,"_71":70},[139],[2395],{},"Trivial API:",{"_37":199,"_39":14281,"_41":3388,"_43":14282,"_67":14283,"_69":14284,"_71":70},"PaYsuNuO",{"_194":3876},[],"GNUnet supports an efficient revocation mechanism with the following properties:",{"_37":190,"_39":14286,"_41":3388,"_43":14287,"_67":14288,"_69":14289,"_71":70},"SaFQK0J5",{"_194":195},[],"Key Revocation",{"_33":14291,"_35":14412},[14292,14303,14354,14405],{"_33":14293,"_35":14294},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14295,"_41":3388,"_43":14296,"_67":14297,"_69":14302,"_71":70},"OI4GXpA-",{},[14298],{"_37":232,"_233":14299,"_238":14300,"_43":14301,"_71":70},[553,6366],[7372,3778],{},"GNUnet integrates PSYC2 and GNS to support decentralized social networking applications.",{"_33":14304,"_35":14349},[14305,14316,14327,14338],{"_33":14306,"_35":14307},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14308,"_41":3388,"_43":14309,"_67":14310,"_69":14315,"_71":70},"QHmGWjUP",{},[14311],{"_37":232,"_233":14312,"_238":14313,"_43":14314,"_71":70},[139],[48],{},"nym → A pseudonym of another user in the network.",{"_33":14317,"_35":14318},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14319,"_41":3388,"_43":14320,"_67":14321,"_69":14326,"_71":70},"C3zaThoe",{},[14322],{"_37":232,"_233":14323,"_238":14324,"_43":14325,"_71":70},[139],[792],{},"place → A virtual space where social interactions happen.",{"_33":14328,"_35":14329},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14330,"_41":3388,"_43":14331,"_67":14332,"_69":14337,"_71":70},"oSN4uv4O",{},[14333],{"_37":232,"_233":14334,"_238":14335,"_43":14336,"_71":70},[139],[4120],{},"host → The owner of a place.",{"_33":14339,"_35":14340},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14341,"_41":3388,"_43":14342,"_67":14343,"_69":14348,"_71":70},"LJjUuesl",{},[14344],{"_37":232,"_233":14345,"_238":14346,"_43":14347,"_71":70},[139],[792],{},"guest → A visitor in a place.",{"_37":199,"_39":14350,"_41":3388,"_43":14351,"_67":14352,"_69":14353,"_71":70},"DYxVIs1n",{"_194":3876},[],"Key concepts:",{"_33":14355,"_35":14400},[14356,14367,14378,14389],{"_33":14357,"_35":14358},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14359,"_41":3388,"_43":14360,"_67":14361,"_69":14366,"_71":70},"ryoXpvBJ",{},[14362],{"_37":4656,"_233":14363,"_238":14364,"_43":14365,"_71":70},[139,931],[792,2395],{},"enter, leave → Users joining and exiting places.",{"_33":14368,"_35":14369},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14370,"_41":3388,"_43":14371,"_67":14372,"_69":14377,"_71":70},"qpFbOy4c",{},[14373],{"_37":4656,"_233":14374,"_238":14375,"_43":14376,"_71":70},[139,2395,5379],[4670,3778,4098],{},"host_eject, host_entry_decision, host_announce → Host controls over guests.",{"_33":14379,"_35":14380},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14381,"_41":3388,"_43":14382,"_67":14383,"_69":14388,"_71":70},"2-N-kyGh",{},[14384],{"_37":4656,"_233":14385,"_238":14386,"_43":14387,"_71":70},[139],[4670],{},"guest_talk → Communication within the place.",{"_33":14390,"_35":14391},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14392,"_41":3388,"_43":14393,"_67":14394,"_69":14399,"_71":70},"W_bKuzs5",{},[14395],{"_37":4656,"_233":14396,"_238":14397,"_43":14398,"_71":70},[139,4023],[6084,4797],{},"place_history_replay, place_look_at → Interaction history and visibility.",{"_37":199,"_39":14401,"_41":3388,"_43":14402,"_67":14403,"_69":14404,"_71":70},"PiWDLuu9",{"_194":3876},[],"The API provides a vocabulary for managing social interactions:",{"_33":14406,"_35":14407},[],{"_37":199,"_39":14408,"_41":3388,"_43":14409,"_67":14410,"_69":14411,"_71":70},"HNkj8rA1",{},[],"This revision improves readability by enhancing sentence structure, adding clarity, and using formatting to highlight key concepts. Let me know if you want further refinements! 🚀",{"_37":190,"_39":14413,"_41":3388,"_43":14414,"_67":14415,"_69":14416,"_71":70},"TUCZqWCJ",{"_194":195},[],"Social Network Applications in GNUnet",[55],"/private-notes/robust-opennes/gnunet-key-learnings",{"_83":3410},{},{"_39":3385,"_97":55,"_56":14422,"_72":3388,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,1321,3387],1772124425163,[151,3385,3388],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/robust-opennes/gnunet-key-learnings\",\"bafy2bzacecsleaek5piqvges5rge25nloegde43elg57e5tbf6om6qoemjrhu\"]",{"_112":14427,"_149":14438,"_152":14439},{"_114":14428,"_133":134,"_135":14437,"_137":-5,"_138":139,"_140":139,"_141":139,"_142":-5,"_143":-5,"_144":8,"_145":146,"_147":148},{"_37":28,"_28":14429,"_39":14435},{"_30":14430,"_72":2370,"_73":55,"_74":14431,"_56":14432,"_77":2377,"_79":2377,"_81":14433,"_86":14434,"_88":2370,"_90":91},[],[55],"/private-notes/references",{"_83":2386},{},{"_39":2367,"_97":55,"_56":14436,"_72":2370,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5,"_96":6},[57,2369],1772124425443,[151,2367,2370],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/private-notes/references\",\"bafy2bzacecoj3a3s4hrzxdysiislhlywrhcf2kp4bav7pkuvxzzxygaxwn3sk\"]","enableWebSigning","origin","homeMetadata",{"_83":328,"_329":104,"_330":104,"_331":332,"_333":334,"_335":70,"_336":337,"_338":70,"_339":8,"_340":341,"_342":14444},{"_344":345},"originHomeId",{"_97":55,"_39":382,"_56":14447,"_72":-5,"_99":-5,"_100":-5,"_101":-5,"_102":-5},[],"meta",{"_14450":14451,"_16574":16575},"values",{"_92":14452,"_14454":14455,"_14456":14457,"_14459":14460,"_14461":14462,"_14464":14465,"_14466":14467,"_14468":14469,"_14470":14471,"_14472":14473,"_14474":14475,"_14476":14477,"_14478":14479,"_14480":14481,"_14482":14483,"_14484":14485,"_14486":14487,"_14488":14489,"_14490":14491,"_14492":14493,"_14494":14495,"_14496":14497,"_14498":14499,"_14500":14501,"_14502":14503,"_14504":14505,"_14506":14507,"_14508":14509,"_14510":14511,"_14512":14513,"_14514":14515,"_14516":14517,"_14518":14519,"_14520":14521,"_14522":14523,"_14524":14525,"_14526":14527,"_14528":14529,"_14530":14531,"_14532":14533,"_14534":14535,"_14536":14537,"_14538":14539,"_14540":14541,"_14542":14543,"_14544":14545,"_14546":14547,"_14548":14549,"_14550":14551,"_14552":14553,"_14554":14555,"_14556":14557,"_14558":14559,"_14560":14561,"_14562":14563,"_14564":14565,"_14566":14567,"_14568":14569,"_14570":14571,"_14572":14573,"_14574":14575,"_14576":14577,"_14578":14579,"_14580":14581,"_14582":14583,"_14584":14585,"_14586":14587,"_14588":14589,"_14590":14591,"_14592":14593,"_14594":14595,"_14596":14597,"_14598":14599,"_14600":14601,"_14602":14603,"_14604":14605,"_14606":14607,"_14608":14609,"_14610":14611,"_14612":14613,"_14614":14615,"_14616":14617,"_14618":14619,"_14620":14621,"_14622":14623,"_14624":14625,"_14626":14627,"_14628":14629,"_14630":14631,"_14632":14633,"_14634":14635,"_14636":14637,"_14638":14639,"_14640":14641,"_14642":14643,"_14644":14645,"_14646":14647,"_14648":14649,"_14650":14651,"_14652":14653,"_14654":14655,"_14656":14657,"_14658":14659,"_14660":14661,"_14662":14663,"_14664":14665,"_14666":14667,"_14668":14669,"_14670":14671,"_14672":14673,"_14674":14675,"_14676":14677,"_14678":14679,"_14680":14681,"_14682":14683,"_14684":14685,"_14686":14687,"_14688":14689,"_14690":14691,"_14692":14693,"_14694":14695,"_14696":14697,"_14698":14699,"_14700":14701,"_14702":14703,"_14704":14705,"_14706":14707,"_14708":14709,"_14710":14711,"_14712":14713,"_14714":14715,"_14716":14717,"_14718":14719,"_14720":14721,"_14722":14723,"_14724":14725,"_14726":14727,"_14728":14729,"_14730":14731,"_14732":14733,"_14734":14735,"_14736":14737,"_14738":14739,"_14740":14741,"_14742":14743,"_14744":14745,"_14746":14747,"_14748":14749,"_14750":14751,"_14752":14753,"_14754":14755,"_14756":14757,"_14758":14759,"_14760":14761,"_14762":14763,"_14764":14765,"_14766":14767,"_14768":14769,"_14770":14771,"_14772":14773,"_14774":14775,"_14776":14777,"_14778":14779,"_14780":14781,"_14782":14783,"_14784":14785,"_14786":14787,"_14788":14789,"_14790":14791,"_14792":14793,"_14794":14795,"_14796":14797,"_14798":14799,"_14800":14801,"_14802":14803,"_14804":14805,"_14806":14807,"_14808":14809,"_14810":14811,"_14812":14813,"_14814":14815,"_14816":14817,"_14818":14819,"_14820":14821,"_14822":14823,"_14824":14825,"_14826":14827,"_14828":14829,"_14830":14831,"_14832":14833,"_14834":14835,"_14836":14837,"_14838":14839,"_14840":14841,"_14842":14843,"_14844":14845,"_14846":14847,"_14848":14849,"_14850":14851,"_14852":14853,"_14854":14855,"_14856":14857,"_14858":14859,"_14860":14861,"_14862":14863,"_14864":14865,"_14866":14867,"_14868":14869,"_14870":14871,"_14872":14873,"_14874":14875,"_14876":14877,"_14878":14879,"_14880":14881,"_14882":14883,"_14884":14885,"_14886":14887,"_14888":14889,"_14890":14891,"_14892":14893,"_14894":14895,"_14896":14897,"_14898":14899,"_14900":14901,"_14902":14903,"_14904":14905,"_14906":14907,"_14908":14909,"_14910":14911,"_14912":14913,"_14914":14915,"_14916":14917,"_14918":14919,"_14920":14921,"_14922":14923,"_14924":14925,"_14926":14927,"_14928":14929,"_14930":14931,"_14932":14933,"_14934":14935,"_14936":14937,"_14938":14939,"_14940":14941,"_14942":14943,"_14944":14945,"_14946":14947,"_14948":14949,"_14950":14951,"_14952":14953,"_14954":14955,"_14956":14957,"_14958":14959,"_14960":14961,"_14962":14963,"_14964":14965,"_14966":14967,"_14968":14969,"_14970":14971,"_14972":14973,"_14974":14975,"_14976":14977,"_14978":14979,"_14980":14981,"_14982":14983,"_14984":14985,"_14986":14987,"_14988":14989,"_14990":14991,"_14992":14993,"_14994":14995,"_14996":14997,"_14998":14999,"_15000":15001,"_15002":15003,"_15004":15005,"_15006":15007,"_15008":15009,"_15010":15011,"_15012":15013,"_15014":15015,"_15016":15017,"_15018":15019,"_15020":15021,"_15022":15023,"_15024":15025,"_15026":15027,"_15028":15029,"_15030":15031,"_15032":15033,"_15034":15035,"_15036":15037,"_15038":15039,"_15040":15041,"_15042":15043,"_15044":15045,"_15046":15047,"_15048":15049,"_15050":15051,"_15052":15053,"_15054":15055,"_15056":15057,"_15058":15059,"_15060":15061,"_15062":15063,"_15064":15065,"_15066":15067,"_15068":15069,"_15070":15071,"_15072":15073,"_15074":15075,"_15076":15077,"_15078":15079,"_15080":15081,"_15082":15083,"_15084":15085,"_15086":15087,"_15088":15089,"_15090":15091,"_15092":15093,"_15094":15095,"_15096":15097,"_15098":15099,"_15100":15101,"_15102":15103,"_15104":15105,"_15106":15107,"_15108":15109,"_15110":15111,"_15112":15113,"_15114":15115,"_15116":15117,"_15118":15119,"_15120":15121,"_15122":15123,"_15124":15125,"_15126":15127,"_15128":15129,"_15130":15131,"_15132":15133,"_15134":15135,"_15136":15137,"_15138":15139,"_15140":15141,"_15142":15143,"_15144":15145,"_15146":15147,"_15148":15149,"_15150":15151,"_15152":15153,"_15154":15155,"_15156":15157,"_15158":15159,"_15160":15161,"_15162":15163,"_15164":15165,"_15166":15167,"_15168":15169,"_15170":15171,"_15172":15173,"_15174":15175,"_15176":15177,"_15178":15179,"_15180":15181,"_15182":15183,"_15184":15185,"_15186":15187,"_15188":15189,"_15190":15191,"_15192":15193,"_15194":15195,"_15196":15197,"_15198":15199,"_15200":15201,"_15202":15203,"_15204":15205,"_15206":15207,"_15208":15209,"_15210":15211,"_15212":15213,"_15214":15215,"_15216":15217,"_15218":15219,"_15220":15221,"_15222":15223,"_15224":15225,"_15226":15227,"_15228":15229,"_15230":15231,"_15232":15233,"_15234":15235,"_15236":15237,"_15238":15239,"_15240":15241,"_15242":15243,"_15244":15245,"_15246":15247,"_15248":15249,"_15250":15251,"_15252":15253,"_15254":15255,"_15256":15257,"_15258":15259,"_15260":15261,"_15262":15263,"_15264":15265,"_15266":15267,"_15268":15269,"_15270":15271,"_15272":15273,"_15274":15275,"_15276":15277,"_15278":15279,"_15280":15281,"_15282":15283,"_15284":15285,"_15286":15287,"_15288":15289,"_15290":15291,"_15292":15293,"_15294":15295,"_15296":15297,"_15298":15299,"_15300":15301,"_15302":15303,"_15304":15305,"_15306":15307,"_15308":15309,"_15310":15311,"_15312":15313,"_15314":15315,"_15316":15317,"_15318":15319,"_15320":15321,"_15322":15323,"_15324":15325,"_15326":15327,"_15328":15329,"_15330":15331,"_15332":15333,"_15334":15335,"_15336":15337,"_15338":15339,"_15340":15341,"_15342":15343,"_15344":15345,"_15346":15347,"_15348":15349,"_15350":15351,"_15352":15353,"_15354":15355,"_15356":15357,"_15358":15359,"_15360":15361,"_15362":15363,"_15364":15365,"_15366":15367,"_15368":15369,"_15370":15371,"_15372":15373,"_15374":15375,"_15376":15377,"_15378":15379,"_15380":15381,"_15382":15383,"_15384":15385,"_15386":15387,"_15388":15389,"_15390":15391,"_15392":15393,"_15394":15395,"_15396":15397,"_15398":15399,"_15400":15401,"_15402":15403,"_15404":15405,"_15406":15407,"_15408":15409,"_15410":15411,"_15412":15413,"_15414":15415,"_15416":15417,"_15418":15419,"_15420":15421,"_15422":15423,"_15424":15425,"_15426":15427,"_15428":15429,"_15430":15431,"_15432":15433,"_15434":15435,"_15436":15437,"_15438":15439,"_15440":15441,"_15442":15443,"_15444":15445,"_15446":15447,"_15448":15449,"_15450":15451,"_15452":15453,"_15454":15455,"_15456":15457,"_15458":15459,"_15460":15461,"_15462":15463,"_15464":15465,"_15466":15467,"_15468":15469,"_15470":15471,"_15472":15473,"_15474":15475,"_15476":15477,"_15478":15479,"_15480":15481,"_15482":15483,"_15484":15485,"_15486":15487,"_15488":15489,"_15490":15491,"_15492":15493,"_15494":15495,"_15496":15497,"_15498":15499,"_15500":15501,"_15502":15503,"_15504":15505,"_15506":15507,"_15508":15509,"_15510":15511,"_15512":15513,"_15514":15515,"_15516":15517,"_15518":15519,"_15520":15521,"_15522":15523,"_15524":15525,"_15526":15527,"_15528":15529,"_15530":15531,"_15532":15533,"_15534":15535,"_15536":15537,"_15538":15539,"_15540":15541,"_15542":15543,"_15544":15545,"_15546":15547,"_15548":15549,"_15550":15551,"_15552":15553,"_15554":15555,"_15556":15557,"_15558":15559,"_15560":15561,"_15562":15563,"_15564":15565,"_15566":15567,"_15568":15569,"_15570":15571,"_15572":15573,"_15574":15575,"_15576":15577,"_15578":15579,"_15580":15581,"_15582":15583,"_15584":15585,"_15586":15587,"_15588":15589,"_15590":15591,"_15592":15593,"_15594":15595,"_15596":15597,"_15598":15599,"_15600":15601,"_15602":15603,"_15604":15605,"_15606":15607,"_15608":15609,"_15610":15611,"_15612":15613,"_15614":15615,"_15616":15617,"_15618":15619,"_15620":15621,"_15622":15623,"_15624":15625,"_15626":15627,"_15628":15629,"_15630":15631,"_15632":15633,"_15634":15635,"_15636":15637,"_15638":15639,"_15640":15641,"_15642":15643,"_15644":15645,"_15646":15647,"_15648":15649,"_15650":15651,"_15652":15653,"_15654":15655,"_15656":15657,"_15658":15659,"_15660":15661,"_15662":15663,"_15664":15665,"_15666":15667,"_15668":15669,"_15670":15671,"_15672":15673,"_15674":15675,"_15676":15677,"_15678":15679,"_15680":15681,"_15682":15683,"_15684":15685,"_15686":15687,"_15688":15689,"_15690":15691,"_15692":15693,"_15694":15695,"_15696":15697,"_15698":15699,"_15700":15701,"_15702":15703,"_15704":15705,"_15706":15707,"_15708":15709,"_15710":15711,"_15712":15713,"_15714":15715,"_15716":15717,"_15718":15719,"_15720":15721,"_15722":15723,"_15724":15725,"_15726":15727,"_15728":15729,"_15730":15731,"_15732":15733,"_15734":15735,"_15736":15737,"_15738":15739,"_15740":15741,"_15742":15743,"_15744":15745,"_15746":15747,"_15748":15749,"_15750":15751,"_15752":15753,"_15754":15755,"_15756":15757,"_15758":15759,"_15760":15761,"_15762":15763,"_15764":15765,"_15766":15767,"_15768":15769,"_15770":15771,"_15772":15773,"_15774":15775,"_15776":15777,"_15778":15779,"_15780":15781,"_15782":15783,"_15784":15785,"_15786":15787,"_15788":15789,"_15790":15791,"_15792":15793,"_15794":15795,"_15796":15797,"_15798":15799,"_15800":15801,"_15802":15803,"_15804":15805,"_15806":15807,"_15808":15809,"_15810":15811,"_15812":15813,"_15814":15815,"_15816":15817,"_15818":15819,"_15820":15821,"_15822":15823,"_15824":15825,"_15826":15827,"_15828":15829,"_15830":15831,"_15832":15833,"_15834":15835,"_15836":15837,"_15838":15839,"_15840":15841,"_15842":15843,"_15844":15845,"_15846":15847,"_15848":15849,"_15850":15851,"_15852":15853,"_15854":15855,"_15856":15857,"_15858":15859,"_15860":15861,"_15862":15863,"_15864":15865,"_15866":15867,"_15868":15869,"_15870":15871,"_15872":15873,"_15874":15875,"_15876":15877,"_15878":15879,"_15880":15881,"_15882":15883,"_15884":15885,"_15886":15887,"_15888":15889,"_15890":15891,"_15892":15893,"_15894":15895,"_15896":15897,"_15898":15899,"_15900":15901,"_15902":15903,"_15904":15905,"_15906":15907,"_15908":15909,"_15910":15911,"_15912":15913,"_15914":15915,"_15916":15917,"_15918":15919,"_15920":15921,"_15922":15923,"_15924":15925,"_15926":15927,"_15928":15929,"_15930":15931,"_15932":15933,"_15934":15935,"_15936":15937,"_15938":15939,"_15940":15941,"_15942":15943,"_15944":15945,"_15946":15947,"_15948":15949,"_15950":15951,"_15952":15953,"_15954":15955,"_15956":15957,"_15958":15959,"_15960":15961,"_15962":15963,"_15964":15965,"_15966":15967,"_15968":15969,"_15970":15971,"_15972":15973,"_15974":15975,"_15976":15977,"_15978":15979,"_15980":15981,"_15982":15983,"_15984":15985,"_15986":15987,"_15988":15989,"_15990":15991,"_15992":15993,"_15994":15995,"_15996":15997,"_15998":15999,"_16000":16001,"_16002":16003,"_16004":16005,"_16006":16007,"_16008":16009,"_16010":16011,"_16012":16013,"_16014":16015,"_16016":16017,"_16018":16019,"_16020":16021,"_16022":16023,"_16024":16025,"_16026":16027,"_16028":16029,"_16030":16031,"_16032":16033,"_16034":16035,"_16036":16037,"_16038":16039,"_16040":16041,"_16042":16043,"_16044":16045,"_16046":16047,"_16048":16049,"_16050":16051,"_16052":16053,"_16054":16055,"_16056":16057,"_16058":16059,"_16060":16061,"_16062":16063,"_16064":16065,"_16066":16067,"_16068":16069,"_16070":16071,"_16072":16073,"_16074":16075,"_16076":16077,"_16078":16079,"_16080":16081,"_16082":16083,"_16084":16085,"_16086":16087,"_16088":16089,"_16090":16091,"_16092":16093,"_16094":16095,"_16096":16097,"_16098":16099,"_16100":16101,"_16102":16103,"_16104":16105,"_16106":16107,"_16108":16109,"_16110":16111,"_16112":16113,"_16114":16115,"_16116":16117,"_16118":16119,"_16120":16121,"_16122":16123,"_16124":16125,"_16126":16127,"_16128":16129,"_16130":16131,"_16132":16133,"_16134":16135,"_16136":16137,"_16138":16139,"_16140":16141,"_16142":16143,"_16144":16145,"_16146":16147,"_16148":16149,"_16150":16151,"_16152":16153,"_16154":16155,"_16156":16157,"_16158":16159,"_16160":16161,"_16162":16163,"_16164":16165,"_16166":16167,"_16168":16169,"_16170":16171,"_16172":16173,"_16174":16175,"_16176":16177,"_16178":16179,"_16180":16181,"_16182":16183,"_16184":16185,"_16186":16187,"_16188":16189,"_16190":16191,"_16192":16193,"_16194":16195,"_16196":16197,"_16198":16199,"_16200":16201,"_16202":16203,"_16204":16205,"_16206":16207,"_16208":16209,"_16210":16211,"_16212":16213,"_16214":16215,"_16216":16217,"_16218":16219,"_16220":16221,"_16222":16223,"_16224":16225,"_16226":16227,"_16228":16229,"_16230":16231,"_16232":16233,"_16234":16235,"_16236":16237,"_16238":16239,"_16240":16241,"_16242":16243,"_16244":16245,"_16246":16247,"_16248":16249,"_16250":16251,"_16252":16253,"_16254":16255,"_16256":16257,"_16258":16259,"_16260":16261,"_16262":16263,"_16264":16265,"_16266":16267,"_16268":16269,"_16270":16271,"_16272":16273,"_16274":16275,"_16276":16277,"_16278":16279,"_16280":16281,"_16282":16283,"_16284":16285,"_16286":16287,"_16288":16289,"_16290":16291,"_16292":16293,"_16294":16295,"_16296":16297,"_16298":16299,"_16300":16301,"_16302":16303,"_16304":16305,"_16306":16307,"_16308":16309,"_16310":16311,"_16312":16313,"_16314":16315,"_16316":16317,"_16318":16319,"_16320":16321,"_16322":16323,"_16324":16325,"_16326":16327,"_16328":16329,"_16330":16331,"_16332":16333,"_16334":16335,"_16336":16337,"_16338":16339,"_16340":16341,"_16342":16343,"_16344":16345,"_16346":16347,"_16348":16349,"_16350":16351,"_16352":16353,"_16354":16355,"_16356":16357,"_16358":16359,"_16360":16361,"_16362":16363,"_16364":16365,"_16366":16367,"_16368":16369,"_16370":16371,"_16372":16373,"_16374":16375,"_16376":16377,"_16378":16379,"_16380":16381,"_16382":16383,"_16384":16385,"_16386":16387,"_16388":16389,"_16390":16391,"_16392":16393,"_16394":16395,"_16396":16397,"_16398":16399,"_16400":16401,"_16402":16403,"_16404":16405,"_16406":16407,"_16408":16409,"_16410":16411,"_16412":16413,"_16414":16415,"_16416":16417,"_16418":16419,"_16420":16421,"_16422":16423,"_16424":16425,"_16426":16427,"_16428":16429,"_16430":16431,"_16432":16433,"_16434":16435,"_16436":16437,"_16438":16439,"_16440":16441,"_16442":16443,"_16444":16445,"_16446":16447,"_16448":16449,"_16450":16451,"_16452":16453,"_16454":16455,"_16456":16457,"_16458":16459,"_16460":16461,"_16462":16463,"_16464":16465,"_16466":16467,"_16468":16469,"_16470":16471,"_16472":16473,"_16474":16475,"_16476":16477,"_16478":16479,"_16480":16481,"_16482":16483,"_16484":16485,"_16486":16487,"_16488":16489,"_16490":16491,"_16492":16493,"_16494":16495,"_16496":16497,"_16498":16499,"_16500":16501,"_16502":16503,"_16504":16505,"_16506":16507,"_16508":16509,"_16510":16511,"_16512":16513,"_16514":16515,"_16516":16517,"_16518":16519,"_16520":16521,"_16522":16523,"_16524":16525,"_16526":16527,"_16528":16529,"_16530":16531,"_16532":16533,"_16534":16535,"_16536":16537,"_16538":16539,"_16540":16541,"_16542":16543,"_16544":16545,"_16546":16547,"_16548":16549,"_16550":16551,"_16552":16553,"_16554":16555,"_16556":16557,"_16558":16559,"_16560":16561,"_16562":16563,"_16564":16565,"_16566":16567,"_16568":16569,"_16570":16571,"_16572":16573},[14453],"undefined","dehydratedState.queries.1.queryKey.2",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.createTime.seconds",[14458],"bigint","dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.sortTime",[14463],"Date","dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.8.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.9.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.9.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.9.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.9.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.9.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.9.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.9.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.10.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.10.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.10.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.10.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.10.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.10.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.10.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.11.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.11.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.11.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.11.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.11.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.11.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.11.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.12.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.12.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.12.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.12.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.12.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.12.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.12.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.13.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.13.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.13.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.13.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.13.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.13.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.13.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.14.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.14.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.14.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.14.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.14.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.14.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.14.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.15.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.15.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.15.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.15.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.15.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.15.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.15.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.0.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.0.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.0.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.0.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.0.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.1.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.1.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.1.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.1.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.1.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.2.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.2.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.2.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.2.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.2.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.3.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.3.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.3.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.3.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.3.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.4.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.4.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.4.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.4.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.4.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.5.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.5.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.5.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.5.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.5.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.6.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.6.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.6.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.6.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.6.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.7.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.7.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.7.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.7.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.7.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.8.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.8.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.8.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.8.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.8.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.8.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.8.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.9.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.9.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.9.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.9.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.9.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.9.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.9.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.10.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.10.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.10.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.10.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.10.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.10.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.10.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.11.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.11.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.11.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.11.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.11.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.11.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.11.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.12.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.12.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.12.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.12.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.12.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.12.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.12.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.13.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.13.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.13.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.13.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.13.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.13.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.13.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.14.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.14.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.14.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.14.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.14.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.14.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.14.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.15.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.15.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.15.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.15.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.15.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.15.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.15.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.16.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.16.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.16.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.16.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.16.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.16.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.16.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.17.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.17.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.17.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.17.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.17.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.17.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.17.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.18.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.18.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.18.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.18.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.18.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.18.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.18.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.19.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.19.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.19.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.19.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.19.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.19.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.19.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.20.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.20.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.20.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.20.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.20.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.20.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.20.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.21.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.21.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.21.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.21.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.21.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.21.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.21.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.22.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.22.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.22.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.22.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.22.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.22.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.22.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.23.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.23.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.23.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.23.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.23.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.23.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.23.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.24.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.24.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.24.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.24.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.24.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.24.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.24.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.25.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.25.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.25.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.25.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.25.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.25.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.25.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.26.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.26.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.26.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.26.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.26.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.26.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.26.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.27.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.27.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.27.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.27.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.27.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.27.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.27.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.28.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.28.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.28.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.28.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.28.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.28.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.28.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.29.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.29.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.29.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.29.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.29.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.29.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.29.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.30.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.30.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.30.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.30.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.30.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.30.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.30.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.31.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.31.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.31.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.31.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.31.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.31.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.31.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.32.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.32.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.32.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.32.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.32.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.32.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.32.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.33.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.33.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.33.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.33.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.33.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.33.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.33.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.34.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.34.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.34.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.34.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.34.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.34.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.34.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.35.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.35.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.35.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.35.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.35.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.35.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.35.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.36.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.36.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.36.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.36.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.36.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.36.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.36.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.37.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.37.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.37.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.37.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.37.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.37.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.37.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.38.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.38.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.38.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.38.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.38.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.38.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.38.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.39.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.39.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.39.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.39.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.39.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.39.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.39.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.40.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.40.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.40.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.40.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.40.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.40.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.40.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.41.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.41.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.41.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.41.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.41.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.41.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.41.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.42.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.42.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.42.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.42.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.42.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.42.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.42.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.43.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.43.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.43.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.43.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.43.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.43.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.43.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.44.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.44.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.44.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.44.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.44.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.44.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.44.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.45.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.45.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.45.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.45.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.45.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.45.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.45.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.46.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.46.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.46.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.46.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.46.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.46.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.46.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.47.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.47.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.47.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.47.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.47.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.47.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.47.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.48.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.48.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.48.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.48.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.48.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.48.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.48.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.49.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.49.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.49.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.49.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.49.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.49.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.49.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.50.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.50.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.50.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.50.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.50.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.50.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.50.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.51.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.51.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.51.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.51.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.51.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.51.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.51.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.52.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.52.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.52.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.52.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.52.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.52.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.52.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.53.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.53.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.53.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.53.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.53.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.53.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.53.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.54.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.54.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.54.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.54.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.54.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.54.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.54.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.55.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.55.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.55.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.55.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.55.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.55.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.55.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.56.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.56.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.56.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.56.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.56.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.56.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.56.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.57.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.57.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.57.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.57.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.57.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.57.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.57.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.58.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.58.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.58.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.58.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.58.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.58.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.58.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.59.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.59.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.59.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.59.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.59.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.59.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.59.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.60.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.60.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.60.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.60.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.60.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.60.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.60.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.61.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.61.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.61.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.61.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.61.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.61.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.61.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.62.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.62.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.62.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.62.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.62.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.62.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.62.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.63.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.63.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.63.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.63.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.63.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.63.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.63.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.64.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.64.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.64.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.64.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.64.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.64.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.64.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.65.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.65.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.65.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.65.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.65.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.65.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.3.state.data.65.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.0.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.0.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.0.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.0.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.0.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.1.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.1.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.1.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.1.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.1.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.2.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.2.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.2.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.2.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.2.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.3.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.3.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.3.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.3.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.3.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.4.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.4.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.4.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.4.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.4.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.5.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.5.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.5.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.5.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.5.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.6.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.6.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.6.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.6.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.6.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.7.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.7.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.7.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.7.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.7.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.8.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.8.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.8.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.8.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.8.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.8.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.8.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.9.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.9.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.9.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.9.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.9.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.9.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.9.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.10.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.10.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.10.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.10.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.10.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.10.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.10.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.11.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.11.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.11.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.11.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.11.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.11.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.11.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.12.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.12.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.12.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.12.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.12.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.12.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.12.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.13.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.13.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.13.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.13.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.13.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.13.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.13.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.14.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.14.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.14.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.14.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.14.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.14.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.14.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.15.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.15.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.15.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.15.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.15.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.15.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.15.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.16.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.16.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.16.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.16.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.16.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.16.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.16.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.17.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.17.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.17.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.17.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.17.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.17.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.17.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.18.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.18.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.18.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.18.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.18.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.18.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.18.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.19.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.19.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.19.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.19.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.19.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.19.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.19.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.20.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.20.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.20.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.20.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.20.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.20.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.20.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.21.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.21.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.21.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.21.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.21.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.21.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.21.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.22.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.22.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.22.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.22.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.22.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.22.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.22.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.23.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.23.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.23.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.23.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.23.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.23.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.23.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.24.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.24.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.24.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.24.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.24.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.24.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.24.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.25.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.25.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.25.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.25.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.25.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.25.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.25.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.26.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.26.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.26.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.26.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.26.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.26.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.26.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.27.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.27.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.27.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.27.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.27.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.27.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.27.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.28.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.28.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.28.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.28.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.28.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.28.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.28.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.29.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.29.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.29.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.29.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.29.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.29.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.29.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.30.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.30.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.30.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.30.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.30.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.30.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.30.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.31.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.31.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.31.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.31.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.31.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.31.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.31.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.32.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.32.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.32.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.32.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.32.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.32.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.32.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.33.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.33.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.33.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.33.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.33.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.33.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.33.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.34.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.34.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.34.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.34.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.34.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.34.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.34.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.35.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.35.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.35.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.35.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.35.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.35.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.35.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.36.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.36.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.36.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.36.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.36.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.36.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.36.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.37.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.37.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.37.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.37.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.37.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.37.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.37.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.38.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.38.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.38.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.38.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.38.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.38.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.38.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.39.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.39.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.39.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.39.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.39.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.39.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.39.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.40.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.40.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.40.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.40.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.40.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.40.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.40.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.41.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.41.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.41.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.41.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.41.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.41.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.41.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.42.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.42.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.42.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.42.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.42.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.42.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.42.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.43.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.43.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.43.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.43.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.43.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.43.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.43.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.44.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.44.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.44.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.44.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.44.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.44.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.44.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.45.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.45.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.45.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.45.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.45.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.45.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.45.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.46.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.46.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.46.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.46.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.46.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.46.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.46.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.47.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.47.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.47.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.47.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.47.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.47.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.47.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.48.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.48.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.48.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.48.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.48.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.48.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.48.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.49.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.49.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.49.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.49.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.49.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.49.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.49.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.50.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.50.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.50.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.50.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.50.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.50.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.50.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.51.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.51.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.51.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.51.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.51.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.51.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.51.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.52.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.52.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.52.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.52.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.52.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.52.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.52.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.53.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.53.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.53.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.53.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.53.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.53.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.53.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.54.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.54.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.54.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.54.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.54.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.54.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.54.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.55.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.55.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.55.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.55.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.55.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.55.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.55.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.56.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.56.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.56.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.56.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.56.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.56.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.56.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.57.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.57.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.57.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.57.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.57.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.57.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.57.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.58.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.58.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.58.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.58.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.58.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.58.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.58.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.59.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.59.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.59.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.59.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.59.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.59.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.59.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.60.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.60.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.60.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.60.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.60.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.60.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.60.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.61.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.61.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.61.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.61.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.61.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.61.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.61.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.62.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.62.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.62.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.62.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.62.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.62.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.62.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.63.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.63.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.63.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.63.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.63.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.63.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.63.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.64.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.64.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.64.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.64.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.64.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.64.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.64.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.65.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.65.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.65.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.65.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.65.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.65.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.65.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.66.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.66.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.66.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.66.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.66.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.66.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.66.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.67.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.67.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.67.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.67.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.67.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.67.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.67.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.68.createTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.68.updateTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.68.sortTime",[14463],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.68.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.68.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.68.generationInfo.generation",[14458],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.68.redirectInfo",[14453],"dehydratedState.queries.6.state.data.metadata.summary",[14453],"referentialEqualities",{"_14459":16576,"_14474":16577,"_14488":16578,"_14500":16579,"_14514":16580,"_14516":16581,"_14524":16582,"_14530":16583,"_14542":16584,"_14558":16585,"_14572":16586,"_14586":16587,"_14600":16588,"_14612":16589,"_14628":16590,"_14642":16591,"_14654":16592,"_14670":16593,"_14682":16594,"_14688":16595,"_14692":16596,"_14696":16597,"_14702":16598,"_14706":16599,"_14710":16600,"_14720":16601,"_14724":16602,"_14726":16603,"_14730":16604,"_14734":16605,"_14738":16606,"_14744":16607,"_14748":16608,"_14752":16609,"_14754":16610,"_14762":16611,"_14766":16612,"_14776":16613,"_14780":16614,"_14782":16615,"_14786":16616,"_14790":16617,"_14794":16618,"_14804":16619,"_14808":16620,"_14818":16621,"_14822":16622,"_14824":16623,"_14828":16624,"_14832":16625,"_14836":16626,"_14838":16627,"_14846":16628,"_14850":16629,"_14852":16630,"_14860":16631,"_14866":16632,"_14870":16633,"_14880":16634,"_14888":16635,"_14892":16636,"_14894":16637,"_14902":16638,"_14906":16639,"_14916":16640,"_14920":16641,"_14930":16642,"_14934":16643,"_14944":16644,"_14948":16645,"_14950":16646,"_14962":16647,"_14972":16648,"_14976":16649,"_14978":16650,"_14986":16651,"_14990":16652,"_15000":16653,"_15004":16654,"_15014":16655,"_15018":16656,"_15028":16657,"_15032":16658,"_15046":16659,"_15056":16660,"_15060":16661,"_15070":16662,"_15074":16663,"_15084":16664,"_15090":16665,"_15094":16666,"_15098":16667,"_15102":16668,"_15104":16669,"_15112":16670,"_15116":16671,"_15122":16672,"_15126":16673,"_15130":16674,"_15132":16675,"_15136":16676,"_15140":16677,"_15144":16678,"_15154":16679,"_15158":16680,"_15168":16681,"_15172":16682,"_15178":16683,"_15182":16684,"_15186":16685,"_15196":16686,"_15200":16687,"_15210":16688,"_15214":16689,"_15224":16690,"_15228":16691,"_15238":16692,"_15242":16693,"_15252":16694,"_15256":16695,"_15258":16696,"_15262":16697,"_15266":16698,"_15270":16699,"_15272":16700,"_15280":16701,"_15284":16702,"_15286":16703,"_15290":16704,"_15294":16705,"_15298":16706,"_15304":16707,"_15308":16708,"_15312":16709,"_15322":16710,"_15326":16711,"_15336":16712,"_15340":16713,"_15342":16714,"_15346":16715,"_15350":16716,"_15354":16717,"_15364":16718,"_15368":16719,"_15370":16720,"_15378":16721,"_15382":16722,"_15392":16723,"_15396":16724,"_15398":16725,"_15406":16726,"_15410":16727,"_15420":16728,"_15424":16729,"_15426":16730,"_15434":16731,"_15438":16732,"_15440":16733,"_15448":16734,"_15454":16735,"_15462":16736,"_15466":16737,"_15476":16738,"_15480":16739,"_15482":16740,"_15490":16741,"_15494":16742,"_15504":16743,"_15508":16744,"_15518":16745,"_15522":16746,"_15524":16747,"_15532":16748,"_15536":16749,"_15538":16750,"_15546":16751,"_15550":16752,"_15560":16753,"_15564":16754,"_15574":16755,"_15578":16756,"_15588":16757,"_15592":16758,"_15602":16759,"_15832":16760,"_16502":16761,"_16544":16762},[14466],[14480],[14494],[14502,14508],[14864,14878,15788,15802],[14522],[14608,14636,14874,14958,15042,15088,15452,15798,15896,15980,16026,16390],[14536],[14544,14550],[14564],[14578],[14592],[14606],[14614,14620],[14634],[14648],[14656,14662],[14676],[14684,15606,15608,14690,15614],[15612],[15616],[14698,15620,15622,14704,15628],[15626],[15630],[14712,15634,15636,14718,15642],[15644],[15648],[15650,14732,15656],[15654],[15658],[14740,15662,15664,14746,15670],[15668],[15672],[15676],[15678,14760,15684],[15686],[14768,15690,15692,14774,15698],[15700],[15704],[15706,14788,15712],[15710],[15714],[14796,15718,15720,14802,15726],[15728],[14810,15732,15734,14816,15740],[15742],[15746],[15748,14830,15754],[15752],[15756],[15760],[15762,14844,15768],[15770],[15774],[15776,14858,15782],[15784],[15790,14872,15796],[15794],[15804,14886,15810],[15812],[15816],[15818,14900,15824],[15826],[14908,15844,15846,14914,15852],[15854],[14922,15858,15860,14928,15866],[15868],[14936,15872,15874,14942,15880],[15882],[15886],[15888,14956,15894],[14964,15900,15902,14970,15908],[15910],[15914],[15916,14984,15922],[15924],[14992,15928,15930,14998,15936],[15938],[15006,15942,15944,15012,15950],[15952],[15020,15956,15958,15026,15964],[15966],[15034,15970,15972,15040,15978],[15048,15984,15986,15054,15992],[15994],[15062,15998,16000,15068,16006],[16008],[15076,16012,16014,15082,16020],[16022],[16028,15096,16034],[16032],[16036],[16040],[16042,15110,16048],[16050],[15118,16054,16056,15124,16062],[16060],[16064],[16068],[16070,15138,16076],[16074],[16078],[15146,16082,16084,15152,16090],[16092],[15160,16096,16098,15166,16104],[16106],[15174,16110,16112,15180,16118],[16116],[16120],[15188,16124,16126,15194,16132],[16134],[15202,16138,16140,15208,16146],[16148],[15216,16152,16154,15222,16160],[16162],[15230,16166,16168,15236,16174],[16176],[15244,16180,16182,15250,16188],[16190],[16194],[16196,15264,16202],[16200],[16204],[16208],[16210,15278,16216],[16218],[16222],[16224,15292,16230],[16228],[16232],[15300,16236,16238,15306,16244],[16242],[16246],[15314,16250,16252,15320,16258],[16260],[15328,16264,16266,15334,16272],[16274],[16278],[16280,15348,16286],[16284],[16288],[15356,16292,16294,15362,16300],[16302],[16306],[16308,15376,16314],[16316],[15384,16320,16322,15390,16328],[16330],[16334],[16336,15404,16342],[16344],[15412,16348,16350,15418,16356],[16358],[16362],[16364,15432,16370],[16372],[16376],[16378,15446,16384],[16386],[16392,15460,16398],[16400],[15468,16404,16406,15474,16412],[16414],[16418],[16420,15488,16426],[16428],[15496,16432,16434,15502,16440],[16442],[15510,16446,16448,15516,16454],[16456],[16460],[16462,15530,16468],[16470],[16474],[16476,15544,16482],[16484],[15552,16488,16490,15558,16496],[16498],[15566,16516,16518,15572,16524],[16526],[15580,16530,16532,15586,16538],[16540],[15594,16558,16560,15600,16566],[16568],[15838],[16504,16510],[16546,16552],"actionData","errors"]